A laboratory study of railway ballast behaviour under traffic loading and tamping maintenance

Since it is difficult to conduct railway ballast testing in-situ, it is important to simulate the conditions experienced in the real track environment and study their influences on ballast in a controlled experimental manner. In this research, extensive laboratory tests were performed on three types of ballast, namely granites A and B and limestone. The grading of the tested ballast conforms to the grading specification in The Railway Specification RT/CE/S/006 Issue 3 (2000). The major laboratory tests in this research were used to simulate the traffic loading and tamping maintenance undertaken by the newly developed Railway Test Facility (RTF) and large-scale triaxial test facility. The Railway Test Facility is a railway research facility that is housed in a 2.1 m (width) x 4.1 m (length) x 1.9 m (depth) concrete pit and comprises subgrade material, ballast, and three sleepers. The sleepers are loaded with out of phase sinusoidal loading to simulate traffic loading. The ballast in the facility can also be tamped by a tamping bank which is a modified real Plasser tamping machine. Ballast breakage in the RTF was quantified by placing columns of painted ballast beneath a pair of the tamping tines, in the location where the other pair of tamping tines squeeze, and under the rail seating. The painted ballast was collected by hand and sieved after each test. It was found from the RTF tests that the amount of breakage generated from the tests was not comparable to the fouling in the real track environment. This is because the external input (such as wagon spillage and airborne dirt) which is the major source of fouling material was not included in the tests. Furthermore, plunging of the tamping tines caused more damage to the ballast than squeezing. The tested ballast was also subjected to Los Angeles Abrasion (LAA) and Micro-Deval Attrition (MDA) tests. It was found that the LAA and MDA values correlated well with the ballast damage from tamping and could indicate the durability of ballast. The large-scale triaxial test machine was specially manufactured for testing a cylindrical ballast sample with 300-mm diameter and 450-mm height and can perform both cyclic and monotonic tests with constant confining stress. Instead of using on-sample instrumentations to measure the radial movement of the sample, it measures sample volume change by measuring a head difference between the level of water that surrounds the sample and a fixed reference water level with a differential pressure transducer. The test results from cyclic tests were related to the simulated traffic loading test in the RTF by an elastic computer model. Even with some deficiencies, the model could relate the stress condition in the RTF to cyclic triaxial test with different confining stresses and q/p' stress ratios

A laboratory study of railway ballast behaviour under traffic loading and tamping maintenance

Since it is difficult to conduct railway ballast testing in-situ, it is important to simulate the conditions experienced in the real track environment and study their influences on ballast in a controlled experimental manner. In this research, extensive laboratory tests were performed on three types of ballast, namely granites A and B and limestone. The grading of the tested ballast conforms to the grading specification in The Railway Specification RT/CE/S/006 Issue 3 (2000). The major laboratory tests in this research were used to simulate the traffic loading and tamping maintenance undertaken by the newly developed Railway Test Facility (RTF) and large-scale triaxial test facility. The Railway Test Facility is a railway research facility that is housed in a 2.1 m (width) x 4.1 m (length) x 1.9 m (depth) concrete pit and comprises subgrade material, ballast, and three sleepers. The sleepers are loaded with out of phase sinusoidal loading to simulate traffic loading. The ballast in the facility can also be tamped by a tamping bank which is a modified real Plasser tamping machine. Ballast breakage in the RTF was quantified by placing columns of painted ballast beneath a pair of the tamping tines, in the location where the other pair of tamping tines squeeze, and under the rail seating. The painted ballast was collected by hand and sieved after each test. It was found from the RTF tests that the amount of breakage generated from the tests was not comparable to the fouling in the real track environment. This is because the external input (such as wagon spillage and airborne dirt) which is the major source of fouling material was not included in the tests. Furthermore, plunging of the tamping tines caused more damage to the ballast than squeezing. The tested ballast was also subjected to Los Angeles Abrasion (LAA) and Micro-Deval Attrition (MDA) tests. It was found that the LAA and MDA values correlated well with the ballast damage from tamping and could indicate the durability of ballast. The large-scale triaxial test machine was specially manufactured for testing a cylindrical ballast sample with 300-mm diameter and 450-mm height and can perform both cyclic and monotonic tests with constant confining stress. Instead of using on-sample instrumentations to measure the radial movement of the sample, it measures sample volume change by measuring a head difference between the level of water that surrounds the sample and a fixed reference water level with a differential pressure transducer. The test results from cyclic tests were related to the simulated traffic loading test in the RTF by an elastic computer model. Even with some deficiencies, the model could relate the stress condition in the RTF to cyclic triaxial test with different confining stresses and q/p' stress ratios

