Assessment of an automatic prosthetic elbow control strategy using residual limb motion for transhumeral amputated individuals with socket or osseointegrated prostheses

International audienceMost transhumeral amputated individuals deplore the lack of functionality of their prosthesis due to control-related limitations. Commercialized prosthetic elbows are controlled via myoelectric signals, yielding complex control schemes when users have to control an entire prosthetic limb. Limited control yields the development of compensatory strategies. An alternative control strategy associates residual limb motions to automatize the prosthetic elbow motion using a model of physiological shoulder/elbow synergies. Preliminary studies have shown that elbow motion could be predicted from residual limb kinematic measurements, but results with transhumeral amputated individuals were lacking. This study focuses on the experimental assessment of automatic prosthetic elbow control during a reaching task, compared to conventional myoelectric control, with six transhumeral amputated individuals, among whom, three had an osseointegrated device. Part of the recruited participants had an osseointegrated prosthetic device. The task was achieved within physiological precision errors with both control modes. Automatic elbow control reduced trunk compensations, and restored a physiologically-like shoulder/elbow movement synchronization. However, the kinematic assessment showed that amputation and prosthesis wear modifies the shoulder movements in comparison with physiological shoulder kinematics. Overall, participants described the automatic elbow control strategy as intuitive, and this work highlights the interest of automatized prosthetic elbow motion

Analysis of the Interlimb similarity of motor patterns for improving stroke assessment and neurorehabilitation

