Fruit sizing using AI: A review of methods and challenges

Fruit size at harvest is an economically important variable for high-quality table fruit production in orchards and vineyards. In addition, knowing the number and size of the fruit on the tree is essential in the framework of precise production, harvest, and postharvest management. A prerequisite for analysis of fruit in a real-world environment is the detection and segmentation from background signal. In the last five years, deep learning convolutional neural network have become the standard method for automatic fruit detection, achieving F1-scores higher than 90 %, as well as real-time processing speeds. At the same time, different methods have been developed for, mainly, fruit size and, more rarely, fruit maturity estimation from 2D images and 3D point clouds. These sizing methods are focused on a few species like grape, apple, citrus, and mango, resulting in mean absolute error values of less than 4 mm in apple fruit. This review provides an overview of the most recent methodologies developed for in-field fruit detection/counting and sizing as well as few upcoming examples of maturity estimation. Challenges, such as sensor fusion, highly varying lighting conditions, occlusions in the canopy, shortage of public fruit datasets, and opportunities for research transfer, are discussed.This work was partly funded by the Department of Research and Universities of the Generalitat de Catalunya (grants 2017 SGR 646 and 2021 LLAV 00088) and by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation / AEI/10.13039/501100011033 / FEDER (grants RTI2018-094222-B-I00 [PAgFRUIT project] and PID2021-126648OB-I00 [PAgPROTECT project]). The Secretariat of Universities and Research of the Department of Business and Knowledge of the Generalitat de Catalunya and European Social Fund (ESF) are also thanked for financing Juan Carlos Miranda’s pre-doctoral fellowship (2020 FI_B 00586). The work of Jordi Gené-Mola was supported by the Spanish Ministry of Universities through a Margarita Salas postdoctoral grant funded by the European Union - NextGenerationEU.info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersio

A Review of the Challenges of Using Deep Learning Algorithms to Support Decision-Making in Agricultural Activities

Deep Learning has been successfully applied to image recognition, speech recognition, and natural language processing in recent years. Therefore, there has been an incentive to apply it in other fields as well. The field of agriculture is one of the most important fields in which the application of deep learning still needs to be explored, as it has a direct impact on human well-being. In particular, there is a need to explore how deep learning models can be used as a tool for optimal planting, land use, yield improvement, production/disease/pest control, and other activities. The vast amount of data received from sensors in smart farms makes it possible to use deep learning as a model for decision-making in this field. In agriculture, no two environments are exactly alike, which makes testing, validating, and successfully implementing such technologies much more complex than in most other industries. This paper reviews some recent scientific developments in the field of deep learning that have been applied to agriculture, and highlights some challenges and potential solutions using deep learning algorithms in agriculture. The results in this paper indicate that by employing new methods from deep learning, higher performance in terms of accuracy and lower inference time can be achieved, and the models can be made useful in real-world applications. Finally, some opportunities for future research in this area are suggested.This work is supported by the R&D Project BioDAgro—Sistema operacional inteligente de informação e suporte á decisão em AgroBiodiversidade, project PD20-00011, promoted by Fundação La Caixa and Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia, taking place at the C-MAST-Centre for Mechanical and Aerospace Sciences and Technology, Department of Electromechanical Engineering of the University of Beira Interior, Covilhã, Portugal.info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersio

Fruit ripeness classification: A survey

Fruit is a key crop in worldwide agriculture feeding millions of people. The standard supply chain of fruit products involves quality checks to guarantee freshness, taste, and, most of all, safety. An important factor that determines fruit quality is its stage of ripening. This is usually manually classified by field experts, making it a labor-intensive and error-prone process. Thus, there is an arising need for automation in fruit ripeness classification. Many automatic methods have been proposed that employ a variety of feature descriptors for the food item to be graded. Machine learning and deep learning techniques dominate the top-performing methods. Furthermore, deep learning can operate on raw data and thus relieve the users from having to compute complex engineered features, which are often crop-specific. In this survey, we review the latest methods proposed in the literature to automatize fruit ripeness classification, highlighting the most common feature descriptors they operate on

Review of the state of the art of deep learning for plant diseases: a broad analysis and discussion

