The Cost of Application-Class Processing: Energy and Performance Analysis of a Linux-Ready 1.7-GHz 64-Bit RISC-V Core in 22-nm FDSOI Technology

The open-source RISC-V instruction set architecture (ISA) is gaining traction, both in industry and academia. The ISA is designed to scale from microcontrollers to server-class processors. Furthermore, openness promotes the availability of various open-source and commercial implementations. Our main contribution in this paper is a thorough power, performance, and efficiency analysis of the RISC-V ISA targeting baseline "application class" functionality, i.e., supporting the Linux OS and its application environment based on our open-source single-issue in-order implementation of the 64-bit ISA variant (RV64GC) called Ariane. Our analysis is based on a detailed power and efficiency analysis of the RISC-V ISA extracted from silicon measurements and calibrated simulation of an Ariane instance (RV64IMC) taped-out in GlobalFoundries 22FDX technology. Ariane runs at up to 1.7-GHz, achieves up to 40-Gop/sW energy efficiency, which is superior to similar cores presented in the literature. We provide insight into the interplay between functionality required for the application-class execution (e.g., virtual memory, caches, and multiple modes of privileged operation) and energy cost. We also compare Ariane with RISCY, a simpler and a slower microcontroller-class core. Our analysis confirms that supporting application-class execution implies a nonnegligible energy-efficiency loss and that compute performance is more cost-effectively boosted by instruction extensions (e.g., packed SIMD) rather than the high-frequency operation

Low-cost error detection through high-level synthesis

System-on-chip design is becoming increasingly complex as technology scaling enables more and more functionality on a chip. This scaling and complexity has resulted in a variety of reliability and validation challenges including logic bugs, hot spots, wear-out, and soft errors. To make matters worse, as we reach the limits of Dennard scaling, efforts to improve system performance and energy efficiency have resulted in the integration of a wide variety of complex hardware accelerators in SoCs. Thus the challenge is to design complex, custom hardware that is efficient, but also correct and reliable. High-level synthesis shows promise to address the problem of complex hardware design by providing a bridge from the high-productivity software domain to the hardware design process. Much research has been done on high-level synthesis efficiency optimizations. This thesis shows that high-level synthesis also has the power to address validation and reliability challenges through two solutions. One solution for circuit reliability is modulo-3 shadow datapaths: performing lightweight shadow computations in modulo-3 space for each main computation. We leverage the binding and scheduling flexibility of high-level synthesis to detect control errors through diverse binding and minimize area cost through intelligent checkpoint scheduling and modulo-3 reducer sharing. We introduce logic and dataflow optimizations to further reduce cost. We evaluated our technique with 12 high-level synthesis benchmarks from the arithmetic-oriented PolyBench benchmark suite using FPGA emulated netlist-level error injection. We observe coverages of 99.1% for stuck-at faults, 99.5% for soft errors, and 99.6% for timing errors with a 25.7% area cost and negligible performance impact. Leveraging a mean error detection latency of 12.75 cycles (4150x faster than end result check) for soft errors, we also explore a rollback recovery method with an additional area cost of 28.0%, observing a 175x increase in reliability against soft errors. Another solution for rapid post-silicon validation of accelerator designs is Hybrid Quick Error Detection (H-QED): inserting signature generation logic in a hardware design to create a heavily compressed signature stream that captures the internal behavior of the design at a fine temporal and spatial granularity for comparison with a reference set of signatures generated by high-level simulation to detect bugs. Using H-QED, we demonstrate an improvement in error detection latency (time elapsed from when a bug is activated to when it manifests as an observable failure) of two orders of magnitude and a threefold improvement in bug coverage compared to traditional post-silicon validation techniques. H-QED also uncovered previously unknown bugs in the CHStone benchmark suite, which is widely used by the HLS community. H-QED incurs less than 10% area overhead for the accelerator it validates with negligible performance impact, and we also introduce techniques to minimize any possible intrusiveness introduced by H-QED

Fine-grained Energy / Power Instrumentation for Software-level Efficiency Optimization

