ENTRA:Whole-systems energy transparency

Promoting energy efficiency to a first class system design goal is an important research challenge. Although more energy-efficient hardware can be designed, it is software that controls the hardware; for a given system the potential for energy savings is likely to be much greater at the higher levels of abstraction in the system stack. Thus the greatest savings are expected from energy-aware software development, which is the vision of the EU ENTRA project. This article presents the concept of energy transparency as a foundation for energy-aware software development. We show how energy modelling of hardware is combined with static analysis to allow the programmer to understand the energy consumption of a program without executing it, thus enabling exploration of the design space taking energy into consideration. The paper concludes by summarising the current and future challenges identified in the ENTRA project.Comment: Revised preprint submitted to MICPRO on 27 May 2016, 23 pages, 3 figure

Massively Parallel Computation Using Graphics Processors with Application to Optimal Experimentation in Dynamic Control

The rapid increase in the performance of graphics hardware, coupled with recent improvements in its programmability has lead to its adoption in many non-graphics applications, including wide variety of scientific computing fields. At the same time, a number of important dynamic optimal policy problems in economics are athirst of computing power to help overcome dual curses of complexity and dimensionality. We investigate if computational economics may benefit from new tools on a case study of imperfect information dynamic programming problem with learning and experimentation trade-off that is, a choice between controlling the policy target and learning system parameters. Specifically, we use a model of active learning and control of linear autoregression with unknown slope that appeared in a variety of macroeconomic policy and other contexts. The endogeneity of posterior beliefs makes the problem difficult in that the value function need not be convex and policy function need not be continuous. This complication makes the problem a suitable target for massively-parallel computation using graphics processors. Our findings are cautiously optimistic in that new tools let us easily achieve a factor of 15 performance gain relative to an implementation targeting single-core processors and thus establish a better reference point on the computational speed vs. coding complexity trade-off frontier. While further gains and wider applicability may lie behind steep learning barrier, we argue that the future of many computations belong to parallel algorithms anyway.Graphics Processing Units, CUDA programming, Dynamic programming, Learning, Experimentation

An efficient design space exploration framework to optimize power-efficient heterogeneous many-core multi-threading embedded processor architectures

By the middle of this decade, uniprocessor architecture performance had hit a roadblock due to a combination of factors, such as excessive power dissipation due to high operating frequencies, growing memory access latencies, diminishing returns on deeper instruction pipelines, and a saturation of available instruction level parallelism in applications. An attractive and viable alternative embraced by all the processor vendors was multi-core architectures where throughput is improved by using micro-architectural features such as multiple processor cores, interconnects and low latency shared caches integrated on a single chip. The individual cores are often simpler than uniprocessor counterparts, use hardware multi-threading to exploit thread-level parallelism and latency hiding and typically achieve better performance-power figures. The overwhelming success of the multi-core microprocessors in both high performance and embedded computing platforms motivated chip architects to dramatically scale the multi-core processors to many-cores which will include hundreds of cores on-chip to further improve throughput. With such complex large scale architectures however, several key design issues need to be addressed. First, a wide range of micro- architectural parameters such as L1 caches, load/store queues, shared cache structures and interconnection topologies and non-linear interactions between them define a vast non-linear multi-variate micro-architectural design space of many-core processors; the traditional method of using extensive in-loop simulation to explore the design space is simply not practical. Second, to accurately evaluate the performance (measured in terms of cycles per instruction (CPI)) of a candidate design, the contention at the shared cache must be accounted in addition to cycle-by-cycle behavior of the large number of cores which superlinearly increases the number of simulation cycles per iteration of the design exploration. Third, single thread performance does not scale linearly with number of hardware threads per core and number of cores due to memory wall effect. This means that at every step of the design process designers must ensure that single thread performance is not unacceptably slowed down while increasing overall throughput. While all these factors affect design decisions in both high performance and embedded many-core processors, the design of embedded processors required for complex embedded applications such as networking, smart power grids, battlefield decision-making, consumer electronics and biomedical devices to name a few, is fundamentally different from its high performance counterpart because of the need to consider (i) low power and (ii) real-time operations. This implies the design objective for embedded many-core processors cannot be to simply maximize performance, but improve it in such a way that overall power dissipation is minimized and all real-time constraints are met. This necessitates additional power estimation models right at the design stage to accurately measure the cost and reliability of all the candidate designs during the exploration phase. In this dissertation, a statistical machine learning (SML) based design exploration framework is presented which employs an execution-driven cycle- accurate simulator to accurately measure power and performance of embedded many-core processors. The embedded many-core processor domain is Network Processors (NePs) used to processed network IP packets. Future generation NePs required to operate at terabits per second network speeds captures all the aspects of a complex embedded application consisting of shared data structures, large volume of compute-intensive and data-intensive real-time bound tasks and a high level of task (packet) level parallelism. Statistical machine learning (SML) is used to efficiently model performance and power of candidate designs in terms of wide ranges of micro-architectural parameters. The method inherently minimizes number of in-loop simulations in the exploration framework and also efficiently captures the non-linear interactions between the micro-architectural design parameters. To ensure scalability, the design space is partitioned into (i) core-level micro-architectural parameters to optimize single core architectures subject to the real-time constraints and (ii) shared memory level micro- architectural parameters to explore the shared interconnection network and shared cache memory architectures and achieves overall optimality. The cost function of our exploration algorithm is the total power dissipation which is minimized, subject to the constraints of real-time throughput (as determined from the terabit optical network router line-speed) required in IP packet processing embedded application