Deep learning (DL) represents the golden era in the machine learning (ML) domain, and it has gradually become the leading approach in many fields. It is currently playing a vital role in the early detection and classification of plant diseases. The use of ML techniques in this field is viewed as having brought considerable improvement in cultivation productivity sectors, particularly with the recent emergence of DL, which seems to have increased accuracy levels. Recently, many DL architectures have been implemented accompanying visualisation techniques that are essential for determining symptoms and classifying plant diseases. This review investigates and analyses the most recent methods, developed over three years leading up to 2020, for training, augmentation, feature fusion and extraction, recognising and counting crops, and detecting plant diseases, including how these methods can be harnessed to feed deep classifiers and their effects on classifier accuracy

Tree Trunk Detection of Eastern Red Cedar in Rangeland Environment with Deep Learning Technique

Uncontrolled spread of eastern red cedar invades the United States Great Plains prairie ecosystems and lowers biodiversity across native grasslands. The eastern red cedar (ERC) infestations cause significant challenges for ranchers and landowners, including the high costs of removing mature red cedars, reduced livestock forage feed, and reduced revenue from hunting leases. Therefore, a fleet of autonomous ground vehicles (AGV) is proposed to address the ERC infestation. However, detecting the target tree or trunk in a rangeland environment is critical in automating an ERC cutting operation. A tree trunk detection method was developed in this study for ERC trees trained in natural rangeland environments using a deep learning-based YOLOv5 model. An action camera acquired RGB images in a natural rangeland environment. A transfer learning method was adopted, and the YOLOv5 was trained to detect the varying size of the ERC tree trunk. A trained model precision, recall, and average precision were 87.8%, 84.3%, and 88.9%. The model accurately predicted the varying tree trunk sizes and differentiated between trunk and branches. This study demonstrated the potential for using pretrained deep learning models for tree trunk detection with RGB images. The developed machine vision system could be effectively integrated with a fleet of AGVs for ERC cutting. The proposed ERC tree trunk detection models would serve as a fundamental element for the AGV fleet, which would assist in effective rangeland management to maintain the ecological balance of grassland systems

A Counting Method of Red Jujube Based on Improved YOLOv5s

Due to complex environmental factors such as illumination, shading between leaves and fruits, shading between fruits, and so on, it is a challenging task to quickly identify red jujubes and count red jujubes in orchards. A counting method of red jujube based on improved YOLOv5s was proposed, which realized the fast and accurate detection of red jujubes and reduced the model scale and estimation error. ShuffleNet V2 was used as the backbone of the model to improve model detection ability and light the weight. In addition, the Stem, a novel data loading module, was proposed to prevent the loss of information due to the change in feature map size. PANet was replaced by BiFPN to enhance the model feature fusion capability and improve the model accuracy. Finally, the improved YOLOv5s detection model was used to count red jujubes. The experimental results showed that the overall performance of the improved model was better than that of YOLOv5s. Compared with the YOLOv5s, the improved model was 6.25% and 8.33% of the original network in terms of the number of model parameters and model size, and the Precision, Recall, F1-score, AP, and Fps were improved by 4.3%, 2.0%, 3.1%, 0.6%, and 3.6%, respectively. In addition, RMSE and MAPE decreased by 20.87% and 5.18%, respectively. Therefore, the improved model has advantages in memory occupation and recognition accuracy, and the method provides a basis for the estimation of red jujube yield by vision

Vineyard Gap Detection by Convolutional Neural Networks Fed by Multi-Spectral Images