In the pursuit of both increased energy-efficiency, as well as high-performance, architects are constructing increasingly complex Systems-on-Chip with a variety of processor cores and DMA controllers. This complexity makes software implementation and optimization difficult, particularly when multiple independent applications may be running concurrently on such a heterogeneous platform. In order to take full advantage of the underlying system, increased visibility into the interaction between the software and hardware is needed. This paper proposes on-line and off-line fine-grained instrumentation of SoC components in hardware (e.g. as part of the debug & trace infrastructure) in order to enable improvements and optimization for energy efficiency to be undertaken at higher levels of abstraction, i.e. the programmer and runtime scheduler. Energy counters are incorporated for each component that keep track of energy use. These counters are indexed by customer number tags, that are used to distinguish between the transactions executed on any given component by client applications running in a multitasking SoC environment. The contents of the counters for each augmented component, correlated with the appropriate consumer-numbers, are extracted from a running SoC under test via existing debug & trace interfaces like GDBserver, JTAG and various proprietary trace probes. In addition, auxiliary processing on-chip computes local and global energy figures and offers them through a 4-layer abstraction stack so that programmer-level finegrained energy measurement is made available. Both the O/S scheduler and programmers can adapt their policies and coding styles for their desired energy/performance tradeoff

Automated Debugging Methodology for FPGA-based Systems

Electronic devices make up a vital part of our lives. These are seen from mobiles, laptops, computers, home automation, etc. to name a few. The modern designs constitute billions of transistors. However, with this evolution, ensuring that the devices fulfill the designer’s expectation under variable conditions has also become a great challenge. This requires a lot of design time and effort. Whenever an error is encountered, the process is re-started. Hence, it is desired to minimize the number of spins required to achieve an error-free product, as each spin results in loss of time and effort. Software-based simulation systems present the main technique to ensure the verification of the design before fabrication. However, few design errors (bugs) are likely to escape the simulation process. Such bugs subsequently appear during the post-silicon phase. Finding such bugs is time-consuming due to inherent invisibility of the hardware. Instead of software simulation of the design in the pre-silicon phase, post-silicon techniques permit the designers to verify the functionality through the physical implementations of the design. The main benefit of the methodology is that the implemented design in the post-silicon phase runs many order-of-magnitude faster than its counterpart in pre-silicon. This allows the designers to validate their design more exhaustively. This thesis presents five main contributions to enable a fast and automated debugging solution for reconfigurable hardware. During the research work, we used an obstacle avoidance system for robotic vehicles as a use case to illustrate how to apply the proposed debugging solution in practical environments. The first contribution presents a debugging system capable of providing a lossless trace of debugging data which permits a cycle-accurate replay. This methodology ensures capturing permanent as well as intermittent errors in the implemented design. The contribution also describes a solution to enhance hardware observability. It is proposed to utilize processor-configurable concentration networks, employ debug data compression to transmit the data more efficiently, and partially reconfiguring the debugging system at run-time to save the time required for design re-compilation as well as preserve the timing closure. The second contribution presents a solution for communication-centric designs. Furthermore, solutions for designs with multi-clock domains are also discussed. The third contribution presents a priority-based signal selection methodology to identify the signals which can be more helpful during the debugging process. A connectivity generation tool is also presented which can map the identified signals to the debugging system. The fourth contribution presents an automated error detection solution which can help in capturing the permanent as well as intermittent errors without continuous monitoring of debugging data. The proposed solution works for designs even in the absence of golden reference. The fifth contribution proposes to use artificial intelligence for post-silicon debugging. We presented a novel idea of using a recurrent neural network for debugging when a golden reference is present for training the network. Furthermore, the idea was also extended to designs where golden reference is not present