Self-adaptivity of applications on network on chip multiprocessors: the case of fault-tolerant Kahn process networks

Technology scaling accompanied with higher operating frequencies and the ability to integrate more functionality in the same chip has been the driving force behind delivering higher performance computing systems at lower costs. Embedded computing systems, which have been riding the same wave of success, have evolved into complex architectures encompassing a high number of cores interconnected by an on-chip network (usually identified as Multiprocessor System-on-Chip). However these trends are hindered by issues that arise as technology scaling continues towards deep submicron scales. Firstly, growing complexity of these systems and the variability introduced by process technologies make it ever harder to perform a thorough optimization of the system at design time. Secondly, designers are faced with a reliability wall that emerges as age-related degradation reduces the lifetime of transistors, and as the probability of defects escaping post-manufacturing testing is increased. In this thesis, we take on these challenges within the context of streaming applications running in network-on-chip based parallel (not necessarily homogeneous) systems-on-chip that adopt the no-remote memory access model. In particular, this thesis tackles two main problems: (1) fault-aware online task remapping, (2) application-level self-adaptation for quality management. For the former, by viewing fault tolerance as a self-adaptation aspect, we adopt a cross-layer approach that aims at graceful performance degradation by addressing permanent faults in processing elements mostly at system-level, in particular by exploiting redundancy available in multi-core platforms. We propose an optimal solution based on an integer linear programming formulation (suitable for design time adoption) as well as heuristic-based solutions to be used at run-time. We assess the impact of our approach on the lifetime reliability. We propose two recovery schemes based on a checkpoint-and-rollback and a rollforward technique. For the latter, we propose two variants of a monitor-controller- adapter loop that adapts application-level parameters to meet performance goals. We demonstrate not only that fault tolerance and self-adaptivity can be achieved in embedded platforms, but also that it can be done without incurring large overheads. In addressing these problems, we present techniques which have been realized (depending on their characteristics) in the form of a design tool, a run-time library or a hardware core to be added to the basic architecture

Low-Impact Profiling of Streaming, Heterogeneous Applications

Computer engineers are continually faced with the task of translating improvements in fabrication process technology: i.e., Moore\u27s Law) into architectures that allow computer scientists to accelerate application performance. As feature-size continues to shrink, architects of commodity processors are designing increasingly more cores on a chip. While additional cores can operate independently with some tasks: e.g. the OS and user tasks), many applications see little to no improvement from adding more processor cores alone. For many applications, heterogeneous systems offer a path toward higher performance. Significant performance and power gains have been realized by combining specialized processors: e.g., Field-Programmable Gate Arrays, Graphics Processing Units) with general purpose multi-core processors. Heterogeneous applications need to be programmed differently than traditional software. One approach, stream processing, fits these systems particularly well because of the segmented memories and explicit expression of parallelism. Unfortunately, debugging and performance tools that support streaming, heterogeneous applications do not exist. This dissertation presents TimeTrial, a performance measurement system that enables performance optimization of streaming applications by profiling the application deployed on a heterogeneous system. TimeTrial performs low-impact measurements by dedicating computing resources to monitoring and by aggressively compressing performance traces into statistical summaries guided by user specification of the performance queries of interest

