Unraveling complex relations between forest-cover change and conflicts through spatial and relational analyses

Unidad de excelencia María de Maeztu MdM-2015-0552Despite the increasing prevalence of forest-cover change and conflicts, most studies have been unable to unravel the complex relations between the two processes. We attribute this failure to methodological limitations. We put forward an alternative approach that combines different datasets (remote sensing, GIS, local narratives, official censuses, newspaper articles), methods (spatial and relational analyses), and scales (subregions, economic sectors, land-based activities) to create a robust explanation of the relations between different intensities of forest-cover change and conflict in the Meseta Purépecha region, central Mexico. This is an important forest region, inhabited by indigenous and mestizo peasants; it has a worldwide reputation for community forestry and is also the epicenter of international avocado production. Forest-cover change is intense and there are recurrent episodes of conflict. We clustered communities in three subregions according to their patterns of forest-cover change. We analyzed the spatial patterns of forest-cover change and conflicts and we characterized the structure and function of the different economic sectors to unravel the nonlinear, interdependent (and sometimes contradictory) relations among these processes. We found that avocado production has differentially shaped the composition and working of society within each subregion, leading to three diverging patterns. Avocado production has provoked conflicts over landownership and over illegal logging in nearby areas. In some areas, a low incidence of conflicts over forest clearance might be explained by high profits, coercion, and violence. We suggest that, by combining spatial and relational analyses, we can integrate and check the congruence of nonequivalent representations from quantitative sources and observant participation at different scales and explain the heterogeneity that processes display across space. Our methodological approach can thus improve our understanding of similar and other complex and uncertain environmental problems elsewhere, especially when accurate or appropriate data are missing

Innovación social en el contexto del COVID-19: Hacia la conformación de sistemas territoriales de innovación

Ante la pandemia Covid-19, instituciones, organismos y empresas de diferentes sectores han llevado a cabo diferentes esfuerzos para reducir y contrarrestar los efectos negativos; algunos relacionados con el desarrollo de nuevos o mejorados productos, procesos, servicios y modelos que impactan directamente en la prevención, tratamiento y mejoras en calidad de vida de quienes han superado la enfermedad. Lo anterior, implica una respuesta a la problemática mediante el desarrollo de innovaciones, algunas de ellas, no han estado motivadas necesariamente por la ganancia, ante la creciente brecha de desigualdad socioeconómica, sino que han tenido el objetivo principal de generar valor social o cambios sociales positivos con la finalidad de atender la problemática, como es el caso de instituciones académicas, centros públicos de investigación, organizaciones sociales, entre otras. En este sentido, la emergencia de múltiples iniciativas, invenciones, procesos, productos y servicios han favorecido el desarrollo de innovaciones sociales, misas que se asocian con la novedad proveniente de la generación y aplicación del conocimiento, en la búsqueda de atender problemas y necesidades sociales (o generar valor social), mejorando así las condiciones de vida. Así, la emergencia de innovaciones sociales para atender la pandemia COVID-19, nos ha llevado a plantear la necesidad de contar con mecanismos que permitan institucionalizar y territorializar dichos esfuerzos, además de promover la generación de un mayor número de este tipo de innovaciones; lo anterior, al retomar el análisis de los sistemas de innovación que nos permita desarrollar el diseño y la articulación de sistemas territoriales de innovación social. En este sentido el objetivo general de esta propuesta consiste Analizar la emergencia de innovaciones sociales relacionadas con la pandemia COVID-19 para su institucionalización mediante el diseño de sistemas territoriales de innovación social; del cual se desprenden tres objetivos particulares: 1) Identificar las invenciones tecnológicas relacionadas con la pandemia COVID-19 a nivel global; 2) Analizar las innovaciones sociales que han surgido de la pandemia COVID-19 en México y, 3) Proponer el diseño de sistemas territoriales de innovación social relacionados con la pandemia COVID-19. Para el cumplimiento de dichos objetivos, se consideran como estrategias y métodos la utilización de diversas fuentes como son la observación, la revisión documental, el análisis de bases de datos, la vigilancia tecnológica, el análisis de contenido, las entrevistas semiestructuradas con dos tipos de muestreo no probabilístico (intencional y de bola de nieva), la síntesis cruzada en los estudios de caso múltiples y el mapeo de actores y capacidades para el diseño del sistema territorial de innovación social

