"Virtual malleability" applied to MPI jobs to improve their execution in a multiprogrammed environment"

This work focuses on scheduling of MPI jobs when executing in shared-memory multiprocessors (SMPs). The objective was to obtain the best performance in response time in multiprogrammed multiprocessors systems using batch systems, assuming all the jobs have the same priority. To achieve that purpose, the benefits of supporting malleability on MPI jobs to reduce fragmentation and consequently improve the performance of the system were studied. The contributions made in this work can be summarized as follows:· Virtual malleability: A mechanism where a job is assigned a dynamic processor partition, where the number of processes is greater than the number of processors. The partition size is modified at runtime, according to external requirements such as the load of the system, by varying the multiprogramming level, making the job contend for resources with itself. In addition to this, a mechanism which decides at runtime if applying local or global process queues to an application depending on the load balancing between processes of it. · A job scheduling policy, that takes decisions such as how many processes to start with and the maximum multiprogramming degree based on the type and number of applications running and queued. Moreover, as soon as a job finishes execution and where there are queued jobs, this algorithm analyzes whether it is better to start execution of another job immediately or just wait until there are more resources available. · A new alternative to backfilling strategies for the problema of window execution time expiring. Virtual malleability is applied to the backfilled job, reducing its partition size but without aborting or suspending it as in traditional backfilling. The evaluation of this thesis has been done using a practical approach. All the proposals were implemented, modifying the three scheduling levels: queuing system, processor scheduler and runtime library. The impact of the contributions were studied under several types of workloads, varying machine utilization, communication and, balance degree of the applications, multiprogramming level, and job size. Results showed that it is possible to offer malleability over MPI jobs. An application obtained better performance when contending for the resources with itself than with other applications, especially in workloads with high machine utilization. Load imbalance was taken into account obtaining better performance if applying the right queue type to each application independently.The job scheduling policy proposed exploited virtual malleability by choosing at the beginning of execution some parameters like the number of processes and maximum multiprogramming level. It performed well under bursty workloads with low to medium machine utilizations. However as the load increases, virtual malleability was not enough. That is because, when the machine is heavily loaded, the jobs, once shrunk are not able to expand, so they must be executed all the time with a partition smaller than the job size, thus degrading performance. Thus, at this point the job scheduling policy concentrated just in moldability.Fragmentation was alleviated also by applying backfilling techniques to the job scheduling algorithm. Virtual malleability showed to be an interesting improvement in the window expiring problem. Backfilled jobs even on a smaller partition, can continue execution reducing memory swapping generated by aborts/suspensions In this way the queueing system is prevented from reinserting the backfilled job in the queue and re-executing it in the future.Postprint (published version

"Virtual malleability" applied to MPI jobs to improve their execution in a multiprogrammed environment"

This work focuses on scheduling of MPI jobs when executing in shared-memory multiprocessors (SMPs). The objective was to obtain the best performance in response time in multiprogrammed multiprocessors systems using batch systems, assuming all the jobs have the same priority. To achieve that purpose, the benefits of supporting malleability on MPI jobs to reduce fragmentation and consequently improve the performance of the system were studied. The contributions made in this work can be summarized as follows:· Virtual malleability: A mechanism where a job is assigned a dynamic processor partition, where the number of processes is greater than the number of processors. The partition size is modified at runtime, according to external requirements such as the load of the system, by varying the multiprogramming level, making the job contend for resources with itself. In addition to this, a mechanism which decides at runtime if applying local or global process queues to an application depending on the load balancing between processes of it. · A job scheduling policy, that takes decisions such as how many processes to start with and the maximum multiprogramming degree based on the type and number of applications running and queued. Moreover, as soon as a job finishes execution and where there are queued jobs, this algorithm analyzes whether it is better to start execution of another job immediately or just wait until there are more resources available. · A new alternative to backfilling strategies for the problema of window execution time expiring. Virtual malleability is applied to the backfilled job, reducing its partition size but without aborting or suspending it as in traditional backfilling. The evaluation of this thesis has been done using a practical approach. All the proposals were implemented, modifying the three scheduling levels: queuing system, processor scheduler and runtime library. The impact of the contributions were studied under several types of workloads, varying machine utilization, communication and, balance degree of the applications, multiprogramming level, and job size. Results showed that it is possible to offer malleability over MPI jobs. An application obtained better performance when contending for the resources with itself than with other applications, especially in workloads with high machine utilization. Load imbalance was taken into account obtaining better performance if applying the right queue type to each application independently.The job scheduling policy proposed exploited virtual malleability by choosing at the beginning of execution some parameters like the number of processes and maximum multiprogramming level. It performed well under bursty workloads with low to medium machine utilizations. However as the load increases, virtual malleability was not enough. That is because, when the machine is heavily loaded, the jobs, once shrunk are not able to expand, so they must be executed all the time with a partition smaller than the job size, thus degrading performance. Thus, at this point the job scheduling policy concentrated just in moldability.Fragmentation was alleviated also by applying backfilling techniques to the job scheduling algorithm. Virtual malleability showed to be an interesting improvement in the window expiring problem. Backfilled jobs even on a smaller partition, can continue execution reducing memory swapping generated by aborts/suspensions In this way the queueing system is prevented from reinserting the backfilled job in the queue and re-executing it in the future

