NAT-resilient Gossip Peer Sampling

International audienceCet article explique comment réaliser un protocole de diffusion par gossip fonctionnant en présence de NATs

Gozar: NAT-friendly Peer Sampling with One-Hop Distributed NAT Traversal

Gossip-based peer sampling protocols have been widely used as a building block for many large-scale distributed applications. However, Network Address Translation gateways (NATs) cause most existing gossiping protocols to break down, as nodes cannot establish direct connections to nodes behind NATs (private nodes). In addition, most of the existing NAT traversal algorithms for establishing connectivity to private nodes rely on third party servers running at a well-known, public IP addresses. In this paper, we present Gozar, a gossip-based peer sampling service that: (i) provides uniform random samples in the presence of NATs, and (ii) enables direct connectivity to sampled nodes using a fully distributed NAT traversal service, where connection messages require only a single hop to connect to private nodes. We show in simulation that Gozar preserves the randomness properties of a gossip-based peer sampling service. We show the robustness of Gozar when a large fraction of nodes reside behind NATs and also in catastrophic failure scenarios. For example, if 80% of nodes are behind NATs, and 80% of the nodes fail, more than 92% of the remaining nodes stay connected. In addition, we compare Gozar with existing NAT-friendly gossip-based peer sampling services, Nylon and ARRG. We show that Gozar is the only system that supports one-hop NAT traversal, and its overhead is roughly half of Nylon’s

Shuffling with a Croupier: Nat-Aware Peer-Sampling

Despite much recent research on peer-to-peer (P2P) protocols for the Internet, there have been relatively few practical protocols designed to explicitly account for Network Address Translation gateways (NATs). Those P2P protocols that do handle NATs circumvent them using relaying and hole-punching techniques to route packets to nodes residing behind NATs. In this paper, we present Croupier, a peer sampling service (PSS) that provides uniform random samples of nodes in the presence of NATs in the network. It is the first NAT-aware PSS that works without the use of relaying or hole-punching. By removing the need for relaying and hole-punching, we decrease the complexity and overhead of our protocol as well as increase its robustness to churn and failure. We evaluated Croupier in simulation, and, in comparison with existing NAT-aware PSS’, our results show similar randomness properties, but improved robustness in the presence of both high percentages of nodes behind NATs and massive node failures. Croupier also has substantially lower protocol overhead

LayStream: composing standard gossip protocols for live video streaming

Gossip-based live streaming is a popular topic, as attested by the vast literature on the subject. Despite the particular merits of each proposal, all need to implement and deal with common challenges such as membership management, topology construction and video packets dissemination. Well-principled gossip-based protocols have been proposed in the literature for each of these aspects. Our goal is to assess the feasibility of building a live streaming system, \sys, as a composition of these existing protocols, to deploy the resulting system on real testbeds, and report on lessons learned in the process. Unlike previous evaluations conducted by simulations and considering each protocol independently, we use real deployments. We evaluate protocols both independently and as a layered composition, and unearth specific problems and challenges associated with deployment and composition. We discuss and present solutions for these, such as a novel topology construction mechanism able to cope with the specificities of a large-scale and delay-sensitive environment, but also with requirements from the upper layer. Our implementation and data are openly available to support experimental reproducibility

LiFTinG: Lightweight Freerider-Tracking Protocol in Gossip

This report presents LiFTinG, the first protocol to detect freeriders, including colluding ones, in gossip-based content dissemination systems with asymmetric data exchanges. LiFTinG relies on nodes tracking abnormal behaviors by cross-checking the history of their previous interactions, and exploits the fact that nodes pick neighbors at random to prevent colluding nodes from covering up each others' bad actions. We present a methodology to set the parameters of LiFTinG based on a theoretical analysis. In addition to simulations, we report on the deployment of LiFTinG on PlanetLab. In a 300-node system, where a stream of 674 kbps is broadcast, LiFTinG incurs a maximum overhead of only 8% while providing good results: for instance, with 10% of freeriders decreasing their contribution by 30%, LiFTinG detects 86% of the freeriders after only 30 seconds and wrongfully expels only a few honest nodes

PULP: an Adaptive Gossip-Based Dissemination Protocol for Multi-Source Message Streams

Gossip-based protocols provide a simple, scalable, and robust way to disseminate messages in large-scale systems. In such protocols, messages are spread in an epidemic manner. Gossiping may take place between nodes using push, pull, or a combination. Push-based systems achieve reasonable latency and high resilience to failures but may impose an unnecessarily large redundancy and overhead on the system. At the other extreme, pull-based protocols impose a lower overhead on the network at the price of increased latencies. A few hybrid approaches have been proposed-typically pushing control messages and pulling data-to avoid the redundancy of high-volume content and single-source streams. Yet, to the best of our knowledge, no other system intermingles push and pull in a multiple-senders scenario, in such a way that data messages of one help in carrying control messages of the other and in adaptively adjusting its rate of operation, further reducing overall cost and improving both on delays and robustness. In this paper, we propose an efficient generic push-pull dissemination protocol, Pulp, which combines the best of both worlds. Pulp exploits the efficiency of push approaches, while limiting redundant messages and therefore imposing a low overhead, as pull protocols do. Pulp leverages the dissemination of multiple messages from diverse sources: by exploiting the push phase of messages to transmit information about other disseminations, Pulp enables an efficient pulling of other messages, which themselves help in turn with the dissemination of pending messages. We deployed Pulp on a cluster and on PlanetLab. Our results demonstrate that Pulp achieves an appealing trade-off between coverage, message redundancy, and propagation delay. © 2011 Springer Science+Business Media, LLC