Massively Parallel Computation Using Graphics Processors with Application to Optimal Experimentation in Dynamic Control

The rapid increase in the performance of graphics hardware, coupled with recent improvements in its programmability has lead to its adoption in many non-graphics applications, including wide variety of scientific computing fields. At the same time, a number of important dynamic optimal policy problems in economics are athirst of computing power to help overcome dual curses of complexity and dimensionality. We investigate if computational economics may benefit from new tools on a case study of imperfect information dynamic programming problem with learning and experimentation trade-off that is, a choice between controlling the policy target and learning system parameters. Specifically, we use a model of active learning and control of linear autoregression with unknown slope that appeared in a variety of macroeconomic policy and other contexts. The endogeneity of posterior beliefs makes the problem difficult in that the value function need not be convex and policy function need not be continuous. This complication makes the problem a suitable target for massively-parallel computation using graphics processors. Our findings are cautiously optimistic in that new tools let us easily achieve a factor of 15 performance gain relative to an implementation targeting single-core processors and thus establish a better reference point on the computational speed vs. coding complexity trade-off frontier. While further gains and wider applicability may lie behind steep learning barrier, we argue that the future of many computations belong to parallel algorithms anyway

Architectural techniques to extend multi-core performance scaling

Multi-cores have successfully delivered performance improvements over the past decade; however, they now face problems on two fronts: power and off-chip memory bandwidth. Dennard\u27s scaling is effectively coming to an end which has lead to a gradual increase in chip power dissipation. In addition, sustaining off-chip memory bandwidth has become harder due to the limited space for pins on the die and greater current needed to drive the increasing load . My thesis focuses on techniques to address the power and off-chip memory bandwidth challenges in order to avoid the premature end of the multi-core era. ^ In the first part of my thesis, I focus on techniques to address the power problem. One option to cope with the power limit, as suggested by some recent papers, is to ensure that an increasing number of cores are kept powered down (i.e., dark silicon) due to lack of power; but this option imposes a low upper bound on performance. The alternative option of customizing the cores to improve power efficiency may incur increased effort for hardware design, verification and test, and degraded programmability. I propose a gentler evolutionary path for multi-cores, called successive frequency unscaling ( SFU), to cope with the slowing of Dennard\u27s scaling. SFU keeps powered significantly more cores (compared to the option of keeping them \u27dark\u27) running at clock frequencies on the extended Pareto frontier that are successively lowered every generation to stay within the power budget. ^ In the second part of my thesis, I focus on techniques to avert the limited off-chip memory bandwidth problem. Die-stacking of DRAM on a processor die promises to continue scaling the pin bandwidth to off-chip memory. While the die-stacked DRAM is expected to be used as a cache, storing any part of the tag in the DRAM itself erodes the bandwidth advantage of die-stacking. As such, the on-die space overhead of the large DRAM cache\u27s tag is a concern. A well-known compromise is to employ a small on-die tag cache (T$) for the tag metadata while the full tag stays in the DRAM. However, tag caching fundamentally requires exploiting page-level metadata locality to ensure efficient use of the 3-D DRAM bandwidth. Plain sub-blocking exploits this locality but incurs holes in the cache (i.e., diminished DRAM cache capacity), whereas decoupled organizations avoid holes but destroy this locality. I propose Bandwidth-Efficient Tag Access (BETA) DRAM cache (β$ ) which avoids holes while exploiting the locality through various metadata organizational techniques. Using simulations, I conclusively show that the primary concern in DRAM caches is bandwidth and not latency, and that due to β$\u27s tag bandwidth efficiency, β$ with a T$performs 15$

