Music-based interventions for aphasia could act through a motor-speech mechanism : a systematic review and case-control analysis of published individual participant data

Background: Melodic Intonation Therapy, a music-based intervention for the recovery of oral language production in aphasia, has been shown to be particularly effective in patients with Broca’s aphasia compared to other aphasia subtypes. It has been suggested that this therapy might improve language output by acting on motor-speech deficits often associated with Broca’s aphasia. In this article, we examine the relevance of a motor-speech mechanism for music-based interventions designed to improve verbal expression in patients with any type of aphasia. Aim: To test the association between the presence of motor-speech disorders (MSDs) and improvement with music-based protocols targeting verbal expression in participants with aphasia. Methods and procedures: We conducted a systematic review of publications reporting language production outcomes following a music-based intervention in participants with aphasia and performed a case–control analysis on extracted individual participant data (IPD). The databases PubMed, MEDLINE (1800 to 9 March 2018), and PsycINFO (1806 to March 2018) were screened, followed with cross-referencing. We recorded data at the level of study and, when possible, at the IPD level. When not explicitly reported, we applied a series of heuristics to infer the presence/absence of an MSD in participants. Binomial logistic regressions were performed to ascertain the effects of the presence of an MSD, aphasia severity, treatment duration (in weeks), and treatment intensity (hours/week) on the likelihood that participants would show a speech or a language improvement following intervention. Outcomes & Results: Forty original articles were included in this review. Twenty-two reported sufficient details to be included in our IPD analysis, for a total sample of 105 participants. Most interventions included some sort of singing as their primary music-based facilitation technique for language production. For speech improvement, statistically significant predictor variables were the presence of an MSD and treatment intensity. For language improvement, statistically significant predictor variables were the presence of an MSD, treatment intensity, and duration. Severity of aphasia was not associated with the likelihood of speech or language improvement. Conclusion: Music-based interventions for language production in aphasia may act via a motor-speech mechanism. We suggest that music and singing-based therapies might be further investigated as treatment options for patients with MSDs, whether associated with aphasia or not

Les bénéfices du chant dans la réadaptation de l’aphasie

Les personnes ayant une aphasie, un trouble acquis du langage causé par une lésion cérébrale, parviennent temporairement à mieux prononcer des mots quand elles les chantent dans des chansons familières ou en chant choral. Dans cette thèse nous examinons comment le chant peut entrainer des bénéfices durables sur le langage et la communication de ces personnes. Deux contextes sont envisagés : (1) une thérapie chantée de l’aphasie, la Melodic intonation therapy en anglais (MIT), et (2) une activité de loisir, une chorale de personnes aphasiques. La première étude de cette thèse (Chapitre 2) est une recension critique de la variété de recherches dont la MIT a fait l’objet. Nous soutenons que plusieurs protocoles de traitement présentés sous le label MIT ne correspondent pas à la MIT originale et que les effets immédiats du chant, qui sont examinés dans des études transversales, ne devraient pas être confondus avec les effets durables, observés dans des études longitudinales. Cette grille de lecture permet de réconcilier des conclusions d’études contradictoires à propos des mécanismes de la MIT et met en évidence des questions de recherches en suspens, notamment sur la contribution relative du rythme et de la hauteur musicale dans les effets de cette thérapie, que nous traitons dans le troisième chapitre. Nous y rapportons une étude avec trois participants ayant une aphasie de Broca chronique. Trois traitements ont été comparés dans un devis en carré latin : une thérapie comportant de la parole chantée (i.e., avec rythme et hauteurs musicales) proche de la MIT originale, une thérapie équivalente avec de la parole uniquement rythmée, et une thérapie comportant de la parole normale. Puisque seule la thérapie chantée a amélioré le langage dans le discours naturel des participants, nous soutenons que le chant dans son entièreté est un élément actif de la MIT. Enfin, dans le quatrième chapitre, nous présentons la première étude de groupe contrôlée, randomisée et à simple insu tentant de déterminer si le chant pratiqué comme simple loisir peut aussi avoir un effet bénéfique dans la réadaptation de l’aphasie. Nous avons comparé les progrès en communication fonctionnelle de 17 personnes ayant différents types d’aphasies chroniques réparties dans un groupe chorale, où elles devaient participer à six mois d’activité hebdomadaire de chorale, un groupe théâtre, où elles devaient suivre un atelier de théâtre, et une liste d’attente pour ces deux activités seulement. Nos résultats ont montré une corrélation positive entre l’amélioration de la communication fonctionnelle et le nombre de présences aux activités sociales, quelles qu’elles soient, mais nous n’avons pas trouvé d’effet spécifique à l’activité de chorale. Ainsi, la pratique du chant en chorale pourrait avoir un potentiel thérapeutique général, mais pas spécifique à l’utilisation du chant. D’autres études sont toutefois nécessaires pour le confirmer. Ainsi, cette thèse soutient globalement que dans la réadaptation de l’aphasie, le chant apporte des bénéfices spécifiques sur le langage lorsqu’il est intégré dans une thérapie comme la MIT et des bénéfices comparables à d’autres activités sociales lorsqu’il est pratiqué comme activité de loisir dans une chorale.People with aphasia, an acquired disorder of language caused by brain injury, can temporarily better pronounce words when they sing them as part of familiar songs or in choral singing with a model they can imitate. In this thesis, we examine how singing can lead to lasting benefits on the linguistic and communicative abilities of these people. Two contexts are considered: (1) an aphasia therapy based on singing, the Melodic Intonation Therapy (MIT), and (2) a recreational choir activity for people with aphasia. Our first study (Chapter 2) presents a critical review of studies having centered on MIT. We argue that several treatment protocols subsumed under the rubric of MIT do not in fact correspond well to the original MIT specification and that immediate effects of singing studied in cross-sectional studies should not be confused with the lasting effects observed in longitudinal studies. This interpretative framework makes it possible to reconcile the findings of contradictory studies concerning the mechanisms of MIT and highlights yet unresolved research questions, including the relative contribution of rhythm and pitch to the effects of this therapy. This latter question forms the central topic of our third chapter in which we report a study with three chronic Broca's aphasia patients. Three treatments were compared in a Latin square design: a therapy using sung speech (i.e., with both rhythm and pitch) closely resembling that of the original MIT, an equivalent therapy using only rhythmic speech, and a therapy with normal speech. Since only the full singing therapy improved the natural speech of participants, we argue that the rhythm and pitch combination in singing is most effective for MIT. Finally, in the fourth chapter we present the first randomized, controlled, and single-blinded group study aiming to determine if recreational singing can also be beneficial in the rehabilitation of aphasia. We evaluated the progress in functional communication for 17 people with different types of chronic aphasia during six months of weekly activity in either a choir group, a drama group, or a waiting list group that participated in neither of these activities. Our results showed a positive correlation between improvement in functional communication and attendance to any and all social events in which participants were involved, but we did not find any specific effect of choir activity. Thus, the practice of choral singing may have a general therapeutic potential, but not one specific to singing. Further studies are needed to confirm this. Thus, this thesis maintains that in the rehabilitation of aphasia, singing brings specific benefits to language when integrated into a therapy such as MIT and benefits comparable to other social activities when it is practiced as a leisure activity in a choir

