20 research outputs found

    The invisibility of privilege: a critique of intersectional models of identity

    Get PDF
    In this paper, I argue that intersectionality, the prevailing way of conceptualizing the relation between axes or systems of oppression (race, class, gender), illicitly imports the very model it purports to overcome: that is, the unitary model of identity. I first define “intersectionality” and distinguish between three senses that are frequently conflated. Then I subject the model to an analytic critique, revealing its hidden presuppositions about identity. Finally, I suggest that solidarity serves as a better norm for feminist practice than inclusion of “difference,” which seems to be the norm underlying many intersectional accounts.Dans cet article, je soutiens que « l’intersectionalitĂ© », la conception la plus frĂ©quemment acceptĂ©e du rapport entre les axes ou entre les systĂšmes d’oppression (la race, la classe sociale et le genre), s’appuie clandestinement sur le modĂšle qu’elle prĂ©tend surmonter : c’est-Ă -dire, le modĂšle unitaire de l’identitĂ©. En premier lieu, je prĂ©sente la dĂ©finition «d’intersectionalité», et je diffĂ©rencie trois interprĂ©tations de ce concept qui sont souvent confondues. Ensuite, je propose une lecture analytique du modĂšle qui a pour but de rĂ©vĂ©ler des prĂ©suppositions qui fondent les notions d’identitĂ©. En conclusion, si la norme d’intĂ©gration de la «diffĂ©rence» est le fondement de discours intersectionels, je suggĂšre que la solidaritĂ© serait prĂ©fĂ©rable Ă  celle-ci pour la pratique fĂ©ministe

    Intersectionality

    Get PDF
    Intersectionality intervenes in the field of intersectionality studies: the integrative examination of the effects of racial, gendered, and class power on people’s lives. While “intersectionality” circulates as a buzzword, Anna Carastathis joins other critical voices to urge a more careful reading. Challenging the narratives of arrival that surround it, Carastathis argues that intersectionality is a horizon, illuminating ways of thinking that have yet to be realized; consequently, calls to “go beyond” intersectionality are premature. A provisional interpretation of intersectionality can disorient habits of essentialism, categorial purity, and prototypicality and overcome dynamics of segregation and subordination in political movements.Through a close reading of critical race theorist KimberlĂ© Williams Crenshaw’s germinal texts, published more than twenty-five years ago, Carastathis urges analytic clarity, contextual rigor, and a politicized, historicized understanding of this widely traveling concept. Intersectionality’s roots in social justice movements and critical intellectual projects—specifically Black feminism—must be retraced and synthesized with a decolonial analysis so its radical potential to actualize coalitions can be enacted

    Intersectionality

    Get PDF
    Intersectionality intervenes in the field of intersectionality studies: the integrative examination of the effects of racial, gendered, and class power on people’s lives. While “intersectionality” circulates as a buzzword, Anna Carastathis joins other critical voices to urge a more careful reading. Challenging the narratives of arrival that surround it, Carastathis argues that intersectionality is a horizon, illuminating ways of thinking that have yet to be realized; consequently, calls to “go beyond” intersectionality are premature. A provisional interpretation of intersectionality can disorient habits of essentialism, categorial purity, and prototypicality and overcome dynamics of segregation and subordination in political movements.Through a close reading of critical race theorist KimberlĂ© Williams Crenshaw’s germinal texts, published more than twenty-five years ago, Carastathis urges analytic clarity, contextual rigor, and a politicized, historicized understanding of this widely traveling concept. Intersectionality’s roots in social justice movements and critical intellectual projects—specifically Black feminism—must be retraced and synthesized with a decolonial analysis so its radical potential to actualize coalitions can be enacted

    Crisis, What Crisis? Immigrants, Refugees, and Invisible Struggles

    Get PDF
    Different evocations of “crisis” create distinct categories that in turn evoke certain social reactions. After 2008 Greece became the epicentre of the “financial crisis”; since 2015 with the advent of the “refugee crisis,” it became the “hotspot of Europe.” What are the different vocabularies of crisis? Moreover, how have both representations of crisis-facilitated humanitarian crises to become phenomena for European and transnational institutional management? What are the hegemonically-constructed subjects of the different crises? The everyday reality in the crisis-ridden hotspot of Europe is invisible in these representations. It is precisely the daily, soft, lived, and unspoken realities of intersecting crises that hegemonic discourses of successive, overlapping, or “nesting crises” render invisible. By shifting the focus from who belongs to which state-devised category to an open-ended, polyvocal account of capitalist oppressions, we aim to question the state’s and supranational efforts to divide the “migrant mob” into discrete juridical categories of citizens (emigrants), refugees, and illegal immigrants, thereby undermining coalitional struggles between precaritised groups. DiffĂ©rentes Ă©vocations liĂ©es au terme « crise » crĂ©ent des catĂ©gories distinctes qui, Ă  leur tour, sont Ă©vocatrices de rĂ©actions sociales particuliĂšres. Depuis 2008, la GrĂšce est devenue l’épicentre de la  « crise financiĂšre »; depuis 2015, avec l’apparition de la « crise des rĂ©fugiĂ©s », ce pays est aussi devenu le « hotspot de l’Europe ». Quels sont les diffĂ©rents vocabulaires de crise? Plus encore, comment ces deux reprĂ©sentations de crise ont-elles favorisĂ© la perception des crises humanitaires en tant que phĂ©nomĂšne de la gestion institutionnelle transnationale? Quels sont les sujets des diffĂ©rentes crises qui ont Ă©tĂ© construits de maniĂšre hĂ©gĂ©mo-nique? La rĂ©alitĂ© quotidienne en temps de crise au « hotspot de l’Europe » est invisible dans ces reprĂ©sentations. Ce sont prĂ©cisĂ©ment les rĂ©alitĂ©s quotidiennes, intangibles, vĂ©cues et non dites des crises intersectionnelles que les discours hĂ©gĂ©moniques des crises successives, des crises superposĂ©es ou des « crises emboĂźtĂ©es » rendent invisibles. En dĂ©plaçant le centre d’intĂ©rĂȘt des catĂ©gories dĂ©finies par l’état, et des personnes qu’elles regroupent, Ă  une description plurivoque ouverte des oppressions capitalistes, nous avons pour objec-tif de questionner les efforts des Ă©tats et les efforts suprana-tionaux pour rĂ©partir la « foule des migrants » en catĂ©gories juridiques distinctes de citoyens (Ă©migrĂ©s), rĂ©fugiĂ©s, et immigrants illĂ©gaux, et dĂ©stabiliser ainsi les luttes de coalition entre les groupes prĂ©carisĂ©s

