Energy efficient wireless sensor network protocols for monitoring and prognostics of large scale systems

In this work, energy-efficient protocols for wireless sensor networks (WSN) with applications to prognostics are investigated. Both analytical methods and verification are shown for the proposed methods via either hardware experiments or simulation. This work is presented in five papers. Energy-efficiency methods for WSN include distributed algorithms for i) optimal routing, ii) adaptive scheduling, iii) adaptive transmission power and data-rate control --Abstract, page iv

A dependability framework for WSN-based aquatic monitoring systems

Wireless Sensor Networks (WSN) are being progressively used in several application areas, particularly to collect data and monitor physical processes. Moreover, sensor nodes used in environmental monitoring applications, such as the aquatic sensor networks, are often subject to harsh environmental conditions while monitoring complex phenomena. Non-functional requirements, like reliability, security or availability, are increasingly important and must be accounted for in the application development. For that purpose, there is a large body of knowledge on dependability techniques for distributed systems, which provides a good basis to understand how to satisfy these non-functional requirements of WSN-based monitoring applications. Given the data-centric nature of monitoring applications, it is of particular importance to ensure that data is reliable or, more generically, that it has the necessary quality. The problem of ensuring the desired quality of data for dependable monitoring using WSNs is studied herein. With a dependability-oriented perspective, it is reviewed the possible impairments to dependability and the prominent existing solutions to solve or mitigate these impairments. Despite the variety of components that may form a WSN-based monitoring system, it is given particular attention to understanding which faults can affect sensors, how they can affect the quality of the information, and how this quality can be improved and quantified. Open research issues for the specific case of aquatic monitoring applications are also discussed. One of the challenges in achieving a dependable system behavior is to overcome the external disturbances affecting sensor measurements and detect the failure patterns in sensor data. This is a particular problem in environmental monitoring, due to the difficulty in distinguishing a faulty behavior from the representation of a natural phenomenon. Existing solutions for failure detection assume that physical processes can be accurately modeled, or that there are large deviations that may be detected using coarse techniques, or more commonly that it is a high-density sensor network with value redundant sensors. This thesis aims at defining a new methodology for dependable data quality in environmental monitoring systems, aiming to detect faulty measurements and increase the sensors data quality. The framework of the methodology is overviewed through a generically applicable design, which can be employed to any environment sensor network dataset. The methodology is evaluated in various datasets of different WSNs, where it is used machine learning to model each sensor behavior, exploiting the existence of correlated data provided by neighbor sensors. It is intended to explore the data fusion strategies in order to effectively detect potential failures for each sensor and, simultaneously, distinguish truly abnormal measurements from deviations due to natural phenomena. This is accomplished with the successful application of the methodology to detect and correct outliers, offset and drifting failures in real monitoring networks datasets. In the future, the methodology can be applied to optimize the data quality control processes of new and already operating monitoring networks, and assist in the networks maintenance operations.As redes de sensores sem fios (RSSF) têm vindo cada vez mais a serem utilizadas em diversas áreas de aplicação, em especial para monitorizar e capturar informação de processos físicos em meios naturais. Neste contexto, os sensores que estão em contacto direto com o respectivo meio ambiente, como por exemplo os sensores em meios aquáticos, estão sujeitos a condições adversas e complexas durante o seu funcionamento. Esta complexidade conduz à necessidade de considerarmos, durante o desenvolvimento destas redes, os requisitos não funcionais da confiabilidade, da segurança ou da disponibilidade elevada. Para percebermos como satisfazer estes requisitos da monitorização com base em RSSF para aplicações ambientais, já existe uma boa base de conhecimento sobre técnicas de confiabilidade em sistemas distribuídos. Devido ao foco na obtenção de dados deste tipo de aplicações de RSSF, é particularmente importante garantir que os dados obtidos na monitorização sejam confiáveis ou, de uma forma mais geral, que tenham a qualidade necessária para o objetivo pretendido. Esta tese estuda o problema de garantir a qualidade de dados necessária para uma monitorização confiável usando RSSF. Com o foco na confiabilidade, revemos os possíveis impedimentos à obtenção de dados confiáveis e as soluções existentes capazes de corrigir ou mitigar esses impedimentos. Apesar de existir uma grande variedade de componentes que formam ou podem formar um sistema de monitorização com base em RSSF, prestamos particular atenção à compreensão das possíveis faltas que podem afetar os sensores, a como estas faltas afetam a qualidade dos dados recolhidos pelos sensores e a como podemos melhorar os dados e quantificar a sua qualidade. Tendo em conta o caso específico dos sistemas de monitorização em meios aquáticos, discutimos ainda as várias linhas de investigação em aberto neste tópico. Um dos desafios para se atingir um sistema de monitorização confiável é a deteção da influência de fatores externos relacionados com o ambiente monitorizado, que afetam as medições obtidas pelos sensores, bem como a deteção de comportamentos de falha nas medições. Este desafio é um problema particular na monitorização em ambientes naturais adversos devido à dificuldade da distinção entre os comportamentos associados às falhas nos sensores e os comportamentos dos sensores afetados pela à influência de um evento natural. As soluções existentes para este problema, relacionadas com deteção de faltas, assumem que os processos físicos a monitorizar podem ser modelados de forma eficaz, ou que os comportamentos de falha são caraterizados por desvios elevados do comportamento expectável de forma a serem facilmente detetáveis. Mais frequentemente, as soluções assumem que as redes de sensores contêm um número suficientemente elevado de sensores na área monitorizada e, consequentemente, que existem sensores redundantes relativamente à medição. Esta tese tem como objetivo a definição de uma nova metodologia para a obtenção de qualidade de dados confiável em sistemas de monitorização ambientais, com o intuito de detetar a presença de faltas nas medições e aumentar a qualidade dos dados dos sensores. Esta metodologia tem uma estrutura genérica de forma a ser aplicada a uma qualquer rede de sensores ambiental ou ao respectivo conjunto de dados obtido pelos sensores desta. A metodologia é avaliada através de vários conjuntos de dados de diferentes RSSF, em que aplicámos técnicas de aprendizagem automática para modelar o comportamento de cada sensor, com base na exploração das correlações existentes entre os dados obtidos pelos sensores da rede. O objetivo é a aplicação de estratégias de fusão de dados para a deteção de potenciais falhas em cada sensor e, simultaneamente, a distinção de medições verdadeiramente defeituosas de desvios derivados de eventos naturais. Este objectivo é cumprido através da aplicação bem sucedida da metodologia para detetar e corrigir outliers, offsets e drifts em conjuntos de dados reais obtidos por redes de sensores. No futuro, a metodologia pode ser aplicada para otimizar os processos de controlo da qualidade de dados quer de novos sistemas de monitorização, quer de redes de sensores já em funcionamento, bem como para auxiliar operações de manutenção das redes.Laboratório Nacional de Engenharia Civi

