A Survey on Approximate Multiplier Designs for Energy Efficiency: From Algorithms to Circuits

Given the stringent requirements of energy efficiency for Internet-of-Things edge devices, approximate multipliers, as a basic component of many processors and accelerators, have been constantly proposed and studied for decades, especially in error-resilient applications. The computation error and energy efficiency largely depend on how and where the approximation is introduced into a design. Thus, this article aims to provide a comprehensive review of the approximation techniques in multiplier designs ranging from algorithms and architectures to circuits. We have implemented representative approximate multiplier designs in each category to understand the impact of the design techniques on accuracy and efficiency. The designs can then be effectively deployed in high-level applications, such as machine learning, to gain energy efficiency at the cost of slight accuracy loss.Comment: 38 pages, 37 figure

Compressor based approximate multiplier architectures for media processing applications

Approximate computing is an attractive technique to gain substantial improvement in the area, speed, and power in applications where exact computation is not required. This paper proposes two improved multiplier designs based on a new 4:2 approximate compressor circuit to simplify the hardware at the partial product reduction stage. The proposed multiplier designs are targeted towards error-tolerant applications. Exhaustive error and hardware analysis has been carried out on the existing and proposed multiplier designs. The results prove that the proposed approximate multiplier architecture performs better than the existing architectures without significant compromise on quality metrics. Experimental results show that die-area and power consumed are reduced upto 28%, and 25.29% respectively in comparison with the existing designs without significant compromise on accuracy

A Study on Efficient Designs of Approximate Arithmetic Circuits

Approximate computing is a popular field where accuracy is traded with energy. It can benefit applications such as multimedia, mobile computing and machine learning which are inherently error resilient. Error introduced in these applications to a certain degree is beyond human perception. This flexibility can be exploited to design area, delay and power efficient architectures. However, care must be taken on how approximation compromises the correctness of results. This research work aims to provide approximate hardware architectures with error metrics and design metrics analyzed and their effects in image processing applications. Firstly, we study and propose unsigned array multipliers based on probability statistics and with approximate 4-2 compressors, full adders and half adders. This work deals with a new design approach for approximation of multipliers. The partial products of the multiplier are altered to introduce varying probability terms. Logic complexity of approximation is varied for the accumulation of altered partial products based on their probability. The proposed approximation is utilized in two variants of 16-bit multipliers. Synthesis results reveal that two proposed multipliers achieve power savings of 72% and 38% respectively compared to an exact multiplier. They have better precision when compared to existing approximate multipliers. Mean relative error distance (MRED) figures are as low as 7.6% and 0.02% for the proposed approximate multipliers, which are better than the previous state-of-the-art works. Performance of the proposed multipliers is evaluated with geometric mean filtering application, where one of the proposed models achieves the highest peak signal to noise ratio (PSNR). Second, approximation is proposed for signed Booth multiplication. Approximation is introduced in partial product generation and partial product accumulation circuits. In this work, three multipliers (ABM-M1, ABM-M2, and ABM-M3) are proposed in which the modified Booth algorithm is approximated. In all three designs, approximate Booth partial product generators are designed with different variations of approximation. The approximations are performed by reducing the logic complexity of the Booth partial product generator, and the accumulation of partial products is slightly modified to improve circuit performance. Compared to the exact Booth multiplier, ABM-M1 achieves up to 15% reduction in power consumption with an MRED value of 7.9 × 10-4. ABM-M2 has power savings of up to 60% with an MRED of 1.1 × 10-1. ABM-M3 has power savings of up to 50% with an MRED of 3.4 × 10-3. Compared to existing approximate Booth multipliers, the proposed multipliers ABM-M1 and ABM-M3 achieve up to a 41% reduction in power consumption while exhibiting very similar error metrics. Image multiplication and matrix multiplication are used as case studies to illustrate the high performance of the proposed approximate multipliers. Third, distributed arithmetic based sum of products units approximation is analyzed. Sum of products units are key elements in many digital signal processing applications. Three approximate sum of products models which are based on distributed arithmetic are proposed. They are designed for different levels of accuracy. First model of approximate sum of products achieves an improvement up to 64% on area and 70% on power, when compared to conventional unit. Other two models provide an improvement of 32% and 48% on area and 54% and 58% on power, respectively, with a reduced error rate compared to the first model. Third model achieves MRED and normalized mean error distance (NMED) as low as 0.05% and 0.009%. Performance of approximate units is evaluated with a noisy image smoothing application, where the proposed models are capable of achieving higher PSNR than existing state of the art techniques. Fourth, approximation is applied in division architecture. Two approximation models are proposed for restoring divider. In the first design, approximation is performed at circuit level, where approximate divider cells are utilized in place of exact ones by simplifying the logic equations. In the second model, restoring divider is analyzed strategically and number of restoring divider cells are reduced by finding the portions of divisor and dividend with significant information. An approximation factor $p$ is used in both designs. In model 1, the design with p=8 has a 58% reduction in both area and power consumption compared to exact design, with a Q-MRED of 1.909 × 10-2 and Q-NMED of 0.449 × 10-2. The second model with an approximation factor p=4 has 54% area savings and 62% power savings compared to exact design. The proposed models are found to have better error metrics compared to existing designs, with better performance at similar error values. A change detection image processing application is used for real time assessment of proposed and existing approximate dividers and one of the models achieves a PSNR of 54.27 dB