Funding Information: This research was partially funded by Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia under Projects UIDB/00066/2020, UIDB/04111/2020, foRESTER PCIF/SSI/0102/2017, and IF/00325/2015; Instituto Lusófono de Investigação e Desenvolvimento (ILIND) under Project COFAC/ILIND/COPELABS/1/2020; Project “(Link4S)ustainability—A new generation connectivity system for creation and integration of networks of objects for new sustainability paradigms [POCI-01-0247-FEDER-046122 | LISBOA-01-0247-FEDER-046122]” is financed by the Operational Competitiveness and Internationalization Programmes COMPETE 2020 and LISBOA 2020, under the PORTUGAL 2020 Partnership Agreement, and through the European Structural and Investment Funds in the FEDER component; and also IEoT: Intelligent Edge of Things under under Project LISBOA-01-0247-FEDER-069537. Publisher Copyright: © 2022 by the authors.This paper focuses on the gaps that occur inside plantations; these gaps, although not having anything growing in them, still happen to be watered. This action ends up wasting tons of liters of water every year, which translates into financial and environmental losses. To avoid these losses, we suggest early detection. To this end, we analyzed the different available neural networks available with multispectral images. This entailed training each regional and regression-based network five times with five different datasets. Networks based on two possible solutions were chosen: unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) depletion or post-processing with external software. The results show that the best network for UAV depletion is the Tiny-YOLO (You Only Look Once) version 4-type network, and the best starting weights for Mask-RCNN were from the Tiny-YOLO network version. Although no mean average precision (mAP) of over 70% was achieved, the final trained networks managed to detect mostly gaps, including low-vegetation areas and very small gaps, which had a tendency to be overlooked during the labeling stage.publishersversionpublishe

Fruit Detection and Tree Segmentation for Yield Mapping in Orchards

Accurate information gathering and processing is critical for precision horticulture, as growers aim to optimise their farm management practices. An accurate inventory of the crop that details its spatial distribution along with health and maturity, can help farmers efficiently target processes such as chemical and fertiliser spraying, crop thinning, harvest management, labour planning and marketing. Growers have traditionally obtained this information by using manual sampling techniques, which tend to be labour intensive, spatially sparse, expensive, inaccurate and prone to subjective biases. Recent advances in sensing and automation for field robotics allow for key measurements to be made for individual plants throughout an orchard in a timely and accurate manner. Farmer operated machines or unmanned robotic platforms can be equipped with a range of sensors to capture a detailed representation over large areas. Robust and accurate data processing techniques are therefore required to extract high level information needed by the grower to support precision farming. This thesis focuses on yield mapping in orchards using image and light detection and ranging (LiDAR) data captured using an unmanned ground vehicle (UGV). The contribution is the framework and algorithmic components for orchard mapping and yield estimation that is applicable to different fruit types and orchard configurations. The framework includes detection of fruits in individual images and tracking them over subsequent frames. The fruit counts are then associated to individual trees, which are segmented from image and LiDAR data, resulting in a structured spatial representation of yield. The first contribution of this thesis is the development of a generic and robust fruit detection algorithm. Images captured in the outdoor environment are susceptible to highly variable external factors that lead to significant appearance variations. Specifically in orchards, variability is caused by changes in illumination, target pose, tree types, etc. The proposed techniques address these issues by using state-of-the-art feature learning approaches for image classification, while investigating the utility of orchard domain knowledge for fruit detection. Detection is performed using both pixel-wise classification of images followed instance segmentation, and bounding-box regression approaches. The experimental results illustrate the versatility of complex deep learning approaches over a multitude of fruit types. The second contribution of this thesis is a tree segmentation approach to detect the individual trees that serve as a standard unit for structured orchard information systems. The work focuses on trellised trees, which present unique challenges for segmentation algorithms due to their intertwined nature. LiDAR data are used to segment the trellis face, and to generate proposals for individual trees trunks. Additional trunk proposals are provided using pixel-wise classification of the image data. The multi-modal observations are fine-tuned by modelling trunk locations using a hidden semi-Markov model (HSMM), within which prior knowledge of tree spacing is incorporated. The final component of this thesis addresses the visual occlusion of fruit within geometrically complex canopies by using a multi-view detection and tracking approach. Single image fruit detections are tracked over a sequence of images, and associated to individual trees or farm rows, with the spatial distribution of the fruit counting forming a yield map over the farm. The results show the advantage of using multi-view imagery (instead of single view analysis) for fruit counting and yield mapping. This thesis includes extensive experimentation in almond, apple and mango orchards, with data captured by a UGV spanning a total of 5 hectares of farm area, over 30 km of vehicle traversal and more than 7,000 trees. The validation of the different processes is performed using manual annotations, which includes fruit and tree locations in image and LiDAR data respectively. Additional evaluation of yield mapping is performed by comparison against fruit counts on trees at the farm and counts made by the growers post-harvest. The framework developed in this thesis is demonstrated to be accurate compared to ground truth at all scales of the pipeline, including fruit detection and tree mapping, leading to accurate yield estimation, per tree and per row, for the different crops. Through the multitude of field experiments conducted over multiple seasons and years, the thesis presents key practical insights necessary for commercial development of an information gathering system in orchards

