Power Bounded Computing on Current & Emerging HPC Systems

Power has become a critical constraint for the evolution of large scale High Performance Computing (HPC) systems and commercial data centers. This constraint spans almost every level of computing technologies, from IC chips all the way up to data centers due to physical, technical, and economic reasons. To cope with this reality, it is necessary to understand how available or permissible power impacts the design and performance of emergent computer systems. For this reason, we propose power bounded computing and corresponding technologies to optimize performance on HPC systems with limited power budgets. We have multiple research objectives in this dissertation. They center on the understanding of the interaction between performance, power bounds, and a hierarchical power management strategy. First, we develop heuristics and application aware power allocation methods to improve application performance on a single node. Second, we develop algorithms to coordinate power across nodes and components based on application characteristic and power budget on a cluster. Third, we investigate performance interference induced by hardware and power contentions, and propose a contention aware job scheduling to maximize system throughput under given power budgets for node sharing system. Fourth, we extend to GPU-accelerated systems and workloads and develop an online dynamic performance & power approach to meet both performance requirement and power efficiency. Power bounded computing improves performance scalability and power efficiency and decreases operation costs of HPC systems and data centers. This dissertation opens up several new ways for research in power bounded computing to address the power challenges in HPC systems. The proposed power and resource management techniques provide new directions and guidelines to green exscale computing and other computing systems

An approach to resource-aware coscheduling for cmps.

ABSTRACT We develop real-time scheduling techniques for improving performance and energy for multiprogrammed workloads that scale nonuniformly with increasing thread counts. Multithreaded programs generally deliver higher throughput than single-threaded programs on chip multiprocessors, but performance gains from increasing threads decrease when there is contention for shared resources. We use analytic metrics to derive local search heuristics for creating efficient multiprogrammed, multithreaded workload schedules. Programs are allocated fewer cores than requested, and scheduled to space-share the CMP to improve global throughput. Our holistic approach attempts to co-schedule programs that complement each other with respect to shared resource consumption. We find application co-scheduling for performance and energy in a resource-aware manner achieves better results than solely targeting total throughput or concurrently co-scheduling all programs. Our schedulers improve overall energy delay (E*D) by a factor of 1.5 over time-multiplexed gang scheduling

Intelligent Management of Inter-Thread Synchronization Dependencies for Concurrent Programs.

Power dissipation limits and design complexity have made the microprocessor industry less successful in improving the performance of monolithic processors, even though semiconductor technology continues to scale. Consequently, chip multiprocessors (CMPs) have become a standard for all ranges of computing from cellular phones to high-performance servers. As sufficient thread level parallelism (TLP) is necessary to exploit the computational power provided by CMPs, most performance-aware programmers need to parallelize their programs. For shared memory multi-threaded programs, synchronization mechanisms such as mutexes, barriers, and condition variables, are used to enforce the threads to interact with each other in the way the programmers intended. However, employing synchronization operations in both correct and efficient way at the same time is extremely difficult, and there have been trade-offs between programmability and efficiency of using synchronizations. This thesis proposes a collection of works that increase the programmability and efficiency of concurrent programs by intelligently managing the synchronization operations. First, we focus on mutex locks and unlocks. Many concurrency bug detection tools and automated bug fixers rely on the precise identification of critical sections guarded by lock/unlock operations. We suggest a practical lock/unlock pairing mechanism that combines static analysis with dynamic instrumentation to identify critical sections in POSIX multi-threaded C/C++ programs. Second, we present Dynamic Core Boosting (DCB) to accelerate critical paths in multi-thread programs. Inter-thread dependencies through synchronizations form critical paths. These critical paths are major performance bottlenecks for concurrent programs, and they are exacerbated by workload imbalances in performance asymmetric CMPs. DCB coordinates its compiler, runtime subsystem, and architecture to mitigates such performance bottlenecks. Finally, we propose exploiting synchronization operations for better energy efficiency through dynamic power management.PhDComputer Science & EngineeringUniversity of Michigan, Horace H. Rackham School of Graduate Studieshttp://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/108886/1/netforce_1.pd

Automatic Performance Optimization on Heterogeneous Computer Systems using Manycore Coprocessors

