Valuing improvements in the water rights system in South Africa : a contingent ranking approach

In the context of increasing water scarcity, understanding is growing that irrigation water rights are important and that a lack of effective water rights systems constitute a major reason for inefficient water management. This study carried out a contingent ranking experiment to study how smallholder irrigators in South Africa would value potential changes in water rights. Three specific dimensions of water rights, relevant for the South African case, are considered: duration, quality of title and transferability. Results indicate that smallholder irrigators are prepared to pay considerably higher water prices if improvements are made in the water rights system. This implies that the proposed interventions in the water rights system would improve the efficiency and productivity of the small-scale irrigation sector. The increased willingness to pay could furthermore also assist South African government to reach the objective of increased cost recovery

Needs, Rights and Responsibilities in Water Governance: Some Reflections

This article discusses needs, rights and responsibilities with regard to water, drawing on global discourses and cases from South Africa. Taking the New Delhi and Dublin Statements as a point of departure, it describes the prevalent global discourses and sets of dichotomies that have characterised much of the water governance debates, such as human right/economic good, public/private, formal/informal, etc. It explores the boundaries of responsibilities between actors, and argues that, rather than an ‘either/or’ approach, new constellations of governance arrangements need to be sought in urban and rural settings, that acknowledge the differential needs of people and communities. While water is a public, justiciable socioeconomic good, the provision of which should lie ultimately with the government, there are myriad constellations across the spectrum of public to private provision that can meet the challenges. The dichotomies, and in particular the idea of ‘public’ and ‘private’, are only useful to a limited extent, as there are many ‘publics’ and many ‘privates’. The question is not so much who offers the service, but how it is offered or organised, how and by whom needs are defined and contested, to what extent needs are met or not, and how clear lines of accountability are established

Preferences for Domestic Water Services in the Middle Olifants Sub-Basin of South Africa

Using household survey data, this study investigates preferences for domestic water services in the Middle Olifants sub-basin of South Africa. Water is a relatively scarce resource in South Africa that is distributed unevenly both geographically and seasonally as well as sociopolitically. For a water management addressing the policy objectives of efficiency in use, equity in access and benefits and long-term sustainability, economic valuation of the different water uses is required. In order to detect households' preferences, a choice experiment of the various water services was conducted. Results suggested the presence of preference heterogeneity and therefore, a latent class model was applied, dividing households into homogeneous groups according to their preferences. Four distinct groups of households could be identified which differ significantly in terms of their socio-economic characteristics, their attitudes toward pricing of water and their satisfaction with current water service levels. Willingness to pay (WTP) estimates of different water service characteristics in all groups indicate that households are willing to pay higher prices for a better and more reliable water services provision. But the amount households are willing to pay differs among the groups. This information is helpful for policy-makers to enable the design of water services in the Middle Olifants according to preferences of local households. Besides, WTP estimation can provide a basis for setting water tariffs

Transforming water resources management in South Africa. 'Catchment management agencies' and the ideal of democratic development

This article addresses the dilemma of the democratic development of water resources management in the context of Post-Apartheid South Africa and unequal access to water. Using a political sociology of public policy approach as a conceptual framework, this article focuses on the actual functioning of the catchment management agencies (CMAs). On the basis of case studies’ analysis, it is argued that CMAs are essentially political arenas although the semi-structured interviews conducted reveal that this political dimension is mainly denied by most of CMAs members and staff as well as by policy makers. Finally, the risks of professionalising interest representation within CMAs are evoked.The French Embassy of South Africa and the South African Department of Science and Technology as part of the Joint South African–French network for research in science and technology—SAFeWater Arise project : New Water Governance over Water Resources for Sustainable Rural Development : Research on Social, Economic and Institutional Aspects.http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/journal/10.1002/(ISSN)1099-1328hb2016Agricultural Economics, Extension and Rural Developmen

Vegetation structure and effects of human use of Dambos ecosystem in northern Mozambique