High-Performance Accurate and Approximate Multipliers for FPGA-Based Hardware Accelerators

Multiplication is one of the widely used arithmetic operations in a variety of applications, such as image/video processing and machine learning. FPGA vendors provide high-performance multipliers in the form of DSP blocks. These multipliers are not only limited in number and have fixed locations on FPGAs but can also create additional routing delays and may prove inefficient for smaller bit-width multiplications. Therefore, FPGA vendors additionally provide optimized soft IP cores for multiplication. However, in this work, we advocate that these soft multiplier IP cores for FPGAs still need better designs to provide high-performance and resource efficiency. Toward this, we present generic area-optimized, low-latency accurate, and approximate softcore multiplier architectures, which exploit the underlying architectural features of FPGAs, i.e., lookup table (LUT) structures and fast-carry chains to reduce the overall critical path delay (CPD) and resource utilization of multipliers. Compared to Xilinx multiplier LogiCORE IP, our proposed unsigned and signed accurate architecture provides up to 25% and 53% reduction in LUT utilization, respectively, for different sizes of multipliers. Moreover, with our unsigned approximate multiplier architectures, a reduction of up to 51% in the CPD can be achieved with an insignificant loss in output accuracy when compared with the LogiCORE IP. For illustration, we have deployed the proposed multiplier architecture in accelerators used in image and video applications, and evaluated them for area and performance gains. Our library of accurate and approximate multipliers is opensource and available online at https://cfaed.tu-dresden.de/pd-downloads to fuel further research and development in this area, facilitate reproducible research, and thereby enabling a new research direction for the FPGA community

Improving the Hardware Performance of Arithmetic Circuits using Approximate Computing