Robust and reliable hardware accelerator design through high-level synthesis

System-on-chip design is becoming increasingly complex as technology scaling enables more and more functionality on a chip. This scaling-driven complexity has resulted in a variety of reliability and validation challenges including logic bugs, hot spots, wear-out, and soft errors. To make matters worse, as we reach the limits of Dennard scaling, efforts to improve system performance and energy efficiency have resulted in the integration of a wide variety of complex hardware accelerators in SoCs. Thus the challenge is to design complex, custom hardware that is efficient, but also correct and reliable. High-level synthesis shows promise to address the problem of complex hardware design by providing a bridge from the high-productivity software domain to the hardware design process. Much research has been done on high-level synthesis efficiency optimizations. This dissertation shows that high-level synthesis also has the power to address validation and reliability challenges through three automated solutions targeting three key stages in the hardware design and use cycle: pre-silicon debugging, post-silicon validation, and post-deployment error detection. Our solution for rapid pre-silicon debugging of accelerator designs is hybrid tracing: comparing a datapath-level trace of hardware execution with a reference software implementation at a fine temporal and spatial granularity to detect logic bugs. An integrated backtrace process delivers source-code meaning to the hardware designer, pinpointing the location of bug activation and providing a strong hint for potential bug fixes. Experimental results show that we are able to detect and aid in localization of logic bugs from both C/C++ specifications as well as the high-level synthesis engine itself. A variation of this solution tailored for rapid post-silicon validation of accelerator designs is hybrid hashing: inserting signature generation logic in a hardware design to create a heavily compressed signature stream that captures the internal behavior of the design at a fine temporal and spatial granularity for comparison with a reference set of signatures generated by high-level simulation to detect bugs. Using hybrid hashing, we demonstrate an improvement in error detection latency (time elapsed from when a bug is activated to when it manifests as an observable failure) of two orders of magnitude and a threefold improvement in bug coverage compared to traditional post-silicon validation techniques. Hybrid hashing also uncovered previously unknown bugs in the CHStone benchmark suite, which is widely used by the HLS community. Hybrid hashing incurs less than 10% area overhead for the accelerator it validates with negligible performance impact, and we also introduce techniques to minimize any possible intrusiveness introduced by hybrid hashing. Finally, our solution for post-deployment error detection is modulo-3 shadow datapaths: performing lightweight shadow computations in modulo-3 space for each main computation. We leverage the binding and scheduling flexibility of high-level synthesis to detect control errors through diverse binding and minimize area cost through intelligent checkpoint scheduling and modulo-3 reducer sharing. We introduce logic and dataflow optimizations to further reduce cost. We evaluated our technique with 12 high-level synthesis benchmarks from the arithmetic-oriented PolyBench benchmark suite using FPGA emulated netlist-level error injection. We observe coverages of 99.1% for stuck-at faults, 99.5% for soft errors, and 99.6% for timing errors with a 25.7% area cost and negligible performance impact. Leveraging a mean error detection latency of 12.75 cycles (4150× faster than end result check) for soft errors, we also explore a rollback recovery method with an additional area cost of 28.0%, observing a 175× increase in reliability against soft errors. While the area cost of our modulo shadow datapaths is much better than traditional modular redundancy approaches, we want to maximize the applicability of our approach. To this end, we take a dive into gate-level architectural design for modulo arithmetic functional units. We introduce new low-cost gate-level architectures for all four key functional units in a shadow datapath: (1) a modulo reduction algorithm that generates architectures consisting entirely of full-adder standard cells; (2) minimum-area modulo adder and subtractor architectures; (3) an array-based modulo multiplier design; and (4) a modulo equality comparator that handles the residue encoding produced by the above. We compare our new functional units to the previous state-of-the-art approach, observing a 12.5% reduction in area and a 47.1% reduction in delay for a 32-bit mod-3 reducer; that our reducer costs, which tend to dominate shadow datapath costs, do not increase with larger modulo bases; and that for modulo-15 and above, all of our modulo functional units have better area and delay then their previous counterparts. We also demonstrate the practicality of our approach by designing a custom shadow datapath for error detection of a multiply accumulate functional unit, which has an area overhead of only 12% for a 32-bit main datapath and 2-bit modulo-3 shadow datapath. Taking our reliability solution further, we look at the bigger picture of modulo shadow datapaths combined with other solutions at different abstraction layers, looking to answer the following question: Given all of the existing reliability improvement techniques for application-specific hardware accelerators, what techniques or combinations of techniques are the most cost-effective? To answer this question, we consider a soft error fault model and empirically evaluate cross-layer combinations of ABFT, EDDI, and modulo shadow datapaths in the context of high-level synthesis; parity in logic synthesis; and flip-flop hardening techniques at the physical design level. We measure the reliability benefit and area, energy, and performance cost of each technique individually and for interesting technique combinations through FPGA emulated fault-injection and physical place-and-route. Our results show that a combination of parity and flip-flop hardening is the most cost-effective in general with an average 1.3% area cost and 5.7% energy cost for a 50× improvement in reliability. The addition of modulo-3 shadow datapaths to this combination provides some additional benefit for some applications, even without considering its combinational logic, stuck-at fault, and timing error protection benefits. We also observe new efficiency challenges for ABFT and EDDI when used for hardware accelerators