Job scheduling considering best-effort and soft real-time applications on non-dedicated clusters

As Network Of Workstations (NOWs) emerge as a viable platform for a wide range of workloads, new scheduling approaches are needed to allocate the collection of resources from competing applications. New workload types introduce high uncertainty into the predictability of the system, hindering the applicability of the job scheduling strategies. A new kind of parallel applications has appeared in business or scientific domains, namely Soft Real-Time (SRT). They, together with new SRT desktop applications, turn prediction into a more difficult goal by adding inherent complexity to estimation procedures. In previous work, we introduced an estimation engine into our job scheduling system, termed CISNE. In this work, the estimation engine is extended, by adding two new kernels, both SRT aware. Experimental results confirm the better performance of simulated respect to the analytical kernels and show a maximum average prediction error deviation of 20%.Mientras las Redes de Estaciones de Trabajo (NOWs) emergen como una plataforma viable para un amplio espectro de aplicaciones, son necesarios nuevos enfoques para planificar los recursos disponibles entre las aplicaciones que compiten por ellos. Los nuevos tipos de cargas introducen una alta incertidumbre en la predictibilidad del sistema, afectando la aplicabilidad de las estrategias de planificación de tareas. Un nuevo tipo de aplicaciones paralelas, denominado tiempo real débil (SRT), ha aparecido tanto en los ámbitos comerciales como científicos. Las nuevas aplicaciones paralelas SRT, conjuntamente con los nuevos tipos de aplicaciones SRT de escritorio, convierten la predicción en una meta aún más difícil, al agregar complejidad a los procedimientos de estimación. En trabajos anteriores dotamos al sistema CISNE de un motor de estimación. En este trabajo añadimos al sistema de predicción fuera de línea dos nuevos núcleos de estimación con capacidad SRT. Los resultados experimentales muestran un mejor rendimiento del núcleo simulado con respecto a su homólogo analítico, mostrando un promedio de desviación máximo del 20%.VIII Workshop de Procesamiento Distribuido y ParaleloRed de Universidades con Carreras en Informática (RedUNCI

Job scheduling considering best-effort and soft real-time applications on non-dedicated clusters

As Network Of Workstations (NOWs) emerge as a viable platform for a wide range of workloads, new scheduling approaches are needed to allocate the collection of resources from competing applications. New workload types introduce high uncertainty into the predictability of the system, hindering the applicability of the job scheduling strategies. A new kind of parallel applications has appeared in business or scientific domains, namely Soft Real-Time (SRT). They, together with new SRT desktop applications, turn prediction into a more difficult goal by adding inherent complexity to estimation procedures. In previous work, we introduced an estimation engine into our job scheduling system, termed CISNE. In this work, the estimation engine is extended, by adding two new kernels, both SRT aware. Experimental results confirm the better performance of simulated respect to the analytical kernels and show a maximum average prediction error deviation of 20%.Mientras las Redes de Estaciones de Trabajo (NOWs) emergen como una plataforma viable para un amplio espectro de aplicaciones, son necesarios nuevos enfoques para planificar los recursos disponibles entre las aplicaciones que compiten por ellos. Los nuevos tipos de cargas introducen una alta incertidumbre en la predictibilidad del sistema, afectando la aplicabilidad de las estrategias de planificación de tareas. Un nuevo tipo de aplicaciones paralelas, denominado tiempo real débil (SRT), ha aparecido tanto en los ámbitos comerciales como científicos. Las nuevas aplicaciones paralelas SRT, conjuntamente con los nuevos tipos de aplicaciones SRT de escritorio, convierten la predicción en una meta aún más difícil, al agregar complejidad a los procedimientos de estimación. En trabajos anteriores dotamos al sistema CISNE de un motor de estimación. En este trabajo añadimos al sistema de predicción fuera de línea dos nuevos núcleos de estimación con capacidad SRT. Los resultados experimentales muestran un mejor rendimiento del núcleo simulado con respecto a su homólogo analítico, mostrando un promedio de desviación máximo del 20%.VIII Workshop de Procesamiento Distribuido y ParaleloRed de Universidades con Carreras en Informática (RedUNCI