Application of Artificial Intelligence algorithms to support decision-making in agriculture activities

Deep Learning has been successfully applied to image recognition, speech recognition, and natural language processing in recent years. Therefore, there has been an incentive to apply it in other fields as well. The field of agriculture is one of the most important in which the application of artificial intelligence algorithms, and particularly, of deep learning needs to be explored, as it has a direct impact on human well-being. In particular, there is a need to explore how deep learning models for decision-making can be used as a tool for optimal planting, land use, yield improvement, production/disease/pest control, and other activities. The vast amount of data received from sensors in smart farms makes it possible to use deep learning as a model for decision-making in this field. In agriculture, no two environments are exactly alike, which makes testing, validating, and successfully implementing such technologies much more complex than in most other sectors. Recent scientific developments in the field of deep learning, applied to agriculture, are reviewed and some challenges and potential solutions using deep learning algorithms in agriculture are discussed. Higher performance in terms of accuracy and lower inference time can be achieved, and the models can be made useful in real-world applications. Finally, some opportunities for future research in this area are suggested. The ability of artificial neural networks, specifically Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) and Bidirectional LSTM (BLSTM), to model daily reference evapotranspiration and soil water content is investigated. The application of these techniques to predict these parameters was tested for three sites in Portugal. A single-layer BLSTM with 512 nodes was selected. Bayesian optimization was used to determine the hyperparameters, such as learning rate, decay, batch size, and dropout size. The model achieved mean square error (MSE) values ranging from 0.07 to 0.27 (mm d–1)² for ETo (Reference Evapotranspiration) and 0.014 to 0.056 (m³m–3)² for SWC (Soil Water Content), with R2 values ranging from 0.96 to 0.98. A Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) model was added to the LSTM to investigate potential performance improvement. Performance dropped in all datasets due to the complexity of the model. The performance of the models was also compared with CNN, traditional machine learning algorithms Support Vector Regression, and Random Forest. LSTM achieved the best performance. Finally, the impact of the loss function on the performance of the proposed models was investigated. The model with the mean square error (MSE) as loss function performed better than the model with other loss functions. Afterwards, the capabilities of these models and their extension, BLSTM and Bidirectional Gated Recurrent Units (BGRU) to predict end-of-season yields are investigated. The models use historical data, including climate data, irrigation scheduling, and soil water content, to estimate endof- season yield. The application of this technique was tested for tomato and potato yields at a site in Portugal. The BLSTM network outperformed the GRU, the LSTM, and the BGRU networks on the validation dataset. The model was able to capture the nonlinear relationship between irrigation amount, climate data, and soil water content and predict yield with an MSE of 0.017 to 0.039 kg/ha. The performance of the BLSTM in the test was compared with the most commonly used deep learning method called CNN, and machine learning methods including a Multi-Layer Perceptrons model and Random Forest regression. The BLSTM out-performed the other models with a R2-score between 0.97 and 0.99. The results show that analyzing agricultural data with the LSTM model improves the performance of the model in terms of accuracy. The CNN model achieved the second-best performance. Therefore, the deep learning model has a remarkable ability to predict the yield at the end of the season. Additionally, a Deep Q-Network was trained for irrigation scheduling. The agent was trained to schedule irrigation for a tomato field in Portugal. Two LSTM models trained previously were used as the agent environment. One predicts the total water in the soil profile on the next day. The other one was employed to estimate the yield based on the environmental condition during a season and then measure the net return. The agent uses this information to decide the