Pasteurella multocida toxin type D serological assay as an alternative to the toxin neutralisation lethality test in mice

The objective of this work was to develop an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for the detection of antibodies against Pasteurella multocida toxin type D, that correlated to a mouse lethality test. Currently, the mouse lethality test is one of several tests used world-wide to evaluate serological responses in animals immunised with vaccines containing toxoids. The mouse lethality test involves injecting mice with a mixture of toxin and test serum sample (from animals that have been vaccinated with a toxoid), and then determining antibody titre of the test serum from the number of mice that survive. Thus, the titre calculated is based on the neutralising activity of the test serum. The mouse lethality test requires large numbers of animals and causes severe distress to the animals. Organisations world-wide are working towards alternatives to animals in the development and control of biological products for human and veterinary use. Additionally, the mouse lethality test is labour-intensive, costly and lacks robustness and may be difficult to reproduce between different technicians. We have developed a double sandwich ELISA to measure anti- P. multocida toxoid type D antibodies in swine serum. Sera from swine immunised with vaccines containing type D toxoid showed good correlation to the mouse lethality assay (Spearman analysis=0.94 and Pearson analysis=0.84). When compared to the mouse lethality test, titres obtained using the ELISA format had higher correlation with protective immunity (i.e., lower turbinate atrophy) following challenge with virulent P. multocida. The ELISA assay is more robust, reproducible and costs less than the mouse lethality assay; and it complements efforts to reduce the use of animals in testing