Towards Other Cinemas : a critical re-assessment of 1970s independent film and video

Four screenings curated by Claire M. Holdsworth (Kingston School of Art) with writer and director Professor Sue Clayton (Goldsmiths University London) and theorist Professor Laura Mulvey (Birkbeck, University of London) in partnership with LUX, London and the Whitechapel Gallery. Each installment examined experimental film- and video- making in 1970s Britain, bringing together thematic collections of diverse works to explore how younger generations re-activate this recent past, engaging with essays in a new collection of writings. 4037 The opening event (Saturday 16 September) screened works by Clayton and Mulvey at Close-Up cinema, with a Q&A chaired by Helen de Witt (Curator, BFI). This was followed by a day-long series (Sunday 17 September) at the Whitechapel Gallery cinema: ‘Activated Spaces’ (chair, Clayton) with guest speaker Dr Steve Presence (Research Fellow, University of the West of England, Bristol); ‘Listening In’ (chair, Holdsworth) with Dr Lucy Reynolds (Senior Lecturer and researcher, Westminster University, London); and ‘Time and Place’ (chair Mulvey) with Kodwo Eshun (Lecturer in Contemporary Art Theory at Goldsmiths, Visiting Professor, Haut Ecole d’Art et Design, Genève and co-founder of the Turner Prize nominated Otolith Group)

A Bayesian mixture modelling approach for spatial proteomics.

Analysis of the spatial sub-cellular distribution of proteins is of vital importance to fully understand context specific protein function. Some proteins can be found with a single location within a cell, but up to half of proteins may reside in multiple locations, can dynamically re-localise, or reside within an unknown functional compartment. These considerations lead to uncertainty in associating a protein to a single location. Currently, mass spectrometry (MS) based spatial proteomics relies on supervised machine learning algorithms to assign proteins to sub-cellular locations based on common gradient profiles. However, such methods fail to quantify uncertainty associated with sub-cellular class assignment. Here we reformulate the framework on which we perform statistical analysis. We propose a Bayesian generative classifier based on Gaussian mixture models to assign proteins probabilistically to sub-cellular niches, thus proteins have a probability distribution over sub-cellular locations, with Bayesian computation performed using the expectation-maximisation (EM) algorithm, as well as Markov-chain Monte-Carlo (MCMC). Our methodology allows proteome-wide uncertainty quantification, thus adding a further layer to the analysis of spatial proteomics. Our framework is flexible, allowing many different systems to be analysed and reveals new modelling opportunities for spatial proteomics. We find our methods perform competitively with current state-of-the art machine learning methods, whilst simultaneously providing more information. We highlight several examples where classification based on the support vector machine is unable to make any conclusions, while uncertainty quantification using our approach provides biologically intriguing results. To our knowledge this is the first Bayesian model of MS-based spatial proteomics data.LG was supported by the BBSRC Strategic Longer and Larger grant (Award BB/L002817/1) and the Wellcome Trust Senior Investigator Award 110170/Z/15/Z awarded to KSL. PDWK was supported by the MRC (project reference MC_UP_0801/1). CMM was supported by a Wellcome Trust Technology Development Grant (Grant number 108467/Z/15/Z). OMC is a Wellcome Trust Mathematical Genomics and Medicine student supported financially by the School of Clinical Medicine, University of Cambridge. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript

A Bioconductor workflow for processing and analysing spatial proteomics data [version 2; referees: 2 approved]

Spatial proteomics is the systematic study of protein sub-cellular localisation. In this workflow, we describe the analysis of a typical quantitative mass spectrometry-based spatial proteomics experiment using the MSnbase and pRoloc Bioconductor package suite. To walk the user through the computational pipeline, we use a recently published experiment predicting protein sub-cellular localisation in pluripotent embryonic mouse stem cells. We describe the software infrastructure at hand, importing and processing data, quality control, sub-cellular marker definition, visualisation and interactive exploration. We then demonstrate the application and interpretation of statistical learning methods, including novelty detection using semi-supervised learning, classification, clustering and transfer learning and conclude the pipeline with data export. The workflow is aimed at beginners who are familiar with proteomics in general and spatial proteomics in particular

Dynamic proteomic profiling of extra-embryonic endoderm differentiation in mouse embryonic stem cells