Original research articleThe Niassa National Reserve (NNR) is the most extensive conservation area in Mozambique and the third largest in Africa, encompassing 42,000 km2 of endemic miombo vegetation. Dambos wetlands occur within the wooded grassland and grassland vegetation of NNR and provide a wide range of Ecosystem Services (ES), including life support for animal species, regulation of water flow and prevention of soil erosion. It also generates income for the livelihoods of local communities by providing land for agriculture and harvesting of non-timber products. The dynamics of these ecosystems is poorly understood despite the contribution of the dambos to global biodiversity and ES. This research is the first preliminary assessment of the vegetation structure and composition of six dambos within NNR, selected using Google Earth, MODIS satellite images and an exploratory field visit. Field data collection was performed using a two-stage systematic sampling approach, along transect lines of 100 10m (0.1 ha), perpendicular to the dambos' flow. Square plots of 0.25m2 were established for grass survey within the transects where grass vegetation was measured, counted and identified. Data were analyzed with R software. The sociological position of each species was analyzed with regard to the vertical structure while for horizontal structure, the abundance, dominance, frequency and Importance Value Index (IVI) were determined. In order to understand the differences between dambos, evenness (H) and reciprocal of Simpson's heterogeneity index (Hill's N2) were calculated. Principal Coordinates Analysis (PCoA) and Cluster Analysis were also used to characterize the surveyed species communities. A total of 58 transects (5.8 ha) and 336 subplots were assessed, recording 110 woody and 73 grass species, respectively. The most common tree species were Vitex doniana, Burkea africana, Syzygium cordatum and Annona senegalensis, while for grass vegetation the most abundant species were Andropogon eucomus and Helictotrichon turgidulum. According to the IVI, the most dominant tree and shrub species were V. doniana, Pseudolachnostylis maprouneifolia, A. senegalensis and S. cordatum. Homogeneity (Hill's N2 ¼18.92) and evenness (H¼ 4.27) were, on average, low in all dambos. Dambo 2 was the most heterogeneous (Hill's N2 ¼18.21) while dambo 1 was the least heterogeneous (Hill's N2 ¼ 5.71). Dambo 6 was most equitable (H¼ 1.35) whereas dambo 2 the least equitable (H¼ 3.72). Using species abundance and based on PCoA and cluster analysis, four main groups of dambos were identified based mainly on the water gradient, with data variation captured by the first three axes reaching almost 83%. The p-value (0.42), suggested no significant differences between species communities in the dambos, and thus, human disturbances appear not to be enough to modify dambos microenvironment. Accordingly, the results suggest that human activities, at this level, do not necessarily affect the structure and diversity of dambos in the NNR. The results also suggest that the species A. senegalensis, Combretum psidioides, Crossopteryx febrifuga, Protea nitida, P. maprouneifolia and S. cordatum can be used as indicator dambo species in NNR, with high likelihood of occurrenceinfo:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersio

Economic Analysis of Water Supply Cost Structure in the Middle Olifants Sub-Basin of South Africa

Using data gathered from the National Treasury of South Africa, we examine the structure of water supply costs and tariffs of Water Service Authorities (WSAs) in the Middle Olifants sub-basin of South Africa. Using the translog cost function method, the marginal cost of water supply and economies of scale are estimated. Comparison of tariffs and marginal costs show that the estimated marginal cost is higher than the actual tariff paid by consumers. This implies that WSAs in the Middle Olifants are not charging enough to recover the costs of the water services. Thus, among other things, pricing of water at its marginal cost would partly assist in solving the cost recovery problem. Raised tariffs would in turn contribute to improved efficiency of water use. As evidenced by estimation results of returns to scale (greater than one), merger of WSAs would be economically advantageous. Hence, reversing the process of transferring water services’ authority to ‘local’ municipality level and thus up-scaling WSAs into the ‘district’ municipality level is an important policy option for improving water services efficiency in the Middle Olifants sub-basin of South Africa

Contamination of rural surface and ground water by endosulfan in farming areas of the Western Cape, South Africa