Stroke is the leading cause of adult disability, with upper limb hemiparesis being one of the most common consequences. Regaining voluntary arm movement is one of the major goals of rehabilitation. However, even with intensive rehabilitation, approximately 30% of patients remain permanently disabled and only 5 to 20% of them recover full independence. Hence, there is an increasing interest in incorporating the latest advances in neuroscience, medicine and engineering to improve the efficacy of conventional therapies. In the last years, a variety of promising targets have been identified to improve rehabilitation. However, there is no consensus on which measure should be applied as a gold standard to study functional recovery. This fact dramatically hinders the development of new interventions since it turns difficult to compare different clinical trials and draw consistent conclusions about therapeutic efficiency. In addition, available scales are subjective, qualitative and often lead to incongruent outcomes. Indeed, there is increasing suspicion that the lack of optimal assessment measures hampers the detection of benefits of new therapies. Moreover, existing scales totally ignore the neuromuscular state of the patient masking the ongoing recovery processes. In consequence, making appropriate clinical decisions in such environment is almost impossible. In light of all these facts, the need for new objective biomarkers to develop effective therapies is undeniable. To give response to these demands we have organized this thesis into two main branches. On the one hand, we have developed an innovative physiological scale that reveals the neuromuscular state of the patient and is able to discriminate between motor impairment levels. The innovation here resides in the concept of interlimb similarity (ILS). Based on the latest findings about the modular organization of the motor system and taking into account that stroke provokes unilateral motor damage, we propose comparing the control structure of the unaffected arm with the control structure of the paretic arm to quantify motor impairment. We have defined the control structure as the set of muscle synergies and activation coefficients needed to complete a task. The advantage of this approach is not only its capacity to provide neuromuscular information about the patient, but also that the ILS is personalized to each patient and can purposely guide rehabilitation based on the patient¿s own physiological patterns. This supposes a huge advance taking into account the heterogeneity of stroke pathogenesis. On other hand, we have characterized the therapeutic potential of Visual Feedback (VF) as a tool to purposely induce neuroplastic changes. We have chosen VF among the various interventions proven to improve motor performance, because VF is a cheap strategy that can be implemented in almost any rehabilitation center. We demonstrate that VF is able to modulate the human control structure. In healthy subjects, it seems that VF makes accessible the refined dominant motor programs for the nondominant hemisphere giving rise to an increased interlimb similarity of the control structure. Interestingly, in stroke patients VF is able to manipulate the ILS of upper-limb kinematics in favor of finer motor control but a single training session seems not to be enough to fix those changes in the neuromuscular system of a damaged brain. Overall, these findings offer a new promising framework to develop and assess an effective intervention to guide the restoration of the original neuromuscular patterns and avoid unwanted maladaptive neuroplasticity. In conclusion, this thesis seeks moving forward in the understanding of human motor recovery processes and their relationship with neuroplasticity. In this sense, it provides important advances in the design of a new biomarker of motor impairment and tests the power of VF to modulate the neuromuscular control of patients with stroke.L'ictus és la principal causa de discapacitat en adults, essent l'hemiparèsia del membre superior una de les conseqüències més comunes. Els programes de rehabilitació tenen com a objectiu fonamental restituir la mobilitat del braç afectat. No obstant això, es calcula que només entre el 5 i el 20% dels pacients aconsegueixen recuperar la seva independència mentre que el 30% queden incapacitats permanentment. En front d'aquest escenari es fa necessari incorporar els últims avenços de la neurociència, la medicina i l'enginyeria en aquesta àrea. En els darrers anys s'han identificat diversos aspectes clau per intentar millorar la rehabilitació. El problema, però, és que no hi ha consens per definir una mesura com a "gold estàndard" per avaluar la recuperació funcional, motiu pel qual, el desenvolupament de noves teràpies queda profundament afectat, ja que esdevé impossible poder comparar diferents assajos clínics i extreure conclusions consistents sobre la seva eficiència terapèutica. A més, les diverses mesures que s'utilitzen són subjectives, qualitatives i sovint donen resultats incongruents. De fet, se sospita que la manca de mesures d'avaluació òptimes dificulta la detecció dels beneficis de noves teràpies. A tot això se li ha d'afegir que les mesures actuals no consideren l'estat neuromuscular del pacient, emmascarant els processos reparadors subjacents. Així doncs, prendre les decisions clíniques adequades sota aquestes condicions esdevé pràcticament impossible. En aquestes circumstàncies, no es pot ignorar el requeriment de nous biomarcadors que proporcionin dades objectives per catalitzar el disseny de teràpies efectives. Per donar resposta a aquesta situació, la tesi s'ha estructurat en dues parts. Per una banda, s'ha desenvolupat una innovadora escala fisiològica que revela l'estat neuromuscular del pacient i és capaç de discriminar entre diferents nivells d'incapacitat motora. La innovació rau en el concepte de similitud entre membres (ILS, en anglès). Així, basant-nos en els darrers descobriments sobre l'organització modular del sistema motor, i en el fet que l'ictus provoca dany unilateral, proposem comparar l'estructura de control del braç no-afectat amb l'estructura de control del braç parètic per quantificar la incapacitat motora. L'estructura de control l'hem definida com el conjunt de sinergies musculars i coeficients d'activació que es necessiten per a dur a terme una tasca. L'avantatge d'aquesta proposta és doble, ja que proporciona informació sobre l'estat neuromuscular del pacient i en ser personalitzable, pot guiar la rehabilitació d'acord amb els patrons fisiològics propis de cada pacient. Això suposa un enorme avenç en aquesta àrea, donada la immensa heterogeneïtat de la patogènesi d'aquest trastorn. D'altra banda, s'ha caracteritzat el potencial terapèutic del feedback visual (VF) per induir canvis neuroplàstics. Aquesta és una eina molt interessant perquè a més de millorar el control motor, és assequible per gairebé qualsevol centre de rehabilitació. S'ha demostrat que el VF és capaç de modular l'estructura de control. Concretament, el VF sembla transferir els programes motors de l'hemisferi dominant al costat no dominant augmentant així el ILS dels subjectes sans. En pacients amb ictus, el VF és capaç d'augmentar el ILS cinemàtic afavorint patrons de control més fins. En conclusió, l'objectiu d'aquesta tesi és aprofundir en la comprensió dels processos de recuperació motora i la seva relació amb la neuroplasticitat. La tesi ofereix un nou i prometedor marc per desenvolupar i avaluar procediments efectius per guiar la restauració dels patrons neuromusculars originals i evitar que el cervell pateixi canvis neuroplàstics indesitjables. Així, la tesi proporciona avanços importants en el disseny d'un biomarcador per quantificar la incapacitat motora i avaluar el potencial del VF per modular el control neuromuscular de pacients amb ictus

Neuromuscular Control Strategy during Object Transport while Walking: Adaptive Integration of Upper and Lower Limb Movements

