A structural perspective on the dynamics of kinesin motors

Despite significant fluctuation under thermal noise, biological machines in cells perform their tasks with exquisite precision. Using molecular simulation of a coarse-grained model and theoretical arguments we envisaged how kinesin, a prototype of biological machines, generates force and regulates its dynamics to sustain persistent motor action. A structure based model, which can be versatile in adapting its structure to external stresses while maintaining its native fold, was employed to account for several features of kinesin dynamics along the biochemical cycle. This analysis complements our current understandings of kinesin dynamics and connections to experiments. We propose a thermodynamic cycle for kinesin that emphasizes the mechanical and regulatory role of the neck-linker and clarify issues related the motor directionality, and the difference between the external stalling force and the internal tension responsible for the head-head coordination. The comparison between the thermodynamic cycle of kinesin and macroscopic heat engines highlights the importance of structural change as the source of work production in biomolecular machines.Comment: 35 pages, 8 figures, 1 Tabl

Multiscale computational modeling of single cell migration in 3D

La migración celular es un proceso complejo, orquestado por factores químicos y biológicos, por la microestructura y por las propiedades mecánicas de la matriz extracelular. Este fenómeno es fundamental para el desarrollo de tejidos en los organismos pluricelulares, y como seres humanos, nos acompaña durante toda la vida, desde el mismo momento de la concepción hasta la muerte. Juega un papel fundamental durante el desarrollo embrionario determinando la formación de los diferentes órganos (morfogénesis) y es clave en todos los procesos regenerativos como la renovación de la piel, la respuesta inflamatoria o la cicatrización de heridas. Sin embargo, también contribuye al desarrollo de procesos patológicos como la metástasis, el retraso mental, la osteoporosis o enfermedades vasculares entre otros. Es por ello de vital importancia el conocer los mecanismos fundamentales que controlan la migración celular con el fin de tratar de manera efectiva las diferentes patologías, así como avanzar en el trasplante de órganos y el desarrollo de tejidos artificiales. Así pues, el objetivo de esta Tesis es el desarrollo de modelos a distintas escalas y centrados en diversos aspectos de la migración, de manera que faciliten la compresión de fenómenos específicos y sirvan como guía para el diseño de experimentos. Dada la complejidad y las grandes diferencias respecto a la migración colectiva, todos los modelos y análisis de esta Tesis se centran en células individuales. En primer lugar se ha estudiado la migración tridimensional de una célula individual embebida en una matriz extracelular donde su velocidad y orientación se consideran reguladas por estímulos mecánicos. Para ello se ha desarrollado un modelo mecanosensor basado en elementos finitos y se ha analizado el comportamiento celular en función de diferentes rigideces y condiciones de contorno a escala celular. A medida que el trabajo ha progresado, los resultados del modelo unidos a nuevos avances científicos publicados en este ámbito, han reforzado la idea de que el mecansimo mecanosensor juega un papel crítico en los procesos que dirigen la migración celular. Por ello, se ha necesitado un estudio más profundo de este fenómeno para lo que se ha utilizado un modelo mucho más detallado a escala intracelular. Así pues, se ha explorado la estructura interna del citoesqueleto y su comportamiento ante cambios mecánicos en la matriz extracelular, utilizando un modelo discreto de partículas basado en dinámica Browniana con el que se ha simulado la formación de una red de actina (polimerización) entrecruzada con proteínas y motores moleculares. En concreto, se ha estudiado el comportamiento activo de estos motores y su papel como sensores de estímulos mecánicos externos (mecanosensores) de manera que los resultados obtenidos con este modelo “micro” han permitido validar las hipótesis del modelo previo. Consecuentemente, se ha revisado el modelo mecánico y se le ha añadido dependencia temporal, obteniendo un modelo continuo capaz de predecir respuestas celulares macroscópicas basadas en el comportamiento de los componentes microestructurales. En otras palabras, esta simplificación ha permitido la introducción de la respuesta macroscópica emergente obtenida del comportamiento dinámico de la microestructura, disminuyendo enormemente el coste computacional y por tanto permitiendo simulaciones a mayores escalas espacio-temporales. A continuación se han introducido las nuevas hipótesis en un modelo probabilístico de migración a escala celular basado en elementos finitos que permite al mismo tiempo el estudio de factores tanto a escala macroscópica (velocidades, trayectorias) como a escala celular (orientación, área de adhesión, tensiones celulares, desplazamientos de la matriz etc.). Adicionalmente, este modelo es sensible no sólo a la mecánica sino a las condiciones fluido-químicas del entorno, las cuales han sido analizadas igualmente mediante simulaciones por elementos finitos. Con todo esto, los modelos desarrollados todavía no incluyen una descripción detallada de procesos importantes envueltos en la migración celular como la protrusión de la membrana, la polimerización de actina en el frente celular o la formación de adhesiones focales. Por lo tanto, para completar la Tesis, se ha desarrollado un modelo continuo basado en diferencias finitas que permite el estudio del comportamiento dinámico del lamelipodio y el papel fundamental que juegan la polimerización de actina, los motores moleculares y las adhesiones focales (FAs) en el frente celular durante la migración. Cell migration is a complex process, orchestrated by biological and chemical factors, and by the microstructure and extracellular matrix (ECM) mechanical properties among others. It is essential for tissue development in multicellular organisms, and as human beings, it accompanies us throughout life, from conception to death. It plays a major role during embryonic development, defining organ formation (morphogenesis) and being crucial in all the regenerative processes such as skin renewal, inflammatory response or wound healing. However, it is also involved in several pathological processes e.g. metastasis, mental retardation, osteoporosis or vascular diseases. Therefore, understanding the fundamental mechanisms controling cell migration is vitally important to effectively treat different pathologies and to make progress in organ transplantation and tissue development. Thus, the main scope of this Thesis is the development of mathematical models at different scales and focused on different aspects of cell migration so that specific phenomena can be better understood, serving as a guide for the development of new experiments. All the models and analysis contained in this thesis are focused on single cells, firstly due to the complexity and marked differences with respect to collective cell migration, and secondly owing to the importance of individual migration in important processes such as metastatic tumor cell migration. In addition, since three- dimensional environments are physiologically more relevant, 3D approaches have been considered in most of the models here developed to better mimic in vivo conditions. Firstly, single cell migration of a cell embedded in a three-dimensional matrix was studied, regulating its velocity and polarization through mechanical clues. For this purpose, a finite element (FE) based mechanosensing model was developed, analyzing cell behavior according to different ECM rigidities and boundary conditions at the cell scale. As work advanced, results from the model together with recent findings from literature strengthened the idea that mechanosensing plays a critical role in cell motility driving processes. For this reason, a deeper understanting of this mechanism was needed, resulting in the development of a specific and more detailed model (at the intracellular scale). Hence, the cytoskeletal structure response to mechanical stimuli has been explored using a discrete particle-based Brownian dynamics model. This model was used to simulate the formation of actin networks (through actin polymerization) cross-linked with proteins (ACPs) and molecular motors. Specifically, the active role of molecular motors and their role as mechanosensors were studied, so that the results of the intracellular scale approach allowed the validation of the previous model main assumptions. As a consequence, the mechanical hypothesis were revised and a temporal dependence was incorporated, obtaining a new continuum model able to predict macroscopic cell responses based on microstructural components behavior. In other words, this simplification allowed introducing the emergent macroscopic response obtained from the active behavior of the microstructure, saving large amounts of computational time and permitting simulations at higher time and length scales. Next, the new hypotheses were incorporated into a probabilistic, FE-voxel-based cell-scale migration model, permitting simultaneously the study of macro-scale factors (velocities, trajectories) and cell-scale ones (polarization, adhesion area, cell stress, ECM displacements etc.). Additionally this model includes the effect of fluid-chemical stimuli, which was also analyzed by means of FE-simulations. With all this, the developed models still lacked a detailed description of important processes involved in cell migration such as membrane protrusion, actin polymerization or focal adhesion (FA) formation. As a result, a continuum model was designed to study the lamellipodium dynamics and the major role of actin polymerization and focal adhesions (FA) at the cell front during cell migration

