Variation et évolution de la composition du venin des guêpes parasitoïdes Psyttalia (Hymenoptera, Braconidae) et Leptopilina (Hymenoptera, Figitidae) : une cause possible d'échec et de succès en lutte biologique ?

Endoparasitoid wasps lay eggs and develop inside arthropod hosts, leading to their death. They have evolved various strategies to ensure parasitism success, notably the injection with the eggs of venom that suppresses the host immunity. Although venom composition has been characterized in a growing number of parasitoid families and recent studies suggest that parasitoid virulence can rapidly evolve, the intraspecific variation of venom and its short-Term evolvability remained to be investigated. This information is however essential for understanding the evolution of parasitoid host range and may have implications in biological control. This thesis allowed to demonstrate the occurrence of inter-Individual variability of venom and to develop a method based on the analysis of electrophoretic 1D profiles and the use of “R” functions allowing statistic comparison of protein quantities from numerous individuals. Then, to study the effect of this variability of the venom composition, experimental evolution studies were performed on Psyttalia lounsburyi and Leptopilina boulardi. Overall, the thesis evidenced that parasitoid venom composition (i) is variable at all studied biological levels (ii) changes rapidly, confirming its high evolvability, and (iii) influences key parameters of the parasitoid biology. This may have important implications in biocontrol and raises the question of the mechanisms sustaining this variability.Les guêpes endoparasitoïdes effectuent leur développement dans un hôte arthropode, entraînant sa mort. Parmi les stratégies assurant leur succès parasitaire, la plus commune est l’injection de venin dans l’hôte lors de l’oviposition, provoquant la suppression de l’immunité de l’hôte. Il est connu que la composition du venin est variable entre espèces et que la virulence des parasitoïdes peut évoluer rapidement. Pourtant la variation intraspécifique de la composition du venin n’a jamais été étudiée alors qu’elle est essentielle pour comprendre l’évolution de la gamme d’hôte des parasitoïdes, un paramètre clé en lutte biologique. Cette thèse a permis de démontrer l’existence d’une variabilité inter-Individuelle du venin, et de développer une méthode basée sur l’analyse de profiles d’électrophorèse 1D à l’aide de fonctions “R” permettant la comparaison statistique de la composition protéique d’un grand nombre d’individus. Des évolutions expérimentales ont ensuite été réalisée sur Psyttalia lounsburyi et Leptopilina boulardi pour étudier les effets de la variabilité du venin lors d’un changement d’environnement brutal. Globalement, cette thèse a mis en évidence que la composition du venin (i) est très variable à tous les niveaux étudiés, (ii) évolue rapidement et (iii) impacte des paramètres clés de la biologie des parasitoïdes. Ceci pourrait avoir d’importantes implications en lutte biologique et pose la question des mécanismes de maintien de la variabilité du venin dans le milieu naturel

Variation in the Venom of Parasitic Wasps, Drift, or Selection? Insights From a Multivariate QST Analysis

Differentiation of traits among populations can evolve by drift when gene flow is low relative to drift or selection when there are different local optima in each population (heterogeneous selection), whereas homogeneous selection tends to prevent evolution of such a differentiation. Analyses of geographical variations in venom composition have been done in several taxa such as wasps, spiders, scorpions, cone snails and snakes, but surprisingly never in parasitoid wasps, although their venom should constrain their ability to succeed on locally available hosts. Such a study is now facilitated by the development of an accurate method (quantitative digital analysis) that allows analyzing the quantitative variation of large sets of proteins from several individuals. This method was used here to analyse the venom-based differentiation of four samples of Leptopilina boulardi and five samples of L. heterotoma from populations along a 300 km long south-north gradient in the Rhône-Saône valley (South-East of France). A major result is that the composition of the venom allows to differentiate the populations studied even when separated by few kilometers. We further analyzed these differentiations on the populations (reared under similar conditions to exclude environmental variance) with a QST analysis which compared the variance of a quantitative trait (Q) among the subpopulations (S) to the total variance (T). We also used random forest clustering analyses to detect the venom components the most likely to be adapted locally. The signature of the natural selection was strong for L. heterotoma and L. boulardi. For the latter, the comparison with the differentiation observed at some neutral markers revealed that differentiation was partly due to some local adaptation. The combination of methods used here appears to be a powerful framework for population proteomics and for the study of eco-evolutionary feedbacks between proteomic level and population and ecosystem levels. This is of interest not only for studying field evolution at an intermediate level between the genome and phenotypes, or for understanding the role of evolution in chemical ecology, but also for more applied issues in biological control

Variation and evolution of venom contents in the parasitoid wasps Psyttalia (Hymenoptera, Braconidae) and Leptopilina (Hymenoptera, Figitidae) : a cause of success and failure in biological control ?

