WCET Optimizations and Architectural Support for Hard Real-Time Systems

As time predictability is critical to hard real-time systems, it is not only necessary to accurately estimate the worst-case execution time (WCET) of the real-time tasks but also desirable to improve either the WCET of the tasks or time predictability of the system, because the real-time tasks with lower WCETs are easy to schedule and more likely to meat their deadlines. As a real-time system is an integration of software and hardware, the optimization can be achieved through two ways: software optimization and time-predictable architectural support. In terms of software optimization, we fi rst propose a loop-based instruction prefetching approach to further improve the WCET comparing with simple prefetching techniques such as Next-N-Line prefetching which can enhance both the average-case performance and the worst-case performance. Our prefetching approach can exploit the program controlow information to intelligently prefetch instructions that are most likely needed. Second, as inter-thread interferences in shared caches can signi cantly a ect the WCET of real-time tasks running on multicore processors, we study three multicore-aware code positioning methods to reduce the inter-core L2 cache interferences between co-running real-time threads. One strategy focuses on decreasing the longest WCET among the co-running threads, and two other methods aim at achieving fairness in terms of the amount or percentage of WCET reduction among co-running threads. In the aspect of time-predictable architectural support, we introduce the concept of architectural time predictability (ATP) to separate timing uncertainty concerns caused by hardware from software, which greatly facilitates the advancement of time-predictable processor design. We also propose a metric called Architectural Time-predictability Factor (ATF) to measure architectural time predictability quantitatively. Furthermore, while cache memories can generally improve average-case performance, they are harmful to time predictability and thus are not desirable for hard real-time and safety-critical systems. In contrast, Scratch-Pad Memories (SPMs) are time predictable, but they may lead to inferior performance. Guided by ATF, we propose and evaluate a variety of hybrid on-chip memory architectures to combine both caches and SPMs intelligently to achieve good time predictability and high performance. Detailed implementation and experimental results discussion are presented in this dissertation

WCET-aware prefetching of unlocked instruction caches: a technique for reconciling real-time guarantees and energy efficiency

Tese (doutorado) - Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina, Centro Tecnológico, Programa de Pós-Graduação em Engenharia de Automação e Sistemas, Florianópolis, 2015.A computação embarcada requer crescente vazão sob baixa potência. Ela requer um aumento de eficiência energética quando se executam programas de crescente complexidade. Muitos sistemas embarcados são também sistemas de tempo real, cuja correção temporal precisa ser garantida através de análise de escalonabilidade, a qual costuma assumir que o WCET de uma tarefa é conhecido em tempo de projeto. Como resultado da crescente complexidade do software, uma quantidade significativa de energia é gasta ao se prover instruções através da hierarquia de memória. Como a cache de instruções consome cerca de 40% da energia gasta em um processador embarcado e afeta a energia consumida em memória principal, ela se torna um relevante alvo para otimização. Entretanto, como ela afeta substancialmente o WCET, o comportamento da cache precisa ser restrito via  cache locking ou previsto via análise de WCET. Para obter eficiência energética sob restrições de tempo real, é preciso estender a consciência que o compilador tem da plataforma de hardware. Entretanto, compiladores para tempo real ignoram a energia, embora determinem rapidamente limites superiores para o WCET, enquanto compiladores para sistemas embarcados estimem com precisão a energia, mas gastem muito tempo em  profiling . Por isso, esta tese propõe um método unificado para estimar a energia gasta em memória, o qual é baseado em Interpretação Abstrata, exatamente o mesmo substrato matemático usado para a análise de WCET em caches. As estimativas mostram derivadas que são tão precisas quanto as obtidas via  profiling , mas são computadas 1000 vezes mais rápido, sendo apropriadas para induzir otimização de código através de melhoria iterativa. Como  cache locking troca eficiência energética por previsibilidade, esta tese propõe uma nova otimização de código, baseada em pré-carga por software, a qual reduz a taxa de faltas de caches de instruções e, provadamente, não aumenta o WCET. A otimização proposta é comparada com o estado-da-arte em  cache locking parcial para 37 programas do  Malardalen WCET benchmark para 36 configurações de cache e duas tecnologias distintas (2664 casos de uso). Em média, para obter uma melhoria de 68% no WCET,  cache locking parcial requer 8% mais energia. Por outro lado, a pré-carga por software diminui o consumo de energia em 11% enquanto melhora em 15% o WCET, reconciliando assim eficiência energética e garantias de tempo real.Abstract : Embedded computing requires increasing throughput at low power budgets. It asks for growing energy efficiency when executing programs of rising complexity. Many embedded systems are also real-time systems, whose temporal correctness is asserted through schedulability analysis, which often assumes that the WCET of each task is known at design-time. As a result of the growing software complexity, a significant amount of energy is spent in supplying instructions through the memory hierarchy. Since an instruction cache consumes around 40% of an embedded processor s energy and affects the energy spent in main memory, it becomes a relevant optimization target. However, since it largely impacts the WCET, cache behavior must be either constrained via cache locking or predicted by WCET analysis. To achieve energy efficiency under real-time constraints, a compiler must have extended awareness of the hardware platform. However, real-time compilers ignore energy, although they quickly determine bounds for WCET, whereas embedded compilers accurately estimate energy but require time-consuming profiling. That is why this thesis proposes a unifying method to estimate memory energy consumption that is based on Abstract Interpretation, the very same mathematical framework employed for the WCET analysis of caches. The estimates exhibit derivatives that are as accurate as those obtained by profiling, but are computed 1000 times faster, being suitable for driving code optimization through iterative improvement. Since cache locking gives up energy efficiency for predictability, this thesis proposes a novel code optimization, based on software prefetching, which reduces miss rate of unlocked instruction caches and, provenly, does not increase the WCET. The proposed optimization is compared with a state-of-the-art partial cache locking technique for the 37 programs of the Malardalen WCET benchmarks under 36 cache configurations and two distinct target technologies (2664 use cases). On average, to achieve an improvement of 68% in the WCET, partial cache locking required 8% more energy. On the other hand, software prefetching decreased the energy consumption by 11% while leading to an improvement of 15% in the WCET, thereby reconciling energy efficiency and real-time guarantees