When carrying an object while walking, a significant challenge for the central nervous system (CNS) is to preserve the object’s stability against the inter-segmental interaction torques and ground reaction forces. Studies documented several strategies used by the CNS: modulation of grip force (GF), alterations in upper limb kinematics, and gait adaptations. However, the question of how the CNS organizes the multi-segmental joint and muscle coordination patterns to deal with gait-induced perturbations remains poorly understood. This dissertation aimed to explore the neuromuscular control strategy utilized by the CNS to transport an object during walking successfully. Study 1 examined the inter-limb coordination patterns of the upper limbs when carrying a cylinder-shaped object while walking on a treadmill. It was predicted that transporting an object in one hand would affect the movement pattern of the contralateral arm to maintain the overall angular momentum. The results showed that transporting an object caused a decreased anti-phase coordination, but it did not induce significant kinematic and muscle activation changes in the unconstrained arm. Study 2 examined muscle synergy patterns for upper limb damping behavior by using non-negative matrix factorization (NNMF) method. Four synergies were identified, showing a proximal-to-distal pattern of activation preceding heel contacts. Study 3 examined the effect of different precision demands (carrying a cup with or without a ball) and altered visual information (looking forward vs. looking at an object) on the upper limb damping behavior and muscle synergies. Increasing precision demand induced stronger damping behavior and increased the electromyography (EMG) activation of wrist/hand flexors and extensors. The NNMF results replicated Study 2 in that the stabilization of proximal joints occurred before the distal joints. The results indicated that the damping incorporates tonic and phasic muscle activation to ensure object stabilization. Overall, three experiments showed that the CNS adopts a similar synergy pattern regardless of task constraint or altered gaze direction while modulating the amount of muscle activation for object stabilization. Kinematic changes can differ depending on the different levels of constraint, as shown in the smaller movement amplitude of the shoulder joint in the transverse plane during the task with higher precision demand

The Investigation of Motor Primitives During Human Reaching Movements and the Quantification of Post-Stroke Motor Impairment

Movement is a complex task, requiring precise and coordinated muscle contractions. The forces and torques produced during multi-segmental movement of the upper limbs in humans, must be controlled, in order for movement to be achieved successfully. Although a critical aspect of everyday life, there remain questions regarding the specific controller used by the central nervous system to govern movement. Furthermore, how this system is affected by neurological injuries such as stroke also remains in question. It was the goal of this thesis to examine the neurological control of movement in healthy individuals and apply these findings to the further investigation of chronically motor impaired stroke patients. Additionally, this work aimed at providing clinicians with a more reliable, easy to use, and inexpensive approach to quantify post-stroke motor impairment

Analysis of the Interlimb similarity of motor patterns for improving stroke assessment and neurorehabilitation

