Multiple mortality modeling in Poisson Lee-Carter framework

The academic literature in longevity field has recently focused on models for detecting multiple population trends (D'Amato et al., 2012b; Njenga and Sherris, 2011; Russolillo et al., 2011, etc.). In particular, increasing interest has been shown about "related" population dynamics or "parent" populations characterized by similar socioeconomic conditions and eventually also by geographical proximity. These studies suggest dependence across multiple populations and common long-run relationships between countries (for instance, see Lazar et al., 2009). In order to investigate cross-country longevity common trends, we adopt a multiple population approach. The algorithm we propose retains the parametric structure of the Lee-Carter model, extending the basic framework to include some cross-dependence in the error term. As far as time dependence is concerned, we allow for all idiosyncratic components (both in the common stochastic trend and in the error term) to follow a linear process, thus considering a highly flexible specification for the serial dependence structure of our data. We also relax the assumption of normality, which is typical of early studies on mortality (Lee and Carter, 1992) and on factor models (see e.g., the textbook by Anderson, 1984). The empirical results show that the multiple Lee-Carter approach works well in the presence of dependence

Pricing reverse mortgages in Spain

[EN] In Spain, as in other European countries, the continuous ageing of the population creates a need for long-term care services and their financing. However, in Spain the development of this kind of services is still embryonic. The aim of this article is to obtain a calculation method for reverse mortgages in Spain based on the fit and projection of dynamic tables for Spanish mortality, using the Lee and Carter model. Mortality and life expectancy for the next 20 years are predicted using the fitted model, and confidence intervals are obtained from the prediction errors of parameters for the mortality index of the model. The last part of the article illustrates an application of the results to calculate the reverse mortgage model promoted by the Spanish Instituto de Crédito Oficial (Spanish State Financial Agency), for which the authors have developed a computer application.The authors are indebted to Jose Garrido, whose suggestions improved the original manuscript, and to the anonymous referee for his/her valuable comments. This work was partially supported by grants from the MEyC (Ministerio de Educacio´n y Ciencia, Spain), projects MTM2010- 14961 and MTM2008-05152.Debón Aucejo, AM.; Montes, F.; Sala, R. (2013). Pricing reverse mortgages in Spain. European Actuarial Journal. 3:23-43. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13385-013-0071-yS23433Blay-Berrueta D (2007) Sistemas de cofinaciaciación de la dependencia: seguro privado frente a hipoteca inversa. Cuadernos de la Fundación, Fundación Mapfre Estudios, Madrid.Booth H (2006) Demographic forecasting: 1980 to 2005 in review. Int J Forecast 22(3):547–582Booth H, Hyndman R, Tickle L, de Jong P (2006) Lee–Carter mortality forecasting: a multi-country comparison of variants and extensions. Demogr Res 15(9):289–310Booth H, Maindonald J, Smith L (2002) Applying Lee–Carter under conditions of variable mortality decline. Popul Stud 56(3):325–336Booth H, Tickle L (2003) The future aged: new projections of Australia’s ederly population. Popul Stud 22(4):38–44Brouhns N, Denuit M, Keilegom IV (2005) Bootstrapping Poisson log-bilinear model for mortality forecasting. Scand Actuar J 2005(3):212–224Brouhns N, Denuit M, Vermunt J (2002) A Poisson log-bilinear regression approach to the construction of projected lifetables. Insur Math