Best practice for caching of single-path code

Single-path code has some unique properties that make it interesting to explore different caching and prefetching alternatives for the stream of instructions. In this paper, we explore different cache organizations and how they perform with single-path code

Smart hardware designs for probabilistically-analyzable processor architectures

Future Critical Real-Time Embedded Systems (CRTES), like those is planes, cars or trains, require more and more guaranteed performance in order to satisfy the increasing performance demands of advanced complex software features. While increased performance can be achieved by deploying processor techniques currently used in High-Performance Computing (HPC) and mainstream domains, their use challenges the software timing analysis, a necessary step in CRTES' verification and validation. Cache memories are known to have high impact in performance, and in fact, current CRTES include multicores usually with several levels of cache. In this line, this Thesis aims at increasing the guaranteed performance of CRTES by using techniques for caches building upon time randomization and providing probabilistic guarantees of tasks' execution time. In this Thesis, we first focus on on improving cache placement and replacement to improve guaranteed performance. For placement, different existing policies are explored in a multi-level cache setup, and a solution is reached in which different of those policies are combined. For cache replacement, we analyze a pathological scenario that no cache policy so far accounts and propose several policies that fix this pathological scenario. For shared caches in multicore we observe that contention is mainly caused by private writes that go through to the shared cache, yet using a pure write-back policy also has its drawbacks. We propose a hybrid approach to mitigate this contention. Building on this solution, the next contribution tackles a problem caused by the need of some reliability mechanisms in CRTES. Implementing reliability close to the processor's core has a significant impact in performance. A look-ahead error detection solution is proposed to greatly mitigate the performance impact. The next contribution proposes the first hardware prefetcher for CRTES with arbitrary cache hierarchies. Given its speculative nature, prefetchers that have a guaranteed positive impact on performance are difficult to design. We present a framework that provides execution time guarantees and obtains a performance benefit. Finally, we focus on the impact of timing anomalies in CRTES with caches. For the first time, a definition and taxonomy of timing anomalies is given for Measurement-Based Timing Analysis. Then, we focus on a specific timing anomaly that can happen with caches and provide a solution to account for it in the execution time estimates.Los Sistemas Empotrados de Tiempo-Real Crítico (SETRC), como los de los aviones, coches o trenes, requieren más y más rendimiento garantizado para satisfacer la demanda al alza de rendimiento para funciones complejas y avanzadas de software. Aunque el incremento en rendimiento puede ser adquirido utilizando técnicas de arquitectura de procesadores actualmente utilizadas en la Computación de Altas Prestaciones (CAP) i en los dominios convencionales, este uso presenta retos para el análisis del tiempo de software, un paso necesario en la verificación y validación de SETRC. Las memorias caches son conocidas por su gran impacto en rendimiento y, de hecho, los actuales SETRC incluyen multicores normalmente con diversos niveles de cache. En esta línea, esta Tesis tiene como objetivo mejorar el rendimiento garantizado de los SETRC utilizando técnicas para caches y utilizando métodos como la randomización del tiempo y proveyendo garantías probabilísticas de tiempo de ejecución de las tareas. En esta Tesis, primero nos centramos en mejorar la colocación y el reemplazo de caches para mejorar el rendimiento garantizado. Para la colocación, diferentes políticas son exploradas en un sistema cache multi-nivel, y se llega a una solución donde diversas de estas políticas son combinadas. Para el reemplazo, analizamos un escenario patológico que ninguna política actual tiene en cuenta, y proponemos varias políticas que solucionan este escenario patológico. Para caches compartidas en multicores, observamos que la contención es causada principalmente por escrituras privadas que van a través de la cache compartida, pero usar una política de escritura retardada pura también tiene sus consecuencias. Proponemos un enfoque híbrido para mitigar la contención. Sobre esta solución, la siguiente contribución ataca un problema causado por la necesidad de mecanismos de fiabilidad en SETRC. Implementar fiabilidad cerca del núcleo del procesador tiene un impacto significativo en rendimiento. Una solución basada en anticipación se propone para mitigar el impacto en rendimiento. La siguiente contribución propone el primer prefetcher hardware para SETRC con una jerarquía de caches arbitraria. Por primera vez, se da una definición y taxonomía de anomalías temporales para Análisis Temporal Basado en Medidas. Después, nos centramos en una anomalía temporal concreta que puede pasar con caches y ofrecemos una solución que la tiene en cuenta en las estimaciones del tiempo de ejecución.Postprint (published version