Adaptation and reliability of the Cinderella story retell task in Canadian French persons without brain injury

Purpose: Main concept (MC) analysis is a well-documented method of discourse analysis in adults with and without brain injury. This study aims to develop a MC checklist that is culturally and linguistically adapted for Canadian French speakers and examine its reliability. We also documented microstructural properties and provide a normative reference in persons not brain injured (PNBIs). Method: Discourse samples from 43 PNBIs were collected. All participants completed the Cinderella story retell task twice. Manual transcription was performed for all samples. The 34 MCs for the Cinderella story retell task were adapted into Canadian French and used to score all transcripts. In addition, microstructural variables were extracted using Computerized Language Analysis (CLAN). Intraclass correlation coefficients were computed to assess interrater reliability for MC codes and microstructural variables. Test–retest reliability was assessed using intraclass correlations, Spearman's rho correlations, and the Wilcoxon signed-ranks test. Bland–Altman plots were used to examine the agreement of the discourse measures between the two sessions. Results: The MC checklist for the Cinderella story retell task adapted for Canadian French speakers is provided. Good-to-excellent interrater reliability was obtained for most MC codes; however, reliability ranged from poor to excellent for the “inaccurate and incomplete” code. Microstructural variables demonstrated excellent interrater reliability. Test–retest reliability ranged from poor to excellent for all variables, with the majority falling between moderate and excellent. Bland–Altman plots illustrated the limits of agreement between test and retest. Conclusions: This study provides the MC checklist for clinicians and researchers working with Canadian French speakers when assessing discourse with the Cinderella story retell task. It also addresses the gap in available psychometric data regarding test–retest reliability in PNBIs

Differential effects of speech and Language therapy and rTMS in chronic versus subacute post-stroke aphasia: Results of the NORTHSTAR-CA trial