Econ 31(3):373–393Carter L, Lee R (1992) Modeling and forecasting US sex differentials in mortality. Int J Forecast 8(3):393–411Carter L, Prkawetz A (2001) Examining structural shifs in mortality using the Lee–Carter method. Mpidr wp 2001–2007, Center for Demography and Ecology Information, University of Wisconsin-Madison.Chinloy P, Megbolugbe I (1994) Reverse mortgages: contracting and crossover. J Am Real Estate Urban Econ Assoc 22(2):367–386Coale A, Guo G (1989) Revisited regional model life tables at very low levels of mortality. Popul Index 55:613–643Coale A, Kisker E (1990) Defects in data old age mortality in the United States: New procedures for calculating approximately accurate mortality schedules and lifes tables at the highest ages. Asian Pac Popul Forum 4:1–31Cossette H, Delwarde A, Denuit M, Guillot F, Étienne M (2007) Pension plan valuation and mortality projection: a case study with mortality data. N Am Actuar J 11(2):1–34.Costa-Font J (2009) Ageing in place? exploring elderly people’s housing preferences in Spain. Urban Stud 46(2):295–316Costa-Font J (2013) Housing-related well-being in older people: the impact of environmental and financial influences. Urban Stud 50(4):657–673Currie I, Kirkby J, Durban M, Eilers P (2004) Smooth Lee–Carter models and beyond. In: Workshop on Lee–Carter Methods, http://www.ma.hw.ac.uk/~iain/workshop/workshop.html . Accessed 4 Mar 2005Czado C, Delwarde A, Denuit M (2005) Bayesian Poisson log-bilinear mortality projections. Insur Math Econ 36(3):260–284D’Amato V, Haberman S, Piscopo G, Russolillo M (2012) Modelling dependent data for longevity projections. Insur Math Econ 51(3):694–701Davidoff T (2012) Can ‘high costs’ justify weak demand for the home equity conversion mortgage? Technical report, available at SSRNDavidoff T, Welke G (2007) Selection and moral hazard in the reverse mortgage market. Technical report, Haas School of Business, UC BerkeleyDebón A, Montes F, Mateu J, Porcu E, Bevilacqua M (2008) Modelling residuals dependence in dymanic life tables. Comput Stat Data Anal 52(3):3128–3147Debón A, Montes F, Puig F (2008) Modelling and forecasting mortality in Spain. Eur J Oper Res 189(3):624–637Debón A, Montes F, Sala R (2009) Tablas de mortalidad dinámicas. Una aplicación a la hipoteca inversa en España. Fundación ICO. Publicaciones de la Universitat de Valéncia, ValenciaDebón A, Montes F, Martínez-Ruiz F (2011) Statistical methods to compare mortality for a group with non-divergent populations: an application to Spanish regions. Eur Actuar J 1:291–308Delwarde A, Denuit M, Eilers P (2007) Smoothing the Lee–Carter and poisson log-bilinear models for mortality forecasting: a penalized log-likelihood approach. Stat Modell 7(1):29–48Denuit M (2007) Distribution of the random future life expectancies in log-bilinear mortality projections models. Lifetime Data Anal 13(3):381–397Denuit M, Goderniaux A (2004) Closing and projecting lifetables using log-linear models. Mitteilungen. der Schweizerischen Aktuarvereingung 1:29–49Felipe A, Guillén M, Pérez-Marín A (2002) Recent mortality trends in the Spanish population. Br Actuar J 8(4):757–786.Forfar D, McCutcheon J, Wilkie A (1988) On graduation by mathematical formula. J Inst Actuar 115(459):1–149Guillen M, Vidiella-i-Anguera A (2005) Forecasting Spanish natural life expectancy. Risk Anal 25(5):1161–1170Heligman L, Pollard J (1980) The age pattern of mortality. J Inst Actuar 107:49–80Herranz-Gonzalez R (2006) Hipoteca inversa y figuras afines. Informes Portal Mayores 49, IMSERSO, Madrid, http://www.imsersomayores.csic.es/documentos/documentos/herranz-hipoteca-01.pdfHoriuchi S, Wilmoth J (1998) Decelaration in the age pattern of mortality at older ages. Demography 35:391–412Hyndman RJ (2008) Forecast: forecasting functions for time series. R