On the Selection of Tuning Methodology of FOPID Controllers for the Control of Higher Order Processes

In this paper, a comparative study is done on the time and frequency domain tuning strategies for fractional order (FO) PID controllers to handle higher order processes. A new fractional order template for reduced parameter modeling of stable minimum/non-minimum phase higher order processes is introduced and its advantage in frequency domain tuning of FOPID controllers is also presented. The time domain optimal tuning of FOPID controllers have also been carried out to handle these higher order processes by performing optimization with various integral performance indices. The paper highlights on the practical control system implementation issues like flexibility of online autotuning, reduced control signal and actuator size, capability of measurement noise filtration, load disturbance suppression, robustness against parameter uncertainties etc. in light of the above tuning methodologies.Comment: 27 pages, 10 figure

Fractional-order controller design with partial pole-zero cancellation

Master´s thesis in Mechatronics (MAS500

Modeling Aspects of Magnetic Actuators and Magnetic Suspension Systems

This dissertation is a study of new modeling techniques developed for magnetic suspension systems. The techniques discussed are modifications of magnetic circuit theory and fundamental eddy current models. The techniques are compared against experimental test results and finite element data. The information gained from the experimental testing is used to provide insight into magnetic bearing design. A small-gap modeling technique called extended circuit theory is developed that incorporates information about the system gained from finite element data, or experimental data, to be included in the analytic model. The variations between the classical magnetic circuit model and the finite element model are used to develop performance coefficients, which are in turn incorporated into the extended circuit model. The coefficients modify the classical theory to account for magnetomotive force losses, flux leakage and flux fringing. The theory is developed from fundamental principles. The techniques used to determine, and predict, the coefficients are discussed. The use of this method in optimal bearing design is also discussed. The extended circuit model is verified against experimental test results of a family of magnetic actuators. The actuators consist of a “C-shaped” stator and a flat armature. The pole separation distance was varied along with the location of the biasing permanent magnets and the windings. The permanent magnets were placed either on the pole faces, in the center of the armature, or at both locations, and the windings were wound on poles of the stator or on the back of the stator, resulting in a total of 22 design permutations. The experimental performance of each design is analyzed and efficiency trends are discussed. The diffusive model for eddy currents is analyzed along with the lumped parameter model to explore the “half-order” behavior of eddy currents commonly observed in experimental testing. A fractional order eddy current model is developed and compared against finite element data and experimental test results. The models developed are based on a frequency dependent resistance. The implications of using fractional order modeling techniques, along with control considerations, are discussed

Applications of equivalent representations of fractional- and integer-order linear time-invariant systems