Pattern Formation and Organization of Epithelial Tissues

Developmental biology is a study of how elaborate patterns, shapes, and functions emerge as an organism grows and develops its body plan. From the physics point of view this is very much a self-organization process. The genetic blueprint contained in the DNA does not explicitly encode shapes and patterns an animal ought to make as it develops from an embryo. Instead, the DNA encodes various proteins which, among other roles, specify how different cells function and interact with each other. Epithelial tissues, from which many organs are sculpted, serve as experimentally- and analytically-tractable systems to study patterning mechanisms in animal development. Despite extensive studies in the past decade, the mechanisms that shape epithelial tissues into functioning organs remain incompletely understood. This thesis summarizes various studies we have done on epithelial organization and patterning, both in abstract theory and in close contact with experiments. A novel mechanism to establish cellular left-right asymmetry based on planar polarity instabilities is discussed. Tissue chirality is often assumed to originate from handedness of biological molecules. Here we propose an alternative where it results from spontaneous symmetry breaking of planar polarity mechanisms. We show that planar cell polarity (PCP), a class of well-studied mechanisms that allows epithelia to spontaneously break rotational symmetry, is also generically capable of spontaneously breaking reflection symmetry. Our results provide a clear interpretation of many mutant phenotypes, especially those that result in incomplete inversion. To bridge theory and experiments, we develop quantitative methods to analyze fluorescence microscopy images. Included in this thesis are algorithms to selectively project intensities from a surface in z-stack images, analysis of cells forming short chain fragments, analysis of thick fluorescent bands using steerable ridge detector, and analysis of cell recoil in laser ablation experiments. These techniques, though developed in the context of zebrafish retina mosaic, are general and can be adapted to other systems. Finally we explore correlated noise in morphogenesis of fly pupa notum. Here we report unexpected correlation of noise in cell movements between left and right halves of developing notum, suggesting that feedback or other mechanisms might be present to counteract stochastic noise and maintain left-right symmetry.PHDPhysicsUniversity of Michigan, Horace H. Rackham School of Graduate Studieshttps://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/138800/1/hjeremy_1.pd

Modelling cytosolic flow and vesicle transport in the growing pollen tube

Scientific interest in the mathematical modelling of pollen tube growth has increased steadily over the last few decades. The highly localized and rapid nature of this growth necessitates large--scale actomyosin transport of cellular material throughout the cell cytoplasm. This directed movement of cellular material induces a flow in the cytosol, also known as 'cyclosis'. The extent to which inclusion of this flow is important to modelling the distribution of elements in the cytoplasm is currently unclear, with its effect often conflated with that of actomyosin transport. In this thesis, a finite volume method (FVM) is developed for the numerical evaluation of transport equations describing vesicle distribution in the pollen tube cytoplasm. This is coupled with a novel method of regularized ringlets, derived via analytical azimuthal integration of the regularized Stokeslet, for obtaining numerical solutions to axisymmetric Stokes flows. Using this method of regularized ringlets, we present an axisymmetric velocity profile for cytosolic flow in the pollen tube based on the drag induced by actomyosin vesicle transport. When used in the transport equation for vesicle distribution, we find that recreation of the apical `inverted vesicle cone' requires the use of an enlarged effective fluid viscosity amongst other results