Stroke is the leading cause of adult disability, with upper limb hemiparesis being one of the most common consequences. Regaining voluntary arm movement is one of the major goals of rehabilitation. However, even with intensive rehabilitation, approximately 30% of patients remain permanently disabled and only 5 to 20% of them recover full independence. Hence, there is an increasing interest in incorporating the latest advances in neuroscience, medicine and engineering to improve the efficacy of conventional therapies. In the last years, a variety of promising targets have been identified to improve rehabilitation. However, there is no consensus on which measure should be applied as a gold standard to study functional recovery. This fact dramatically hinders the development of new interventions since it turns difficult to compare different clinical trials and draw consistent conclusions about therapeutic efficiency. In addition, available scales are subjective, qualitative and often lead to incongruent outcomes. Indeed, there is increasing suspicion that the lack of optimal assessment measures hampers the detection of benefits of new therapies. Moreover, existing scales totally ignore the neuromuscular state of the patient masking the ongoing recovery processes. In consequence, making appropriate clinical decisions in such environment is almost impossible. In light of all these facts, the need for new objective biomarkers to develop effective therapies is undeniable. To give response to these demands we have organized this thesis into two main branches. On the one hand, we have developed an innovative physiological scale that reveals the neuromuscular state of the patient and is able to discriminate between motor impairment levels. The innovation here resides in the concept of interlimb similarity (ILS). Based on the latest findings about the modular organization of the motor system and taking into account that stroke provokes unilateral motor damage, we propose comparing the control structure of the unaffected arm with the control structure of the paretic arm to quantify motor impairment. We have defined the control structure as the set of muscle synergies and activation coefficients needed to complete a task. The advantage of this approach is not only its capacity to provide neuromuscular information about the patient, but also that the ILS is personalized to each patient and can purposely guide rehabilitation based on the patient¿s own physiological patterns. This supposes a huge advance taking into account the heterogeneity of stroke pathogenesis. On other hand, we have characterized the therapeutic potential of Visual Feedback (VF) as a tool to purposely induce neuroplastic changes. We have chosen VF among the various interventions proven to improve motor performance, because VF is a cheap strategy that can be implemented in almost any rehabilitation center. We demonstrate that VF is able to modulate the human control structure. In healthy subjects, it seems that VF makes accessible the refined dominant motor programs for the nondominant hemisphere giving rise to an increased interlimb similarity of the control structure. Interestingly, in stroke patients VF is able to manipulate the ILS of upper-limb kinematics in favor of finer motor control but a single training session seems not to be enough to fix those changes in the neuromuscular system of a damaged brain. Overall, these findings offer a new promising framework to develop and assess an effective intervention to guide the restoration of the original neuromuscular patterns and avoid unwanted maladaptive neuroplasticity. In conclusion, this thesis seeks moving forward in the understanding of human motor recovery processes and their relationship with neuroplasticity. In this sense, it provides important advances in the design of a new biomarker of motor impairment and tests the power of VF to modulate the neuromuscular control of patients with stroke.L'ictus és la principal causa de discapacitat en adults, essent l'hemiparèsia del membre superior una de les conseqüències més comunes. Els programes de rehabilitació tenen com a objectiu fonamental restituir la mobilitat del braç afectat. No obstant això, es calcula que només entre el 5 i el 20% dels pacients aconsegueixen recuperar la seva independència mentre que el 30% queden incapacitats permanentment. En front d'aquest escenari es fa necessari incorporar els últims avenços de la neurociència, la medicina i l'enginyeria en aquesta àrea. En els darrers anys s'han identificat diversos aspectes clau per intentar millorar la rehabilitació. El problema, però, és que no hi ha consens per definir una mesura com a "gold estàndard" per avaluar la recuperació funcional, motiu pel qual, el desenvolupament de noves teràpies queda profundament afectat, ja que esdevé impossible poder comparar diferents assajos clínics i extreure conclusions consistents sobre la seva eficiència terapèutica. A més, les diverses mesures que s'utilitzen són subjectives, qualitatives i sovint donen resultats incongruents. De fet, se sospita que la manca de mesures d'avaluació òptimes dificulta la detecció dels beneficis de noves teràpies. A tot això se li ha d'afegir que les mesures actuals no consideren l'estat neuromuscular del pacient, emmascarant els processos reparadors subjacents. Així doncs, prendre les decisions clíniques adequades sota aquestes condicions esdevé pràcticament impossible. En aquestes circumstàncies, no es pot ignorar el requeriment de nous biomarcadors que proporcionin dades objectives per catalitzar el disseny de teràpies efectives. Per donar resposta a aquesta situació, la tesi s'ha estructurat en dues parts. Per una banda, s'ha desenvolupat una innovadora escala fisiològica que revela l'estat neuromuscular del pacient i és capaç de discriminar entre diferents nivells d'incapacitat motora. La innovació rau en el concepte de similitud entre membres (ILS, en anglès). Així, basant-nos en els darrers descobriments sobre l'organització modular del sistema motor, i en el fet que l'ictus provoca dany unilateral, proposem comparar l'estructura de control del braç no-afectat amb l'estructura de control del braç parètic per quantificar la incapacitat motora. L'estructura de control l'hem definida com el conjunt de sinergies musculars i coeficients d'activació que es necessiten per a dur a terme una tasca. L'avantatge d'aquesta proposta és doble, ja que proporciona informació sobre l'estat neuromuscular del pacient i en ser personalitzable, pot guiar la rehabilitació d'acord amb els patrons fisiològics propis de cada pacient. Això suposa un enorme avenç en aquesta àrea, donada la immensa heterogeneïtat de la patogènesi d'aquest trastorn. D'altra banda, s'ha caracteritzat el potencial terapèutic del feedback visual (VF) per induir canvis neuroplàstics. Aquesta és una eina molt interessant perquè a més de millorar el control motor, és assequible per gairebé qualsevol centre de rehabilitació. S'ha demostrat que el VF és capaç de modular l'estructura de control. Concretament, el VF sembla transferir els programes motors de l'hemisferi dominant al costat no dominant augmentant així el ILS dels subjectes sans. En pacients amb ictus, el VF és capaç d'augmentar el ILS cinemàtic afavorint patrons de control més fins. En conclusió, l'objectiu d'aquesta tesi és aprofundir en la comprensió dels processos de recuperació motora i la seva relació amb la neuroplasticitat. La tesi ofereix un nou i prometedor marc per desenvolupar i avaluar procediments efectius per guiar la restauració dels patrons neuromusculars originals i evitar que el cervell pateixi canvis neuroplàstics indesitjables. Així, la tesi proporciona avanços importants en el disseny d'un biomarcador per quantificar la incapacitat motora i avaluar el potencial del VF per modular el control neuromuscular de pacients amb ictus.Postprint (published version