During mammalian pre-implantation development, the cells of the blastocyst’s inner cell mass differentiate into the epiblast and primitive endoderm lineages, which give rise to the fetus and extra-embryonic tissues, respectively. Extra-embryonic endoderm differentiation can be modeled in vitro by induced expression of GATA transcription factors in mouse embryonic stem cells. Here we use this GATA-inducible system to quantitatively monitor the dynamics of global proteomic changes during the early stages of this differentiation event and also investigate the fully differentiated phenotype, as represented by embryo-derived extra-embryonic endoderm (XEN) cells. Using mass spectrometry-based quantitative proteomic profiling with multivariate data analysis tools, we reproducibly quantified 2,336 proteins across three biological replicates and have identified clusters of proteins characterized by distinct, dynamic temporal abundance profiles. We first used this approach to highlight novel marker candidates of the pluripotent state and extra-embryonic endoderm differentiation. Through functional annotation enrichment analysis, we have shown that the downregulation of chromatin-modifying enzymes, the re-organization of membrane trafficking machinery and the breakdown of cell-cell adhesion are successive steps of the extra-embryonic differentiation process. Thus, applying a range of sophisticated clustering approaches to a time-resolved proteomic dataset has allowed the elucidation of complex biological processes which characterize stem cell differentiation and could establish a general paradigm for the investigation of these processes.This work was supported by the European Union 7th Framework Program (PRIME-XS project grant number 262067 to K.S.L., L.G and C.M.M), the Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC grant number BB/L002817/1 to K.S.L and L.G.), as well as a HFSP grant (RGP0029/2010) and a European Research Council (ERC) Advanced Investigator grant to A.M.A.. C.S was supported by an EMBO long term fellowship and a Marie Curie IEF. L.T.Y.C. and K.K.N. were supported by the Medical Research Council (MRC, UK, MC_UP_1202/9) and the March of Dimes Foundation (FY11-436). We also thank Professor Steve Oliver and Dr. A.K.Hadjantonakis for helpful discussions and advice.This is the author accepted manuscript. The final version is available from Wiley via http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/stem.206

A draft map of the mouse pluripotent stem cell spatial proteome.

Knowledge of the subcellular distribution of proteins is vital for understanding cellular mechanisms. Capturing the subcellular proteome in a single experiment has proven challenging, with studies focusing on specific compartments or assigning proteins to subcellular niches with low resolution and/or accuracy. Here we introduce hyperLOPIT, a method that couples extensive fractionation, quantitative high-resolution accurate mass spectrometry with multivariate data analysis. We apply hyperLOPIT to a pluripotent stem cell population whose subcellular proteome has not been extensively studied. We provide localization data on over 5,000 proteins with unprecedented spatial resolution to reveal the organization of organelles, sub-organellar compartments, protein complexes, functional networks and steady-state dynamics of proteins and unexpected subcellular locations. The method paves the way for characterizing the impact of post-transcriptional and post-translational modification on protein location and studies involving proteome-level locational changes on cellular perturbation. An interactive open-source resource is presented that enables exploration of these data.The authors thank Andreas Hühmer, Philip Remes, Jesse Canterbury and Graeme McAlister of Thermo Fisher Scientific, San Jose, CA, USA, for their advice regarding operation of the Orbitrap Fusion. We also thank Mike Deery for assistance with checking sample integrity on the mass spectrometers in the Cambridge Centre for Proteomics on equipment purchased via a Wellcome Trust grant (099135/Z/12/Z ), and Brian Hendrich of the Wellcome Trust-MRC Stem Cell Institute in Cambridge and Sean Munro of the MRC Laboratory of Molecular Biology in Cambridge for insightful comments about the data. AC was supported by BBSRC grant (BB/D526088/1). C.M.M. and L.G. were supported by European Union 7th Framework Program (PRIMEXS project, grant agreement number 262067), L.M.B was supported by a BBSRC Tools and Resources Development Fund (Award BB/K00137X/1), and P.C.H. was supported by an ERC Advanced Investigator grant to A.M.A. A.G. was funded through the Alexander S. Onassis Public Benefit Foundation, the Foundation for Education and European Culture (IPEP) and the Embiricos Trust Scholarship of Jesus College Cambridge. T.H. was supported by Commonwealth Split Site PhD Scholarship. T.N. was supported by an ERASMUS Placement scholarshipThis is the final version of the article. It was first available from NPG via http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/ncomms999

A foundation for reliable spatial proteomics data analysis.

Quantitative mass-spectrometry-based spatial proteomics involves elaborate, expensive, and time-consuming experimental procedures, and considerable effort is invested in the generation of such data. Multiple research groups have described a variety of approaches for establishing high-quality proteome-wide datasets. However, data analysis is as critical as data production for reliable and insightful biological interpretation, and no consistent and robust solutions have been offered to the community so far. Here, we introduce the requirements for rigorous spatial proteomics data analysis, as well as the statistical machine learning methodologies needed to address them, including supervised and semi-supervised machine learning, clustering, and novelty detection. We present freely available software solutions that implement innovative state-of-the-art analysis pipelines and illustrate the use of these tools through several case studies involving multiple organisms, experimental designs, mass spectrometry platforms, and quantitation techniques. We also propose sound analysis strategies for identifying dynamic changes in subcellular localization by comparing and contrasting data describing different biological conditions. We conclude by discussing future needs and developments in spatial proteomics data analysis..G., C.M.M., and M.F. were supported by the European Union 7th Framework Program (PRIME-XS Project, Grant No. 262067). L.M.B. was supported by a BBSRC Tools and Resources Development Fund (Award No. BB/K00137X/1). T.B. was supported by the Proteomics French Infrastructure (ProFI, ANR-10-INBS-08). A.C. was supported by BBSRC Grant No. BB/D526088/1. A.J.G. was supported by BBSRC Grant No. BB/E024777/ and a generous gift from King Abdullah University for Science and Technology, Saudi Arabia. D.J.N.H. was supported by a BBSRC CASE studentship (BB/I016147/1)

Dynamic Proteomic Profiling of Extra-Embryonic Endoderm Differentiation in Mouse Embryonic Stem Cells.

