44 research outputs found
Respiratory physiotherapy interventions focused on exercise training and enhancing physical activity levels in people with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease are likely to be cost-effective: a systematic review
Question: What is the cost-effectiveness of respiratory physiotherapy interventions for people with chronic
obstructive pulmonary disease? Design: Systematic review of full economic evaluations alongside clinical
trials published between 1997 and 2021. Reviewers independently screened studies for inclusion, extracted
data and assessed methodological quality. Participants: People with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.
Intervention: Respiratory physiotherapy interventions as defined in the respiratory physiotherapy curricu-
lum of the European Respiratory Society. Outcome measures: Costs expressed in monetary units, effect sizes
expressed in terms of disease-specific quality of life (QOL), quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) or monetary
units. Results: This review included 11 randomised trials with 3,261 participants. The interventions were
pulmonary rehabilitation, airway clearance techniques, an integrated disease-management program and an
early assisted discharge program, including inpatient respiratory physiotherapy. Meta-analysis was consid-
ered irrelevant due to the extensive heterogeneity of the reported interventions. A total of 45 incremental
cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs) were extracted. Regardless of the economic perspectives, 67% of all QOL-
related ICERs and 71% of all QALY-related ICERs were situated in the north-east or south-east quadrants of
the cost-effectiveness plane. Six studies could be seen as cost-effective when compared with a specified cost-
effectiveness threshold per QALY gained. Conclusion: Respiratory physiotherapy interventions focusing on
exercise training in combination with enhancing physical activity levels are likely to be cost-effective in
terms of costs per unit QOL gained and QALYs. Some uncertainty still exists on the various estimates of cost-
effectiveness due to differences in the content and intensity of the type of interventions, outcome measures
and comparators. Registration: PROSPERO CRD42018088699
Recommended from our members
Monitoring the world's agriculture
Agriculture must be transformed. Although global food production is increasing, today's farming systems undermine the well-being of communities in many ways. For instance, farming has destroyed huge regions of natural habitat and caused an untold loss of ecosystem services, and it is responsible for about 30% of greenhouse-gas emissions. Already, about 1 billion people are undernourished. Yet to feed the global population expected by 2050, more than 1 billion hectares of wild land will need to be converted to farmland if current approaches continue to be used
Recommended from our members
Effective monitoring of agriculture: a response
The development of effective agricultural monitoring networks is essential to track, anticipate and manage changes in the social, economic and environmental aspects of agriculture. We welcome the perspective of Lindenmayer and Likens (J. Environ. Monit., 2011, 13, 1559) as published in the Journal of Environmental Monitoring on our earlier paper, âMonitoring the World's Agricultureâ (Sachs et al., Nature, 2010, 466, 558â560). In this response, we address their three main critiques labeled as âthe passive approachâ, âthe problem with uniform metricsâ and âthe problem with composite metricsâ. We expand on specific research questions at the core of the network design, on the distinction between key universal and site-specific metrics to detect change over time and across scales, and on the need for composite metrics in decision-making. We believe that simultaneously measuring indicators of the three pillars of sustainability (environmentally sound, social responsible and economically viable) in an effectively integrated monitoring system will ultimately allow scientists and land managers alike to find solutions to the most pressing problems facing global food security
Spatio-temporal development of forests - Current trends in field methods and models
We present a critical review of current trends in research of spatio-temporal development of forests. The paper addresses (1) field methods for the development of spatially-explicit models of forest dynamics and their integration in models of forest dynamics, (2) strengths and limitations of traditional patch models versus spatially-explicit, individual-based models, and (3) the potential for moment-based methods in the analysis of forest dynamics. These topics are discussed with reference to their potential for solving open questions in the studies of forest dynamics. The study of spatio-temporal processes provides a link between pattern and process in plant communities, and plays a crucial role in understanding ecosystem dynamics. In the last decade, the development of spatially-explicit, individual-based models shifted the focus of forest dynamics modelling from the dynamics of discrete patches to the interactions among individual organisms, thus encapsulating the theory of "neighbourhood" dynamics. In turn, the stochastic properties and the complexity of spatially-explicit, individual-based models gave rise to the development of a new suite of so-called moment-based models. These new models describe the dynamics of individuals and of pairs of individuals in terms of their densities, thus directly capturing second-order information on spatial structure. So far, this approach has not been applied to forests; we indicate extensions needed for such applications. Moment-based models may be an important complement to spatially explicit individual-based models in developing a general spatial theory of forest dynamics. However, both kinds of models currently focus on fine scales, whereas a critical issue in forest dynamics is to understand the interaction of fine-scale processes with coarser-scale disturbances. To obtain a more complete picture of forest dynamics, the relevant links and interactions between fine-, intermediate-, and coarse-scale processes ought to be identified. Intensive links between modelling work and field studies designed across different scales are a promising means to create a new perspective on forest dynamics