Extending Scojo-PECT by migration based on system-level checkpointing

In recent years, a significant amount of research has been done on job scheduling in high performance computing area. Parallel jobs have different running time and require a different number of processors, thus jobs need to be scheduled and packed to improve system utilization. Scojo-PECT is a job scheduler which provides service guarantees by using coarse-grain time sharing. However, Scojo-PECT does not provide process migration. We extend the Scojo-PECT by migrating parallel jobs based on system-level checkpointing. We investigate different cases in the Scojo-PECT scheduling algorithm where migration based on system-level checkpointing can be used to improve resource utilization and reduce job response time. Our experimental results show reduction of relative response times on medium jobs over the results of the original Scojo-PECT scheduler and the long jobs do not suffer any disadvantage

Designing SSI clusters with hierarchical checkpointing and single I/O space

Adopting a new hierarchical checkpointing architecture, the authors develop a single I/O address space for building highly available clusters of computers. They propose a systematic approach to achieving a single system image by integrating existing middleware support with the newly developed features.published_or_final_versio

Guaranteed bandwidth implementation of message passing interface on workstation clusters

Due to their wide availability, networks of workstations (NOW) are an attractive platform for parallel processing. Parallel programming environments such as Parallel Virtual Machine (PVM), and Message Passing Interface (MPI) offer the user a convenient way to express parallel computing and communication for a network of workstations. Currently, a number of MPI implementations are available that offer low (average ) latency and high bandwidth environments to users by utilizing an efficient MPI library specification and high speed networks. In addition to high bandwidth and low average latency requirements, mission critical distributed applications, audio/video communications require a completely different type of service, guaranteed bandwidth and worst case delays (worst case latency) to be guaranteed by underlying protocol. The hypothesis presented in this paper is that it is possible to provide an application a low level reliable transport protocol with performance and guaranteed bandwidth as close to the hardware on which it is executing. The hypothesis is proven by designing and implementing a reliable high performance message passing protocol interface which also provides the guaranteed bandwidth to MPI and to mission critical distributed MPI applications. This protocol interface works with the Fiber Distributed Data Interface (FDDI) driver which has been designed and implemented for Performance Technology Inc. commercial high performance FDDI product, the Station Management Software 7.3, and the ADI / MPICH (Argonne National Laboratory and Mississippi State University\u27s free MPI implementation)

Analytical Modeling of High Performance Reconfigurable Computers: Prediction and Analysis of System Performance.

The use of a network of shared, heterogeneous workstations each harboring a Reconfigurable Computing (RC) system offers high performance users an inexpensive platform for a wide range of computationally demanding problems. However, effectively using the full potential of these systems can be challenging without the knowledge of the system’s performance characteristics. While some performance models exist for shared, heterogeneous workstations, none thus far account for the addition of Reconfigurable Computing systems. This dissertation develops and validates an analytic performance modeling methodology for a class of fork-join algorithms executing on a High Performance Reconfigurable Computing (HPRC) platform. The model includes the effects of the reconfigurable device, application load imbalance, background user load, basic message passing communication, and processor heterogeneity. Three fork-join class of applications, a Boolean Satisfiability Solver, a Matrix-Vector Multiplication algorithm, and an Advanced Encryption Standard algorithm are used to validate the model with homogeneous and simulated heterogeneous workstations. A synthetic load is used to validate the model under various loading conditions including simulating heterogeneity by making some workstations appear slower than others by the use of background loading. The performance modeling methodology proves to be accurate in characterizing the effects of reconfigurable devices, application load imbalance, background user load and heterogeneity for applications running on shared, homogeneous and heterogeneous HPRC resources. The model error in all cases was found to be less than five percent for application runtimes greater than thirty seconds and less than fifteen percent for runtimes less than thirty seconds. The performance modeling methodology enables us to characterize applications running on shared HPRC resources. Cost functions are used to impose system usage policies and the results of vii the modeling methodology are utilized to find the optimal (or near-optimal) set of workstations to use for a given application. The usage policies investigated include determining the computational costs for the workstations and balancing the priority of the background user load with the parallel application. The applications studied fall within the Master-Worker paradigm and are well suited for a grid computing approach. A method for using NetSolve, a grid middleware, with the model and cost functions is introduced whereby users can produce optimal workstation sets and schedules for Master-Worker applications running on shared HPRC resources