An application that can produce a useful result despite some level of computational error is said to be error resilient. Approximate computing can be applied to error resilient applications by intentionally introducing error to the computation in order to improve performance, and it has been shown that approximation is especially well-suited for application in arithmetic computing hardware. In this thesis, novel approximate arithmetic architectures are proposed for three different operations, namely multiplication, division, and the multiply accumulate (MAC) operation. For all designs, accuracy is evaluated in terms of mean relative error distance (MRED) and normalized mean error distance (NMED), while hardware performance is reported in terms of critical path delay, area, and power consumption. Three approximate Booth multipliers (ABM-M1, ABM-M2, ABM-M3) are designed in which two novel inexact partial product generators are used to reduce the dimensions of the partial product matrix. The proposed multipliers are compared to other state-of-the-art designs in terms of both accuracy and hardware performance, and are found to reduce power consumption by up to 56% when compared to the exact multiplier. The function of the multipliers is verified in several image processing applications. Two approximate restoring dividers (AXRD-M1, AXRD-M2) are proposed along with a novel inexact restoring divider cell. In the first divider, the conventional cells are replaced with the proposed inexact cells in several columns. The second divider computes only a subset of the trial subtractions, after which the divisor and partial remainder are rounded and encoded so that they may be used to estimate the remaining quotient bits. The proposed dividers are evaluated for accuracy and hardware performance alongside several benchmarking designs, and their function is verified using change detection and foreground extraction applications. An approximate MAC unit is presented in which the multiplication is implemented using a modified version of ABM-M3. The delay is reduced by using a fused architecture where the accumulator is summed as part of the multiplier compression. The accuracy and hardware savings of the MAC unit are measured against several works from the literature, and the design is utilized in a number of convolution operations

Approximate Computing Survey, Part II: Application-Specific & Architectural Approximation Techniques and Applications

The challenging deployment of compute-intensive applications from domains such Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Digital Signal Processing (DSP), forces the community of computing systems to explore new design approaches. Approximate Computing appears as an emerging solution, allowing to tune the quality of results in the design of a system in order to improve the energy efficiency and/or performance. This radical paradigm shift has attracted interest from both academia and industry, resulting in significant research on approximation techniques and methodologies at different design layers (from system down to integrated circuits). Motivated by the wide appeal of Approximate Computing over the last 10 years, we conduct a two-part survey to cover key aspects (e.g., terminology and applications) and review the state-of-the art approximation techniques from all layers of the traditional computing stack. In Part II of our survey, we classify and present the technical details of application-specific and architectural approximation techniques, which both target the design of resource-efficient processors/accelerators & systems. Moreover, we present a detailed analysis of the application spectrum of Approximate Computing and discuss open challenges and future directions.Comment: Under Review at ACM Computing Survey

Design of approximate overclocked datapath

Embedded applications can often demand stringent latency requirements. While high degrees of parallelism within custom FPGA-based accelerators may help to some extent, it may also be necessary to limit the precision used in the datapath to boost the operating frequency of the implementation. However, by reducing the precision, the engineer introduces quantisation error into the design. In this thesis, we describe an alternative circuit design methodology when considering trade-offs between accuracy, performance and silicon area. We compare two different approaches that could trade accuracy for performance. One is the traditional approach where the precision used in the datapath is limited to meet a target latency. The other is a proposed new approach which simply allows the datapath to operate without timing closure. We demonstrate analytically and experimentally that for many applications it would be preferable to simply overclock the design and accept that timing violations may arise. Since the errors introduced by timing violations occur rarely, they will cause less noise than quantisation errors. Furthermore, we show that conventional forms of computer arithmetic do not fail gracefully when pushed beyond the deterministic clocking region. In this thesis we take a fresh look at Online Arithmetic, originally proposed for digit serial operation, and synthesize unrolled digit parallel online arithmetic operators to allow for graceful degradation. We quantify the impact of timing violations on key arithmetic primitives, and show that substantial performance benefits can be obtained in comparison to binary arithmetic. Since timing errors are caused by long carry chains, these result in errors in least significant digits with online arithmetic, causing less impact than conventional implementations.Open Acces

Approximation Opportunities in Edge Computing Hardware : A Systematic Literature Review

With the increasing popularity of the Internet of Things and massive Machine Type Communication technologies, the number of connected devices is rising. However, while enabling valuable effects to our lives, bandwidth and latency constraints challenge Cloud processing of their associated data amounts. A promising solution to these challenges is the combination of Edge and approximate computing techniques that allows for data processing nearer to the user. This paper aims to survey the potential benefits of these paradigms’ intersection. We provide a state-of-the-art review of circuit-level and architecture-level hardware techniques and popular applications. We also outline essential future research directions.publishedVersionPeer reviewe