The challenge of mapping the human connectome based on diffusion tractography

Tractography based on non-invasive diffusion imaging is central to the study of human brain connectivity. To date, the approach has not been systematically validated in ground truth studies. Based on a simulated human brain data set with ground truth tracts, we organized an open international tractography challenge, which resulted in 96 distinct submissions from 20 research groups. Here, we report the encouraging finding that most state-of-the-art algorithms produce tractograms containing 90% of the ground truth bundles (to at least some extent). However, the same tractograms contain many more invalid than valid bundles, and half of these invalid bundles occur systematically across research groups. Taken together, our results demonstrate and confirm fundamental ambiguities inherent in tract reconstruction based on orientation information alone, which need to be considered when interpreting tractography and connectivity results. Our approach provides a novel framework for estimating reliability of tractography and encourages innovation to address its current limitations

Structural connectivity based on diffusion Kurtosis imaging

Structural connectivity models based on Diffusion Tensor Imaging (DTI) are strongly affected by the technique’s inability to resolve crossing fibres, either intra- or inter-hemispherical connections. Several models have been proposed to address this issue, including an algorithm aiming to resolve crossing fibres which is based on Diffusion Kurtosis Imaging (DKI). This technique is clinically feasible, even when multi-band acquisitions are not available, and compatible with multi-shell acquisition schemes. DKI is an extension of DTI enabling the estimation of diffusion tensor and diffusion kurtosis metrics. In this study we compare the performance of DKI and DTI in performing structural brain connectivity. Six healthy subjects were recruited, aged between 25 and 35 (three females). The MRI experiments were performed using a 3T Siemens Trio with a 32-channel head coil. The scans included a T1-weighted sequence (1mm3), and a DWI with b-values 0, 1000 and 2000 s:mm2. For each b-value, 64 equally spaced gradient directions were sampled. For DTI fitting only images with b-value of 0 and 1000 s:mm2 were considered, whereas for the DKI fitting, the whole cohort of images were considered. To fit both DTI and DKI tensors, extract the metrics and perform tract reconstructions, the toolbox DKIu was used, and the structural connectivity analysis was accomplished using the MIBCA toolbox. Tractography results revealed, as expected, that DKI-based tractography models can resolve crossing fibres within the same voxel, which posed a limitation to the DTI-based tractography models. Structural connectivity analysis showed DKI-based networks’ ability to establish both more inter-hemisphere and intra-hemisphere connections, when compared to DTI-based networks. This may be a direct consequence of the inability to resolve crossing fibres when using the DTI model. The DKI model ability to resolve crossing fibres may provide increased sensitivity to both inter- and intra-hemispherical connections. DTI-based modularity connectograms show a distinct intra-hemispherical configuration, whereas DKI-based connectograms show an increased number of inter-hemispherical connections, with several clusters extending over both hemispheres. Global and local connectivity metrics were also studied, but yielded no conclusive results. This may be due to a lack of reproducibility of the metrics or of the small cohort of subjects considered. DKI seems to provide additional insights into structural brain connectivity by resolving crossing fibres, otherwise undetected by DTI

Relationship between large-scale structural and functional brain connectivity in the human lifespan

