Preference relations based unsupervised rank aggregation for metasearch

Rank aggregation mechanisms have been used in solving problems from various domains such as bioinformatics, natural language processing, information retrieval, etc. Metasearch is one such application where a user gives a query to the metasearch engine, and the metasearch engine forwards the query to multiple individual search engines. Results or rankings returned by these individual search engines are combined using rank aggregation algorithms to produce the final result to be displayed to the user. We identify few aspects that should be kept in mind for designing any rank aggregation algorithms for metasearch. For example, generally equal importance is given to the input rankings while performing the aggregation. However, depending on the indexed set of web pages, features considered for ranking, ranking functions used etc. by the individual search engines, the individual rankings may be of different qualities. So, the aggregation algorithm should give more weight to the better rankings while giving less weight to others. Also, since the aggregation is performed when the user is waiting for response, the operations performed in the algorithm need to be light weight. Moreover, getting supervised data for rank aggregation problem is often difficult. In this paper, we present an unsupervised rank aggregation algorithm that is suitable for metasearch and addresses the aspects mentioned above. We also perform detailed experimental evaluation of the proposed algorithm on four different benchmark datasets having ground truth information. Apart from the unsupervised Kendall-Tau distance measure, several supervised evaluation measures are used for performance comparison. Experimental results demonstrate the efficacy of the proposed algorithm over baseline methods in terms of supervised evaluation metrics. Through these experiments we also show that Kendall-Tau distance metric may not be suitable for evaluating rank aggregation algorithms for metasearch

Aggregated search: a new information retrieval paradigm

International audienceTraditional search engines return ranked lists of search results. It is up to the user to scroll this list, scan within different documents and assemble information that fulfill his/her information need. Aggregated search represents a new class of approaches where the information is not only retrieved but also assembled. This is the current evolution in Web search, where diverse content (images, videos, ...) and relational content (similar entities, features) are included in search results. In this survey, we propose a simple analysis framework for aggregated search and an overview of existing work. We start with related work in related domains such as federated search, natural language generation and question answering. Then we focus on more recent trends namely cross vertical aggregated search and relational aggregated search which are already present in current Web search

iAggregator: Multidimensional Relevance Aggregation Based on a Fuzzy Operator

International audienceRecently, an increasing number of information retrieval studies have triggered a resurgence of interest in redefining the algorithmic estimation of relevance, which implies a shift from topical to multidimensional relevance assessment. A key underlying aspect that emerged when addressing this concept is the aggregation of the relevance assessments related to each of the considered dimensions. The most commonly adopted forms of aggregation are based on classical weighted means and linear combination schemes to address this issue. Although some initiatives were recently proposed, none was concerned with considering the inherent dependencies and interactions existing among the relevance criteria, as is the case in many real-life applications. In this article, we present a new fuzzy-based operator, called iAggregator, for multidimensional relevance aggregation. Its main originality, beyond its ability to model interactions between different relevance criteria, lies in its generalization of many classical aggregation functions. To validate our proposal, we apply our operator within a tweet search task. Experiments using a standard benchmark, namely, Text REtrieval Conference Microblog,1 emphasize the relevance of our contribution when compared with traditional aggregation schemes. In addition, it outperforms state-of-the-art aggregation operators such as the Scoring and the And prioritized operators as well as some representative learning-to-rank algorithms

Model-based learning from preference data

International audiencePreference data occurs when assessors express comparative opinions about a set of items, by rating, ranking, pair comparing, liking or clicking. The purpose of preference learning is to (i) infer on the shared consensus preference of a group of users, sometimes called rank aggregation; or (ii) estimate for each user her individual ranking of the items, when the user indicates only incomplete preferences; this is an important part of recom-mender systems. We provide an overview of probabilistic approaches to preference learning, including the Mallows, Plackett-Luce, Bradley-Terry models and collaborative filtering, and some of their variations. We illustrate , compare and discuss the use of these models by means of an experiment in which assessors rank potatoes, and with a simulation. The purpose of this paper is not to recommend the use of one best method, but to present a palette of different possibilities for different questions and different types of data