Emergent Properties of Biomolecular Organization

The organization of molecules within a cell is central to cellular processes ranging from metabolism and damage repair to migration and replication. Uncovering the emergent properties of this biomolecular organization can improve our understanding of how organisms function and reveal ways to repurpose their components outside of the cell. This dissertation focuses on the role of organization in two widely studied systems: enzyme cascades and active cytoskeletal filaments.Part I of this dissertation studies the emergent properties of the spatial organization of enzyme cascades. Enzyme cascades consist of a series of enzymes that catalyze sequential reactions: the product of one enzyme is the substrate of a subsequent enzyme. Enzyme cascades are a fundamental component of cellular reaction pathways, and spatial organization of the cascading enzymes is often essential to their function. For example, cascading enzymes assembled into multi-enzyme complexes can protect unstable cascade intermediates from the environment by forming tunnels between active sites. We use mathematical modeling to investigate the role of spatial organization in three specific systems. First, we examine enzyme cascade reactions occurring in multi-enzyme complexes where active sites are connected by tunnels. Using stochastic simulations and theoretical results from queueing theory, we demonstrate that the fluctuations arising from the small number of molecules involved can cause non-negligible disruptions to cascade throughput. Second, we develop a set of design principles for a compartmentalized cascade reaction with an unstable intermediate and show that there exists a critical kinetics-dependent threshold at which compartments become useful. Third, we investigate enzyme cascades immobilized on a synthetic DNA origami scaffold and show that the scaffold can create a favorable microenvironment for catalysis. Part II of this dissertation focuses on the organization of active cytoskeletal filaments. Many mechanical processes of a cell, such as cell division, cell migration, and intracellular transport, are driven by the ATP-fueled motion of motor proteins (kinesin, dynein, or myosin) along cytoskeletal filaments (microtubules or actin filaments). Over the past two decades, researchers have been repurposing motor protein-driven propulsion outside of the cell to create systems where cytoskeletal filaments glide on surfaces coated with motor proteins. The study of these systems not only elucidates the mechanisms of force production within the cell, but also opens new avenues for applications ranging from molecular detection to computation. We examine how microtubules gliding on surfaces coated with kinesin motor proteins can generate collective behavior in response to mutualistic interactions between the filaments and motors, thereby maximizing the utilization of system components and production. To this end, we used a microtubule-kinesin system where motors reversibly bind to the surface. In experiments, microtubules gliding on these reversibly bound motors were unable to cross each other and at high enough densities began to align and form long, dense bundles. The kinesin motors accumulated in trails surrounding the microtubule bundles and participated in microtubule transport. In conclusion, our study of the emergent properties of the spatial organization of enzyme cascades and the mutualistic interactions within active systems of motor proteins and cytoskeletal filaments provides insight into both how these systems function within cells and how they can be repurposed outside of them