Opportunities, Constraints and Perceptions of Rural Communities Regarding Their Potential to Contribute to Forest Landscape Transitions Under REDD+: Case Studies from Mexico

In Mexico, REDD+ is being presented as a win-win policy enabling forest communities to benefit financially and diversify their income sources while preserving and increasing their forest carbon stocks through more sustainable management. Under the national programme, it is expected that forest communities will have opportunities to tailor their own approaches. However, to date there is little understanding about what opportunities and constraints exist in reality for forest communities to contribute to REDD+, and even less about how their members perceive these opportunities. We assess potential and constraints at community level and investigate perceptions about opportunities in REDD+ and strategies that communities are currently envisaging for participation, in seven communities in the Ayuquila River Basin and around the Chamela-Cuixmala Biosphere Reserve in Jalisco, and in the area surrounding the Monarch Butterfly Reserve in Michoacan. We find that there is more opportunity for reduced degradation and forest enhancement than for reduced deforestation, in all the communities; that it may be difficult to establish additionality for REDD+ activities in some communities; that the amount of forest resource per community may greatly affect the potential to participate; that the presence of people with no land rights may complicate the distribution of benefits; that communities expect REDD+ in general to follow the Payment for Environmental Services model, and that lack of information about what activities may count as REDD+ activities and what level of financial rewards may be expected mean that communities cannot at present adequately appraise whether REDD+ will be worth their while or no

Protecting people and wildlife from the potential harms of drone use in biodiversity conservation: interdisciplinary dialogues

In this policy intervention, we recount the process of producing a policy briefing targeting researchers and practitioners who use drones in biodiversity conservation. We use the writing process as a springboard to think through the ways that interdisciplinary exchange has and might further inform the ethical use of new technologies, such as drones. This approach is vital, we argue, because while drones may be deployed as tools that enable or empower forest, wildlife or habitat monitoring practices, so too can they be variously disruptive, repurposed and/or exceed these applications in significant ways. From questions of surveillance and capture, data ownership and security, to noise disruption, drone use requires careful and critical reflection, particularly in sensitive contexts. Yet, interdisciplinary exchange attentive to the ethical, social and experiential dimensions of drone use remains patchy and thin. To this end, this intervention reflects on the process of a group of scholars from ecological, environmental and social science backgrounds coming together in an interdisciplinary project grappling with diverse issues around responsible conservation drone use. After recounting our methodology, including the surprises and learning that emerged in practice, we contextualise the key themes we chose to foreground in our published policy briefing. We conclude by connecting our collaboration with wider actions and energies in the context of existing (conservation) drone policy and practice, while underscoring our contributions to existing work

Textural classification of land cover using support vector machines : an empirical comparison with parametric, non parametric and hybrid classifiers in the Bolivian Amazon

Land cover classification is a key research field in remote sensing and land change science as thematic maps derived from remotely sensed data have become the basis for analyzing many socio-ecological issues. However, land cover classification remains a difficult task and it is especially challenging in heterogeneous tropical landscapes where nonetheless such maps are of great importance. The present study aims to establish an efficient classification approach to accurately map all broad land cover classes in a large, heterogeneous tropical area of Bolivia, as a basis for further studies (e.g., land cover-land use change). Specifically, we compare the performance of parametric (maximum likelihood), non-parametric (k-nearest neighbour and four different support vector machines - SVM), and hybrid classifiers, using both hard and soft (fuzzy) accuracy assessments. In addition, we test whether the inclusion of a textural index (homogeneity) in the classifications improves their performance. We classified Landsat imagery for two dates corresponding to dry and wet seasons and found that non-parametric, and particularly SVM classifiers, outperformed both parametric and hybrid classifiers. We also found that the use of the homogeneity index along with reflectance bands significantly increased the overall accuracy of all the classifications, but particularly of SVM algorithms. We observed that improvements in producer's and user's accuracies through the inclusion of the homogeneity index were different depending on land cover classes. Earlygrowth/degraded forests, pastures, grasslands and savanna were the classes most improved, especially with the SVM radial basis function and SVM sigmoid classifiers, though with both classifiers all land cover classes were mapped with producer's and user's accuracies of around 90%. Our approach seems very well suited to accurately map land cover in tropical regions, thus having the potential to contribute to conservation initiatives, climate change mitigation schemes such as REDD+, and rural development policies