Approaches to implement and evaluate aggregated search

La recherche d'information agrégée peut être vue comme un troisième paradigme de recherche d'information après la recherche d'information ordonnée (ranked retrieval) et la recherche d'information booléenne (boolean retrieval). Les deux paradigmes les plus explorés jusqu'à aujourd'hui retournent un ensemble ou une liste ordonnée de résultats. C'est à l'usager de parcourir ces ensembles/listes et d'en extraire l'information nécessaire qui peut se retrouver dans plusieurs documents. De manière alternative, la recherche d'information agrégée ne s'intéresse pas seulement à l'identification des granules (nuggets) d'information pertinents, mais aussi à l'assemblage d'une réponse agrégée contenant plusieurs éléments. Dans nos travaux, nous analysons les travaux liés à la recherche d'information agrégée selon un schéma général qui comprend 3 parties: dispatching de la requête, recherche de granules d'information et agrégation du résultat. Les approches existantes sont groupées autours de plusieurs perspectives générales telle que la recherche relationnelle, la recherche fédérée, la génération automatique de texte, etc. Ensuite, nous nous sommes focalisés sur deux pistes de recherche selon nous les plus prometteuses: (i) la recherche agrégée relationnelle et (ii) la recherche agrégée inter-verticale. * La recherche agrégée relationnelle s'intéresse aux relations entre les granules d'information pertinents qui servent à assembler la réponse agrégée. En particulier, nous nous sommes intéressés à trois types de requêtes notamment: requête attribut (ex. président de la France, PIB de l'Italie, maire de Glasgow, ...), requête instance (ex. France, Italie, Glasgow, Nokia e72, ...) et requête classe (pays, ville française, portable Nokia, ...). Pour ces requêtes qu'on appelle requêtes relationnelles nous avons proposés trois approches pour permettre la recherche de relations et l'assemblage des résultats. Nous avons d'abord mis l'accent sur la recherche d'attributs qui peut aider à répondre aux trois types de requêtes. Nous proposons une approche à large échelle capable de répondre à des nombreuses requêtes indépendamment de la classe d'appartenance. Cette approche permet l'extraction des attributs à partir des tables HTML en tenant compte de la qualité des tables et de la pertinence des attributs. Les différentes évaluations de performances effectuées prouvent son efficacité qui dépasse les méthodes de l'état de l'art. Deuxièmement, nous avons traité l'agrégation des résultats composés d'instances et d'attributs. Ce problème est intéressant pour répondre à des requêtes de type classe avec une table contenant des instances (lignes) et des attributs (colonnes). Pour garantir la qualité du résultat, nous proposons des pondérations sur les instances et les attributs promouvant ainsi les plus représentatifs. Le troisième problème traité concerne les instances de la même classe (ex. France, Italie, Allemagne, ...). Nous proposons une approche capable d'identifier massivement ces instances en exploitant les listes HTML. Toutes les approches proposées fonctionnent à l'échelle Web et sont importantes et complémentaires pour la recherche agrégée relationnelle. Enfin, nous proposons 4 prototypes d'application de recherche agrégée relationnelle. Ces derniers peuvent répondre des types de requêtes différents avec des résultats relationnels. Plus précisément, ils recherchent et assemblent des attributs, des instances, mais aussi des passages et des images dans des résultats agrégés. Un exemple est la requête ``Nokia e72" dont la réponse sera composée d'attributs (ex. prix, poids, autonomie batterie, ...), de passages (ex. description, reviews, ...) et d'images. Les résultats sont encourageants et illustrent l'utilité de la recherche agrégée relationnelle. * La recherche agrégée inter-verticale s'appuie sur plusieurs moteurs de recherche dits verticaux tel que la recherche d'image, recherche vidéo, recherche Web traditionnelle, etc. Son but principal est d'assembler des résultats provenant de toutes ces sources dans une même interface pour répondre aux besoins des utilisateurs. Les moteurs de recherche majeurs et la communauté scientifique nous offrent déjà une série d'approches. Notre contribution consiste en une étude sur l'évaluation et les avantages de ce paradigme. Plus précisément, nous comparons 4 types d'études qui simulent des situations de recherche sur un total de 100 requêtes et 9 sources différentes. Avec cette étude, nous avons identifiés clairement des avantages de la recherche agrégée inter-verticale et nous avons pu déduire de nombreux enjeux sur son évaluation. En particulier, l'évaluation traditionnelle utilisée en RI, certes la moins rapide, reste la plus réaliste. Pour conclure, nous avons proposé des différents approches et études sur deux pistes prometteuses de recherche dans le cadre de la recherche d'information agrégée. D'une côté, nous avons traité trois problèmes importants de la recherche agrégée relationnelle qui ont porté à la construction de 4 prototypes d'application avec des résultats encourageants. De l'autre côté, nous avons mis en place 4 études sur l'intérêt et l'évaluation de la recherche agrégée inter-verticale qui ont permis