Nicht-ganzzahlige - fraktionale - Ableitungsoperatoren beschreiben Prozesse mit Gedächtniseffekten, deshalb werden sie zur Modellierung verschiedenster Phänomene, z.B. viskoelastischen Verhaltens, genutzt. In der Regelungstechnik wird das Konzept vor allem wegen des erhöhten Freiheitsgrades im Frequenzbereich verwendet. Deshalb wurden in den vergangenen Dekaden neben einer Verallgemeinerung des PID-Reglers auch fortgeschrittenere Regelungskonzepte auf nicht-ganzzahlige Operatoren erweitert. Das Gedächtnis der nicht-ganzzahligen Ableitung ist zwar essentiell für die Modellbildung, hat jedoch Nachteile, wenn z.B. Zustände geschätzt oder Regler implementiert werden müssen: Das Gedächtnis führt zu einer langsamen, algebraischen Konvergenz der Transienten und da eine numerische Approximation ist speicherintensiv. Im Zentrum der Arbeit steht die Frage, mit welchen Maßnahmen sich das Konvergenzverhalten dieser nicht ganzzahligen Systeme beeinflussen lässt. Es wird vorgeschlagen, die Ordnung der nicht ganzzahligen Ableitung zu ändern. Zunächst werden Beobachter für verschiedene Klassen linearer zeitinvarianter Systeme entworfen. Die Entwurfsmethodik basiert dabei auf einer assoziierten Systemdarstellung, welche einen Differenzialoperator mit höherer Ordnung verwendet. Basierend auf dieser Systembeschreibung können Beobachter entworfen werden, welche das Gedächtnis besser mit einbeziehen und so schneller konvergieren. Anschließend werden ganzzahlige lineare zeitinvariante Systeme mit Hilfe nicht-ganzzahliger Operatoren dargestellt. Dies ermöglicht eine erhöhte Konvergenz im Zeitintervall direkt nach dem Anfangszeitpunkt auf Grund einer unbeschränkten ersten Ableitung. Die periodische Löschung des so eingeführten Gedächtnisses wird erzielt, indem die nicht ganzzahlige Dynamik periodisch zurückgesetzt wird. Damit wird der algebraischen Konvergenz entgegen gewirkt und exponentielle Stabilität erzielt. Der Reset reduziert den Speicherbedarf und induziert eine unterlagerte zeitdiskrete Dynamik. Diese bestimmt die Stabilität des hybriden nicht-ganzzahligen Systems und kann genutzt werden um den Frequenzgang für niedrige Frequenzen zu bestimmen. So lassen sich Beobachter und Regler für ganzzahlige System entwerfen. Im Rahmen des Reglerentwurfs können durch den Resets das Verhalten für niedrige und hohe Frequenzen in gewissen Grenzen getrennt voneinander entworfen werden.Non-integer, so-called fractional-order derivative operators allow to describe systems with infinite memory. Hence they are attractive to model various phenomena, e.g. viscoelastic deformation. In the field of control theory, both the higher degree of freedom in the frequency domain as well as the easy generalization of PID control have been the main motivation to extend various advanced control concepts to the fractional-order domain. The long term memory of these operators which helps to model real life phenomena, has, however, negative effects regarding the application as controllers or observers. Due to the infinite memory, the transients only decay algebraically and the implementation requires a lot of physical memory. The main focus of this thesis is the question of how to influence the convergence rates of these fractional-order systems by changing the type of convergence. The first part is concerned with the observer design for different classes of linear time-invariant fractional-order systems. We derive associated system representations with an increased order of differentiation. Based on these systems, the observers are designed to take the unknown memory into account and lead to higher convergence rates. The second part explores the representation of integer-order linear time-invariant systems in terms of fractional-order derivatives. The application of the fractional-order operator introduces an unbounded first-order derivative at the initial time. This accelerates the convergence for a short time interval. With periodic deletion of the memory - a reset of the fractional-order dynamics - the slow algebraic decay is avoided and exponential stability can be achieved despite the fractional-order terms. The periodic reset leads to a reduced implementation demand and also induces underlying discrete time dynamics which can be used to prove stability of the hybrid fractional-order system and to give an interpretation of the reset in the frequency domain for the low frequency signals. This concept of memory reset is applied to design an observer and improve fractional-order controllers for integer-order processes. For the controller design this gives us the possibility to design the high-frequency response independently from the behavior at lower frequencies within certain limits

LQR based improved discrete PID controller design via optimum selection of weighting matrices using fractional order integral performance index

This is the author accepted manuscript. The final version is available from Elsevier via the DOI in this record.The continuous and discrete time Linear Quadratic Regulator (LQR) theory has been used in this paper for the design of optimal analog and discrete PID controllers respectively. The PID controller gains are formulated as the optimal state-feedback gains, corresponding to the standard quadratic cost function involving the state variables and the controller effort. A real coded Genetic Algorithm (GA) has been used next to optimally find out the weighting matrices, associated with the respective optimal state-feedback regulator design while minimizing another time domain integral performance index, comprising of a weighted sum of Integral of Time multiplied Squared Error (ITSE) and the controller effort. The proposed methodology is extended for a new kind of fractional order (FO) integral performance indices. The impact of fractional order (as any arbitrary real order) cost function on the LQR tuned PID control loops is highlighted in the present work, along with the achievable cost of control. Guidelines for the choice of integral order of the performance index are given depending on the characteristics of the process, to be controlled.This work has been supported by the Dept. of Science & Technology (DST), Govt. of India under PURSE programme

Continuous Order Identification of PHWR Models Under Step-back for the Design of Hyper-damped Power Tracking Controller with Enhanced Reactor Safety

This is the author accepted manuscript. The final version is available from Elsevier via the DOI in this record.In this paper, discrete time higher integer order linear transfer function models have been identified first for a 500 MWe Pressurized Heavy Water Reactor (PHWR) which has highly nonlinear dynamical nature. Linear discrete time models of the nonlinear nuclear reactor have been identified around eight different operating points (power reduction or step-back conditions) with least square estimator (LSE) and its four variants. From the synthetic frequency domain data of these identified discrete time models, fractional order (FO) models with sampled continuous order distribution are identified for the nuclear reactor. This enables design of continuous order Proportional-Integral-Derivative (PID) like compensators in the complex w-plane for global power tracking at a wide range of operating conditions. Modeling of the PHWR is attempted with various levels of discrete commensurate-orders and the achievable accuracies are also elucidated along with the hidden issues, regarding modeling and controller design. Credible simulation studies are presented to show the effectiveness of the proposed reactor modeling and power level controller design. The controller pushes the reactor poles in higher Riemann sheets and thus makes the closed loop system hyper-damped which ensures safer reactor operation at varying dc-gain while making the power tracking temporal response slightly sluggish; but ensuring greater safety margin.This work has been supported by Department of Science and Technology (DST), Govt. of India, under the PURSE programme