During mammalian preimplantation development, the cells of the blastocyst's inner cell mass differentiate into the epiblast and primitive endoderm lineages, which give rise to the fetus and extra-embryonic tissues, respectively. Extra-embryonic endoderm (XEN) differentiation can be modeled in vitro by induced expression of GATA transcription factors in mouse embryonic stem cells. Here, we use this GATA-inducible system to quantitatively monitor the dynamics of global proteomic changes during the early stages of this differentiation event and also investigate the fully differentiated phenotype, as represented by embryo-derived XEN cells. Using mass spectrometry-based quantitative proteomic profiling with multivariate data analysis tools, we reproducibly quantified 2,336 proteins across three biological replicates and have identified clusters of proteins characterized by distinct, dynamic temporal abundance profiles. We first used this approach to highlight novel marker candidates of the pluripotent state and XEN differentiation. Through functional annotation enrichment analysis, we have shown that the downregulation of chromatin-modifying enzymes, the reorganization of membrane trafficking machinery, and the breakdown of cell-cell adhesion are successive steps of the extra-embryonic differentiation process. Thus, applying a range of sophisticated clustering approaches to a time-resolved proteomic dataset has allowed the elucidation of complex biological processes which characterize stem cell differentiation and could establish a general paradigm for the investigation of these processes.This work was supported by the European Union 7th Framework Program (PRIME-XS project grant number 262067 to K.S.L., L.G and C.M.M), the Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC grant number BB/L002817/1 to K.S.L and L.G.), as well as a HFSP grant (RGP0029/2010) and a European Research Council (ERC) Advanced Investigator grant to A.M.A.. C.S was supported by an EMBO long term fellowship and a Marie Curie IEF. L.T.Y.C. and K.K.N. were supported by the Medical Research Council (MRC, UK, MC_UP_1202/9) and the March of Dimes Foundation (FY11-436). We also thank Professor Steve Oliver and Dr. A.K.Hadjantonakis for helpful discussions and advice.This is the author accepted manuscript. The final version is available from Wiley via http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/stem.206

Spatiotemporal proteomic profiling of the pro-inflammatory response to lipopolysaccharide in the THP-1 human leukaemia cell line.

Protein localisation and translocation between intracellular compartments underlie almost all physiological processes. The hyperLOPIT proteomics platform combines mass spectrometry with state-of-the-art machine learning to map the subcellular location of thousands of proteins simultaneously. We combine global proteome analysis with hyperLOPIT in a fully Bayesian framework to elucidate spatiotemporal proteomic changes during a lipopolysaccharide (LPS)-induced inflammatory response. We report a highly dynamic proteome in terms of both protein abundance and subcellular localisation, with alterations in the interferon response, endo-lysosomal system, plasma membrane reorganisation and cell migration. Proteins not previously associated with an LPS response were found to relocalise upon stimulation, the functional consequences of which are still unclear. By quantifying proteome-wide uncertainty through Bayesian modelling, a necessary role for protein relocalisation and the importance of taking a holistic overview of the LPS-driven immune response has been revealed. The data are showcased as an interactive application freely available for the scientific community

Learning from Heterogeneous Data Sources: An Application in Spatial Proteomics.

Sub-cellular localisation of proteins is an essential post-translational regulatory mechanism that can be assayed using high-throughput mass spectrometry (MS). These MS-based spatial proteomics experiments enable us to pinpoint the sub-cellular distribution of thousands of proteins in a specific system under controlled conditions. Recent advances in high-throughput MS methods have yielded a plethora of experimental spatial proteomics data for the cell biology community. Yet, there are many third-party data sources, such as immunofluorescence microscopy or protein annotations and sequences, which represent a rich and vast source of complementary information. We present a unique transfer learning classification framework that utilises a nearest-neighbour or support vector machine system, to integrate heterogeneous data sources to considerably improve on the quantity and quality of sub-cellular protein assignment. We demonstrate the utility of our algorithms through evaluation of five experimental datasets, from four different species in conjunction with four different auxiliary data sources to classify proteins to tens of sub-cellular compartments with high generalisation accuracy. We further apply the method to an experiment on pluripotent mouse embryonic stem cells to classify a set of previously unknown proteins, and validate our findings against a recent high resolution map of the mouse stem cell proteome. The methodology is distributed as part of the open-source Bioconductor pRoloc suite for spatial proteomics data analysis.LMB was supported by a BBSRC Tools and Resources Development Fund (Award BB/K00137X/1) and a Wellcome Trust Technology Development Grant (108441/Z/15/Z). LG was supported by the European Union 7th Framework Program (PRIME-XS project, grant agreement number 262067) and a BBSRC Strategic Longer and Larger Award (Award BB/L002817/1). DW and OK acknowledge funding from the European Union (PRIME-XS, GA 262067) and Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (KO-2313/6-1).This is the final version of the article. It first appeared from PLOS via https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pcbi.100492