Bitumen stabilized ballast: a potential solution for railway track-bed

Railway ballast degradation under dynamic loads progressively leads to loss of mechanical performance and geometry of the track, so that maintenance interventions are frequently needed. In order to systematically avoid this issue, recently solutions have been proposed to reinforce track-bed by using polyurethane and/or resins as well as asphalt layers among others. Nonetheless, their main limitations are related to the high initial cost and low productivity. To cope with these limitations, in this study, bitumen stabilized ballast (BSB) is proposed as a new solution for ballast stabilization. This method aims at improving durability and reducing settlement by modifying both stiffness and the ability of energy dissipation of the layer. The paper introduces the potential of this technology as material to be used in railway track-beds by presenting the results of a laboratory-based investigation using the Precision Unbound Material Analyser (PUMA). Different variables such as ballast grading, bitumen emulsion dosage, compaction method and stress levels are considered. Results showed a significant decrease in permanent deformation and deformation rate associated with modified stiffness and energy dissipation properties of BSB, which suggest the potential for improving long-term performance and sustainability of ballasted track

Modelling the effects of trafficking and tamping on scaled railway ballast in triaxial tests

Most of the world’s railways are on ballasted track, which is generally used in preference to slab track because of its lower initial cost and the relative ease with which track geometry can be adjusted. However, the accumulation of track movements as a result of trafficking leads to a gradual deterioration in track line and level, hence the need for periodic corrective maintenance. This is usually by tamping; a process in which the track is lifted and vibrating tines are inserted into the ballast and moved horizontally to raise the ballast surface back to the required level. The period before further maintenance is required decreases with each tamp. This paper investigates one of the reasons for the deterioration in ballast robustness following tamping, with reference to triaxial tests on scaled ballast in which vertical loading cycles and the stress reversal caused below the railseat by tamping were simulated. It is shown that the stress reversal disrupts and loosens the vertical load bearing ballast structure developed during trafficking to support vertical train loads. On re-loading after tamping, the track settles significantly and, as a result of the loss of vertical load-bearing structure, with further load cycles rapidly returns to its reduced height. The implication is that maintenance by tamping is, on its own, disruptive to the structure and resilience of the ballast to vertical cyclic loading, and should be carried out as rarely as possible

Full scale laboratory testing of ballast and concrete slab tracks under phased cyclic loading

Full-scale laboratory-based testing is used to compare the long-term settlement performance of a precast concrete slab track section to a ballasted track (with concrete sleepers) resting on a compacted substructure. The railway track substructure is constructed from a 1.2 m deep combined subgrade and frost protection layer, according to modern high-speed rail standards such as those specified in Germany. Phased cyclic loading is then used to simulate the primary loading mechanism of a train after 3.4 million load cycles representing many years’ worth of train passages. Displacement transducers, earth pressure cells and accelerometers are employed to determine the permanent settlement, the cyclic displacement, transient stresses and vibrations of the track. The equipment, loading combinations, material properties and experimental displacement results are presented and compared. The results indicate that the ballasted track experienced 20 times more settlement when compared to the concrete slab track under the same loading conditions, even though the ballasted track was tested at a slightly higher compacted state due to the concrete slab track test being conducted first

