Precision of the current methods to measure the alkenone proxy UK'37 and absolute alkenone abundance in sediments : results of an interlaboratory comparison study

Measurements of the UK'37 index and the absolute abundance of alkenones in marine sediments are increasingly used in paleoceanographic research as proxies of past sea surface temperature and haptophyte (mainly coccolith-bearing species) primary productivity, respectively. An important aspect of these studies is to be able to compare reliably data obtained by different laboratories from a wide variety of locations. Hence the intercomparability of data produced by the research community is essential. Here we report results from an anonymous interlaboratory comparison study involving 24 of the leading laboratories that carry out alkenone measurements worldwide. The majority of laboratories produce data that are intercomparable within the considered confidence limits. For the measurement of alkenone concentrations, however, there are systematic biases between laboratories, which might be related to the techniques employed to quantify the components. The maximum difference between any two laboratories for any two single measurements of UK'37 in sediments is estimated, with a probability of 95%, to be <2.18C. In addition, the overall within-laboratory precision for the UK'37 temperature estimates is estimated to be <1.68C (95% probability). Similarly, from the analyses of alkenone concentrations the interlaboratory reproducibility is estimated at 32%, and the repeatability is estimated at 24%. The former is compared to a theoretical estimate of reproducibility and found to be excessively high. Hence there is certainly scope and a demonstrable need to improve reproducibility and repeatability of UK'37 and especially alkenone quantification data across the community of scientists involved in alkenone research

Reassessment of the structural composition of the alkenone distributions in natural environments using an improved method for double bond location based on GC-MS analysis of cyclopropylimines

11 pages, 4 figures, 3 tables.-- PMID: 16540339 [PubMed].-- Printed version published May 2006.The usefulness of n-propyl-, iso-propyl-, and cyclopropylamines for the location of double bonds positions in C37–C40 alkenones after formation of imino derivatives has been evaluated. Cyclopropylamine is the best reagent for its high reaction yields, GC retention time difference between derivatives and precursor compounds, and absence of generation of byproducts. The use of this C3 amine involves higher sensitivity and ease of application than previously reported C5 amines. Examination of a large group of alkenones from cultures of Emiliania huxleyi, water particles, and recent and ancient sediments with cyclopropylamine derivatization shows that, in all cases, the double bonds were located at the same carbon atom distance from the carbonyl group, and spaced in intervals of five methylene groups either from the carbonyl or between them, e.g., at sites 7, 14, 21, and 28. This result represents a correction from previous assumptions in which double-bond positions were situated by reference to the methyl end. 4,4-Dimethyloxazoline derivatization of hexatriacontenoates showed that these compounds have also their unsaturations with seven carbon atom spacing and counting by reference to the carboxyl group. The concurrence of both series of isomers in compounds of different oxygen functionalities indicates that the precursor haptophycean algal species have a major biosynthetic pathway leading to the formation of these lipids. The data presented in this work unify the structures of the known alkenones in the present and the recent past under a common metabolic pathway.The authors thank Professor J. R. Maxwell, University of Bristol, for the synthetic alkenone standards. They thank Drs. Belén Martrat, Tirso García de Oteyza, and Anja Kirch for providing valuable samples. Dr. Roser Chaler and Dori Fanjul are acknowledged for technical support. JFL thanks the Spanish Council for Scientific Research (CSIC) for an I3P grant. The authors acknowledge financial support from the EU Projects PACLIVA (EVK2-CT2002-00143) and HERMES (GOCE-CT-2005-511234).Peer reviewe