Les guêpes endoparasitoïdes effectuent leur développement dans un hôte arthropode, entraînant sa mort. Parmi les stratégies assurant leur succès parasitaire, la plus commune est l’injection de venin dans l’hôte lors de l’oviposition, provoquant la suppression de l’immunité de l’hôte. Il est connu que la composition du venin est variable entre espèces et que la virulence des parasitoïdes peut évoluer rapidement. Pourtant la variation intraspécifique de la composition du venin n’a jamais été étudiée alors qu’elle est essentielle pour comprendre l’évolution de la gamme d’hôte des parasitoïdes, un paramètre clé en lutte biologique. Cette thèse a permis de démontrer l’existence d’une variabilité inter-Individuelle du venin, et de développer une méthode basée sur l’analyse de profiles d’électrophorèse 1D à l’aide de fonctions “R” permettant la comparaison statistique de la composition protéique d’un grand nombre d’individus. Des évolutions expérimentales ont ensuite été réalisée sur Psyttalia lounsburyi et Leptopilina boulardi pour étudier les effets de la variabilité du venin lors d’un changement d’environnement brutal. Globalement, cette thèse a mis en évidence que la composition du venin (i) est très variable à tous les niveaux étudiés, (ii) évolue rapidement et (iii) impacte des paramètres clés de la biologie des parasitoïdes. Ceci pourrait avoir d’importantes implications en lutte biologique et pose la question des mécanismes de maintien de la variabilité du venin dans le milieu naturel.Endoparasitoid wasps lay eggs and develop inside arthropod hosts, leading to their death. They have evolved various strategies to ensure parasitism success, notably the injection with the eggs of venom that suppresses the host immunity. Although venom composition has been characterized in a growing number of parasitoid families and recent studies suggest that parasitoid virulence can rapidly evolve, the intraspecific variation of venom and its short-Term evolvability remained to be investigated. This information is however essential for understanding the evolution of parasitoid host range and may have implications in biological control. This thesis allowed to demonstrate the occurrence of inter-Individual variability of venom and to develop a method based on the analysis of electrophoretic 1D profiles and the use of “R” functions allowing statistic comparison of protein quantities from numerous individuals. Then, to study the effect of this variability of the venom composition, experimental evolution studies were performed on Psyttalia lounsburyi and Leptopilina boulardi. Overall, the thesis evidenced that parasitoid venom composition (i) is variable at all studied biological levels (ii) changes rapidly, confirming its high evolvability, and (iii) influences key parameters of the parasitoid biology. This may have important implications in biocontrol and raises the question of the mechanisms sustaining this variability

Data used in the paper -Statistical analysis of the individual variability of 1D protein profiles as a tool in ecology-

In this folder, their are the data used in the paper "Statistical analysis of the individual variability of 1D protein profiles as a tool in ecology: an application to parasitoid venom"

DRYAD_genotype_frequencies

See README file

Table S4 Data Pea aphid symbionts

Data Pea aphid symbionts survey in Europ

Data from: Rapid evolution of symbiont-mediated resistance compromises biological control of aphids by parasitoids

There is growing interest in biological control as a sustainable and environmentally friendly way to control pest insects. Aphids are among the most detrimental agricultural pests worldwide, and parasitoid wasps are frequently employed for their control. The use of asexual parasitoids may improve the effectiveness of biological control because only females kill hosts and because asexual populations have a higher growth rate than sexuals. However, asexuals may have a reduced capacity to track evolutionary change in their host populations. We used a factorial experiment to compare the ability of sexual and asexual populations of the parasitoid Lysiphlebus fabarum to control caged populations of black bean aphids (Aphis fabae) of high and low clonal diversity. The aphids came from a natural population, and one third of the aphid clones harbored Hamiltonella defensa, a heritable bacterial endosymbiont that increases resistance to parasitoids. We followed aphid and parasitoid population dynamics for three months but found no evidence that the reproductive mode of parasitoids affected their effectiveness as biocontrol agents, independent of host clonal diversity. Parasitoids failed to control aphids in most cases, because their introduction resulted in strong selection for clones protected by H. defensa. The increasingly resistant aphid populations escaped control by parasitoids and we even observed parasitoid extinctions in many cages. The rapid evolution of symbiont-conferred resistance in turn imposed selection on parasitoids. In cages where asexual parasitoids persisted until the end of the experiment, they became dominated by a single genotype able to overcome the protection provided by H. defensa. Thus there was evidence for parasitoid counteradaptation, but it was generally too slow for parasitoids to regain control over aphid populations. It appears that when pest aphids possess defensive symbionts, the presence of parasitoid genotypes able to overcome symbiont-conferred resistance is more important for biocontrol success than their reproductive mode