d'identifier les enjeux d'évaluation et les avantages du paradigme. Comme suite à long terme de ce travail, nous pouvons envisager une recherche d'information qui intègre plus de granules relationnels et plus de multimédia.Aggregated search or aggregated retrieval can be seen as a third paradigm for information retrieval following the Boolean retrieval paradigm and the ranked retrieval paradigm. In the first two, we are returned respectively sets and ranked lists of search results. It is up to the time-poor user to scroll this set/list, scan within different documents and assemble his/her information need. Alternatively, aggregated search not only aims the identification of relevant information nuggets, but also the assembly of these nuggets into a coherent answer. In this work, we present at first an analysis of related work to aggregated search which is analyzed with a general framework composed of three steps: query dispatching, nugget retrieval and result aggregation. Existing work is listed aside different related domains such as relational search, federated search, question answering, natural language generation, etc. Within the possible research directions, we have then focused on two directions we believe promise the most namely: relational aggregated search and cross-vertical aggregated search. * Relational aggregated search targets relevant information, but also relations between relevant information nuggets which are to be used to assemble reasonably the final answer. In particular, there are three types of queries which would easily benefit from this paradigm: attribute queries (e.g. president of France, GDP of Italy, major of Glasgow, ...), instance queries (e.g. France, Italy, Glasgow, Nokia e72, ...) and class queries (countries, French cities, Nokia mobile phones, ...). We call these queries as relational queries and we tackle with three important problems concerning the information retrieval and aggregation for these types of queries. First, we propose an attribute retrieval approach after arguing that attribute retrieval is one of the crucial problems to be solved. Our approach relies on the HTML tables in the Web. It is capable to identify useful and relevant tables which are used to extract relevant attributes for whatever queries. The different experimental results show that our approach is effective, it can answer many queries with high coverage and it outperforms state of the art techniques. Second, we deal with result aggregation where we are given relevant instances and attributes for a given query. The problem is particularly interesting for class queries where the final answer will be a table with many instances and attributes. To guarantee the quality of the aggregated result, we propose the use of different weights on instances and attributes to promote the most representative and important ones. The third problem we deal with concerns instances of the same class (e.g. France, Germany, Italy ... are all instances of the same class). Here, we propose an approach that can massively extract instances of the same class from HTML lists in the Web. All proposed approaches are applicable at Web-scale and they can play an important role for relational aggregated search. Finally, we propose 4 different prototype applications for relational aggregated search. They can answer different types of queries with relevant and relational information. Precisely, we not only retrieve attributes and their values, but also passages and images which are assembled into a final focused answer. An example is the query ``Nokia e72" which will be answered with attributes (e.g. price, weight, battery life ...), passages (e.g. description, reviews ...) and images. Results are encouraging and they illustrate the utility of relational aggregated search. * The second research direction that we pursued concerns cross-vertical aggregated search, which consists of assembling results from different vertical search engines (e.g. image search, video search, traditional Web search, ...) into one single interface. Here, different approaches exist in both research and industry. Our contribution concerns mostly evaluation and the interest (advantages) of this paradigm. We propose 4 different studies which simulate different search situations. Each study is tested with 100 different queries and 9 vertical sources. Here, we could clearly identify new advantages of this paradigm and we could identify different issues with evaluation setups. In particular, we observe that traditional information retrieval evaluation is not the fastest but it remains the most realistic. To conclude, we propose different studies with respect to two promising research directions. On one hand, we deal with three important problems of relational aggregated search following with real prototype applications with encouraging results. On the other hand, we have investigated on the interest and evaluation of cross-vertical aggregated search. Here, we could clearly identify some of the advantages and evaluation issues. In a long term perspective, we foresee a possible combination of these two kinds of approaches to provide relational and cross-vertical information retrieval incorporating more focus, structure and multimedia in search results