Deployment Policies to Reliably Maintain and Maximize Expected Coverage in a Wireless Sensor Network

The long-term operation of a wireless sensor network (WSN) requires the deployment of new sensors over time to restore any loss in network coverage and communication ability resulting from sensor failures. Over the course of several deployment actions it is important to consider the cost of maintaining the WSN in addition to any desired performance measures such as coverage, connectivity, or reliability. The resulting problem formulation is approached first through a time-based deployment model in which the network is restored to a fixed size at periodic time intervals. The network destruction spectrum (D-spectrum) has been introduced to estimate reliability and is more commonly applied to a static network, rather than a dynamic network where new sensors are deployed over time. We discuss how the D-spectrum can be incorporated to estimate reliability of a time-based deployment policy and the features that allow a wide range of deployment policies to be evaluated in an efficient manner. We next focus on a myopic condition-based deployment model where the network is observed at periodic time intervals and a fixed budget is available to deploy new sensors with each observation. With a limited budget available the model must address the complexity present in a dynamic network size in addition to a dynamic network topology, and the dependence of network reliability on the deployment action. We discuss how the D-spectrum can be applied to the myopic condition-based deployment problem, illustrating the value of the D-spectrum in a variety of maintenance settings beyond the traditional static network reliability problem. From the insight of the time-based and myopic condition-based deployment models, we present a Markov decision process (MDP) model for the condition-based deployment problem that captures the benefit of an action beyond the current time period. Methodology related to approximate dynamic programming (ADP) and approximate value iteration algorithms is presented to search for high quality deployment policies. In addition to the time-based and myopic condition-based deployment models, the MDP model is one of the few addressing the repeated deployment of new sensors as well as an emphasis on network reliability. For each model we discuss the relevant problem formulation, methodology to estimate network reliability, and demonstrate the performance in a range of test instances, comparing to alternative policies or models as appropriate. We conclude with a stochastic optimization model focused on a slightly different objective to maximize expected coverage with uncertainty in where a sensor lands in the network. We discuss a heuristic solution method that seeks to determine an optimal deployment of sensors, present results for a wide range of network sizes and explore the impact of sensor failures on both the model formulation and resulting deployment policy

