Laboratory micro-seismic signature of shear faulting and fault slip in shale

This article reports the results of a triaxial deformation experiment conducted on a transversely isotropic shale specimen. This specimen was instrumented with ultrasonic transducers to monitor the evolution of the micro-seismic activity induced by shear faulting (triaxial failure) and subsequent fault slip at two different rates. The strain data demonstrate the anisotropy of the mechanical (quasi-static) compliance of the shale; the P-wave velocity data demonstrate the anisotropy of the elastic (dynamic) compliance of the shale. The spatio-temporal evolution of the micro-seismic activity suggests the development of two distinct but overlapping shear faults, a feature similar to relay ramps observed in large-scale structural geology. The shear faulting of the shale specimen appears quasi-aseismic, at least in the 0.5 MHz range of sensitivity of the ultrasonic transducers used in the experiment. Concomitantly, the rate of micro-seismic activity is strongly correlated with the imposed slip rate and the evolution of the axial stress. The moment tensor inversion of the focal mechanism of the high quality micro-seismic events recorded suggests a transition from a non-shear dominated to a shear dominated micro-seismic activity when the rock evolves from initial failure to larger and faster slip along the fault. The frictional behaviour of the shear faults highlights the possible interactions between small asperities and slow slip of a velocity-strengthening fault, which could be considered as a realistic experimental analogue of natural observations of non-volcanic tremors and (very) low-frequency earthquakes triggered by slow slip events

Comparing “apples” and “oranges” in the Woodford Shale: Pitfalls of the thermal maturity gradient approach for constraining evolution of mudrock porosity

The thermal maturity gradient approach is widely used in comparative studies of mudrocks to assess the evolution of the pore system. The fundamental assumption in this approach is that the compared samples share similar geochemical, mineralogical and textural properties, so that any differences between them can be reasonably attributed to the impact of thermal maturity and burial alteration. However, achieving the desired range of thermal maturity often requires sampling from widely spaced localities which may result in unrecognised microtextural differences owing to regional variations in depositional controls, making it challenging to isolate the effects of thermal alteration on pore system evolution. We use samples from the widely studied siliceous Woodford Shale to highlight the importance of sample screening in characterization studies of pore evolution with progressive thermal maturity. Samples were collected from different cores spanning a gradient of thermal maturity (0.5–1.65 %VRc) across the Cherokee Platform, Arkoma and Anadarko basins, and capturing the wider geographic extent of the formation across Oklahoma. Samples were selected from the same lithofacies type but varying stratigraphic position and screened using the standard bulk geochemical and mineralogical criteria that are widely employed to ensure properties are comparable across a sample set. Notwithstanding this screening step, microscale electron microscope characterization revealed substantial microtextural and compositional differences within the sample set. Our results show that total pore volume is significantly influenced by these seemingly subtle differences, likely because pore evolution pathways vary with the abundance and distribution of primary (i.e. biogenic vs detrital grains) and diagenetic sediment constituents. We conclude that standard sample screening approaches that are limited to bulk mineralogical and geochemical characterization, and cannot identify differences in detrital, biogenic and authigenic components or account for textural differences, are insufficient for thermal gradient studies. A combination of high-resolution imaging, mineral mapping, x-ray diffraction, and low-pressure gas adsorption experiments proved better suited for sample screening ensuring an “apples” to “apples” comparison, as well as for detailed characterization bringing to light the impact of microtextural heterogeneity between samples on measured rock properties.Elizabeth T. Baruch, Stefan C. Lohr, Shujun Han, David N. Dewhurst, Alan S. Collin

Organic hosted porosity in the Wufeng-Longmaxi shale: A combined electron microscopy and neutron scattering approach

© 2019 European Association of Geoscientists and Engineers, EAGE. All Rights Reserved. The upper Ordovician Wufeng shale and lower Silurian Longmaxi shale are part of the Fuling shale gas play located in the south-eastern part of the Sichuan Basin, southern China, representing the first commercial shale gas production project outside North America. We studied the occurrence of porosity at micro- and nano-scale in samples of contrasting organic richness from the post‐mature part of the Wufeng-Longmaxi gas play. Using a combination of high resolution scanning and transmission electron microscopy and small angle neutron scattering we highlight the impact of different types of organic matter (primary versus migrated) on the development of organic matter (OM)-hosted porosity. The results indicate that the overall porosity in the samples is proportional to the organic richness, although the nanoscale imaging revealed that OM-hosted porosity is preferentially present in the migrated bitumen and not in the primary detrital particles. Distinguishing between primary and migrated OM is therefore important for understanding the creation of an interconnected network of OM during hydrocarbon migration. This may have an important control on the estimation of gas in place and the transport properties of the shale

The influence of shale depositional fabric on the kinetics of hydrocarbon generation through control of mineral surface contact area on clay catalysis

Accurately assessing the temperature and hence the depth and timing of hydrocarbon generation is a critical step in the characterization of a petroleum system. Clay catalysis is a potentially significant modifier of hydrocarbon generation temperature, but experimental studies of clay catalysis show inconsistent or contradictory results. This study tests the hypothesis that source rock fabric itself is an influence on clay mineral catalysis as it controls the extent to which organic matter and clay minerals are physically associated. Two endmember clay-organic fabrics distinguish the source rocks studied: (1) a particulate fabric where organic matter is present as discrete, >5 lm particles and (2) a nanocomposite fabric in which amorphous organic matter is associated with clay mineral surfaces at sub-micron scale. High-resolution electron imaging and bulk geochemical characterisation confirm that samples of the Miocene Monterey Formation (California) are representative of the nanocomposite source rock endmember, whereas samples from the Permian Stuart Range Formation (South Australia) represent the particulate source rock endmember. Kinetic experiments are performed on paired whole rock and kerogen isolate samples from these two formations using open system, non-isothermal pyrolysis at three different heating rates (0.7, 2 and 5 K/min) to determine the effects of the different shale fabrics on hydrocarbon generation kinetics. Extrapolation to a modelled geological heating rate shows a 20 C reduction in the onset temperature of hydrocarbon generation in Monterey Formation whole rock samples relative to paired kerogen isolates. This result is consistent with the Monterey Formations’s nanocomposite fabric where clay catalysis can proceed because reactive clay minerals are intimately associated with organic matter. By contrast, there is no significant difference in the modelled hydrocarbon generation temperature of paired whole rock and kerogen isolates from the Stuart Range Formation. This is consistent with its particulate fabric, where relatively large, discrete organic particles have limited contact with the mineral matrix and the clay minerals are mainly diagenetic and physically segregated within pores. While heating rate may have a control on mineral matrix effects, this result shows that the extent to which organic matter and clay minerals are physically associated could have a significant effect on the timing of hydrocarbon generation, and is a function of the depositional environment and detrital vs diagenetic origin of clay minerals in source rocks.Habibur M. Rahman, Martin Kennedy, Stefan Lo, hr, David N. Dewhurst, Neil Sherwood, Shengyu Yang, Brian Horsfiel