    So many bordered gazes: Black Mediterranean geographies of/against anti-Black representations in/by Fortress Europe

    Get PDF
    Commentary on Camilla Hawthorne's "Black Mediterranean Geographies.

    ‘BANISH THOSE OTHER BORDERS’: reframing concepts, coalescing (trans)feminisms

    Get PDF
    Invited book review of _Translocational belongings: intersectional dilemmas and social inequalities_, by Floya Anthias

    Identity Categories as Potential Coalitions

    Full text link

    Introduction

    Get PDF
    While the declared global “refugee crisis” has received considerable scholarly attention, little of it has focused on the intersecting dynamics of oppression, discrimination, violence, and subjugation. Introducing the special issue, this article defines feminist “intersectionality” as a research framework and a no-borders activist orientation in trans-national and anti-national solidarity with people displaced by war, capitalism, and reproductive heteronormativity, encountering militarized nation-state borders. Our introduction surveys work in migration studies that engages with intersectionality as an analytic and offers a synopsis of the articles in the special issue. As a whole, the special issue seeks to make an intersectional feminist intervention in research produced about (forced) migration.Alors que les universitaires se sont beaucoup intĂ©ressĂ©s Ă  la « crise des rĂ©fugiĂ©s » mondiale qui a Ă©tĂ© dĂ©clarĂ©e, ils n’ont que peu envisagĂ© les dynamiques croisĂ©es de l’oppression, la discrimination, la violence et la subjugation. Le texte introductif de ce numĂ©ro spĂ©cial dĂ© nit « l’intersectionnalitĂ© » fĂ©ministe transnationale comme cadre de recherche et comme un activisme orientĂ© sans frontiĂšres solidaire des personnes dĂ©placĂ©es par la guerre, le capitalisme et l’hĂ©tĂ©ronormativitĂ© de la reproduction, qui se heurtent Ă  des frontiĂšres nation- ales et Ă©tatiques militarisĂ©es. Cette introduction examine les Ă©tudes sur la migration qui retiennent l’intersectionnalitĂ© comme perspective d’analyse et offre un sommaire des articles de ce numĂ©ro spĂ©cial qui, envisagĂ© dans son ensemble, vise Ă  dĂ©gager une intervention fĂ©ministe intersectionnelle dans les travaux de recherche qui concernent la migration (forcĂ©e).&nbsp

    Press Release. EU Funded Project "Fostering Queer Feminist Intersectional Resistances against Transnational Anti-Gender Politics (RESIST)" Launches

    Get PDF
    Anti-gender politics pose a grave threat to modern democratic formations because they challenge people's everyday survival, bodily integrity, and self-determination. Anti-gender spans the political spectrum and manifests not only in illiberal and authoritarian regimes but also in democracies that are considered liberal and inclusive. Taking a transnational and intersectional approach, RESIST analyses anti-gender formations in their complexity and contradictions and explores the effects of anti-gender politics on the everyday lives of those vulnerable to it and on democracies on the whole. RESIST engages with heterogeneous manifestations of anti-gender across the EU, Europe, and beyond through eight national case studies (Belarus, France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Poland, Spain, Switzerland) and a transnational case study of people living in exile as a result of anti-gender persecution. RESIST pursues a mixed methods approach to analyse the production and circulation of gender-equality repressive strategies and discourses and their effects on lived experiences and resistances. RESIST innovates methodologically to engender democracy by fostering collaboration between academia and civil society organisations (CSOs), especially amongst people who come to be targets of anti-gender, including women and lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and intersex (LGBTI+) persons. If those social groups whose fundamental rights are most at risk of violation by anti-gender are empowered to resist, then entire democratic societies benefit. RESIST centres feminist agency and collaborative knowledge production in (a) the research contents and results, (b) the methodological design, and (c) the social impact by generating new responsive feminist theories and practical solutions. At a time of increasing political disillusionment, RESIST creates hopeful, imaginative futures, transformative theories, and more inclusive worlds

    Covid-19 discloses unequal geographies

    Get PDF
    The collective editorial discusses inequalities that scholars in Europe and the Americas world have paid attention to during 2020 when the Covid-19 pandemic has unevenly and unpredictably impacted on societies. The critical reflections reveal that the continuing ramifications of the pandemic can only be understood in place; like other large-scale phenomena, this exceptional global crisis concretizes very differently in distinct national, regional and local contexts. The pandemic intertwines with ongoing challenges in societies, for example those related to poverty, armed conflicts, migration, racism, natural hazards, corruption and precarious labor. Through collective contextual understanding, the editorial invites further attention to the unequal geographies made visible and intensified by the current pandemic
    corecore