Low carbon stations for low carbon cities â Final report 2015
1. svensk text VĂ„ra stationssamhĂ€llen Ă€r viktiga för stĂ€ders och regioners utveckling. En utveckling av dessa samhĂ€llen kan möjliggöra en transportsnĂ„l samhĂ€llsplanering, hĂ„llbar ekonomisk utveckling och en attraktiv region. Att förtĂ€ta i stationsnĂ€ra lĂ€gen Ă€r en gemensam utmaning för mĂ„nga aktörer och intressenter. Mistra Urban Futures driver tillsammans med en rad partners, Ă€ven Trafikverket, ett projekt om urbana stationssamhĂ€llen. Projektet vill öka kunskapen om det komplexa i stationsnĂ€ra planering och skapa förutsĂ€ttningar för utveckling av stationssamhĂ€llen. Projektet fokuserar pĂ„ att vitalisera och stötta planeringsprocesser i kommuner för att kunna bygga transporteffektiva region med attraktiva och tĂ€ta stationssamhĂ€llen. Flera delprojekt genomförs för att öka kunskapen och Low carbon stations for low carbon cities Ă€r ett delprojekt. Mistra Urban Futures anser att utformningen av kollektivtrafiknoder Ă€r en viktig parameter för att öka resandet med kollektivtrafiken och minska utslĂ€ppen av koldioxid. Utformningen av stationslĂ€gen Ă€r en globalt viktig frĂ„ga och detta projekt kan tillföra viktig kunskap till plattformarna inom Mistra Urban Futures. Trafikverket har finansierat det europeiska forskarteamet YDF för arbetet med "Low carbon stations for low carbon cities" - en forskning om stationsomrĂ„den och hur man genom en effektivare utformning och planering av flöden för resor och transporter kan minska koldioxidutslĂ€ppen. Syftet med forskningen har varit att fĂ„ fram generella rekommendationer som kan anvĂ€ndas vid utformning av stationsomrĂ„den och dess flöden. Med syfte att fĂ„ underlag för en generaliserbar kunskap med rekommendationer som kan anvĂ€ndas i alla lĂ€nder, har YDF undersökt och jĂ€mfört stationsomrĂ„dens utformning, funktioner och möjligheter i flera vĂ€rldsdelars stĂ€der. I Sverige har YDF undersökt stationsomrĂ„dena i Stockholm, Malmö och Göteborg. Projektets ena rapportdel innehĂ„ller övergripande frĂ„gestĂ€llningar om energieffektivitet kopplat till resor, transporter och design för hĂ„llbarhet i storstadsregioner utifrĂ„n ett stationsperspektiv. Projektets andra rapportdel innehĂ„ller konkreta rĂ„d och rekommendationer om metoder och utformning med anvĂ€ndbar kunskap som efterfrĂ„gas allt mer. Anne Leemans, generalsekreterare i stiftelsen YDF: â Som medborgare och formgivare kĂ€nner vi ansvar att göra vad vi kan för att mildra klimatförĂ€ndringarna. Vi började forska ur resenĂ€rsperspektivet och kopplingen mellan upplevd sĂ€kerhet och design av urbana transporter och utvecklade en metod för att förbĂ€ttra den upplevda tryggheten i och omkring stationerna. Det har visat sig vara viktigt att inte bara öka antalet passagerare och anvĂ€ndare av stationen men ocksĂ„ för att öka detaljhandeln pĂ„ stationen. Hur kan vi pĂ„verka kollektivtrafikens attraktion hos resenĂ€rerna? Hur kan vi öka tilliten för kollektivtrafiken? NĂ€sta frĂ„ga var, med tanke pĂ„ behovet av tillgĂ€nglighet, lokalisering och minskad klimatpĂ„verkan, hur kan vi bidra till en bĂ€ttre integrering av stationer i stadens urbana struktur i olika delar av vĂ€rlden.â 2. English The future role of station communities is crucial for urban and regional development. A development of these communities can enable a transport-efficient urban planning, a sustainable economic development and an attractive region. Densifying station neighborhoods is a common challenge for many actors and stakeholders. Mistra Urban Futures are therefore along with several partners, Swedish Transport Administration is one of them, in the process of developing a project about urban station communities. The project will increase knowledge about the complexity in planning station near locations and create conditions for development of station communities. The project focuses on revitalizing and supporting municipalities regular planning processes to stimulate the building of an efficient transport region with attractive and dense station communities. Mistra Urban Futures think that the design of public transport nodes is an important parameter to increase travel by public transport and reduce emissions of carbon dioxide. The design of the station locations is a globally important issue and the project can bring important knowledge to the platforms in Mistra Urban Futures. The Swedish Transport Administration has funded the European research team YDF for the work of the "Low Carbon station for low carbon cities" - a research of station areas and how, through effective design and planning of flows for travel and transport can reduce carbon emissions. Purpose of the research has been to develop general recommendations that can be used in the design of the station areas and its flows. To get a basis for a generalizable knowledge with recommendations that can be used in all countries, has YDF examined and compared station areas design, features and capabilities in several continents cities. In Sweden has the station areas in Stockholm, Malmö and Gothenburg been examined. The first part of the projectâs report contains general questions about the energy efficiency linked to the travel, transportation and design for sustainability in metropolitan regions from a station perspective. The project's second part of the report contains advice and recommendations on methods, the design of useful knowledge that are increasingly in demand. Anne Leemans , Secretary General of the Foundation YDF: âAs citizens and design professionals we moreover feel we have an obligation to undertake what is within our power and capacity to help mitigate climate change. We started doing research from the perspective of passengers on the link between perceived security and design of urban public transport stations and developed a methodology to improve perceived security in and around stations. It has proved to be important not only to increase the number of passengers and users of the station but also to boost the turn-over of retailers in the station. How can we positively influence the attraction of public transport to passenger? How can we make sure more people trust public transport? The next question was, considering the need for accessible mobility is location and climate independant, how can we contribute to a better integration of stations in the urban tissue both in the global South and North.âMistra Urban Future