Adaptive Resource Relocation in Virtualized Heterogeneous Clusters

Cluster computing has recently gone through an evolution from single processor systems to multicore/multi-socket systems. This has resulted in lowering the cost/performance ratio of the compute machines. Compute farms that host these machines tend to become heterogeneous over time due to incremental extensions, hardware upgrades and/or nodes being purchased for users with particular needs. This heterogeneity is not surprising given the wide range of processor, memory and network technologies that become available and the relatively small price difference between these various options. Different CPU architectures, memory capacities, communication and I/O interfaces of the participating compute nodes present many challenges to job scheduling and often result in under or over utilization of the compute resources. In general, it is not feasible for the application programmers to specifically optimize their programs for such a set of differing compute n odes, due to the difficulty and time-intensiveness of such a task. The trend of heterogeneous compute farms has coincided with resurgence in the virtualization technology. Virtualization technology is receiving widespread adoption, mainly due to the benefits of server consolidation and isolation, load balancing, security and fault tolerance. Virtualization has also generated considerable interest in the High Performance Computing (HPC) community, due to the resulting high availability, fault tolerance, cluster partitioning and accommodation of conflicting user requirements. However, the HPC community is still wary of the potential overheads associated with‘ virtualization, as it results in slower network communications and disk I/O, which need to be addressed. The live migration feature, available to most virtualization technologies, can be leveraged to improve the throughput of a heterogeneous compute farm (HC) used for HPC applications. For this we mitigated the slow network communication in Xen; an open source virtual machine monitor. We present a detailed analysis of the communication framework of Xen and propose communication configurations that give 50% improvement over the conventional Xen network configuration. From a detailed study of the migration facility in Xen, we propose an improvement in the live migration facility specifically targeting HPC applications. This optimization gives around 50% improvement over the default migration facility of Xen. In this thesis, we also investigate resource scheduling in heterogeneous compute farm with the perspective of dynamic resource re-mapping. Our approach is to profile each job in the compute farm at runtime, and propose a better resource mapping compared to the initial allocation. We then migrate the job(s) to the best-suited homogeneous sub-cluster to improve overall throughput of the HC. For this, we develop a novel heterogeneity and virtualization-aware profiling framework, which is able to predict the CPU and communication characteristics of high performance scientific applications. The prediction accuracy of our performance estimation model is over 80%. The framework implementation is lightweight, with an overhead of 3%. Our experiments show that we are able to improve the throughput of the compute farm by 25% and the time saved by the HC with our framework is over 30%. The framework can be readily extended to HCs supporting a cloud computing environment

Portable Checkpointing for Parallel Applications

High Performance Computing (HPC) systems represent the peak of modern computational capability. As ever-increasing demands for computational power have fuelled the demand for ever-larger computing systems, modern HPC systems have grown to incorporate hundreds, thousands or as many as 130,000 processors. At these scales, the huge number of individual components in a single system makes the probability that a single component will fail quite high, with today's large HPC systems featuring mean times between failures on the order of hours or a few days. As many modern computational tasks require days or months to complete, fault tolerance becomes critical to HPC system design. The past three decades have seen significant amounts of research on parallel system fault tolerance. However, as most of it has been either theoretical or has focused on low-level solutions that are embedded into a particular operating system or type of hardware, this work has had little impact on real HPC systems. This thesis attempts to address this lack of impact by describing a high-level approach for implementing checkpoint/restart functionality that decouples the fault tolerance solution from the details of the operating system, system libraries and the hardware and instead connects it to the APIs implemented by the above components. The resulting solution enables applications that use these APIs to become self-checkpointing and self-restarting regardless of the the software/hardware platform that may implement the APIs. The particular focus of this thesis is on the problem of checkpoint/restart of parallel applications. It presents two theoretical checkpointing protocols, one for the message passing communication model and one for the shared memory model. The former is the first protocol to be compatible with application-level checkpointing of individual processes, while the latter is the first protocol that is compatible with arbitrary shared memory models, APIs, implementations and consistency protocols. These checkpointing protocols are used to implement checkpointing systems for applications that use the MPI and OpenMP parallel APIs, respectively, and are first in providing checkpoint/restart to arbitrary implementations of these popular APIs. Both checkpointing systems are extensively evaluated on multiple software/hardware platforms and are shown to feature low overheads