package version 1.11Koissi M, Shapiro A, Hgns G (2006) Evaluating and extending the Lee–Carter model for mortality forecasting confidence interval. Insur Math Econ 38(1):1–20Kutty N (1998) The scope for poverty alleviation among elderly home-owners in the United States through reverse mortgages. Urban Stud 35(1):113–129Lee R (2000) The Lee–Carter method for forecasting mortality, with various extensions and applications. N Am Actuar J 4(1):80–91Lee R, Carter L (1992) Modelling and forecasting US mortality. J Am Stat Assoc 87(419):659–671Lee R, Nault F (1993) Modeling and forecasting provincial mortality in Canada. Montreal world congress of the International Union for Scientific Study of PopulationLee R, Rofman R (1994) Modelación y Proyección de la mortalidad en Chile. Notas Poblacin 22(59):182–213Li N, Lee R (2005) Coherent mortality forecast for a group of populations: an extension of the Lee–Carter method. Demography 42(3):575–593Li S-H, Hardy M, Tan K (2009) Uncertainty in mortality forecasting: an extensin to the classical Lee–Carter approach. Astin Bull 31:137–164Lindbergson M (2001) Mortality among the elderly in Sweden. Scan Actuar J 1:79–94Liu X, Braun WJ (2010) Investigating mortality uncertainty using the block bootstrap. J Probab Stat 2010:385–399McNown R, Rogers A (1989) Forecasting mortality: a parametrized time series aproach. Demography 26(4):645–660McNown R, Rogers A (1992) Forecasting cause-specific mortality using time series methods. Int J Forecast 8(3):413–432Miceli T, Sirmans C (1994) Reverse mortgages and borrower maintenance risk. J Am Real Estate Urban Econ Assoc 22(2):433–450Pedroza C (2006) A bayesian forecasting model: predicting US male mortality. Biostatistics 7(4):530–550Renshaw A, Haberman S (2003) Lee–Carter mortality forecasting: a parallel generalized linear modelling aproach for England and Wales mortality projections. J R Stat Soc C 52(1):119–137Renshaw A, Haberman S (2003) Lee–Carter mortality forecasting with age specific enhancement. Insur Math Econ 33(2):255–272Renshaw A, Haberman S (2003) On the forecasting of mortality reduction factors. Insur Math Econ 32(3):379–401Renshaw A, Haberman S (2006) A cohort-based extension to the Lee–Carter model for mortality reduction factors. Insur Math Econ 38(3):556–570Renshaw A, Haberman S (2008) On simulation-based approaches to risk measurement in mortality with specific reference to poisson Lee–Carter modelling. Insur Math Econ 42(2):797–816Shiller R, Weiss A (2000) Moral hazard in home equity conversion. Real Estate Econ 28(1):1–31Skarr D (2008) Financial planner’s guide to the FHA insured home equity conversion mortgage. J Financ Plan 21(5):68–75Sánchez-Álvarez I, Lpez-Ares S, Quiroga-García R (2007) Diseño de hipotecas inversas en el mercado español. Proyecto 205/05 3, Instituto de Mayores y Servicios SocialesTaffin C (2006) La hipoteca inversa o vitalicia. Informes externos, Asociación Hipotecaria EspañolaThatcher A, Kannisto V, Andreev K (2002) The survivor ratio method for estimating numbers at high ages. Demogr Res 6(1):1–18Thatcher A, Kannisto V, Vaupel J (1998) The force of mortality at ages 80 to 120. Odense University Press, OdenseTuljapurkar S, Li N, Boe C (2000) A universal pattern of mortality decline in the G7 countries. Nature 405(6788):789–792Wang L, Valdez E, Piggott J (2008) Securization of longevity risk in reverse mortgages. N Am Actuar J 12(4):345–370Wilmoth J (1993) Computational methods for fitting and extrapolating the Lee–Carter model of mortality change. Technical report, Departament of Demography, University of California, BerkeleyWilmoth J (1996) Health and mortality among elderly populations, chapter mortality projections for Japan: a comparison of four methods. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 266–28