The design and evaluation of Wireless Sensor Networks for applications in industrial locations

In manufacturing industries, there exist many applications where Wireless Sensor Networks (WSN\u27s) are integrated to provide wireless solution for the automated manufacturing processes. It is well known that industrial environments characterized by extreme conditions such as high temperature, pressure, and electromagnetic (EM) interference that can affect the performance of the WSN\u27s. The key solution to overcome this performance issue is by monitoring the received Signal Strength Index (RSSI) at the received sensor of the WSN device and track frame error rate of wireless packets. ZigBee is a wireless sensor network (WSN) standard designed for specific needs of the remote monitoring sensor system. Zigbee networks can be established by three different topologies: start, hybrid, and mesh. In this research project, the interest in analyzing the characteristics of the Zigbee performance was completed using a star topology network. Three performance parameters were obtained: the RSSI signal to monitor the received wireless packets from the sending node, path-lost exponent to determine the effect of industrial environment on wireless signals, and the frame error rate to know the discontinue time. The study was in three phases and took place in two settings: The first was at the manufacturing laboratory at the University of Northern Iowa, the second and the third were at the facility of a Midwestern manufacturing company. The study aimed to provide an analytical tool to evaluate the performances of Zigbee networks in industrial environments and compare the results to show that harsh environments do affect its performance. The study also involved testing the performance of WSN. This was done by simulating input/output Line passing with digital and analog data. Packets were sent from one node and counted at the receiving side to measure the packet error rate of WSN in industrial environment. In conclusion, investigating the WSN\u27s systems performance in industrial environment provides is crucial to identify the effects of the harsh conditions. It is necessary to run similar investigation to prevent the malfunction of the manufacturing applications. Testing a simple WSN in industrial environment can be capable of predicting the performance of the network. It is also recommended to have an embedded approach to WSN applications that can self-monitor its performance

Fault-tolerant wireless sensor networks using evolutionary games

This dissertation proposes an approach to creating robust communication systems in wireless sensor networks, inspired by biological and ecological systems, particularly by evolutionary game theory. In this approach, a virtual community of agents live inside the network nodes and carry out network functions. The agents use different strategies to execute their functions, and these strategies are tested and selected by playing evolutionary games. Over time, agents with the best strategies survive, while others die. The strategies and the game rules provide the network with an adaptive behavior that allows it to react to changes in environmental conditions by adapting and improving network behavior. To evaluate the viability of this approach, this dissertation also describes a micro-component framework for implementing agent-based wireless sensor network services, an evolutionary data collection protocol built using this framework, ECP, and experiments evaluating the performance of this protocol in a faulty environment. The framework addresses many of the programming challenges in writing network software for wireless sensor networks, while the protocol built using the framework provides a means of evaluating the general viability of the agent-based approach. The results of this evaluation show that an evolutionary approach to designing wireless sensor networks can improve the performance of wireless sensor network protocols in the presence of node failures. In particular, we compared the performance of ECP with a non-evolutionary rule-based variant of ECP. While the purely-evolutionary version of ECP has more routing timeouts than the rule-based approach in failure-free networks, it sends significantly fewer beacon packets and incurs statistically fewer routing timeouts in both simple fault and periodic fault scenarios