Emerging computer architectures and advanced computing technologies, such as Intel’s Many Integrated Core (MIC) Architecture and graphics processing units (GPU), provide a promising solution to employ parallelism for achieving high performance, scalability and low power consumption. As a result, accelerators have become a crucial part in developing supercomputers. Accelerators usually equip with different types of cores and memory. It will compel application developers to reach challenging performance goals. The added complexity has led to the development of task-based runtime systems, which allow complex computations to be expressed as task graphs, and rely on scheduling algorithms to perform load balancing between all resources of the platforms. Developing good scheduling algorithms, even on a single node, and analyzing them can thus have a very high impact on the performance of current HPC systems. Load balancing strategies, at different levels, will be critical to obtain an effective usage of the heterogeneous hardware and to reduce the impact of communication on energy and performance. Implementing efficient load balancing algorithms, able to manage heterogeneous hardware, can be a challenging task, especially when a parallel programming model for distributed memory architecture. In this paper, we presents several novel runtime approaches to determine the optimal data and task partition on heterogeneous platforms, targeting the Intel Xeon Phi accelerated heterogeneous systems

Transparent management of scratchpad memories in shared memory programming models

Cache-coherent shared memory has traditionally been the favorite memory organization for chip multiprocessors thanks to its high programmability. In this organization the cache hierarchy is in charge of moving the data and keeping it coherent between all the caches, enabling the usage of shared memory programming models where the programmer does not need to carry out any data management operation. Unfortunately, performing all the data management operations in hardware causes severe problems, being the primary concerns the power consumption originated in the caches and the amount of coherence traffic in the interconnection network. A good solution is to introduce ScratchPad Memories (SPMs) alongside the cache hierarchy, forming a hybrid memory hierarchy. SPMs are more power-efficient than caches and do not generate coherence traffic, but they degrade programmability. In particular, SPMs require the programmer to partition the data, to program data transfers, and to keep coherence between different copies of the data. A promising solution to exploit the benefits of the SPMs without harming programmability is to allow programmers to use shared memory programming models and to automatically generate code that manages the SPMs. Unfortunately, current compilers and runtime systems encounter serious limitations to automatically generate code for hybrid memory hierarchies from shared memory programming models. This thesis proposes to transparently manage the SPMs of hybrid memory hierarchies in shared memory programming models. In order to achieve this goal this thesis proposes a combination of hardware and compiler techniques to manage the SPMs in fork-join programming models and a set of runtime system techniques to manage the SPMs in task programming models. The proposed techniques allow to program hybrid memory hierarchies with these two well-known and easy-to-use forms of shared memory programming models, capitalizing on the benefits of hybrid memory hierarchies in power consumption and network traffic without harming programmability. The first contribution of this thesis is a hardware/software co-designed coherence protocol to transparently manage the SPMs of hybrid memory hierarchies in fork-join programming models. The solution allows the compiler to always generate code to manage the SPMs with tiling software caches, even in the presence of unknown memory aliasing hazards between memory references to the SPMs and to the cache hierarchy. On the software side, the compiler generates a special form of memory instruction for memory references with possible aliasing hazards. On the hardware side, the special memory instructions are diverted to the correct copy of the data using a set of directories that track what data is mapped to the SPMs. The second contribution of this thesis is a set of runtime system techniques to manage the SPMs of hybrid memory hierarchies in task programming models. The proposed runtime system techniques exploit the characteristics of these programming models to map the data specified in the task dependences to the SPMs. Different policies are proposed to mitigate the communication costs of the data transfers, overlapping them with other execution phases such as the task scheduling phase or the execution of the previous task. The runtime system can also reduce the number of data transfers by using a task scheduler that exploits data locality in the SPMs. In addition, the proposed techniques are combined with mechanisms that reduce the impact of fine-grained tasks, such as hardware runtime systems or large SPM sizes. The accomplishment of this thesis is that hybrid memory hierarchies can be programmed with fork-join and task programming models. Consequently, architectures with hybrid memory hierarchies can be exposed to the programmer as a shared memory multiprocessor, taking advantage of the benefits of the SPMs while maintaining the programming simplicity of shared memory programming models.La memoria compartida con coherencia de caches es la jerarquía de memoria más utilizada en multiprocesadores gracias a su programabilidad. En esta solución la jerarquía de caches se encarga de mover los datos y mantener la coherencia entre las caches, habilitando el uso de modelos de programación de memoria compartida donde el programador no tiene que realizar ninguna operación para gestionar las memorias. Desafortunadamente, realizar estas operaciones en la arquitectura causa problemas severos, siendo especialmente relevantes el consumo de energía de las caches y la cantidad de tráfico de coherencia en la red de interconexión. Una buena solución es añadir Memorias ScratchPad (SPMs) acompañando la jerarquía de caches, formando una jerarquía de memoria híbrida. Las SPMs son más eficientes en energía y tráfico de coherencia, pero dificultan la programabilidad ya que requieren que el programador particione los datos, programe transferencias de datos y mantenga la coherencia entre diferentes copias de datos. Una solución prometedora para beneficiarse de las ventajas de las SPMs sin dificultar la programabilidad es permitir que el programador use modelos de programación de memoria compartida y generar código para gestionar las SPMs automáticamente. El problema es que los compiladores y los entornos de ejecución actuales sufren graves limitaciones al gestionar automáticamente una jerarquía de memoria híbrida en modelos de programación de memoria compartida. Esta tesis propone gestionar automáticamente una jerarquía de memoria híbrida en modelos de programación de memoria compartida. Para conseguir este objetivo esta tesis propone una combinación de técnicas hardware y de compilador para gestionar las SPMs en modelos de programación fork-join, y técnicas en entornos de ejecución para gestionar las SPMs en modelos de programación basados en tareas. Las técnicas propuestas hacen que las jerarquías de memoria híbridas puedan programarse con estos dos modelos de programación de memoria compartida, de tal forma que las ventajas en energía y tráfico de coherencia se puedan explotar sin dificultar la programabilidad. La primera contribución de esta tesis en un protocolo de coherencia hardware/software para gestionar SPMs en modelos de programación fork-join. La propuesta consigue que el compilador siempre pueda generar código para gestionar las SPMs, incluso cuando hay posibles alias de memoria entre referencias a memoria a las SPMs y a la jerarquía de caches. En la solución el compilador genera instrucciones especiales para las referencias a memoria con posibles alias, y el hardware sirve las instrucciones especiales con la copia válida de los datos usando directorios que guardan información sobre qué datos están mapeados en las SPMs. La segunda contribución de esta tesis son una serie de técnicas para gestionar SPMs en modelos de programación basados en tareas. Las técnicas aprovechan las características de estos modelos de programación para mapear las dependencias de las tareas en las SPMs y se complementan con políticas para minimizar los costes de las transferencias de datos, como solaparlas con fases del entorno de ejecución o la ejecución de tareas anteriores. El número de transferencias también se puede reducir utilizando un planificador que tenga en cuenta la localidad de datos y, además, las técnicas se pueden combinar con mecanismos para reducir los efectos negativos de tener tareas pequeñas, como entornos de ejecución en hardware o SPMs de más capacidad. Las propuestas de esta tesis consiguen que las jerarquías de memoria híbridas se puedan programar con modelos de programación fork-join y basados en tareas. En consecuencia, las arquitecturas con jerarquías de memoria híbridas se pueden exponer al programador como multiprocesadores de memoria compartida, beneficiándose de las ventajas de las SPMs en energía y tráfico de coherencia y manteniendo la simplicidad de uso de los modelos de programación de memoria compartida

