A Bang-Bang All-Digital PLL for Frequency Synthesis

abstract: Phase locked loops are an integral part of any electronic system that requires a clock signal and find use in a broad range of applications such as clock and data recovery circuits for high speed serial I/O and frequency synthesizers for RF transceivers and ADCs. Traditionally, PLLs have been primarily analog in nature and since the development of the charge pump PLL, they have almost exclusively been analog. Recently, however, much research has been focused on ADPLLs because of their scalability, flexibility and higher noise immunity. This research investigates some of the latest all-digital PLL architectures and discusses the qualities and tradeoffs of each. A highly flexible and scalable all-digital PLL based frequency synthesizer is implemented in 180 nm CMOS process. This implementation makes use of a binary phase detector, also commonly called a bang-bang phase detector, which has potential of use in high-speed, sub-micron processes due to the simplicity of the phase detector which can be implemented with a simple D flip flop. Due to the nonlinearity introduced by the phase detector, there are certain performance limitations. This architecture incorporates a separate frequency control loop which can alleviate some of these limitations, such as lock range and acquisition time.Dissertation/ThesisM.S. Electrical Engineering 201

LOW-JITTER AND LOW-SPUR RING-OSCILLATOR-BASED PHASE-LOCKED LOOPS

Department of Electrical EngineeringIn recent years, ring-oscillator based clock generators have drawn a lot of attention due to the merits of high area efficiency, potentially wide tuning range, and multi-phase generation. However, the key challenge is how to suppress the poor jitter of ring oscillators. There have been many efforts to develop a ring-oscillator-based clock generator targeting very low-jitter performance. However, it remains difficult for conventional architectures to achieve both low RMS jitter and low levels of reference spurs concurrently while having a high multiplication factor. In this dissertation, a time-domain analysis is presented that provides an intuitive understanding of RMS jitter calculation of the clock generators from their phase-error correction mechanisms. Based on this analysis, we propose new designs of a ring-oscillator-based PLL that addresses the challenges of prior-art ring-based architectures. This dissertation introduces a ring-oscillator-based PLL with the proposed fast phase-error correction (FPEC) technique, which emulates the phase-realignment mechanism of an injection-locked clock multiplier (ILCM). With the FPEC technique, the phase error of the voltage-controlled oscillator (VCO) is quickly removed, achieving ultra-low jitter. In addition, in the transfer function of the proposed architecture, an intrinsic integrator is involved since it is naturally based on a PLL topology. The proposed PLL can thus have low levels of reference spurs while maintaining high stability even for a large multiplication factor. Furthermore, it presents another design of a digital PLL embodying the FPEC technique (or FPEC DPLL). To overcome the problem of a conventional TDC, a low-power optimally-spaced (OS) TDC capable of effectively minimizing the quantization error is presented. In the proposed FPEC DPLL, background digital controllers continuously calibrate the decision thresholds and the gain of the error correction by the loop to be optimal, thus dramatically reducing the quantization error. Since the proposed architecture is implemented in a digital fashion, the variables defining the characteristics of the loop can be easily estimated and calibrated by digital calibrators. As a result, the performances of an ultra-low jitter and the figure-of-merit can be achieved.clos

Clock Generator Circuits for Low-Power Heterogeneous Multiprocessor Systems-on-Chip