Modelling and performability evaluation of Wireless Sensor Networks

This thesis presents generic analytical models of homogeneous clustered Wireless Sensor Networks (WSNs) with a centrally located Cluster Head (CH) coordinating cluster communication with the sink directly or through other intermediate nodes. The focus is to integrate performance and availability studies of WSNs in the presence of sensor nodes and channel failures and repair/replacement. The main purpose is to enhance improvement of WSN Quality of Service (QoS). Other research works also considered in this thesis include modelling of packet arrival distribution at the CH and intermediate nodes, and modelling of energy consumption at the sensor nodes. An investigation and critical analysis of wireless sensor network architectures, energy conservation techniques and QoS requirements are performed in order to improve performance and availability of the network. Existing techniques used for performance evaluation of single and multi-server systems with several operative states are investigated and analysed in details. To begin with, existing approaches for independent (pure) performance modelling are critically analysed with highlights on merits and drawbacks. Similarly, pure availability modelling approaches are also analysed. Considering that pure performance models tend to be too optimistic and pure availability models are too conservative, performability, which is the integration of performance and availability studies is used for the evaluation of the WSN models developed in this study. Two-dimensional Markov state space representations of the systems are used for performability modelling. Following critical analysis of the existing solution techniques, spectral expansion method and system of simultaneous linear equations are developed and used to solving the proposed models. To validate the results obtained with the two techniques, a discrete event simulation tool is explored. In this research, open queuing networks are used to model the behaviour of the CH when subjected to streams of traffic from cluster nodes in addition to dynamics of operating in the various states. The research begins with a model of a CH with an infinite queue capacity subject to failures and repair/replacement. The model is developed progressively to consider bounded queue capacity systems, channel failures and sleep scheduling mechanisms for performability evaluation of WSNs. Using the developed models, various performance measures of the considered system including mean queue length, throughput, response time and blocking probability are evaluated. Finally, energy models considering mean power consumption in each of the possible operative states is developed. The resulting models are in turn employed for the evaluation of energy saving for the proposed case study model. Numerical solutions and discussions are presented for all the queuing models developed. Simulation is also performed in order to validate the accuracy of the results obtained. In order to address issues of performance and availability of WSNs, current research present independent performance and availability studies. The concerns resulting from such studies have therefore remained unresolved over the years hence persistence poor system performance. The novelty of this research is a proposed integrated performance and availability modelling approach for WSNs meant to address challenges of independent studies. In addition, a novel methodology for modelling and evaluation of power consumption is also offered. Proposed model results provide remarkable improvement on system performance and availability in addition to providing tools for further optimisation studies. A significant power saving is also observed from the proposed model results. In order to improve QoS for WSN, it is possible to improve the proposed models by incorporating priority queuing in a mixed traffic environment. A model of multi-server system is also appropriate for addressing traffic routing. It is also possible to extend the proposed energy model to consider other sleep scheduling mechanisms other than On-demand proposed herein. Analysis and classification of possible arrival distribution of WSN packets for various application environments would be a great idea for enabling robust scientific research

Practical Lessons from the Deployment and Management of a Smart City Internet-of-Things Infrastructure: The SmartSantander testbed case

The smart cities vision is inexorably turning into a reality. Among the different approaches used to realize more intelligent and sustainable environments, a common denominator is the role that information and communication technologies will play. Moreover, if there is one of these technologies that emerges among the rest, it is the Internet-of-Things (IoT). The ability to ubiquitously embed sensing and actuating capabilities that this paradigm enables is at the forefront of the technologies driving the urban environments transformation. However, there are very little practical experiences of the IoT infrastructure deployment at a large scale. This paper presents practical solutions to the main challenges faced during the deployment and management of a city-scale IoT infrastructure, which encompasses thousands of sensors and other information sources. The experience we have gained during the deployment and operation of the IoT-based smart city infrastructure carried out at Santander (Spain) has led to a number of practical lessons that are summarized in this paper. Moreover, the challenges and problems examples, excerpted from our own real-life experience, are described as motivators for the adopted solutions.This work was supported in part by the research project SmartSantander through the 7th Framework Programme of the European Commission under Grant FP7-ICT-2009-5 and in part by the Spanish Government by means of the project ADVICE "Dynamic provisioning of connectivity in high density 5G wireless scenarios" under Grant TEC2015-71329-C2-1-R

Surveying Position Based Routing Protocols for Wireless Sensor and Ad-hoc Networks

A focus of the scientific community is to design network oriented position-based routing protocols and this has resulted in a very high number of algorithms, different in approach and performance and each suited only to particular applications. However, though numerous, very few position-based algorithms have actually been adopted for commercial purposes. This article is a survey of almost 50 position-based routing protocols and it comes as an aid in the implementation of this type of routing in various applications which may need to consider the advantages and pitfalls of position-based routing. An emphasis is made on geographic routing, whose notion is clarified as a more restrictive and more efficient type of position-based routing. The protocols are therefore divided into geographic and non-geographic routing protocols and each is characterized according to a number of network design issues and presented in a comparative manner from multiple points of view. The main requirements of current general applications are also studied and, depending on these, the survey proposes a number of protocols for use in particular application areas. This aims to help both researchers and potential users assess and choose the protocol best suited to their interest