following irrigation amount. LSTM and CNN networks were used to estimate the Q-table during training. Unlike the LSTM model, the ANN and the CNN could not estimate the Qtable, and the agent’s reward decreased during training. The comparison of the performance of the model was done with fixed-base irrigation and threshold-based irrigation. The trained model increased productivity by 11% and decreased water consumption by 20% to 30% compared to the fixed method. Also, an on-policy model, Advantage Actor–Critic (A2C), was implemented to compare irrigation scheduling with Deep Q-Network for the same tomato crop. The results show that the on-policy model A2C reduced water consumption by 20% compared to Deep Q-Network with a slight change in the net reward. These models can be developed to be applied to other cultures with high importance in Portugal, such as fruit, cereals, and grapevines, which also have large water requirements. The models developed along this thesis can be re-evaluated and trained with historical data from other cultures with high production in Portugal, such as fruits, cereals, and grapes, which also have high water demand, to create a decision support and recommendation system that tells farmers when and how much to irrigate. This system helps farmers avoid wasting water without reducing productivity. This thesis aims to contribute to the future steps in the development of precision agriculture and agricultural robotics. The models developed in this thesis are relevant to support decision-making in agricultural activities, aimed at optimizing resources, reducing time and costs, and maximizing production.Nos últimos anos, a técnica de aprendizagem profunda (Deep Learning) foi aplicada com sucesso ao reconhecimento de imagem, reconhecimento de fala e processamento de linguagem natural. Assim, tem havido um incen tivo para aplicá-la também em outros sectores. O sector agrícola é um dos mais importantes, em que a aplicação de algoritmos de inteligência artificial e, em particular, de deep learning, precisa ser explorada, pois tem impacto direto no bem-estar humano. Em particular, há uma necessidade de explorar como os modelos de aprendizagem profunda para a tomada de decisão podem ser usados como uma ferramenta para cultivo ou plantação ideal, uso da terra, melhoria da produtividade, controlo de produção, de doenças, de pragas e outras atividades. A grande quantidade de dados recebidos de sensores em explorações agrícolas inteligentes (smart farms) possibilita o uso de deep learning como modelo para tomada de decisão nesse campo. Na agricultura, não há dois ambientes iguais, o que torna o teste, a validação e a implementação bem-sucedida dessas tecnologias muito mais complexas do que na maioria dos outros setores. Desenvolvimentos científicos recentes no campo da aprendizagem profunda aplicada à agricultura, são revistos e alguns desafios e potenciais soluções usando algoritmos de aprendizagem profunda na agricultura são discutidos. Maior desempenho em termos de precisão e menor tempo de inferência pode ser alcançado, e os modelos podem ser úteis em aplicações do mundo real. Por fim, são sugeridas algumas oportunidades para futuras pesquisas nesta área. A capacidade de redes neuronais artificiais, especificamente Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) e LSTM Bidirecional (BLSTM), para modelar a evapotranspiração de referência diária e o conteúdo de água do solo é investigada. A aplicação destas técnicas para prever estes parâmetros foi testada em três locais em Portugal. Um BLSTM de camada única com 512 nós foi selecionado. A otimização bayesiana foi usada para determinar os hiperparâmetros, como taxa de aprendizagem, decaimento, tamanho do lote e tamanho do ”dropout”. O modelo alcançou os valores de erro quadrático médio na faixa de 0,014 a 0,056 e R2 variando de 0,96 a 0,98. Um modelo de Rede Neural Convolucional (CNN – Convolutional Neural Network) foi adicionado ao LSTM para investigar uma potencial melhoria de desempenho. O desempenho decresceu em todos os conjuntos de dados devido à complexidade do modelo. O desempenho dos modelos também foi comparado com CNN, algoritmos tradicionais de aprendizagem máquina Support Vector Regression e Random Forest. O LSTM obteve o melhor desempenho. Por fim, investigou-se o impacto da função de perda no desempenho dos modelos propostos. O modelo com o erro quadrático médio (MSE) como função de perda teve um desempenho melhor do que o modelo com outras funções de perda. Em seguida, são investigadas as capacidades