In this work concepts and circuits for local clock generation in low-power heterogeneous multiprocessor systems-on-chip (MPSoCs) are researched and developed. The targeted systems feature a globally asynchronous locally synchronous (GALS) clocking architecture and advanced power management functionality, as for example fine-grained ultra-fast dynamic voltage and frequency scaling (DVFS). To enable this functionality compact clock generators with low chip area, low power consumption, wide output frequency range and the capability for ultra-fast frequency changes are required. They are to be instantiated individually per core. For this purpose compact all digital phase-locked loop (ADPLL) frequency synthesizers are developed. The bang-bang ADPLL architecture is analyzed using a numerical system model and optimized for low jitter accumulation. A 65nm CMOS ADPLL is implemented, featuring a novel active current bias circuit which compensates the supply voltage and temperature sensitivity of the digitally controlled oscillator (DCO) for reduced digital tuning effort. Additionally, a 28nm ADPLL with a new ultra-fast lock-in scheme based on single-shot phase synchronization is proposed. The core clock is generated by an open-loop method using phase-switching between multi-phase DCO clocks at a fixed frequency. This allows instantaneous core frequency changes for ultra-fast DVFS without re-locking the closed loop ADPLL. The sensitivity of the open-loop clock generator with respect to phase mismatch is analyzed analytically and a compensation technique by cross-coupled inverter buffers is proposed. The clock generators show small area (0.0097mm2 (65nm), 0.00234mm2 (28nm)), low power consumption (2.7mW (65nm), 0.64mW (28nm)) and they provide core clock frequencies from 83MHz to 666MHz which can be changed instantaneously. The jitter performance is compliant to DDR2/DDR3 memory interface specifications. Additionally, high-speed clocks for novel serial on-chip data transceivers are generated. The ADPLL circuits have been verified successfully by 3 testchip implementations. They enable efficient realization of future low-power MPSoCs with advanced power management functionality in deep-submicron CMOS technologies.In dieser Arbeit werden Konzepte und Schaltungen zur lokalen Takterzeugung in heterogenen Multiprozessorsystemen (MPSoCs) mit geringer Verlustleistung erforscht und entwickelt. Diese Systeme besitzen eine global-asynchrone lokal-synchrone Architektur sowie Funktionalität zum Power Management, wie z.B. das feingranulare, schnelle Skalieren von Spannung und Taktfrequenz (DVFS). Um diese Funktionalität zu realisieren werden kompakte Taktgeneratoren benötigt, welche eine kleine Chipfläche einnehmen, wenig Verlustleitung aufnehmen, einen weiten Bereich an Ausgangsfrequenzen erzeugen und diese sehr schnell ändern können. Sie sollen individuell pro Prozessorkern integriert werden. Dazu werden kompakte volldigitale Phasenregelkreise (ADPLLs) entwickelt, wobei eine bang-bang ADPLL Architektur numerisch modelliert und für kleine Jitterakkumulation optimiert wird. Es wird eine 65nm CMOS ADPLL implementiert, welche eine neuartige Kompensationsschlatung für den digital gesteuerten Oszillator (DCO) zur Verringerung der Sensitivität bezüglich Versorgungsspannung und Temperatur beinhaltet. Zusätzlich wird eine 28nm CMOS ADPLL mit einer neuen Technik zum schnellen Einschwingen unter Nutzung eines Phasensynchronisierers realisiert. Der Prozessortakt wird durch ein neuartiges Phasenmultiplex- und Frequenzteilerverfahren erzeugt, welches es ermöglicht die Taktfrequenz sofort zu ändern um schnelles DVFS zu realisieren. Die Sensitivität dieses Frequenzgenerators bezüglich Phasen-Mismatch wird theoretisch analysiert und durch Verwendung von kreuzgekoppelten Taktverstärkern kompensiert. Die hier entwickelten Taktgeneratoren haben eine kleine Chipfläche (0.0097mm2 (65nm), 0.00234mm2 (28nm)) und Leistungsaufnahme (2.7mW (65nm), 0.64mW (28nm)). Sie stellen Frequenzen von 83MHz bis 666MHz bereit, welche sofort geändert werden können. Die Schaltungen erfüllen die Jitterspezifikationen von DDR2/DDR3 Speicherinterfaces. Zusätzliche können schnelle Takte für neuartige serielle on-Chip Verbindungen erzeugt werden. Die ADPLL Schaltungen wurden erfolgreich in 3 Testchips erprobt. Sie ermöglichen die effiziente Realisierung von zukünftigen MPSoCs mit Power Management in modernsten CMOS Technologien

Générateur distribué d'horloge pour puces globalement et localement synchrones de grande taille