Background & objective: Contralesional 1-Hz repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) over the right pars triangularis combined with speech-language therapy (SLT) has shown positive results on the recovery of naming in subacute (5–45 days) post-stroke aphasia. NORTHSTAR-CA is an extension of the previously reported NORTHSTAR trial to chronic aphasia (\u3e6 months post-stroke) designed to compare the effectiveness of the same rTMS protocol in both phases. Methods: Sixty-seven patients with left middle cerebral artery infarcts (28 chronic, 39 subacute) were recruited (01-2014 to 07-2019) and randomized to receive rTMS (N = 34) or sham stimulation (N = 33) with SLT for 10 days. Primary outcome variables were Z-score changes in naming, semantic fluency and comprehension tests and adverse event frequency. Intention-to-treat analyses tested between-group effects at days 1 and 30 post-treatment. Chronic and subacute results were compared. Results: Adverse events were rare, mild, and did not differ between groups. Language outcomes improved significantly in all groups irrespective of treatment and recovery phase. At 30-day follow-up, there was a significant interaction of stimulation and recovery phase on naming recovery (P \u3c.001). Naming recovery with rTMS was larger in subacute (Mdn = 1.91/IQR =.77) than chronic patients (Mdn =.15/IQR = 1.68/P =.015). There was no significant rTMS effect in the chronic aphasia group. Conclusions: The addition of rTMS to SLT led to significant supplemental gains in naming recovery in the subacute phase only. While this needs confirmation in larger studies, our results clarify neuromodulatory vs training-induced effects and indicate a possible window of opportunity for contralesional inhibitory stimulation interventions in post-stroke aphasia. NORTHSTAR trial registration: https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02020421

PLoS One

Age-related macular degeneration (AMD) is a common, progressive multifactorial vision-threatening disease and many genetic and environmental risk factors have been identified. The risk of AMD is influenced by lifestyle and diet, which may be reflected by an altered metabolic profile. Therefore, measurements of metabolites could identify biomarkers for AMD, and could aid in identifying high-risk individuals. Hypothesis-free technologies such as metabolomics have a great potential to uncover biomarkers or pathways that contribute to disease pathophysiology. To date, only a limited number of metabolomic studies have been performed in AMD. Here, we aim to contribute to the discovery of novel biomarkers and metabolic pathways for AMD using a targeted metabolomics approach of 188 metabolites. This study focuses on non-advanced AMD, since there is a need for biomarkers for the early stages of disease before severe visual loss has occurred. Targeted metabolomics was performed in 72 patients with early or intermediate AMD and 72 control individuals, and metabolites predictive for AMD were identified by a sparse partial least squares discriminant analysis. In our cohort, we identified four metabolite variables that were most predictive for early and intermediate stages of AMD. Increased glutamine and phosphatidylcholine diacyl C28:1 levels were detected in non-advanced AMD cases compared to controls, while the rate of glutaminolysis and the glutamine to glutamate ratio were reduced in non-advanced AMD. The association of glutamine with non-advanced AMD corroborates a recent report demonstrating an elevated glutamine level in early AMD using a different metabolomics technique. In conclusion, this study indicates that metabolomics is a suitable method for the discovery of biomarker candidates for AMD. In the future, larger metabolomics studies could add to the discovery of novel biomarkers in yet unknown AMD pathways and expand our insights in AMD pathophysiology

Ophthalmology

OBJECTIVE: In the current study we aimed to identify metabolites associated with age-related macular degeneration (AMD) by performing the largest metabolome association analysis in AMD to date. In addition, we aimed to determine the effect of AMD-associated genetic variants on metabolite levels, and aimed to investigate associations between the identified metabolites and activity of the complement system, one of the main AMD-associated disease pathways. DESIGN: Case-control assocation analysis of metabolomics data. SUBJECTS: 2,267 AMD cases and 4,266 controls from five European cohorts. METHODS: Metabolomics was performed using a high-throughput H-NMR metabolomics platform, which allows the quantification of 146 metabolite measurements and 79 derivative values. Metabolome-AMD associations were studied using univariate logistic regression analyses. The effect of 52 AMD-associated genetic variants on the identified metabolites was investigated using linear regression. In addition, associations between the identified metabolites and activity of the complement pathway (defined by the C3d/C3 ratio) were investigated using linear regression. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Metabolites associated with AMD RESULTS: We identified 60 metabolites that were significantly associated with AMD, including increased levels of large and extra-large HDL subclasses and decreased levels of VLDL, amino acids and citrate. Out of 52 AMD-associated genetic variants, seven variants were significantly associated with 34 of the identified metabolites. The strongest associations were identified for genetic variants located in or near genes involved in lipid metabolism (ABCA1, CETP, APOE, LIPC) with metabolites belonging to the large and extra-large HDL subclasses. In addition, 57 out of 60 metabolites were significantly associated with complement activation levels, and these associations were independent of AMD status. Increased large and extra-large HDL levels and decreased VLDL and amino acid levels were associated with increased complement activation. CONCLUSIONS: Lipoprotein levels were associated with AMD-associated genetic variants, while decreased essential amino acids may point to nutritional deficiencies in AMD. We observed strong associations between the vast majority of the AMD-associated metabolites and systemic complement activation levels, independent of AMD status. This may indicate biological interactions between the main AMD disease pathways, and suggests that multiple pathways may need to be targeted simultaneously for successful treatment of AMD