Scalable High-Quality Graph and Hypergraph Partitioning

The balanced hypergraph partitioning problem (HGP) asks for a partition of the node set of a hypergraph into $k$ blocks of roughly equal size, such that an objective function defined on the hyperedges is minimized. In this work, we optimize the connectivity metric, which is the most prominent objective function for HGP. The hypergraph partitioning problem is NP-hard and there exists no constant factor approximation. Thus, heuristic algorithms are used in practice with the multilevel scheme as the most successful approach to solve the problem: First, the input hypergraph is coarsened to obtain a hierarchy of successively smaller and structurally similar approximations. The smallest hypergraph is then initially partitioned into $k$ blocks, and subsequently, the contractions are reverted level-by-level, and, on each level, local search algorithms are used to improve the partition (refinement phase). In recent years, several new techniques were developed for sequential multilevel partitioning that substantially improved solution quality at the cost of an increased running time. These developments divide the landscape of existing partitioning algorithms into systems that either aim for speed or high solution quality with the former often being more than an order of magnitude faster than the latter. Due to the high running times of the best sequential algorithms, it is currently not feasible to partition the largest real-world hypergraphs with the highest possible quality. Thus, it becomes increasingly important to parallelize the techniques used in these algorithms. However, existing state-of-the-art parallel partitioners currently do not achieve the same solution quality as their sequential counterparts because they use comparatively weak components that are easier to parallelize. Moreover, there has been a recent trend toward simpler methods for partitioning large hypergraphs that even omit the multilevel scheme. In contrast to this development, we present two shared-memory multilevel hypergraph partitioners with parallel implementations of techniques used by the highest-quality sequential systems. Our first multilevel algorithm uses a parallel clustering-based coarsening scheme, which uses substantially fewer locking mechanisms than previous approaches. The contraction decisions are guided by the community structure of the input hypergraph obtained via a parallel community detection algorithm. For initial partitioning, we implement parallel multilevel recursive bipartitioning with a novel work-stealing approach and a portfolio of initial bipartitioning techniques to compute an initial solution. In the refinement phase, we use three different parallel improvement algorithms: label propagation refinement, a highly-localized direct $k$-way FM algorithm, and a novel parallelization of flow-based refinement. These algorithms build on our highly-engineered partition data structure, for which we propose several novel techniques to compute accurate gain values of node moves in the parallel setting. Our second multilevel algorithm parallelizes the $n$-level partitioning scheme used in the highest-quality sequential partitioner KaHyPar. Here, only a single node is contracted on each level, leading to a hierarchy with approximately $n$ levels where $n$ is the number of nodes. Correspondingly, in each refinement step, only a single node is uncontracted, allowing a highly-localized search for improvements. We show that this approach, which seems inherently sequential, can be parallelized efficiently without compromises in solution quality. To this end, we design a forest-based representation of contractions from which we derive a feasible parallel schedule of the contraction operations that we apply on a novel dynamic hypergraph data structure on-the-fly. In the uncoarsening phase, we decompose the contraction forest into batches, each containing a fixed number of nodes. We then uncontract each batch in parallel and use highly-localized versions of our refinement algorithms to improve the partition around the uncontracted nodes. We further show that existing sequential partitioning algorithms considerably struggle to find balanced partitions for weighted real-world hypergraphs. To this end, we present a technique that enables partitioners based on recursive bipartitioning to reliably compute balanced solutions. The idea is to preassign a small portion of the heaviest nodes to one of the two blocks of each bipartition and optimize the objective function on the remaining nodes. We integrated the approach into the sequential hypergraph partitioner KaHyPar and show that our new approach can compute balanced solutions for all tested instances without negatively affecting the solution quality and running time of KaHyPar. In our experimental evaluation, we compare our new shared-memory (hyper)graph partitioner Mt-KaHyPar to $25$ different graph and hypergraph partitioners on over $800$ (hyper)graphs with up to two billion edges/pins. The results indicate that already our fastest configuration outperforms almost all existing hypergraph partitioners with regards to both solution quality and running time. Our highest-quality configuration ($n$-level with flow-based refinement) achieves the same solution quality as the currently best sequential partitioner KaHyPar, while being almost an order of magnitude faster with ten threads. In addition, we optimize our data structures for graph partitioning, which improves the running times of both multilevel partitioners by almost a factor of two for graphs. As a result, Mt-KaHyPar also outperforms most of the existing graph partitioning algorithms. While the shared-memory graph partitioner KaMinPar is still faster than Mt-KaHyPar, its produced solutions are worse by $10\%$ in the median. The best sequential graph partitioner KaFFPa-StrongS computes slightly better partitions than Mt-KaHyPar (median improvement is $1\%$), but is more than an order of magnitude slower on average