Incongruent phylogenetic hypotheses and character conflicts in morphology : the root and early branches of the hexapodan tree

Before the turn of the millenium the investigation of phylogenetic relationships was revolutionized by two major inputs, the use of molecular sequence data for phylogenetic reconstruction, paralleled by the sophistication of computer aided reconstruction methods. The ever growing number of data however did not only result in clarifications of open questions, but brought forth a number of new conflicting phylogenetic hypotheses. Sometimes they are wrongly referred to as conflicts between morphological and molecular approaches, which sporadically even culminated in the rejection of the usefulness of one of the two approaches (e.g. Scotland et al 2003). These scientists overlook the great advantage of having two a priori largely independent data sets (Wägele 2001) which in a synthetic way enable the greatest progress in phylogenetic research. However, solely putting data together will not suffice to choose among conflicting hypotheses. The increasing number of conflicts necessitates approaches that go beyond mere data congruence, but searching for the possible reasons of conflicts. In the present paper, problems in the reconstruction of the phylogenetic origin of Hexapoda, as well as of the early branchings within the Hexapoda, will exemplify approaches of critical re-evaluation and testing of data used in morphological data matrices for phylogenetic analyses. The early cladogenetic events of hexapods are especially suited for such a discussion for several reasons. The hexapods, as the most species-rich group of organisms, look back at a long and multi-faceted history of taxonomic and phylogenetic studies, culminating in a number of conflicting hypotheses. Triggered by incongruences with morphological analyses the reconstruction of the hexapodan roots likewise became a hot-spot of molecular research activities during^the last two decades. Furthermore the phylogenetic positions of the oldest lineages branching off within the hexapodan clade, the Diplura, Protura and Collembola, are in particular very difficult to reconstruct. While at least the latter two are well defined by morphological autapomorphies their phylogenetic position could not be reconstructed unambiguously, since their morphology seems highly derived with respect to the hexapodan ground pattern.Angestoßen durch molekulare Untersuchungen sind die Verwandtschaftsverhältnisse der Großgruppen der Arthropoden in der letzten Dekade ein Hotspot der phylogenetischen Diskussion geworden. Ein heiß diskutiertes Thema ist die Frage nach der Monophylie der Insekten. Die in diesem Zusammenhang besonders interessanten „Ur-Insekten“ bilden eine morphologisch sehr heterogene Gruppe von primär flügellosen Insekten. Während die Annahme verwandtschaftlicher Beziehungen der Archaeognatha und Zygentoma zu den Pterygota (Ectognatha) breite Unterstützung finden, gibt es widersprüchliche Hypothesen hinsichtlich der phylogenetischen Stellung der Collembola, Protura und Diplura. Zu heftigen Diskussionen haben die Analysen mitochondrialer Gene durch Nardi et al. (2003) geführt. In den rekonstruierten Bäumen sind die Ectognatha näher verwandt mit Crustaceen als mit Collembolen, wodurch die Hexapoden eine paraphyletische Gruppierung werden. Dieser Befund hat eine Flut von neuen molekularen Untersuchungen ausgelöst und nahezu alle denkbaren Kombinationen der Verwandtschaftsbeziehungen zwischen Collembola, Protura, Diplura und Ectognatha haben Unterstützung gefunden. Kann die Morphologie zur Klärung dieser phylogenetischen Konflikte entscheidend beitragen? Sind die Hexapoden wirklich ein Monophylum oder ist die Hexapodie mehrfach unabhängig voneinander entstanden? Nach Diskussion ausgewählter Konflikte zur phylogenetischen Stellung der verschiedenen „Ur-Insekten“ werden anhand eigener Untersuchungen exemplarisch einige Probleme morphologischer Datensätze in der modernen stammesgeschichtlichen Forschung aufgezeigt und entsprechende Lösungsmöglichkeiten diskutiert

Can comprehensive background knowledge be incorporated into substitution models to improve phylogenetic analyses? A case study on major arthropod relationships