Eager Stack Cache Memory Transfers

The growing complexity of modern computer architectures increasingly complicates the prediction of the run-time behavior of software. For real-time systems, where a safe estimation of the program\u27s worst-case execution time is needed, time-predictable computer architectures promise to resolve this problem. The stack cache, for instance, allows the compiler to efficiently cache a program\u27s stack, while static analysis of its behavior remains easy. This work introduces an optimization of the stack cache that allows to anticipate memory transfers that might be initiated by future stack cache control instructions. These eager memory transfers thus allow to reduce the average-case latency of those control instructions, very similar to "prefetching" techniques known from conventional caches. However, the mechanism proposed here is guaranteed to have no impact on the worst-case execution time estimates computed by static analysis. Measurements on a dual-core platform using the Patmos processor and imedivision-multiplexing-based memory arbitration, show that our technique can eliminate up to 62% (7%) of the memory transfers from (respectively to) the stack cache on average over all programs of the MiBench benchmark suite

A memory-centric approach to enable timing-predictability within embedded many-core accelerators

There is an increasing interest among real-time systems architects for multi- and many-core accelerated platforms. The main obstacle towards the adoption of such devices within industrial settings is related to the difficulties in tightly estimating the multiple interferences that may arise among the parallel components of the system. This in particular concerns concurrent accesses to shared memory and communication resources. Existing worst-case execution time analyses are extremely pessimistic, especially when adopted for systems composed of hundreds-tothousands of cores. This significantly limits the potential for the adoption of these platforms in real-time systems. In this paper, we study how the predictable execution model (PREM), a memory-aware approach to enable timing-predictability in realtime systems, can be successfully adopted on multi- and manycore heterogeneous platforms. Using a state-of-the-art multi-core platform as a testbed, we validate that it is possible to obtain an order-of-magnitude improvement in the WCET bounds of parallel applications, if data movements are adequately orchestrated in accordance with PREM. We identify which system parameters mostly affect the tremendous performance opportunities offered by this approach, both on average and in the worst case, moving the first step towards predictable many-core systems

WCET-Driven Dynamic Data Scratchpad Management With Compiler-Directed Prefetching

In recent years, the real-time community has produced a variety of approaches targeted at managing on-chip memory (scratchpads and caches) in a predictable way. However, to obtain safe WCET bounds, such techniques generally assume that the processor is stalled while waiting to reload the content of the on-chip memory; hence, they are less effective at hiding main memory latency compared to speculation-based techniques, such as hardware prefetching, that are largely used in general-purpose systems. In this work, we introduce a novel compiler-directed prefetching scheme for scratchpad memory that effectively hides the latency of main memory accesses by overlapping data transfers with the program execution. We implement and test an automated program compilation and optimization flow within the LLVM framework, and we show how to obtain improved WCET bounds through static analysis