Discrete element modelling of scaled railway ballast under triaxial conditions

The aim of this study is to demonstrate the use of tetrahedral clumps to model scaled railway ballast using the discrete element method (DEM). In experimental triaxial tests, the peak friction angles for scaled ballast are less sensitive to the confining pressure when compared to full-sized ballast. This is presumed to be due to the size effect on particle strength, whereby smaller particles are statistically stronger and exhibit less abrasion. To investigate this in DEM, the ballast is modelled using clumps with breakable asperities to produce the correct volumetric deformation. The effects of the quantity and properties of these asperities are investigated, and it is shown that the strength affects the macroscopic shear strength at both high and low confining pressures, while the effects of the number of asperities diminishes with increasing confining pressure due to asperity breakage. It is also shown that changing the number of asperities only affects the peak friction angle but not the ultimate friction angle by comparing the angles of repose of samples with different numbers of asperities

Combined Discrete-Continuum Analysis for Ballasted Rail Tracks

A study on the load-deformation behaviour of railway ballast aggregates subjected to cyclic loadings using a combined discrete-continuum modelling approach is presented. Discrete ballast particles are simulated in the DEM and the continuum-based subgrade is simulated by the FDM. Interface elements are generated to transmit contact forces and displacements between the two domains (i.e. discrete and continuum) whereby the DEM exchanges contact forces to the FDM, and then the FDM transfers the displacement back to the DEM. Distributions of contact forces, coordination number, stress contours on the subgrade and corresponding number of broken bonds (representing ballast breakage) are analysed

Central venous catheter use in severe malaria: time to reconsider the World Health Organization guidelines?

<p>Abstract</p> <p>Background</p> <p>To optimize the fluid status of adult patients with severe malaria, World Health Organization (WHO) guidelines recommend the insertion of a central venous catheter (CVC) and a target central venous pressure (CVP) of 0-5 cmH₂O. However there are few data from clinical trials to support this recommendation.</p> <p>Methods</p> <p>Twenty-eight adult Indian and Bangladeshi patients admitted to the intensive care unit with severe <it>falciparum </it>malaria were enrolled in the study. All patients had a CVC inserted and had regular CVP measurements recorded. The CVP measurements were compared with markers of disease severity, clinical endpoints and volumetric measures derived from transpulmonary thermodilution.</p> <p>Results</p> <p>There was no correlation between the admission CVP and patient outcome (p = 0.67) or disease severity (p = 0.33). There was no correlation between the baseline CVP and the concomitant extravascular lung water (p = 0.62), global end diastolic volume (p = 0.88) or cardiac index (p = 0.44). There was no correlation between the baseline CVP and the likelihood of a patient being fluid responsive (p = 0.37). On the occasions when the CVP was in the WHO target range patients were usually hypovolaemic and often had pulmonary oedema by volumetric measures. Seven of 28 patients suffered a complication of the CVC insertion, although none were fatal.</p> <p>Conclusion</p> <p>The WHO recommendation for the routine insertion of a CVC, and the maintenance of a CVP of 0-5 cmH₂O in adults with severe malaria, should be reconsidered.</p

Railway ballast anisotropy testing via true triaxial apparatus

This paper aims to demonstrate the anisotropic behaviour of railway ballast via true-triaxial tests. To do so, a novel, large-scale, true-triaxial testing apparatus (GeoTT) is designed and constructed. It consists of six hydraulic actuators, designed to apply a distributed stress to large granular cubic test specimens with dimensions: 500 mm × 500 m × 500 mm. To show the capability of the new facility, crushed granite railway ballast with d50 = 43 mm is tested. Three different confining stresses are applied to determine the Poisson’s ratio and modulus in three dimensions. Anisotropic behaviour is clearly evident, with horizontal directions showing a lower modulus compared to the vertical direction. It is also found that confining stress has an important effect on both Poisson’s ratio and modulus when the primary loading is applied in three orthogonal directions. These results are useful for understanding the behaviour of railway ballast and for the calibration of railroad numerical models