Nonlinear dynamics and fluctuations in biological systems

The present habilitation thesis in theoretical biological physics addresses two central dynamical processes in cells and organisms: (i) active motility and motility control and (ii) self-organized pattern formation. The unifying theme is the nonlinear dynamics of biological function and its robustness in the presence of strong fluctuations, structural variations, and external perturbations. We theoretically investigate motility control at the cellular scale, using cilia and flagella as ideal model system. Cilia and flagella are highly conserved slender cell appendages that exhibit spontaneous bending waves. This flagellar beat represents a prime example of a chemo-mechanical oscillator, which is driven by the collective dynamics of molecular motors inside the flagellar axoneme. We study the nonlinear dynamics of flagellar swimming, steering, and synchronization, which encompasses shape control of the flagellar beat by chemical signals and mechanical forces. Mechanical forces can synchronize collections of flagella to beat at a common frequency, despite active motor noise that tends to randomize flagellar synchrony. In Chapter 2, we present a new physical mechanism for flagellar synchronization by mechanical self-stabilization that applies to free-swimming flagellated cells. This new mechanism is independent of direct hydrodynamic interactions between flagella. Comparison with experimental data provided by experimental collaboration partners in the laboratory of J. Howard (Yale, New Haven) confirmed our new mechanism in the model organism of the unicellular green alga Chlamydomonas. Further, we characterize the beating flagellum as a noisy oscillator. Using a minimal model of collective motor dynamics, we argue that measured non-equilibrium fluctuations of the flagellar beat result from stochastic motor dynamics at the molecular scale. Noise and mechanical coupling are antagonists for flagellar synchronization. In addition to the control of the flagellar beat by mechanical forces, we study the control of the flagellar beat by chemical signals in the context of sperm chemotaxis. We characterize a fundamental paradigm for navigation in external concentration gradients that relies on active swimming along helical paths. In this helical chemotaxis, the direction of a spatial concentration gradient becomes encoded in the phase of an oscillatory chemical signal. Helical chemotaxis represents a distinct gradient-sensing strategy, which is different from bacterial chemotaxis. Helical chemotaxis is employed, for example, by sperm cells from marine invertebrates with external fertilization. We present a theory of sensorimotor control, which combines hydrodynamic simulations of chiral flagellar swimming with a dynamic regulation of flagellar beat shape in response to chemical signals perceived by the cell. Our theory is compared to three-dimensional tracking experiments of sperm chemotaxis performed by the laboratory of U. B. Kaupp (CAESAR, Bonn). In addition to motility control, we investigate in Chapter 3 self-organized pattern formation in two selected biological systems at the cell and organism scale, respectively. On the cellular scale, we present a minimal physical mechanism for the spontaneous self-assembly of periodic cytoskeletal patterns, as observed in myofibrils in striated muscle cells. This minimal mechanism relies on the interplay of a passive coarsening process of crosslinked actin clusters and active cytoskeletal forces. This mechanism of cytoskeletal pattern formation exemplifies how local interactions can generate large-scale spatial order in active systems. On the organism scale, we present an extension of Turing’s framework for self-organized pattern formation that is capable of a proportionate scaling of steady-state patterns with system size. This new mechanism does not require any pre-pattering clues and can restore proportional patterns in regeneration scenarios. We analytically derive the hierarchy of steady-state patterns and analyze their stability and basins of attraction. We demonstrate that this scaling mechanism is structurally robust. Applications to the growth and regeneration dynamics in flatworms are discussed (experiments by J. Rink, MPI CBG, Dresden).:1 Introduction 10 1.1 Overview of the thesis 10 1.2 What is biological physics? 12 1.3 Nonlinear dynamics and control 14 1.3.1 Mechanisms of cell motility 16 1.3.2 Self-organized pattern formation in cells and tissues 28 1.4 Fluctuations and biological robustness 34 1.4.1 Sources of fluctuations in biological systems 34 1.4.2 Example of stochastic dynamics: synchronization of noisy oscillators 36 1.4.3 Cellular navigation strategies reveal adaptation to noise 39 2 Selected publications: Cell motility and motility control 56 2.1 “Flagellar synchronization independent of hydrodynamic interactions” 56 2.2 “Cell body rocking is a dominant mechanism for flagellar synchronization” 57 2.3 “Active phase and amplitude fluctuations of the flagellar beat” 58 2.4 “Sperm navigation in 3D chemoattractant landscapes” 59 3 Selected publications: Self-organized pattern formation in cells and tissues 60 3.1 “Sarcomeric pattern formation by actin cluster coalescence” 60 3.2 “Scaling and regeneration of self-organized