This thesis addresses the problem of global synchronization of large system on chip (SoC). It focuses on the study of an alternative clock generation technique to conventional clock distribution and asynchronous communication. It allows implementation of highly reliable synchronous circuit. My PhD project aims to study and implement a large network (10x10) of all digital phase-locked loop (ADPLL), containing 100 nodes generating a clock for each local digital circuitry. The prototype was implemented on silicon generating clocks in the range 903-1161 MHz. It highlights a maximum phase error of less than 40 ps between two clocks in any neighboring zones. Another important result is the analysis of phase error between two non-neighboring oscillators in distance. By studying an FPGA prototype of the network, we obtained that maximum phase error at steady state between any clock signal and the reference signal is less than three steps of the PFD quantification steps. In order to validate the performance of synchronization in ASIC, we designed an on-chip clocking error measurement circuit. This circuit has a low rate for the off-chip readout (several MHz), and a high resolution (+-2.5 ps). Reconfigurability is another attractive feature. We have explored this feature and proposed a novel topology with different configurations for nodes on the border and in the kernel of the network. This topology has an advantage in prohibiting phase error propagation and reflection.Cette thèse aborde le problème de la synchronisation globale de grand système sur puce (SoC). Il est centré sur l'étude d'une technique de remplacement de la distribution d'horloge classique et d'une communication asynchrone. Il permet la mise en œuvre de circuit synchrone très fiable. Mon projet de thèse vise à étudier et mettre en œuvre un vaste réseau (10x10) de boucle à verrouillage de phase tous numérique (ADPLL), contenant 100 nœuds générant une horloge pour chaque circuit numérique local. Le prototype a été réalisé sur les horloges de génération de silicium dans la gamme de 903-1161 MHz. Elle met en évidence une erreur de phase maximale de moins de 40 ps entre deux horloges dans toutes les zones voisines. Un autre résultat important est l'analyse de l'erreur de phase entre les deux oscillateurs non-voisins dans la distance. En étudiant un prototype FPGA du réseau, on a obtenu que l'erreur de phase maximale à l'état d'équilibre entre un signal d'horloge et le signal de référence est inférieur à trois étapes des étapes de quantification PFD. Afin de valider les performances de la synchronisation dans ASIC, nous avons conçu un circuit d'une erreur de mesure sur la puce d'horloge. Ce circuit a un taux faible de la lecture hors puce (quelques MHz), et une résolution élevée (+ -2,5 ps). Reconfiguration constitue une autre caractéristique intéressante. Nous avons exploré cette fonction et a proposé une nouvelle topologie avec des configurations différentes pour les nœuds sur la frontière et dans le noyau du réseau. Cette topologie présente un avantage en interdisant la propagation des erreurs de phase et de réflexion

Special Topics in Information Technology

This open access book presents thirteen outstanding doctoral dissertations in Information Technology from the Department of Electronics, Information and Bioengineering, Politecnico di Milano, Italy. Information Technology has always been highly interdisciplinary, as many aspects have to be considered in IT systems. The doctoral studies program in IT at Politecnico di Milano emphasizes this interdisciplinary nature, which is becoming more and more important in recent technological advances, in collaborative projects, and in the education of young researchers. Accordingly, the focus of advanced research is on pursuing a rigorous approach to specific research topics starting from a broad background in various areas of Information Technology, especially Computer Science and Engineering, Electronics, Systems and Control, and Telecommunications. Each year, more than 50 PhDs graduate from the program. This book gathers the outcomes of the thirteen best theses defended in 2019-20 and selected for the IT PhD Award. Each of the authors provides a chapter summarizing his/her findings, including an introduction, description of methods, main achievements and future work on the topic. Hence, the book provides a cutting-edge overview of the latest research trends in Information Technology at Politecnico di Milano, presented in an easy-to-read format that will also appeal to non-specialists

Toward realizing power scalable and energy proportional high-speed wireline links