Diffusion en directe avec du Gossip

Video streaming has become a killer application for peer-to-peer technologies. By aggregating scarce resources such as upload bandwidth, decentralized video streaming protocols make it possible to serve a video stream to huge numbers of users while requiring very limited investments from broadcasters. In this paper, we present HEAP, a novel peer-to-peer streaming protocol designed for heterogeneous scenarios. Gossip protocols have already shown their effec- tiveness in the context of live video streaming. HEAP, HEterogeneity-Aware gossip Protocol, goes beyond their applicability and performance by incorporating several novel features. First, HEAP includes a fanout-adaptation scheme that tunes the contribution of nodes to the streaming process based on their bandwidth capabilities. Second, HEAP comprises heuristics that improve reliability, as well as operation in the presence of heterogeneous network latency. We extensively evaluate HEAP on a real deployment over 200 nodes on the Grid5000 platform in a variety of settings, and assess its scalability with up to 100k simulated nodes. Our results show that HEAP significantly improves the quality of streamed videos over standard homogeneous gossip protocols, especially when the stream rate is close to the average available bandwidth.Le streaming vidéo est devenu une killer application pour les technologies pair-à- pair. En agrégeant les ressources rares telles que le debit maximale téléversement, les protocoles de diffusion vidéo décentralisée permettent servir un flux vidéo à un grand nombre d’utilisateurs tout en limitant les couts. Dans cet article, nous présentons HEAP, un nouveau protocole de streaming pair-à-pair conçu pour des réseaux hétérogènes. Les protocoles de gossip ont déjà mon- tré leur efficacité dans le contexte du streaming vidéo en direct. HEAP, em HEterogeneity-Aware Gossip Protocol, va au-delà de protocoles existantes en incorporant plusieurs caractéristiques nouvelles. Premièrement, HEAP adapte la contribution des noeuds en fonction de leurs debit maximal. Deuxièmement, HEAP inclut des heuristiques qui améliorent la fiabilité, en présence de latence de réseau hétérogène. Nous évaluons HEAP sur un déploiement réel sur 200 noeuds sur la plate-forme Grid5000 avec une variété de paramètres, et évaluons son passage à l’échelle avec jusqu’à 100k noeuds simulé. Nos résultats montrent que HEAP améliore significativement la qualité des vidéos diffusées par rapport au protocoles standard, surtout lorsque le débit est proche de la bande passante moyenne disponible

Live Streaming in P2P and Hybrid P2P-Cloud Environments for the Open Internet

Peer-to-Peer (P2P) live media streaming is an emerging technology that reduces the barrier to stream live events over the Internet. However, providing a high quality media stream using P2P overlay networks is challenging and gives raise to a number of issues: (i) how to guarantee quality of the service (QoS) in the presence of dynamism, (ii) how to incentivize nodes to participate in media distribution, (iii) how to avoid bottlenecks in the overlay, and (iv) how to deal with nodes that reside behind Network Address Translators gateways (NATs). In this thesis, we answer the above research questions in form of new algorithms and systems. First of all, we address problems (i) and (ii) by presenting our P2P live media streaming solutions: Sepidar, which is a multiple-tree overlay, and GLive, which is a mesh overlay. In both models, nodes with higher upload bandwidth are positioned closer to the media source. This structure reduces the playback latency and increases the playback continuity at nodes, and also incentivizes the nodes to provide more upload bandwidth. We use a reputation model to improve participating nodes in media distribution in Sepidar and GLive. In both systems, nodes audit the behaviour of their directly connected nodes by getting feedback from other nodes. Nodes who upload more of the stream get a relatively higher reputation, and proportionally higher quality streams. To construct our streaming overlay, we present a distributed market model inspired by Bertsekas auction algorithm, although our model does not rely on a central server with global knowledge. In our model, each node has only partial information about the system. Nodes acquire knowledge of the system by sampling nodes using the Gradient overlay, where it facilitates the discovery of nodes with similar upload bandwidth. We address the bottlenecks problem, problem (iii), by presenting CLive that satisfies real-time constraints on delay between the generation of the stream and its actual delivery to users. We resolve this problem by borrowing some resources (helpers) from the cloud, upon need. In our approach, helpers are added on demand to the overlay, to increase the amount of total available bandwidth, thus increasing the probability of receiving the video on time. As the use of cloud resources costs money, we model the problem as the minimization of the economical cost, provided that a set of constraints on QoS is satisfied. Finally, we solve the NAT problem, problem (iv), by presenting two NAT-aware peer sampling services (PSS): Gozar and Croupier. Traditional gossip-based PSS breaks down, where a high percentage of nodes are behind NATs. We overcome this problem in Gozar using one-hop relaying to communicate with the nodes behind NATs. Croupier similarly implements a gossip-based PSS, but without the use of relaying

NAT-resilient Gossip Peer Sampling

International audienceCet article explique comment réaliser un protocole de diffusion par gossip fonctionnant en présence de NATs