patterns” 61 4 Contribution of the author in collaborative publications 62 5 Eidesstattliche Versicherung 64 6 Appendix: Reprints of publications 66Das Thema der vorliegenden Habilitationsschrift in Theoretischer Biologischer Physik ist die nichtlineare Dynamik funktionaler biologischer Systeme und deren Robustheit gegenüber Fluktuationen und äußeren Störungen. Wir entwickeln hierzu theoretische Beschreibungen für zwei grundlegende biologische Prozesse: (i) die zell-autonome Kontrolle aktiver Bewegung, sowie (ii) selbstorganisierte Musterbildung in Zellen und Organismen. In Kapitel 2, untersuchen wir Bewegungskontrolle auf zellulärer Ebene am Modelsystem von Zilien und Geißeln. Spontane Biegewellen dieser dünnen Zellfortsätze ermöglichen es eukaryotischen Zellen, in einer Flüssigkeit zu schwimmen. Wir beschreiben einen neuen physikalischen Mechanismus für die Synchronisation zweier schlagender Geißeln, unabhängig von direkten hydrodynamischen Wechselwirkungen. Der Vergleich mit experimentellen Daten, zur Verfügung gestellt von unseren experimentellen Kooperationspartnern im Labor von J. Howard (Yale, New Haven), bestätigt diesen neuen Mechanismus im Modellorganismus der einzelligen Grünalge Chlamydomonas. Der Gegenspieler dieser Synchronisation durch mechanische Kopplung sind Fluktuationen. Wir bestimmen erstmals Nichtgleichgewichts-Fluktuationen des Geißel-Schlags direkt, wofür wir eine neue Analyse-Methode der Grenzzykel-Rekonstruktion entwickeln. Die von uns gemessenen Fluktuationen entstehen mutmaßlich durch die stochastische Dynamik molekularen Motoren im Innern der Geißeln, welche auch den Geißelschlag antreiben. Um die statistische Physik dieser Nichtgleichgewichts-Fluktuationen zu verstehen, entwickeln wir eine analytische Theorie der Fluktuationen in einem minimalen Modell kollektiver Motor-Dynamik. Zusätzlich zur Regulation des Geißelschlags durch mechanische Kräfte untersuchen wir dessen Regulation durch chemische Signale am Modell der Chemotaxis von Spermien-Zellen. Dabei charakterisieren wir einen grundlegenden Mechanismus für die Navigation in externen Konzentrationsgradienten. Dieser Mechanismus beruht auf dem aktiven Schwimmen entlang von Spiralbahnen, wodurch ein räumlicher Konzentrationsgradient in der Phase eines oszillierenden chemischen Signals kodiert wird. Dieser Chemotaxis-Mechanismus unterscheidet sich grundlegend vom bekannten Chemotaxis-Mechanismus von Bakterien. Wir entwickeln eine Theorie der senso-motorischen Steuerung des Geißelschlags während der Spermien-Chemotaxis. Vorhersagen dieser Theorie werden durch Experimente der Gruppe von U.B. Kaupp (CAESAR, Bonn) quantitativ bestätigt. In Kapitel 3, untersuchen wir selbstorganisierte Strukturbildung in zwei ausgewählten biologischen Systemen. Auf zellulärer Ebene schlagen wir einen einfachen physikalischen Mechanismus vor für die spontane Selbstorganisation von periodischen Zellskelett-Strukturen, wie sie sich z.B. in den Myofibrillen gestreifter Muskelzellen finden. Dieser Mechanismus zeigt exemplarisch auf, wie allein durch lokale Wechselwirkungen räumliche Ordnung auf größeren Längenskalen in einem Nichtgleichgewichtssystem entstehen kann. Auf der Ebene des Organismus stellen wir eine Erweiterung der Turingschen Theorie für selbstorganisierte Musterbildung vor. Wir beschreiben eine neue Klasse von Musterbildungssystemen, welche selbst-organisierte Muster erzeugt, die mit der Systemgröße skalieren. Dieser neue Mechanismus erfordert weder eine vorgegebene Kompartimentalisierung des Systems noch spezielle Randbedingungen. Insbesondere kann dieser Mechanismus proportionale Muster wiederherstellen, wenn Teile des Systems amputiert werden. Wir bestimmen analytisch die Hierarchie aller stationären Muster und analysieren deren Stabilität und Einzugsgebiete. Damit können wir zeigen, dass dieser Skalierungs-Mechanismus strukturell robust ist bezüglich Variationen von Parametern und sogar funktionalen Beziehungen zwischen dynamischen Variablen. Zusammen mit Kollaborationspartnern im Labor von J. Rink (MPI CBG, Dresden) diskutieren wir Anwendungen auf das Wachstum von Plattwürmern und deren Regeneration in Amputations-Experimenten.:1 Introduction 10 1.1 Overview of the thesis 10 1.2 What is biological physics? 12 1.3 Nonlinear dynamics and control 14 1.3.1 Mechanisms of cell motility 16 1.3.2 Self-organized pattern formation in cells and tissues 28 1.4 Fluctuations and biological robustness 34 1.4.1 Sources of fluctuations in biological systems 34 1.4.2 Example of stochastic dynamics: synchronization of noisy oscillators 36 1.4.3 Cellular navigation strategies reveal adaptation to noise 39 2 Selected publications: Cell motility and motility control 56 2.1 “Flagellar synchronization independent of hydrodynamic interactions” 56 2.2 “Cell body rocking is a dominant mechanism for flagellar synchronization” 57 2.3 “Active phase and amplitude fluctuations of the flagellar beat” 58 2.4 “Sperm navigation in 3D chemoattractant landscapes” 59 3 Selected publications: Self-organized pattern formation in cells and tissues 60 3.1 “Sarcomeric pattern formation by actin cluster coalescence” 60 3.2 “Scaling and regeneration of self-organized patterns” 61 4 Contribution of the author in collaborative publications 62 5 Eidesstattliche Versicherung 64 6 Appendix: Reprints of publications 6