Growing computational demand and proliferation of cloud computing has placed high-speed serial links at the center stage. Due to saturating energy efficiency improvements over the last five years, increasing the data throughput comes at the cost of power consumption. Conventionally, serial link power can be reduced by optimizing individual building blocks such as output drivers, receiver, or clock generation and distribution. However, this approach yields very limited efficiency improvement. This dissertation takes an alternative approach toward reducing the serial link power. Instead of optimizing the power of individual building blocks, power of the entire serial link is reduced by exploiting serial link usage by the applications. It has been demonstrated that serial links in servers are underutilized. On average, they are used only 15% of the time, i.e. these links are idle for approximately 85% of the time. Conventional links consume power during idle periods to maintain synchronization between the transmitter and the receiver. However, by powering-off the link when idle and powering it back when needed, power consumption of the serial link can be scaled proportionally to its utilization. This approach of rapid power state transitioning is known as the rapid-on/off approach. For the rapid-on/off to be effective, ideally the power-on time, off-state power, and power state transition energy must all be close to zero. However, in practice, it is very difficult to achieve these ideal conditions. Work presented in this dissertation addresses these challenges. When this research work was started (2011-12), there were only a couple of research papers available in the area of rapid-on/off links. Systematic study or design of a rapid power state transitioning in serial links was not available in the literature. Since rapid-on/off with nanoseconds granularity is not a standard in any wireline communication, even the popular test equipment does not support testing any such feature, neither any formal measurement methodology was available. All these circumstances made the beginning difficult. However, these challenges provided a unique opportunity to explore new architectural techniques and identify trade-offs. The key contributions of this dissertation are as follows. The first and foremost contribution is understanding the underlying limitations of saturating energy efficiency improvements in serial links and why there is a compelling need to find alternative ways to reduce the serial link power. The second contribution is to identify potential power saving techniques and evaluate the challenges they pose and the opportunities they present. The third contribution is the design of a 5Gb/s transmitter with a rapid-on/off feature. The transmitter achieves rapid-on/off capability in voltage mode output driver by using a fast-digital regulator, and in the clock multiplier by accurate frequency pre-setting and periodic reference insertion. To ease timing requirements, an improved edge replacement logic circuit for the clock multiplier is proposed. Mathematical modeling of power-on time as a function of various circuit parameters is also discussed. The proposed transmitter demonstrates energy proportional operation over wide variations of link utilization, and is, therefore, suitable for energy efficient links. Fabricated in 90nm CMOS technology, the voltage mode driver, and the clock multiplier achieve power-on-time of only 2ns and 10ns, respectively. This dissertation highlights key trade-off in the clock multiplier architecture, to achieve fast power-on-lock capability at the cost of jitter performance. The fourth contribution is the design of a 7GHz rapid-on/off LC-PLL based clock multi- plier. The phase locked loop (PLL) based multiplier was developed to overcome the limita- tions of the MDLL based approach. Proposed temperature compensated LC-PLL achieves power-on-lock in 1ns. The fifth and biggest contribution of this dissertation is the design of a 7Gb/s embedded clock transceiver, which achieves rapid-on/off capability in LC-PLL, current-mode transmit- ter and receiver. It was the first reported design of a complete transceiver, with an embedded clock architecture, having rapid-on/off capability. Background phase calibration technique in PLL and CDR phase calibration logic in the receiver enable instantaneous lock on power-on. The proposed transceiver demonstrates power scalability with a wide range of link utiliza- tion and, therefore, helps in improving overall system efficiency. Fabricated in 65nm CMOS technology, the 7Gb/s transceiver achieves power-on-lock in less than 20ns. The transceiver achieves power scaling by 44x (63.7mW-to-1.43mW) and energy efficiency degradation by only 2.2x (9.1pJ/bit-to-20.5pJ/bit), when the effective data rate (link utilization) changes by 100x (7Gb/s-to-70Mb/s). The sixth and final contribution is the design of a temperature sensor to compensate the frequency drifts due to temperature variations, during long power-off periods, in the fast power-on-lock LC-PLL. The proposed self-referenced VCO-based temperature sensor is designed with all digital logic gates and achieves low supply sensitivity. This sensor is suitable for integration in processor and DRAM environments. The proposed sensor works on the principle of directly converting temperature information to frequency and finally to digital bits. A novel sensing technique is proposed in which temperature information is acquired by creating a threshold voltage difference between the transistors used in the oscillators. Reduced supply sensitivity is achieved by employing junction capacitance, and the overhead of voltage regulators and an external ideal reference frequency is avoided. The effect of VCO phase noise on the sensor resolution is mathematically evaluated. Fabricated in the 65nm CMOS process, the prototype can operate with a supply ranging from 0.85V to 1.1V, and it achieves a supply sensitivity of 0.034oC/mV and an inaccuracy of ±0.9oC and ±2.3oC from 0-100oC after 2-point calibration, with and without static nonlinearity correction, respectively. It achieves a resolution of 0.3oC, resolution FoM of 0.3(nJ/conv)res2 , and measurement (conversion) time of 6.5μs