Data from: Non-random associations of maternally transmitted symbionts in insects: the roles of drift versus co-transmission and selection

Virtually all higher organisms form holobionts with associated microbiota. To understand the biology of holobionts we need to know how species assemble and interact. Controlled experiments are suited to study interactions between particular symbionts, but they can only inform about a tiny portion of the diversity within each species. Alternatively, interactions can be inferred from associations among symbionts in the field that are more or less frequent than expected under random assortment. However, random assortment may not be a valid null hypothesis for maternally transmitted symbionts in finite populations, where drift alone can result in associations. Here we report results from a European field survey of endosymbionts in the pea aphid (Acyrthosiphon pisum), and we develop a model to study the effect of drift on symbiont associations under different population sizes, considering varying rates of horizontal and maternal transmission. The model showed that even though horizontal transmissions and maternal transmission failures randomise symbiont associations, drift can induce significant departures from random assortment, at least in moderate-sized populations. Based on these results, we carefully interpret our field survey and we re-visit the association between Spiroplasma and Wolbachia in Drosophila neotestacea reported by Jaenike et al. (2010). For this and for several significant associations between symbionts in European pea aphids we conclude that under reasonable assumptions of effective population size, they are indeed likely to be maintained by biased co-transmission or selection. Our study shows that formulating appropriate null expectations can strengthen the biological inference from co-occurrence patterns in the field

Data from: Evolutionary costs and benefits of infection with diverse strains of Spiroplasma in pea aphids

The heritable endosymbiont Spiroplasma infects many insects and has repeatedly evolved the ability to protect its hosts against different parasites. Defenses do not come for free to the host, and theory predicts that more costly symbionts need to provide stronger benefits to persist in host populations. We investigated the costs and benefits of Spiroplasma infections in pea aphids (Acyrthosiphon pisum), testing 12 bacterial strains from three different clades. Virtually all strains decreased aphid lifespan and reproduction, but only two had a (weak) protective effect against the parasitoid Aphidius ervi, an important natural enemy of pea aphids. Spiroplasma induced fitness costs were variable, with strains from the most slowly evolving clade reaching higher titers and curtailing aphid lifespan more strongly than other strains. Some Spiroplasma strains shared their host with a second endosymbiont, Regiella insecticola. Although the result of an unfortunate handling error, these co-infections proved instructive, because they showed that the cost of infection with Spiroplasma may be attenuated in the presence of Regiella. These results suggest that mechanisms other than protection against A. ervi maintain pea aphid infections with diverse strains of Spiroplasma, and that studying them in isolation will not provide a complete picture of their effects on host fitness

Data from: Evolutionary costs and benefits of infection with diverse strains of Spiroplasma in pea aphids

The heritable endosymbiont Spiroplasma infects many insects and has repeatedly evolved the ability to protect its hosts against different parasites. Defenses do not come for free to the host, and theory predicts that more costly symbionts need to provide stronger benefits to persist in host populations. We investigated the costs and benefits of Spiroplasma infections in pea aphids (Acyrthosiphon pisum), testing 12 bacterial strains from three different clades. Virtually all strains decreased aphid lifespan and reproduction, but only two had a (weak) protective effect against the parasitoid Aphidius ervi, an important natural enemy of pea aphids. Spiroplasma induced fitness costs were variable, with strains from the most slowly evolving clade reaching higher titers and curtailing aphid lifespan more strongly than other strains. Some Spiroplasma strains shared their host with a second endosymbiont, Regiella insecticola. Although the result of an unfortunate handling error, these co-infections proved instructive, because they showed that the cost of infection with Spiroplasma may be attenuated in the presence of Regiella. These results suggest that mechanisms other than protection against A. ervi maintain pea aphid infections with diverse strains of Spiroplasma, and that studying them in isolation will not provide a complete picture of their effects on host fitness