desses modelos e sua extensão, BLSTM e Bidirectional Gated Recurrent Units (BGRU) para prever os rendimentos da produção no final da campanha agrícola. Os modelos usam dados históricos, incluindo dados climáticos, calendário de rega e teor de água do solo, para estimar a produtividade no final da campanha. A aplicação desta técnica foi testada para os rendimentos de tomate e batata em um local em Portugal. A rede BLSTM superou as redes GRU, LSTM e BGRU no conjunto de dados de validação. O modelo foi capaz de captar a relação não linear entre dotação de rega, dados climáticos e teor de água do solo e prever a produtividade com um MSE variando de 0,07 a 0,27 (mm d–1)² para ETo (Evapotranspiração de Referência) e de 0,014 a 0,056 (m³m–3)² para SWC (Conteúdo de Água do Solo), com valores de R2 variando de 0,96 a 0,98. O desempenho do BLSTM no teste foi comparado com o método de aprendizagem profunda CNN, e métodos de aprendizagem máquina, incluindo um modelo Multi-Layer Perceptrons e regressão Random Forest. O BLSTM superou os outros modelos com um R2 entre 97% e 99%. Os resultados mostram que a análise de dados agrícolas com o modelo LSTM melhora o desempenho do modelo em termos de precisão. O modelo CNN obteve o segundo melhor desempenho. Portanto, o modelo de aprendizagem profunda tem uma capacidade notável de prever a produtividade no final da campanha. Além disso, uma Deep Q-Network foi treinada para programação de irrigação para a cultura do tomate. O agente foi treinado para programar a irrigação de uma plantação de tomate em Portugal. Dois modelos LSTM treinados anteriormente foram usados como ambiente de agente. Um prevê a água total no perfil do solo no dia seguinte. O outro foi empregue para estimar a produtividade com base nas condições ambientais durante uma o ciclo biológico e então medir o retorno líquido. O agente usa essas informações para decidir a quantidade de irrigação. As redes LSTM e CNN foram usadas para estimar a Q-table durante o treino. Ao contrário do modelo LSTM, a RNA e a CNN não conseguiram estimar a tabela Q, e a recompensa do agente diminuiu durante o treino. A comparação de desempenho do modelo foi realizada entre a irrigação com base fixa e a irrigação com base em um limiar. A aplicação das doses de rega preconizadas pelo modelo aumentou a produtividade em 11% e diminuiu o consumo de água em 20% a 30% em relação ao método fixo. Além disso, um modelo dentro da táctica, Advantage Actor–Critic (A2C), é foi implementado para comparar a programação de irrigação com o Deep Q-Network para a mesma cultura de tomate. Os resultados mostram que o modelo de táctica A2C reduziu o consumo de água consumo em 20% comparado ao Deep Q-Network com uma pequena mudança na recompensa líquida. Estes modelos podem ser desenvolvidos para serem aplicados a outras culturas com elevada produção em Portugal, como a fruta, cereais e vinha, que também têm grandes necessidades hídricas. Os modelos desenvolvidos ao longo desta tese podem ser reavaliados e treinados com dados históricos de outras culturas com elevada importância em Portugal, tais como frutas, cereais e uvas, que também têm elevados consumos de água. Assim, poderão ser desenvolvidos sistemas de apoio à decisão e de recomendação aos agricultores de quando e quanto irrigar. Estes sistemas poderão ajudar os agricultores a evitar o desperdício de água sem reduzir a produtividade. Esta tese visa contribuir para os passos futuros na evolução da agricultura de precisão e da robótica agrícola. Os modelos desenvolvidos ao longo desta tese são relevantes para apoiar a tomada de decisões em atividades agrícolas, direcionadas à otimização de recursos, redução de tempo e custos, e maximização da produção.Centro-01-0145-FEDER000017-EMaDeS-Energy, Materials, and Sustainable Development, co-funded by the Portugal 2020 Program (PT 2020), within the Regional Operational Program of the Center (CENTRO 2020) and the EU through the European Regional Development Fund (ERDF). Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia (FCT—MCTES) also provided financial support via project UIDB/00151/2020 (C-MAST). It was also supported by the R&D Project BioDAgro – Sistema operacional inteligente de informação e suporte á decisão em AgroBiodiversidade, project PD20-00011, promoted by Fundação La Caixa and Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia, taking place at the C-MAST - Centre for Mechanical and Aerospace Sciences and Technology, Department of Electromechanical Engineering of the University of Beira Interior, Covilhã, Portugal