Memory disambiguation hardware: a review

One of the main challenges of modern processor designs is the implementation of scalable and efficient mechanisms to detect memory access order violations as a result of out-of-order execution. Conventional structures performing this task are complex, inefficient and power-hungry. This fact has generated a large body of work on optimizing address-based memory disambiguation logic, namely the load-store queue. In this paper we review the most significant proposals in this research field, focusing on our own contributions.Facultad de Informátic

Improving processor efficiency by exploiting common-case behaviors of memory instructions

Processor efficiency can be described with the help of a number of  desirable effects or metrics, for example, performance, power, area, design complexity and access latency. These metrics serve as valuable tools used in designing new processors and they also act as  effective standards for comparing current processors. Various factors impact the efficiency of modern out-of-order processors and one important factor is the manner in which instructions are processed through the processor pipeline. In this dissertation research, we study the impact of load and store instructions (collectively known as memory instructions) on processor efficiency,  and show how to improve efficiency by exploiting common-case or  predictable patterns in the behavior of memory instructions. The memory behavior patterns that we focus on in our research are the predictability of memory dependences, the predictability in data forwarding patterns,   predictability in instruction criticality and conservativeness in resource allocation and deallocation policies. We first design a scalable  and high-performance memory dependence predictor and then apply accurate memory dependence prediction to improve the efficiency of the fetch engine of a simultaneous multi-threaded processor. We then use predictable data forwarding patterns to eliminate power-hungry  hardware in the processor with no loss in performance.  We then move to  studying instruction criticality to improve  processor efficiency. We study the behavior of critical load instructions  and propose applications that can be optimized using  predictable, load-criticality  information. Finally, we explore conventional techniques for allocation and deallocation  of critical structures that process memory instructions and propose new techniques to optimize the same.  Our new designs have the potential to reduce  the power and the area required by processors significantly without losing  performance, which lead to efficient designs of processors.Ph.D.Committee Chair: Loh, Gabriel H.; Committee Member: Clark, Nathan; Committee Member: Jaleel, Aamer; Committee Member: Kim, Hyesoon; Committee Member: Lee, Hsien-Hsin S.; Committee Member: Prvulovic, Milo

NoSQ: Store-Load Communication without a Store Queue

This paper presents NoSQ (short for No Store Queue), a microarchitecture that performs store-load communication without a store queue and without executing stores in the out-of-order engine. NoSQ implements store-load communication using speculative memory bypassing (SMB), the dynamic short-circuiting of DEF-store-load-USE chains to DEF-USE chains. Whereas previous proposals used SMB as an opportunistic complement to conventional store queue-based forwarding, NoSQ uses SMB as a store queue replacement. NoSQ relies on two supporting mechanisms. The first is an advanced store-load bypassing predictor that for a given dynamic load can predict whether that load will bypass and the identity of the communicating store. The second is an efficient verification mechanism for both bypassed and non-bypassed loads using in-order load re-execution with an SMB-aware store vulnerability window (SVW) filter. The primary benefit of NoSQ is a simple, fast datapath that does not contain store-load forwarding hardware; all loads get their values either from the data cache or from the register file. Experiments show that this simpler design - despite being more speculative - slightly outperforms a conventional store-queue based design on most benchmarks (by 2% on average)

Reducing the LSQ and L1 data cache power consumption

In most modern processor designs, the HW dedicated to store data and instructions (memory hierarchy) has become a major consumer of power. In order to reduce this power consumption, we propose in this paper two techniques, one to filter accesses to the LSQ (Load-Store Queue) based on both timing and address information, and the other to filter accesses to the first level data cache based on a forwarding predictor. Our simulation results show that the power consumption decreases in 30-40% in each structure, with a negligible performance penalty of less than 0.1%.Presentado en el V Workshop Arquitectura, Redes y Sistemas Operativos (WARSO)Red de Universidades con Carreras en Informática (RedUNCI

Energy Efficient Load Latency Tolerance: Single-Thread Performance for the Multi-Core Era