Prevalence of Age-Related Macular Degeneration in Europe: The Past and the Future

Purpose Age-related macular degeneration (AMD) is a frequent, complex disorder in elderly of European ancestry. Risk profiles and treatment options have changed considerably over the years, which may have affected disease prevalence and outcome. We determined the prevalence of early and late AMD in Europe from 1990 to 2013 using the European Eye Epidemiology (E3) consortium, and made projections for the future. Design Meta-analysis of prevalence data. Participants A total of 42 080 individuals 40 years of age and older participating in 14 population-based cohorts from 10 countries in Europe. Methods AMD was diagnosed based on fundus photographs using the Rotterdam Classification. Prevalence of early and late AMD was calculated using random-effects meta-analysis stratified for age, birth cohort, gender, geographic region, and time period of the study. Best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA) was compared between late AMD subtypes; geographic atrophy (GA) and choroidal neovascularization (CNV). Main Outcome Measures Prevalence of early and late AMD, BCVA, and number of AMD cases. Results Prevalence of early AMD increased from 3.5% (95% confidence interval [CI] 2.1%–5.0%) in those aged 55–59 years to 17.6% (95%

Singing for the Rehabilitation of Acquired Neurogenic Communication Disorders: Continuing the Evidence Dialogue with a Survey of Current Practices in Speech-Language Pathology

Therapeutic applications of singing (e.g., melodic intonation therapy) for acquired neurogenic communication disorders (ANCD) such as post-stroke aphasia, dysarthria, or neurodegenerative diseases have emerged from innovations by clinical speech-language pathologists (SLPs). However, these specialists have never been systematically consulted about the use of singing in their practices. We report a survey of 395 SLPs in France using an online questionnaire (September 2018–January 2019). Most (98%) knew that singing could be a therapeutic tool. A wide variety of uses emerged in our data. Some practices (e.g., song games) have not yet been investigated in research settings. Melodic therapy, which is supported by scientific evidence, is familiar to clinicians (90%), but they lack training and rarely follow a full protocol. Over half of respondents (62%) recognize group singing for various benefits, but do not often use it, mainly due to the lack of adapted or welcoming choirs in their area. These results provide key information for continued dialogue between researchers, clinicians, and the community. Considering the aging population and the associated increase in the prevalence of ANCD, access to group singing in particular could be facilitated for these patients from a social prescription perspective with further research evidence

Cinderella story retell task in Canadian French (Brisebois et al., 2023)

Purpose: Main concept (MC) analysis is a well-documented method of discourse analysis in adults with and without brain injury. This study aims to develop a MC checklist that is culturally and linguistically adapted for Canadian French speakers and examine its reliability. We also documented microstructural properties and provide a normative reference in persons not brain injured (PNBIs).Method: Discourse samples from 43 PNBIs were collected. All participants completed the Cinderella story retell task twice. Manual transcription was performed for all samples. The 34 MCs for the Cinderella story retell task were adapted into Canadian French and used to score all transcripts. In addition, microstructural variables were extracted using Computerized Language Analysis (CLAN). Intraclass correlation coefficients were computed to assess interrater reliability for MC codes and microstructural variables. Test–retest reliability was assessed using intraclass correlations, Spearman’s rho correlations, and the Wilcoxon signed-ranks test. Bland–Altman plots were used to examine the agreement of the discourse measures between the two sessions.Results: The MC checklist for the Cinderella story retell task adapted for Canadian French speakers is provided. Good-to-excellent interrater reliability was obtained for most MC codes; however, reliability ranged from poor to excellent for the “inaccurate and incomplete” code. Microstructural variables demonstrated excellent interrater reliability. Test–retest reliability ranged from poor to excellent for all variables, with the majority falling between moderate and excellent. Bland–Altman plots illustrated the limits of agreement between test and retest.Conclusions: This study provides the MC checklist for clinicians and researchers working with Canadian French speakers when assessing discourse with the Cinderella story retell task. It also addresses the gap in available psychometric data regarding test–retest reliability in PNBIs.Supplemental Material S1. Best Practice Guidelines for Reporting Spoken Discourse in Aphasia and Neurogenic Communication Disorders.Supplemental Material S2. CLAN commands used to extract discourse variables in the transcripts and summary of interrater reliability results.Supplemental Material S3. MC scoring template.Supplemental Material S4. Canadian French adaptation of the Main concepts for the Cinderella retell task.Brisebois, A., Brambati, S. M., Jutras, C., Rochon, E., Leonard, C., Zumbansen, A., Anglade, C., & Marcotte, K. (2023). Adaptation and reliability of the Cinderella story retell task in Canadian French persons without brain injury. American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1044/2023_AJSLP-23-00101</p