Circuits and Systems for On-Chip RF Chemical Sensors and RF FDD Duplexers

Integrating RF bio-chemical sensors and RF duplexers helps to reduce cost and area in the current applications. Furthermore, new applications can exist based on the large scale integration of these crucial blocks. This dissertation addresses the integration of RF bio-chemical sensors and RF duplexers by proposing these initiatives. A low power integrated LC-oscillator-based broadband dielectric spectroscopy (BDS) system is presented. The real relative permittivity ε’r is measured as a shift in the oscillator frequency using an on-chip frequency-to-digital converter (FDC). The imaginary relative permittivity ε”r increases the losses of the oscillator tank which mandates a higher dc biasing current to preserve the same oscillation amplitude. An amplitude-locked loop (ALL) is used to fix the amplitude and linearize the relation between the oscillator bias current and ε”r. The proposed BDS system employs a sensing oscillator and a reference oscillator where correlated double sampling (CDS) is used to mitigate the impact of flicker noise, temperature variations and frequency drifts. A prototype is implemented in 0.18 µm CMOS process with total chip area of 6.24 mm^2 to operate in 1-6 GHz range using three dual bands LC oscillators. The achieved standard deviation in the air is 2.1 ppm for frequency reading and 110 ppm for current reading. A tunable integrated electrical balanced duplexer (EBD) is presented as a compact alternative to multiple bulky SAW and BAW duplexers in 3G/4G cellular transceivers. A balancing network creates a replica of the transmitter signal for cancellation at the input of a single-ended low noise amplifier (LNA) to isolate the receive path from the transmitter. The proposed passive EBD is based on a cross-connected transformer topology without the need of any extra balun at the antenna side. The duplexer achieves around 50 dB TX-RX isolation within 1.6-2.2 GHz range up to 22 dBm. The cascaded noise figure of the duplexer and LNA is 6.5 dB, and TX insertion loss (TXIL) of the duplexer is about 3.2 dB. The duplexer and LNA are implemented in 0.18 µm CMOS process and occupy an active area of 0.35 mm^2

Tanlock based loop with improved performance

This thesis is focused on the design, analysis, simulation and implementation of new improved architectures of the Time Delay Digital Tanlock Loop (TDTL) based digital phase-locked loop (DPLL). The proposed architectures overcome some fundamental limitations exhibited by the original TDTL. These limitations include the presence of nonlinearity in the phase detector (PD), the non-zero phase error of the first-order loop, the restricted locking range, particularly of the second-order loop, the limited acquisition speed and the noise performance. Two approaches were adopted in this work to alleviate these limitations: the first involved modifying the original TDTL through the incorporation of auxiliary circuit blocks that enhance its performance, whilst the second involved designing new tanlock-based architectures. The proposed architectures, which resulted from the above approaches, were tested under various input signal conditions and their performance was compared with the original TDTL. The proposed architectures demonstrated an improvement of up to fourfold in terms of the acquisition times, twofold in noise performance and a marked enhancement in the linearity and in the locking range. The effectiveness of the proposed tanlock-based architectures was also assessed and demonstrated by using them in various applications, which included FM demodulation, FM threshold extension, FM demodulation with improved THD (total harmonic distortion), and Doppler effect improvement. The results from these applications showed that the performance of the new architectures outperformed the original TDTL. Real-time performance of these architectures was evaluated through implementation of some of them on an FPGA (field-programmable gate array) based system. Practical results from the prototype FPGA based implementations confirmed the simulation results obtained from MATLAB/Simulink