BACKGROUND: In South Africa there is little data on environmental pollution of rural water sources by agrochemicals. METHODS: This study investigated pesticide contamination of ground and surface water in three intensive agricultural areas in the Western Cape: the Hex River Valley, Grabouw and Piketberg. Monitoring for endosulfan and chlorpyrifos at low levels was conducted as well as screening for other pesticides. RESULTS: The quantification limit for endosulfan was 0.1 μg/L. Endosulfan was found to be widespread in ground water, surface water and drinking water. The contamination was mostly at low levels, but regularly exceeded the European Drinking Water Standard of 0.1 μg/L. The two most contaminated sites were a sub-surface drain in the Hex River Valley and a dam in Grabouw, with 0.83 ± 1.0 μg/L (n = 21) and 3.16 ± 3.5 μg/L (n = 13) average endosulfan levels respectively. Other pesticides including chlorpyrifos, azinphos-methyl, fenarimol, iprodione, deltamethrin, penconazole and prothiofos were detected. Endosulfan was most frequently detected in Grabouw (69%) followed by Hex River (46%) and Piketberg (39%). Detections were more frequent in surface water (47%) than in groundwater (32%) and coincided with irrigation, and to a lesser extent, to spraying and trigger rains. Total dietary endosulfan intake calculated from levels found in drinking water did not exceed the Joint WHO/FAO Meeting on Pesticide Residues (JMPR) criteria. CONCLUSION: The study has shown the need for monitoring of pesticide contamination in surface and groundwater, and the development of drinking water quality standards for specific pesticides in South Africa

Environmental benefits of improved water and nitrogen management in irrigated sugar cane : a combined crop modelling and life cycle assessment approach

The application of irrigation water and nitrogen (N) fertilizer in excess of crop demand reduces profitability and has multiple detrimental impacts on the environment. N dynamics in agroecosystems are extremely complex, and mechanistic crop models are most often required to quantify the impact of improved management practices on reducing fertilizer N losses. In this study, Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) methodology and mechanistic modelling was used to quantify the environmental benefits of improved management of water and fertilizer N by sugarcane farmers in a case study in Pongola, South Africa. A baseline scenario, representing farmer intuition-based irrigation scheduling management, and two additional scenarios in which water, and water and N were more rationally managed, were compared. Results show that improved water and N management can lead to a 20% reduction in non-renewable energy consumption per functional unit (FU), with sustained or even increased yields. Total GHG emissions can potentially be reduced by 25% through more efficient water and N management. Limiting the rates of fertilizer N applied, made possible by decreasing N leaching through improved irrigation scheduling, resulted in the highest reductions for both impact categories. While total water consumption was very similar between the scenarios, more efficient use of rainfall was achieved through accurate scheduling, reducing blue water requirements. Through the simultaneous consideration of multiple environmental impacts, combining mechanistic crop modelling and LCA shows potential to identify improved management practices as well as to establish environmental stewardship incentives.L'application d'eau d'irrigation et d'engrais azotés (N) en excès par rapport à la demande des cultures réduit la profitabilité et a de multiples impacts négatifs sur l'environnement. La dynamique de l'azote dans les agrosystèmes est extrèmement complexe, et des modèles de culture mécanistes sont souvent nécessaires pour quantifier l'impact de pratiques de gestion améliorées sur la réduction des pertes en azote. Cette étude utilise la méthodologie de l'Analyse du Cycle de Vie (ACV) combinée à la modélisation mécaniste pour quantifier les bénéfices environnementaux d'une gestion améliorée de l'eau et des fertilisants azotés par des producteurs de canne à sucre, dans une étude de cas à Pongola, Afrique du Sud. Un scénario de base représente les pratiques courantes et intuitives des producteurs en termes d'irrigation, et deux scénarios supplémentaires représentent des pratiques de gestion plus rationnelles de l'eau, et de l'eau et des engrais, respectivement. Les résultats montrent qu'une meilleure gestion de l'eau et de l'azote peut générer une réduction de 20% de la consommation en énergie non-renouvelable, avec des rendements maintenus voire améliorés. Les émissions totales de GES peuvent potentiellement être réduites de 25%. La réduction des applications d'engrais, rendue possible par le moindre lessivage de l'azote sous irrigation raisonnée, résulte en de fortes réductions de ces deux catégories d'impacts. La consommation totale en eau est similaire entre scénario de base et scénarios de meilleure gestion de l'eau; cependant l'utilisation de l'eau de pluie est plus efficiente avec les irrigations raisonnées, réduisant ainsi les besoins d'extraction de la ressource. Par la prise en compte simultanée d'impacts environnementaux multiples, la combinaison de l'ACV et de la modélisation mécaniste de culture montre un potentiel pour identifier les pratiques améliorées et pour développer un accompagnement en éco-conception de systèmes.http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/journal/10.1002/(ISSN)1531-03612016-04-30hb201