Sex-specific mortality forecasting for UK countries: a coherent approach

This paper introduces a gender specific model for the joint mortality projection of three countries (England and Wales combined, Scotland, and Northern Ireland) of the United Kingdom. The model, called 2-tier Augmented Common Factor model, extends the classical Lee and Carter [26] and Li and Lee [32] models, with a common time factor for the whole UK population, a sex specific period factor for males and females, and a specific time factor for each country within each gender. As death counts in each subpopulation are modelled directly, a Poisson framework is used. Our results show that the 2-tier ACF model improves the in-sample fitting compared to the use of independent LC models for each subpopulation or of independent Li and Lee models for each couple of genders within each country. Mortality projections also show that the 2-tier ACF model produces coherent forecasts for the two genders within each country and different countries within each gender, thus avoiding the divergence issues arising when independent projections are used. The 2-tier ACF is further extended to include a cohort term to take into account the faster improvements of the UK ‘golden generation’

Computational framework for longevity risk management

Longevity risk threatens the financial stability of private and government sponsored defined benefit pension systems as well as social security schemes, in an environment already characterized by persistent low interest rates and heightened financial uncertainty. The mortality experience of countries in the industrialized world would suggest a substantial age-time interaction, with the two dominant trends affecting different age groups at different times. From a statistical point of view, this indicates a dependence structure. It is observed that mortality improvements are similar for individuals of contiguous ages (Wills and Sherris, Integrating financial and demographic longevity risk models: an Australian model for financial applications, Discussion Paper PI-0817, 2008). Moreover, considering the dataset by single ages, the correlations between the residuals for adjacent age groups tend to be high (as noted in Denton et al., J Population Econ 18:203-227, 2005). This suggests that there is value in exploring the dependence structure, also across time, in other words the inter-period correlation. In this research, we focus on the projections of mortality rates, contravening the most commonly encountered dependence property which is the "lack of dependence" (Denuit et al., Actuarial theory for dependent risks: measures. Orders and models, Wiley, New York, 2005). By taking into account the presence of dependence across age and time which leads to systematic over-estimation or under-estimation of uncertainty in the estimates (Liu and Braun, J Probability Stat, 813583:15, 2010), the paper analyzes a tailor-made bootstrap methodology for capturing the spatial dependence in deriving confidence intervals for mortality projection rates. We propose a method which leads to a prudent measure of longevity risk, avoiding the structural incompleteness of the ordinary simulation bootstrap methodology which involves the assumption of independence

First-Order Mortality Basis for Life Annuities

Mortality improvements pose a challenge for the life annuity business. For the management of such portfolios, it is important to forecast future mortality rates. Standard models for mortality forecasting assume that the force of mortality at age x in calendar year t is of the form exp, where the dynamics of the time index is described by a random walk with drift. Starting from such a best estimate of future mortality (called second-order mortality basis in actuarial science), the paper explains how to determine a conservative life table serving as first-order mortality basis. The idea is to replace the stochastic projected life table with a deterministic conservative one, and to assume mutual independence for the remaining life times. The paper then studies the distribution of the present value of the payments made to a closed group of annuitants. It turns out that De Pril–Panjer algorithm can be used for that purpose under first-order mortality basis. The connection with ruin probabilities is briefly discussed. An inequality between the distribution of the present value of future annuity payments under first-order and second-order mortality basis is provided, which allows to link value-at-risk computed under these two sets of assumptions. A numerical example performed on Belgian mortality statistics illustrates how the approach proposed in this paper can be implemented in practice. The Geneva Risk and Insurance Review (2008) 33, 75–89. doi:10.1057/grir.2008.9

Improving Lee-Carter forecasting: methodology and some results

The aim of the paper is to improve the Lee-Carter model performance developing a methodology able to refine its predictive accuracy. Considering relevant information the discrepancies between the real data and the Lee-Carter outputs, we model a measure of the fitting errors as a Cox-Ingersoll-Ross process. A new LC model is derived, called mLC. We apply the results over a fixed prediction span and with respect to the mortality data relating to the Italian females aged 18 and 65, chosen as examples of the model application. Through the backtesting procedure within a static framework, the model mLC proves itself to outperform the LC model