Around 2003, newly activated power constraints caused single-thread performance growth to slow dramatically. The multi-core era was born with an emphasis on explicitly parallel software. Continuing to grow single-thread performance is still important in the multi-core context, but it must be done in an energy efficient way. One significant impediment to performance growth in both out-of-order and in-order processors is the long latency of last-level cache misses. Prior work introduced the idea of load latency tolerance---the ability to dynamically remove miss-dependent instructions from critical execution structures, continue execution under the miss, and re-execute miss-dependent instructions after the miss returns. However, previously proposed designs were unable to improve performance in an energy-efficient way---they introduced too many new large, complex structures and re-executed too many instructions. This dissertation describes a new load latency tolerant design that is both energy-efficient, and applicable to both in-order and out-of-order cores. Key novel features include formulation of slice re-execution as an alternative use of multi-threading support, efficient schemes for register and memory state management, and new pruning mechanisms for drastically reducing load latency tolerance\u27s dynamic execution overheads. Area analysis shows that energy-efficient load latency tolerance increases the footprint of an out-of-order core by a few percent, while cycle-level simulation shows that it significantly improves the performance of memory-bound programs. Energy-efficient load latency tolerance is more energy-efficient than---and synergistic with---existing performance technique like dynamic voltage and frequency scaling (DVFS)

Scalable hardware memory disambiguation

This dissertation deals with one of the long-standing problems in Computer Architecture – the problem of memory disambiguation. Microprocessors typically reorder memory instructions during execution to improve concurrency. Such microprocessors use hardware memory structures for memory disambiguation, known as LoadStore Queues (LSQs), to ensure that memory instruction dependences are satisfied even when the memory instructions execute out-of-order. A typical LSQ implementation (circa 2006) holds all in-flight memory instructions in a physically centralized LSQ and performs a fully associative search on all buffered instructions to ensure that memory dependences are satisfied. These LSQ implementations do not scale because they use large, fully associative structures, which are known to be slow and power hungry. The increasing trend towards distributed microarchitectures further exacerbates these problems. As on-chip wire delays increase and high-performance processors become necessarily distributed, centralized structures such as the LSQ can limit scalability. This dissertation describes techniques to create scalable LSQs in both centralized and distributed microarchitectures. The problems and solutions described in this thesis are motivated and validated by real system designs. The dissertation starts with a description of the partitioned primary memory system of the TRIPS processor, of which the LSQ is an important component, and then through a series of optimizations describes how the power, area, and centralization problems of the LSQ can be solved with minor performance losses (if at all) even for large number of in flight memory instructions. The four solutions described in this dissertation — partitioning, filtering, late binding and efficient overflow management — enable power-, area-efficient, distributed and scalable LSQs, which in turn enable aggressive large-window processors capable of simultaneously executing thousands of instructions. To mitigate the power problem, we replaced the power-hungry, fully associative search with a power-efficient hash table lookup using a simple address-based Bloom filter. Bloom filters are probabilistic data structures used for testing set membership and can be used to quickly check if an instruction with the same data address is likely to be found in the LSQ without performing the associative search. Bloom filters typically eliminate more than 80% of the associative searches and they are highly effective because in most programs, it is uncommon for loads and stores to have the same data address and be in execution simultaneously. To rectify the area problem, we observe the fact that only a small fraction of all memory instructions are dependent, that only such dependent instructions need to be buffered in the LSQ, and that these instructions need to be in the LSQ only for certain parts of the pipelined execution. We propose two mechanisms to exploit these observations. The first mechanism, area filtering, is a hardware mechanism that couples Bloom filters and dependence predictors to dynamically identify and buffer only those instructions which are likely to be dependent. The second mechanism, late binding, reduces the occupancy and hence size of the LSQ. Both of these optimizations allows the number of LSQ slots to be reduced by up to one-half compared to a traditional organization without any performance degradation. Finally, we describe a new decentralized LSQ design for handling LSQ structural hazards in distributed microarchitectures. Decentralization of LSQs, and to a large extent distributed microarchitectures with memory speculation, has proved to be impractical because of the high performance penalties associated with the mechanisms for dealing with hazards. To solve this problem, we applied classic flow-control techniques from interconnection networks for handling resource con- flicts. The first method, memory-side buffering, buffers the overflowing instructions in a separate buffer near the LSQs. The second scheme, execution-side NACKing, sends the overflowing instruction back to the issue window from which it is later re-issued. The third scheme, network buffering, uses the buffers in the interconnection network between the execution units and memory to hold instructions when the LSQ is full, and uses virtual channel flow control to avoid deadlocks. The network buffering scheme is the most robust of all the overflow schemes and shows less than 1% performance degradation due to overflows for a subset of SPEC CPU 2000 and EEMBC benchmarks on a cycle-accurate simulator that closely models the TRIPS processor. The techniques proposed in this dissertation are independent, architectureneutral and their cumulative benefits result in LSQs that can be partitioned at a fine granularity and have low design complexity. Each of these partitions selectively buffers only memory instructions with true dependences and can be closely coupled with the execution units thus minimizing power, area, and latency. Such LSQ designs with near-ideal characteristics are well suited for microarchitectures with thousands of instructions in-flight and may enable even more aggressive microarchitectures in the future.Computer Science