High overlap between traditional ecological knowledge and forest conservation found in the Bolivian Amazon

Unidad de excelencia María de Maeztu MdM-2015-0552Altres ajuts: FBBVA research grant (BIOCON_06_106-07)It has been suggested that traditional ecological knowledge (TEK) may play a key role in forest conservation. However, empirical studies assessing to what extent TEK is associated with forest conservation compared with other variables are rare. Furthermore, to our knowledge, the spatial overlap of TEK and forest conservation has not been evaluated at fine scales. In this paper, we address both issues through a case study with Tsimane' Amerindians in the Bolivian Amazon. We sampled 624 households across 59 villages to estimate TEK and used remote sensing data to assess forest conservation. We ran statistical and spatial analyses to evaluate whether TEK was associated and spatially overlapped with forest conservation at the village level. We find that Tsimane' TEK is significantly and positively associated with forest conservation although acculturation variables bear stronger and negative associations with forest conservation. We also find a very significant spatial overlap between levels of Tsimane' TEK and forest conservation. We discuss the potential reasons underpinning our results, which provide insights that may be useful for informing policies in the realms of development, conservation, and climate. We posit that the protection of indigenous cultural systems is vital and urgent to create more effective policies in such realms

Titling community land to prevent deforestation: An evaluation of a best-case program in Morona-Santiago, Ecuador

Assigning land title to collective landholders is one of the primary policies land management agencies use to avoid deforestation worldwide. Such programs are designed to improve the ability of landholders to legally exclude competing users and thereby strengthen incentives to manage forests for long-term benefits. Despite the prevalence of this hypothesis, findings about the impacts of land titling programs on deforestation are mixed. Evidence is often unreliable because programs are targeted according to factors that independently influence the conversion of forests. We evaluate a donor-funded land titling and land management program for indigenous communities implemented in Morona-Santiago, Ecuador. This program offers a close to best case scenario for a land titling program to reduce deforestation because of colonization pressure, availability of payments when titled communities maintain forests, and limited opportunities for commercial agriculture. We match plots in program areas with similar plots outside program areas on covariates that influence the conversion of forests. Based on matched comparisons, we do not find evidence that land titling or community management plans reduced forest loss in the five years following legal recognition. The results call into question land titling as a direct deforestation strategy and suggests land titling is better viewed a precursor to other programs. (C) 2015 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd

Participation in biocultural diversity conservation : insights from five Amazonian examples

Unidad de excelencia María de Maeztu CEX2019-000940-MThe past three decades have seen the emergence of myriads of initiatives focused on conserving, revitalizing, and maintaining Indigenous and Local Knowledge (ILK) as part of biocultural approaches to conservation. However, the extent to which these efforts have been participatory has been often overlooked. In this chapter, we focus on five prominent ILK conservation initiatives in the Amazon Basin to examine the participation of Indigenous Peoples and Local Communities (IPLCs) in ILK conservation. Our review illustrates several examples of ILK conservation initiatives offering substantial opportunities for meaningful IPLC participation over the long term. Overall, our case studies suggest that the development of robust and inclusive decision-making processes is essential to optimize IPLC participation in ILK conservation, thereby increasing the legitimacy of these initiatives. Our review is not an exhaustive account of the breadth and depth of all initiatives promoting participatory biocultural conservation in this region, but it illustrates that there are many strategies that can help foster IPLC engagement and lead the participatory turn in biocultural conservation

Mapping, quantifying and assessing the effects of different social factors underlying recent trends in tropical forest cover change and biocultural conservation A case study on the ancestral lands of Tsimane' Amerindians (Bolivian Amazon)