Probabilistic latent variable models for knowledge discovery and optimization

I conduct a systematic study of probabilistic latent variable models (PLVMs) with applications to knowledge discovery and optimization. Probabilistic modeling is a principled means to gain insight of data. By assuming that the observed data are generated from a distribution, we can estimate its density, or the statistics of our interest, by either Maximum Likelihood Estimation or Bayesian inference, depending on whether there is a prior distribution for the parameters of the assumed data distribution. One of the primary goals of various machine learning/data mining models is to reveal the underlying knowledge of observed data. A common practice is to introduce latent variables, which are modeled together with the observations. Such latent variables compute, for example, the class assignments (labels), the cluster membership, as well as other unobserved measurements of the data. Besides, proper exploitation of latent variables facilities the optimization itself, which leads to computationally efficient inference algorithms. In this thesis, I describe a range of applications where latent variables can be leveraged for knowledge discovery and efficient optimization. Works in this thesis demonstrate that PLVMs are a powerful tool for modeling incomplete observations. Through incorporating latent variables and assuming that the observations such as citations, pairwise preferences as well as text are generated following tractable distributions parametrized by the latent variables, PLVMs are flexible and effective to discover knowledge in data mining problems, where the knowledge is mathematically modelled as continuous or discrete values, distributions or uncertainty. In addition, I also explore PLVMs for deriving efficient algorithms. It has been shown that latent variables can be employed as a means for model reduction and facilitates the computation/sampling of intractable distributions. Our results lead to algorithms which take advantage of latent variables in probabilistic models. We conduct experiments against state-of-the-art models and empirical evaluation shows that our proposed approaches improve both learning performance and computational efficiency

Semantically en enhanced information retrieval: an ontology-based aprroach

Tesis doctoral inédita. Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Escuela Politécnica Superior, enero de 2009Bibliogr.: [227]-240 p

Proceedings of the ECIR2010 workshop on information access for personal media archives (IAPMA2010), Milton Keynes, UK, 28 March 2010

Towards e-Memories: challenges of capturing, summarising, presenting, understanding, using, and retrieving relevant information from heterogeneous data contained in personal media archives. This is the proceedings of the inaugural workshop on “Information Access for Personal Media Archives”. It is now possible to archive much of our life experiences in digital form using a variety of sources, e.g. blogs written, tweets made, social network status updates, photographs taken, videos seen, music heard, physiological monitoring, locations visited and environmentally sensed data of those places, details of people met, etc. Information can be captured from a myriad of personal information devices including desktop computers, PDAs, digital cameras, video and audio recorders, and various sensors, including GPS, Bluetooth, and biometric devices. In this workshop research from diverse disciplines was presented on how we can advance towards the goal of effective capture, retrieval and exploration of e-memories