A Hardware and Software Integrated Approach for Adaptive Thread Management in Multicore Multithreaded Microprocessors

The Multicore Multithreaded Microprocessor maximizes parallelism on a chip for the optimal system performance, such that its popularity is growing rapidly in high-performance computing. It increases the complexity in resource distribution on a chip by leading it to two directions: isolation and unification. On one hand, multiple cores are implemented to deliver the computation and memory accessing resources to more than one thread at the same time. Nevertheless, it limits the threads’ access to resources in different cores, even if extensively demanded. On the other hand, simultaneous multithreaded architectures unify the domestic execu- tion resources together for concurrently running threads. In such an environment, threads are greatly affected by the inter-thread interference. Moreover, the impacts of the complicated distribution are enlarged by variation in workload behaviors. As a result, the microprocessor requires an adaptive management scheme to schedule threads throughout different cores and coordinate them within cores. In this study, an adaptive thread management scheme was proposed, integrating both hardware and software approaches. The instruction fetch policy at the hardware level took the responsibility by prioritizing domestic threads, while the Operating System scheduler at the software level was used to pair threads dynami- vi cally to multiple cores. The tie between them was the proposed online linear model, which was dynamically constructed for every thread based on data misses by the regression algorithm. Consequently, the hardware part of the proposed scheme proactively granted higher priority to the threads with less predicted long-latency loads, expecting they would better utilize the shared execution resources. Mean- while, the software part was invoked by such a model upon significant changes in the execution phases and paired threads with different demands to the same core to minimize competition on the chip. The proposed scheme was compared to its peer designs and overall 43% speedup was achieved by the integrated approach over the combination of two baseline policies in hardware and software, respectively. The overhead was examined carefully regarding power, area, storage and latency, as well as the relationship between the overhead and the performance