Los bosques tropicales juegan un papel clave en la conservación de la biodiversidad, la regulación hidrológica, el clima regional y global, y son vitales para el sustento de sus habitantes. Sin embargo, la extensión actual y la intensidad de los cambios de usos del suelo y de cobertura en los bosques tropicales están propiciando su pérdida, fragmentación y degradación a un ritmo alarmante. Por lo tanto, comprender los factores subyacentes a la pérdida y al empobrecimiento de los bosques tropicales es un asunto de enorme importancia para que se puedan implementar políticas de conservación más eficaces. En esta tesis doctoral llevo a cabo un estudio de caso sobre las tierras ancestrales de indígenas Tsimane', una sociedad indígena de cazadores-recolectores y agricultores nativos de la Amazonía boliviana, con los objetivos principales de cartografiar, cuantificar y evaluar los efectos de diferentes factores sociales que subyacen a las tendencias recientes en el cambio de la cubierta forestal y los niveles de conservación biológica y cultural. En concreto, dedico el primer capítulo de investigación a elaborar un enfoque eficaz para mapear con precisión clases generales de usos del suelo/cobertura, que incluyen tanto los bosques en regeneración como los maduros, como base para la evaluación de las tendencias en el cambio de la cubierta forestal y del grado de conservación forestal. En el segundo capítulo de investigación evalúo el efecto de diferentes sistemas de tenencia de la tierra en el cambio de la cubierta forestal, mientras que en el tercero investigo el papel potencial del conocimiento ecológico tradicional indígena en la conservación de los bosques maduros, en un momento en que el conocimiento se está perdiendo debido a un proceso de aculturación rápida. Aunque la tenencia de la tierra y el cambio cultural pueden ser factores subyacentes a los cambios en la cobertura forestal, y por tanto determinantes de su grado de conservación, hasta la fecha sus efectos no han sido adecuadamente examinados, por lo que esta tesis doctoral tiene como objetivo contribuir a la escasa investigación existente sobre estos temas. Los Tsimane' constituyen un excelente caso de estudio para lograr los objetivos de esta tesis porque sus asentamientos están dispersos en diferentes sistemas de tenencia de la tierra, y porque muestran la mayor variación entre los nativos amazónicos bolivianos con respecto a la integración del mercado, lo que también se refleja en una gran variación en cuanto a conocimientos ecológicos tradicionales y aculturación. Además, debido a que han sido ampliamente estudiados en los últimos 15 años y a que hay estudios históricos acerca de ellos, puedo recurrir a los datos y resultados existentes para interpretar mejor mis resultados. Mis resultados contribuyen a mejorar los métodos existentes para mapear y cuantificar los cambios de usos del suelo y de cubiertas en paisajes tropicales heterogéneos, lo cual es difícil y sin embargo fundamental para mejorar las estimaciones de carbono en bosques, las evaluaciones sobre biodiversidad, la gestión de los recursos naturales, y la planificación territorial. Además, uso un enfoque novedoso para integrar y analizar los datos derivados de las imágenes de satélite con datos obtenidos encuestas sociales, lo cual continúa siendo una tarea complicada en la ciencia del cambio de usos del suelo y de cubiertas. A nivel teórico, mis resultados proporcionan nuevos conocimientos sobre los efectos de la tenencia de la tierra y el conocimiento indígena en la conservación de los bosques tropicales, que son factores todavía poco conocidos tanto en la cuenca del Amazonas como otros lugares. Mis resultados tienen implicaciones importantes para las políticas públicas para el desarrollo socioeconómico y la conservación del medio ambiente en la Amazonía y doy algunas recomendaciones en materia de políticas públicas, desde una perspectiva de conservación biocultural. Por ejemplo, mis resultados sobre los efectos de la tenencia de la tierra sobre los cambios en la cubierta forestal demuestran que los territorios indígenas puede ser tan eficaces como las áreas protegidas para la conservación forestal, lo que sugiere los beneficios de ampliar el número y/o tamaño de los territorios indígenas, y la necesidad de fortalecer la gobernanza indígena. Los resultados también muestran que las concesiones madereras pueden ser muy eficaces para prevenir los bosques de la deforestación, y que algún incentivo de conservación es necesario en terrenos privados para reducir sus altos niveles (y crecientes) de la deforestación y la degradación forestal. En cuanto al papel del conocimiento ecológico tradicional de los pueblos indígenas en la conservación forestal, mis resultados muestran que los niveles de ambos están significativamente asociados, y que existe entre ellos una superposición