<p>Abstract</p> <p>Background</p> <p>Whenever different data sets arrive at conflicting phylogenetic hypotheses, only testable causal explanations of sources of errors in at least one of the data sets allow us to critically choose among the conflicting hypotheses of relationships. The large (28S) and small (18S) subunit rRNAs are among the most popular markers for studies of deep phylogenies. However, some nodes supported by this data are suspected of being artifacts caused by peculiarities of the evolution of these molecules. Arthropod phylogeny is an especially controversial subject dotted with conflicting hypotheses which are dependent on data set and method of reconstruction. We assume that phylogenetic analyses based on these genes can be improved further i) by enlarging the taxon sample and ii) employing more realistic models of sequence evolution incorporating non-stationary substitution processes and iii) considering covariation and pairing of sites in rRNA-genes.</p> <p>Results</p> <p>We analyzed a large set of arthropod sequences, applied new tools for quality control of data prior to tree reconstruction, and increased the biological realism of substitution models. Although the split-decomposition network indicated a high noise content in the data set, our measures were able to both improve the analyses and give causal explanations for some incongruities mentioned from analyses of rRNA sequences. However, misleading effects did not completely disappear.</p> <p>Conclusion</p> <p>Analyses of data sets that result in ambiguous phylogenetic hypotheses demand for methods, which do not only filter stochastic noise, but likewise allow to differentiate phylogenetic signal from systematic biases. Such methods can only rely on our findings regarding the evolution of the analyzed data. Analyses on independent data sets then are crucial to test the plausibility of the results. Our approach can easily be extended to genomic data, as well, whereby layers of quality assessment are set up applicable to phylogenetic reconstructions in general.</p

Four myriapod relatives – but who are sisters? No end to debates on relationships among the four major myriapod subgroups

BackgroundPhylogenetic relationships among the myriapod subgroups Chilopoda, Diplopoda, Symphyla and Pauropoda are still not robustly resolved. The first phylogenomic study covering all subgroups resolved phylogenetic relationships congruently to morphological evidence but is in conflict with most previously published phylogenetic trees based on diverse molecular data. Outgroup choice and long-branch attraction effects were stated as possible explanations for these incongruencies. In this study, we addressed these issues by extending the myriapod and outgroup taxon sampling using transcriptome data.ResultsWe generated new transcriptome data of 42 panarthropod species, including all four myriapod subgroups and additional outgroup taxa. Our taxon sampling was complemented by published transcriptome and genome data resulting in a supermatrix covering 59 species. We compiled two data sets, the first with a full coverage of genes per species (292 single-copy protein-coding genes), the second with a less stringent coverage (988 genes). We inferred phylogenetic relationships among myriapods using different data types, tree inference, and quartet computation approaches. Our results unambiguously support monophyletic Mandibulata and Myriapoda. Our analyses clearly showed that there is strong signal for a single unrooted topology, but a sensitivity of the position of the internal root on the choice of outgroups. However, we observe strong evidence for a clade Pauropoda+Symphyla, as well as for a clade Chilopoda+Diplopoda.ConclusionsOur best quartet topology is incongruent with current morphological phylogenies which were supported in another phylogenomic study. AU tests and quartet mapping reject the quartet topology congruent to trees inferred with morphological characters. Moreover, quartet mapping shows that confounding signal present in the data set is sufficient to explain the weak signal for the quartet topology derived from morphological characters. Although outgroup choice affects results, our study could narrow possible trees to derivatives of a single quartet topology. For highly disputed relationships, we propose to apply a series of tests (AU and quartet mapping), since results of such tests allow to narrow down possible relationships and to rule out confounding signal

TOI-4336 A b:A temperate sub-Neptune ripe for atmospheric characterization in a nearby triple M-dwarf system

Small planets transiting bright nearby stars are essential to our understanding of the formation and evolution of exoplanetary systems. However, few constitute prime targets for atmospheric characterization, and even fewer are part of multiple star systems. This work aims to validate TOI-4336 A b, a sub-Neptune-sized exoplanet candidate identified by the TESS space-based transit survey around a nearby M-dwarf. We validate the planetary nature of TOI-4336 A b through the global analysis of TESS and follow-up multi-band high-precision photometric data from ground-based telescopes, medium- and high-resolution spectroscopy of the host star, high-resolution speckle imaging, and archival images. The newly discovered exoplanet TOI-4336 A b has a radius of 2.1±0.1R⊕. Its host star is an M3.5-dwarf star of mass 0.33±0.01M⊙ and radius 0.33±0.02R⊙ member of a hierarchical triple M-dwarf system 22 pc away from the Sun. The planet's orbital period of 16.3 days places it at the inner edge of the Habitable Zone of its host star, the brightest of the inner binary pair. The parameters of the system make TOI-4336 A b an extremely promising target for the detailed atmospheric characterization of a temperate sub-Neptune by transit transmission spectroscopy with JWST