Human-like arm motion generation: a review

In the last decade, the objectives outlined by the needs of personal robotics have led to the rise of new biologically-inspired techniques for arm motion planning. This paper presents a literature review of the most recent research on the generation of human-like arm movements in humanoid and manipulation robotic systems. Search methods and inclusion criteria are described. The studies are analyzed taking into consideration the sources of publication, the experimental settings, the type of movements, the technical approach, and the human motor principles that have been used to inspire and assess human-likeness. Results show that there is a strong focus on the generation of single-arm reaching movements and biomimetic-based methods. However, there has been poor attention to manipulation, obstacle-avoidance mechanisms, and dual-arm motion generation. For these reasons, human-like arm motion generation may not fully respect human behavioral and neurological key features and may result restricted to specific tasks of human-robot interaction. Limitations and challenges are discussed to provide meaningful directions for future investigations.FCT Project UID/MAT/00013/2013FCT–Fundação para a Ciência e Tecnologia within the R&D Units Project Scope: UIDB/00319/2020

Physical demand but not dexterity is associated with motor flexibility during rapid reaching in healthy young adults

Healthy humans are able to place light and heavy objects in small and large target locations with remarkable accuracy. Here we examine how dexterity demand and physical demand affect flexibility in joint coordination and end-effector kinematics when healthy young adults perform an upper extremity reaching task. We manipulated dexterity demand by changing target size and physical demand by increasing external resistance to reaching. Uncontrolled manifold analysis was used to decompose variability in joint coordination patterns into variability stabilizing the end-effector and variability de-stabilizing the end-effector during reaching. Our results demonstrate a proportional increase in stabilizing and de-stabilizing variability without a change in the ratio of the two variability components as physical demands increase. We interpret this finding in the context of previous studies showing that sensorimotor noise increases with increasing physical demands. We propose that the larger de-stabilizing variability as a function of physical demand originated from larger sensorimotor noise in the neuromuscular system. The larger stabilizing variability with larger physical demands is a strategy employed by the neuromuscular system to counter the de-stabilizing variability so that performance stability is maintained. Our findings have practical implications for improving the effectiveness of movement therapy in a wide range of patient groups, maintaining upper extremity function in old adults, and for maximizing athletic performance

Neuromechanical Tuning for Arm Motor Control

Movement is a fundamental behavior that allows us to interact with the external world. Its importance to human health is most evident when it becomes impaired due to disease or injury. Physical and occupational rehabilitation remains the most common treatment for these types of disorders. Although therapeutic interventions may improve motor function, residual deficits are common for many pathologies, such as stroke. The development of novel therapeutics is dependent upon a better understanding of the underlying mechanisms that govern movement. Movement of the human body adheres to the principles of classic Newtonian mechanics. However, due to the inherent complexity of the body and the highly variable repertoire of environmental contexts in which it operates, the musculoskeletal system presents a challenging control problem and the onus is on the central nervous system to reliably solve this problem. The neural motor system is comprised of numerous efferent and afferent pathways with a hierarchical organization which create a complex arrangement of feedforward and feedback circuits. However, the strategy that the neural motor system employs to reliably control these complex mechanics is still unknown. This dissertation will investigate the neural control of mechanics employing a “bottom-up” approach. It is organized into three research chapters with an additional introductory chapter and a chapter addressing final conclusions. Chapter 1 provides a brief description of the anatomical and physiological principles of the human motor system and the challenges and strategies that may be employed to control it. Chapter 2 describes a computational study where we developed a musculoskeletal model of the upper limb to investigate the complex mechanical interactions due to muscle geometry. Muscle lengths and moment arms contribute to force and torque generation, but the inherent redundancy of these actuators create a high-dimensional control problem. By characterizing these relationships, we found mechanical coupling of muscle lengths which the nervous system could exploit. Chapter 3 describes a study of muscle spindle contribution to muscle coactivation using a computational model of primary afferent activity. We investigated whether these afferents could contribute to motoneuron recruitment during voluntary reaching tasks in humans and found that afferent activity was orthogonal to that of muscle activity. Chapter 4 describes a study of the role of the descending corticospinal tract in the compensation of limb dynamics during arm reaching movements. We found evidence that corticospinal excitability is modulated in proportion to muscle activity and that the coefficients of proportionality vary in the course of these movements. Finally, further questions and future directions for this work are discussed in the Chapter 5