espacial muy importante, algo que no había sido evaluado con rigor a escala local, y que puede sugerir la existencia de un conexión funcional entre la diversidad cultural y biológica. Este hallazgo implica que las políticas de conservación forestal deben buscar también la protección del conocimiento indígena, lo cual tiene importantes implicaciones para los derechos indígenas sobre la tierra y los recursos naturales.Tropical forests play a key role in biodiversity conservation, hydrological regulation, regional and global climate, and are vital to support the livelihoods of their dwellers. Nevertheless, the current extent and intensity of land use/cover change in tropical forests is driving their loss, fragmentation, and degradation at alarming rates. Therefore, it is a matter of the utmost importance to understand the underlying driving forces of loss and impoverishment of tropical forests so that more effective conservation policies can be enacted. In this PhD thesis I carry out a case study on the ancestral lands of Tsimane' Amerindians, an indigenous society of hunter-gatherers and farmers native to the Bolivian Amazon, with the primary goals of mapping, quantifying and assessing the effects of different social factors underlying recent trends in forest cover change and levels of biological and cultural conservation. Specifically, I devote the first research chapter to devise an efficient remote sensing classification approach to accurately map broad land cover classes, including both early-growth and old-growth forests, as a basis for the assessments of trends in forest cover change and of forest conservation. In the second research chapter I assess the effects of different land tenure systems on forest cover change, while in the third one I evaluate the potential role of indigenous traditional ecological knowledge in old-growth forest conservation at a time such knowledge is being lost due to a rapid acculturation process. Although land tenure and cultural change may underlie tropical forest cover change and thus forest conservation, to date their effects have not been adequately examined, and this PhD thesis aims to contribute to previous research on such topics. The Tsimane' constitute an excellent case study to accomplish the goals of this thesis because their settlements are currently scattered across different land tenure systems, and because they display the largest variation amongst native Bolivian Amazonians regarding market integration, which also reflects on a great variation regarding traditional ecological knowledge and acculturation. Also, because they have been extensively studied in the last 15 years and there are historical studies about them, so I can draw on previous data and results to better interpret my findings. My results contribute to improving methods for mapping and quantifying land use/cover change in tropical heterogeneous landscapes, which is challenging and nevertheless critical to enhance carbon mapping, biodiversity assessments, natural resource management, and territorial planning. In addition, I use a novel approach to integrate and analyze data derived from remote sensing imagery with data obtained from social surveys, which remains a challenging task in land change science. At a theoretical level, my findings provide new insights into the effects of land tenure and indigenous knowledge on tropical forest conservation, which are factors still poorly understood in the Amazon basin and elsewhere. My results have significant implications for public policies aimed at socioeconomic development and environmental conservation in the Amazon and I give some policy recommendations drawn from a biocultural conservation perspective. For instance, my results on the effects of land tenure on forest cover change show that indigenous territories may be as effective as protected areas for forest conservation, which suggests the benefits of expanding the number and/or size of indigenous territories and the need of strengthening indigenous governance. Results also show that logging concessions may be very effective to prevent forest from clear-cutting, and that conservation incentives are needed in private lands to curtail their high and increasing levels of deforestation and forest degradation. As regards the role of indigenous traditional ecological knowledge in forest conservation, I find both their levels are significantly associated, and that there is a very significant spatial overlap, something that had not been assessed at the local scale, and that suggests the existence of a functional connection between both cultural and biological diversity. This finding implies that forest conservation policies should proceed hand in hand with the protection of indigenous knowledge, which has important implications for indigenous rights to land and natural resources management