Search for new particles in events with energetic jets and large missing transverse momentum in proton-proton collisions at root s=13 TeV

A search is presented for new particles produced at the LHC in proton-proton collisions at root s = 13 TeV, using events with energetic jets and large missing transverse momentum. The analysis is based on a data sample corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 101 fb(-1), collected in 2017-2018 with the CMS detector. Machine learning techniques are used to define separate categories for events with narrow jets from initial-state radiation and events with large-radius jets consistent with a hadronic decay of a W or Z boson. A statistical combination is made with an earlier search based on a data sample of 36 fb(-1), collected in 2016. No significant excess of events is observed with respect to the standard model background expectation determined from control samples in data. The results are interpreted in terms of limits on the branching fraction of an invisible decay of the Higgs boson, as well as constraints on simplified models of dark matter, on first-generation scalar leptoquarks decaying to quarks and neutrinos, and on models with large extra dimensions. Several of the new limits, specifically for spin-1 dark matter mediators, pseudoscalar mediators, colored mediators, and leptoquarks, are the most restrictive to date.Peer reviewe

Combined searches for the production of supersymmetric top quark partners in proton-proton collisions at root s=13 TeV

A combination of searches for top squark pair production using proton-proton collision data at a center-of-mass energy of 13 TeV at the CERN LHC, corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 137 fb(-1) collected by the CMS experiment, is presented. Signatures with at least 2 jets and large missing transverse momentum are categorized into events with 0, 1, or 2 leptons. New results for regions of parameter space where the kinematical properties of top squark pair production and top quark pair production are very similar are presented. Depending on themodel, the combined result excludes a top squarkmass up to 1325 GeV for amassless neutralino, and a neutralinomass up to 700 GeV for a top squarkmass of 1150 GeV. Top squarks with masses from 145 to 295 GeV, for neutralino masses from 0 to 100 GeV, with a mass difference between the top squark and the neutralino in a window of 30 GeV around the mass of the top quark, are excluded for the first time with CMS data. The results of theses searches are also interpreted in an alternative signal model of dark matter production via a spin-0 mediator in association with a top quark pair. Upper limits are set on the cross section for mediator particle masses of up to 420 GeV

Probing effective field theory operators in the associated production of top quarks with a Z boson in multilepton final states at root s=13 TeV

Peer reviewe

Observation of tW production in the single-lepton channel in pp collisions at root s=13 TeV

A measurement of the cross section of the associated production of a single top quark and a W boson in final states with a muon or electron and jets in proton-proton collisions at root s = 13 TeV is presented. The data correspond to an integrated luminosity of 36 fb(-1) collected with the CMS detector at the CERN LHC in 2016. A boosted decision tree is used to separate the tW signal from the dominant t (t) over bar background, whilst the subleading W+jets and multijet backgrounds are constrained using data-based estimates. This result is the first observation of the tW process in final states containing a muon or electron and jets, with a significance exceeding 5 standard deviations. The cross section is determined to be 89 +/- 4 (stat) +/- 12 (syst) pb, consistent with the standard model.Peer reviewe

Measurements of the Electroweak Diboson Production Cross Sections in Proton-Proton Collisions at root s=5.02 TeV Using Leptonic Decays

The first measurements of diboson production cross sections in proton-proton interactions at a center-of-mass energy of 5.02 TeV are reported. They are based on data collected with the CMS detector at the LHC, corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 302 pb(-1). Events with two, three, or four charged light leptons (electrons or muons) in the final state are analyzed. The WW, WZ, and ZZ total cross sections are measured as sigma(WW) = 37:0(-5.2)(+5.5) (stat)(-2.6)(+2.7) (syst) pb, sigma(WZ) = 6.4(-2.1)(+2.5) (stat)(-0.3)(+0.5)(syst) pb, and sigma(ZZ) = 5.3(-2.1)(+2.5)(stat)(-0.4)(+0.5) (syst) pb. All measurements are in good agreement with theoretical calculations at combined next-to-next-to-leading order quantum chromodynamics and next-to-leading order electroweak accuracy