Memory disambiguation hardware: a review

One of the main challenges of modern processor designs is the implementation of scalable and efficient mechanisms to detect memory access order violations as a result of out-of-order execution. Conventional structures performing this task are complex, inefficient and power-hungry. This fact has generated a large body of work on optimizing address-based memory disambiguation logic, namely the load-store queue. In this paper we review the most significant proposals in this research field, focusing on our own contributions.Facultad de Informátic

Design of a distributed memory unit for clustered microarchitectures

Power constraints led to the end of exponential growth in single–processor performance, which characterized the semiconductor industry for many years. Single–chip multiprocessors allowed the performance growth to continue so far. Yet, Amdahl’s law asserts that the overall performance of future single–chip multiprocessors will depend crucially on single–processor performance. In a multiprocessor a small growth in single–processor performance can justify the use of significant resources. Partitioning the layout of critical components can improve the energy–efficiency and ultimately the performance of a single processor. In a clustered microarchitecture parts of these components form clusters. Instructions are processed locally in the clusters and benefit from the smaller size and complexity of the clusters components. Because the clusters together process a single instruction stream communications between clusters are necessary and introduce an additional cost. This thesis proposes the design of a distributed memory unit and first level cache in the context of a clustered microarchitecture. While the partitioning of other parts of the microarchitecture has been well studied the distribution of the memory unit and the cache has received comparatively little attention. The first proposal consists of a set of cache bank predictors. Eight different predictor designs are compared based on cost and accuracy. The second proposal is the distributed memory unit. The load and store queues are split into smaller queues for distributed disambiguation. The mapping of memory instructions to cache banks is delayed until addresses have been calculated. We show how disambiguation can be implemented efficiently with unordered queues. A bank predictor is used to map instructions that consume memory data near the data origin. We show that this organization significantly reduces both energy usage and latency. The third proposal introduces Dispatch Throttling and Pre-Access Queues. These mechanisms avoid load/store queue overflows that are a result of the late allocation of entries. The fourth proposal introduces Memory Issue Queues, which add functionality to select instructions for execution and re-execution to the memory unit. The fifth proposal introduces Conservative Deadlock Aware Entry Allocation. This mechanism is a deadlock safe issue policy for the Memory Issue Queues. Deadlocks can result from certain queue allocations because entries are allocated out-of-order instead of in-order like in traditional architectures. The sixth proposal is the Early Release of Load Queue Entries. Architectures with weak memory ordering such as Alpha, PowerPC or ARMv7 can take advantage of this mechanism to release load queue entries before the commit stage. Together, these proposals allow significantly smaller and more energy efficient load queues without the need of energy hungry recovery mechanisms and without performance penalties. Finally, we present a detailed study that compares the proposed distributed memory unit to a centralized memory unit and confirms its advantages of reduced energy usage and of improved performance

Datacenter Traffic Control: Understanding Techniques and Trade-offs

Datacenters provide cost-effective and flexible access to scalable compute and storage resources necessary for today's cloud computing needs. A typical datacenter is made up of thousands of servers connected with a large network and usually managed by one operator. To provide quality access to the variety of applications and services hosted on datacenters and maximize performance, it deems necessary to use datacenter networks effectively and efficiently. Datacenter traffic is often a mix of several classes with different priorities and requirements. This includes user-generated interactive traffic, traffic with deadlines, and long-running traffic. To this end, custom transport protocols and traffic management techniques have been developed to improve datacenter network performance. In this tutorial paper, we review the general architecture of datacenter networks, various topologies proposed for them, their traffic properties, general traffic control challenges in datacenters and general traffic control objectives. The purpose of this paper is to bring out the important characteristics of traffic control in datacenters and not to survey all existing solutions (as it is virtually impossible due to massive body of existing research). We hope to provide readers with a wide range of options and factors while considering a variety of traffic control mechanisms. We discuss various characteristics of datacenter traffic control including management schemes, transmission control, traffic shaping, prioritization, load balancing, multipathing, and traffic scheduling. Next, we point to several open challenges as well as new and interesting networking paradigms. At the end of this paper, we briefly review inter-datacenter networks that connect geographically dispersed datacenters which have been receiving increasing attention recently and pose interesting and novel research problems.Comment: Accepted for Publication in IEEE Communications Surveys and Tutorial

高効率なメモリ順序違反検出機構に関する研究

学位の種別: 課程博士審査委員会委員 : (主査)東京大学教授 浅見 徹, 東京大学教授 坂井 修一, 東京大学准教授 田浦 健次朗, 東京大学准教授 豊田 正史, 国立情報学研究所教授 五島 正裕University of Tokyo(東京大学