Integration of Flywheel Energy Storage Systems in Low Voltage Distribution Grids

Mit dem Ziel, den Stromsektor zu dekarbonisieren und dem Klimawandel zu begegnen, steigt der Anteil erneuerbarer Energieressourcen in den Energiesystemen rund um den Globus kontinuierlich an. Aufgrund des intermittierenden Charakters dieser Ressourcen kann die Aufrechterhaltung des momentanen Gleichgewichts zwischen Erzeugung und Verbrauch und damit der Netzfrequenz ohne angemessene Maßnahmen jedoch eine Herausforderung darstellen. Da erneuerbare Energiequellen mit Umrichterschnittstellen dem System selbst keine Trägheit verleihen, nimmt gleichzeitig die kumulative Systemträgheit ab, was zu schnelleren Änderungen der Netzfrequenz und Bedenken hinsichtlich der Netzstabilität führt. Ein Schwungrad-Energiespeichersystem (Flywheel Energy Storage System, FESS) kann schnell große Leistungsmengen einspeisen oder aufnehmen, um das Netz nach einer abrupten Änderung der Erzeugung oder des Verbrauchs zu unterstützen. Neben der schnellen Reaktionszeit hat ein FESS den Vorteil einer hohen Leistungsdichte und einer großen Anzahl von Lade- und Entladezyklen ohne Kapazitätsverlust während seiner gesamten Lebensdauer. Diese Eigenschaften machen das FESS zu einem gut geeigneten Kandidaten für die Frequenzstabilisierung des Netzes oder die Glättung kurzfristiger Leistungsschwankungen auf lokaler Ebene. In dieser Dissertation wird die Netzintegration eines Hochgeschwindigkeits-FESS auf der Niederspannungsebene aus mehreren Perspektiven untersucht. Zunächst wird das Problem der Platzierung und Dimensionierung eines FESS in Niederspannungsverteilnetzen für Leistungsglättungsanwendungen behandelt. Um den am besten geeigneten Standort für ein FESS zu finden, wird eine datengetriebene Methode zur Abschätzung der relativen Spannungsempfindlichkeit vorgestellt, die auf dem Konzept der Transinformation basiert. Der Hauptvorteil der vorgeschlagenen Methode besteht darin, dass sie kein Netzmodell erfordert und nur Messwerte an den interessierenden Punkten verwendet. Messergebnisse aus einem realen Netz in Süddeutschland zeigen, dass mit dem vorgeschlagenen Ansatz die Netzanschlusspunkte mit einer höheren Spannungsempfindlichkeit gegenüber Wirkleistungsänderungen, welche am meisten von einem durch FESS ermöglichten, glatteren Leistungsprofil profitieren können, erfolgreich zugeordnet werden können. Darüber hinaus wird eine neue Methode zur Dimensionierung von Energiespeichersystemen unter Verwendung von Messdaten eingeführt. Der vorgeschlagene Ansatz erkennt wiederkehrende Verbrauchsmuster in aufgezeichneten Leistungsprofilen mit Hilfe des "Motif Discovery"-Algorithmus, die dann zur Dimensionierung verschiedener Speichertechnologien, einschließlich eines FESS, verwendet werden. Anhand von gesammelten Messdaten aus mehreren Niederspannungsnetzen in Deutschland wird gezeigt, dass die Speichersysteme mit den aus den detektierten Mustern abgeleiteten Charakteristika während der gesamten Messperiode effektiv für ihre Anwendungen genutzt werden können. Als nächstes wurde ein dynamisches Modell eines Hochgeschwindigkeits-FESS entwickelt und mit experimentellen Ergebnissen in mehreren Szenarien, unter Berücksichtigung der Verluste und des Hilfsenergiebedarfs des Systems, validiert. In den untersuchten Szenarien wurde eine maximale Differenz von nur 0,8 % zwischen dem Ladezustand des Modells und dem realen FESS beobachtet, was die Genauigkeit des entwickelten Modells beschreibt. Nach Festlegung des erforderlichen Aufbaus wurde die Leistungsfähigkeit eines 60 kW Hochgeschwindigkeits-FESS während mehrerer Frequenzabweichungsszenarien mit Hilfe von Power Hardware-in-the-Loop-Tests beurteilt. Die Ergebnisse der PHIL-Tests zeigen, dass das Hochgeschwindigkeits-FESS sehr schnell nach einer plötzlichen Frequenzabweichung reagiert und in knapp 60 ms die erforderliche Leistung erreicht, wobei die neuesten Anforderungen der Anwendungsregeln für die Frequenzunterstützung auf der Niederspannungsebene erfüllt werden. Um schließlich die Vorteile des schnellen Verhaltens des FESS für Energiesysteme mit geringer Trägheit zu demonstrieren, wurde ein neuartiger adaptiver Trägheits-Emulationsregler für das Hochgeschwindigkeits-FESS eingeführt und seine Leistung in einem Microgrid mit geringer Trägheit durch Simulationen und Experimente validiert. Die Simulationsergebnisse zeigen, dass die Verwendung des FESS mit dem vorgeschlagenen Trägheits-Emulationsregler die maximale Änderungsrate der Frequenz um 28 % und die maximale Frequenzabweichung um 44 % während der Inselbildung des untersuchten Microgrid reduzieren kann und mehrere zuvor vorgestellte adaptive Regelungskonzepte übertrifft. Der vorgeschlagene Regler wurde auch auf einem realen 60 kW FESS mit dem Konzept des Rapid Control Prototyping implementiert, und die Leistungsfähigkeit des FESS mit dem neuen Regelungsentwurf wurde mit Hilfe von PHIL-Tests des FESS validiert. Die PHIL-Ergebnisse, die die allererste experimentelle Validierung der Trägheitsemulation mit einem FESS darstellen, bestätigen die Simulationsergebnisse und zeigen die Vorteile des vorgeschlagenen Reglers