Priority-grouping method for parallel multi-scheduling in Grid

With the advent in multicore computers, the scheduling of Grid jobs can be made more effective if scaled to fully utilize the underlying hardware, and parallelized to benefit from the exploitation of multicores. The fact that sequential algorithms do not scale with multicore systems nor benefit from parallelism remains a major obstacle to scheduling in the Grid. As multicore systems become ever more pervasive in our computing lives, over reliance on such systems for passive parallelism does not offer the best option in harnessing the benefits of their multiprocessors for Grid scheduling. An explicit means of exploiting parallelism for Grid scheduling is required. The Group-based Parallel Multi-scheduler, introduced in this paper, is aimed at effectively exploiting the benefits of multicore systems for Grid scheduling by splitting jobs and machines into paired groups and independently scheduling jobs in parallel from those groups. We implemented two job grouping methods, Execution Time Balanced (ETB) and Execution Time Sorted then Balanced (ETSB), and two machine grouping methods, Evenly Distributed (EvenDist) and Similar Together (SimTog). For each method, we varied the number of groups between 2, 4 and 8. We then executed the MinMin Grid scheduling algorithm independently within the groups. We demonstrated that by sharing jobs and machines into groups before scheduling, the computation time for the scheduling process drastically improved by magnitudes of 85% over the ordinary MinMin algorithm when implemented on a HPC system. We also found that our balanced group based approach achieved better results than our previous Priority based grouping approach

Group-based parallel multi-scheduler for grid computing

With the advent in multicore computers, the scheduling of Grid jobs can be made more effective if scaled to fully utilize the underlying hardware, and parallelized to benefit from the exploitation of multicores. The fact that sequential algorithms do not scale with multicore systems nor benefit from parallelism remains a major obstacle to scheduling in the Grid. As multicore systems become ever more pervasive in our computing lives, over reliance on such systems for passive parallelism does not offer the best option in harnessing the benefits of their multiprocessors for Grid scheduling. An explicit means of exploiting parallelism for Grid scheduling is required. The Group-based Parallel Multi-scheduler, introduced in this paper, is aimed at effectively exploiting the benefits of multicore systems for Grid scheduling by splitting jobs and machines into paired groups and independently scheduling jobs in parallel from those groups. We implemented two job grouping methods, Execution Time Balanced (ETB) and Execution Time Sorted then Balanced (ETSB), and two machine grouping methods, Evenly Distributed (EvenDist) and Similar Together (SimTog). For each method, we varied the number of groups between 2, 4 and 8. We then executed the MinMin Grid scheduling algorithm independently within the groups. We demonstrated that by sharing jobs and machines into groups before scheduling, the computation time for the scheduling process drastically improved by magnitudes of 85% over the ordinary MinMin algorithm when implemented on a HPC system. We also found that our balanced group based approach achieved better results than our previous Priority based grouping approach

PiCo: A Domain-Specific Language for Data Analytics Pipelines

In the world of Big Data analytics, there is a series of tools aiming at simplifying programming applications to be executed on clusters. Although each tool claims to provide better programming, data and execution models—for which only informal (and often confusing) semantics is generally provided—all share a common under- lying model, namely, the Dataflow model. Using this model as a starting point, it is possible to categorize and analyze almost all aspects about Big Data analytics tools from a high level perspective. This analysis can be considered as a first step toward a formal model to be exploited in the design of a (new) framework for Big Data analytics. By putting clear separations between all levels of abstraction (i.e., from the runtime to the user API), it is easier for a programmer or software designer to avoid mixing low level with high level aspects, as we are often used to see in state-of-the-art Big Data analytics frameworks. From the user-level perspective, we think that a clearer and simple semantics is preferable, together with a strong separation of concerns. For this reason, we use the Dataflow model as a starting point to build a programming environment with a simplified programming model implemented as a Domain-Specific Language, that is on top of a stack of layers that build a prototypical framework for Big Data analytics. The contribution of this thesis is twofold: first, we show that the proposed model is (at least) as general as existing batch and streaming frameworks (e.g., Spark, Flink, Storm, Google Dataflow), thus making it easier to understand high-level data-processing applications written in such frameworks. As result of this analysis, we provide a layered model that can represent tools and applications following the Dataflow paradigm and we show how the analyzed tools fit in each level. Second, we propose a programming environment based on such layered model in the form of a Domain-Specific Language (DSL) for processing data collections, called PiCo (Pipeline Composition). The main entity of this programming model is the Pipeline, basically a DAG-composition of processing elements. This model is intended to give the user an unique interface for both stream and batch processing, hiding completely data management and focusing only on operations, which are represented by Pipeline stages. Our DSL will be built on top of the FastFlow library, exploiting both shared and distributed parallelism, and implemented in C++11/14 with the aim of porting C++ into the Big Data world