The relationship between the anatomical structure of the brain and its functional organization is not straightforward and has not been elucidated yet, despite the growing interest this topic has received in the last decade. In particular, a new area of research has been defined in these years, called \u2019connectomics\u2019: this is the study of the different kinds of \u2019connections\u2019 existing among micro- and macro-areas of the brain, from structural connectivity \u2014 described by white matter fibre tracts physically linking cortical areas \u2014 to functional connectivity \u2014 defined as temporal correlation between electrical activity of different brain regions \u2014 to effective connectivity\u2014defining causal relationships between functional activity of different brain areas. Cortical areas of the brain physically linked by tracts of white matter fibres are known to exhibit a more coherent functional synchronization than areas which are not anatomically linked, but the absence of physical links between two areas does not imply a similar absence of functional correspondence. Development and ageing, but also structural modifications brought on by malformations or pathology, can modify the relation between structure and function. The aim of my PhD work has been to further investigate the existing relationship between structural and functional connectivity in the human brain at different ages of the human lifespan, in particular in healthy adults and both healthy and pathological neonates and children. These two \u2019categories\u2019 of subjects are very different in terms of the analysis techniques which can be applied for their study, due to the different characteristics of the data obtainable from them: in particular, while healthy adult data can be studied with the most advanced state-of-the-art methods, paediatric and neonatal subjects pose hard constraints to the acquisition methods applicable, and thus to the quality of the data which can be analysed. During this PhD I have studied this relation in healthy adult subjects by comparing structural connectivity from DWI data with functional connectivity from stereo-EEG recordings of epileptic patients implanted with intra-cerebral electrodes. I have then focused on the paediatric age, and in particular on the challenges posed by the paediatric clinical environment to the analysis of structural connectivity. In collaboration with the Neuroradiology Unit of the Giannina Gaslini Hospital in Genova, I have adapted and tested advanced DWI analysis methods for neonatal and paediatric data, which is commonly studied with less effective methods. We applied the same methods to the study of the effects of a specific brain malformation on the structural connectivity in 5 paediatric patients. While diffusion weighted imaging (DWI) is recognised as the best method to compute structural connectivity in the human brain, the most common methods for estimating functional connectivity data \u2014 functional MRI (fMRI) and electroencephalography (EEG) \u2014 suffer from different limitations: fMRI has good spatial resolution but low temporal resolution, while EEG has a better temporal resolution but the localisation of each signal\u2019s originating area is difficult and not always precise. Stereo-EEG (SEEG) combines strong spatial and temporal resolution with a high signal-to-noise ratio and allows to identify the source of each signal with precision, but is not used for studies on healthy subjects because of its invasiveness. Functional connectivity in children can be computed with either fMRI, EEG or SEEG, as in adult subjects. On the other hand, the study of structural connectivity in the paediatric age is met with obstacles posed by the specificity of this data, especially for the application of the advanced DWI analysis techniques commonly used in the adult age. Moreover, the clinical environment introduces even more constraints on the quality of the available data, both in children and adults, further limiting the possibility of applying advanced analysis methods for the investigation of connectivity in the paediatric age. Our results on adult subjects showed a positive correlation between structural and functional connectivity at different granularity levels, from global networks to community structures to single nodes, suggesting a correspondence between structural and functional organization which is maintained at different aggregation levels of brain units. In neonatal and paediatric subjects, we successfully adapted and applied the same advanced DWI analysis method used for the investigation in adults, obtaining white matter reconstructions more precise and anatomically plausible than with methods commonly used in paediatric clinical environments, and we were able to study the effects of a specific type of brain malformation on structural connectivity, explaining the different physical and functional manifestation of this malformation with respect to similar pathologies. This work further elucidates the relationship between structural and functional connectivity in the adult subject, and poses the basis for a corresponding work in the neonatal and paediatric subject in the clinical environment, allowing to study structural connectivity in the healthy and pathological child with clinical data

Studying neuroanatomy using MRI

The study of neuroanatomy using imaging enables key insights into how our brains function, are shaped by genes and environment, and change with development, aging, and disease. Developments in MRI acquisition, image processing, and data modelling have been key to these advances. However, MRI provides an indirect measurement of the biological signals we aim to investigate. Thus, artifacts and key questions of correct interpretation can confound the readouts provided by anatomical MRI. In this review we provide an overview of the methods for measuring macro- and mesoscopic structure and inferring microstructural properties; we also describe key artefacts and confounds that can lead to incorrect conclusions. Ultimately, we believe that, though methods need to improve and caution is required in its interpretation, structural MRI continues to have great promise in furthering our understanding of how the brain works

The Neural Correlates of Visual Hallucinations in Parkinson's Disease

Visual hallucinations are common in Parkinson’s disease (PD) and linked to worse outcomes: increased mortality, higher carer burden, cognitive decline, and worse quality of life. Recent functional studies have aided our understanding, showing large-scale brain network imbalance in PD hallucinations. Imbalance of different influences on visual perception also occurs, with impaired accumulation of feedforward signals from the eyes and visual parts of the brain. Whether feedback signals from higher brain control centres are also affected is unknown and the mechanisms driving network imbalance in PD hallucinations remain unclear. In this thesis I will clarify the computational and structural changes underlying PD hallucinations and link these to functional abnormalities and regional changes at the cellular level. To achieve this, I will employ behavioural testing, diffusion weighted imaging, structural and functional MRI in PD patients with and without hallucinations. I will quantify the use of prior knowledge during a visual learning task and show that PD with hallucinations over-rely on feedback signals. I will examine underlying structural connectivity changes at baseline and longitudinally and will show that posterior thalamic connections are affected early, with frontal connections remaining relatively preserved. I will show that PD hallucinations are associated with a subnetwork of reduced structural connectivity strength, affecting areas crucial for switching the brain between functional states. I will assess the role of the thalamus as a potential driver of network-level changes and show preferential medial thalamus involvement. I will utilise data from the Allen Institute transcription atlas and show how differences in regional gene expression in health contributes to the selective vulnerability of specific white matter connections in PD hallucinations. These findings reveal the structural correlates of visual hallucinations in PD, link these to functional and behavioural changes and provide insights into the cellular mechanisms that drive regional vulnerability, ultimately leading to hallucinations

Accurate Bayesian segmentation of thalamic nuclei using diffusion MRI and an improved histological atlas

The human thalamus is a highly connected brain structure, which is key for the control of numerous functions and is involved in several neurological disorders. Recently, neuroimaging studies have increasingly focused on the volume and connectivity of the specific nuclei comprising this structure, rather than looking at the thalamus as a whole. However, accurate identification of cytoarchitectonically designed histological nuclei on standard in vivo structural MRI is hampered by the lack of image contrast that can be used to distinguish nuclei from each other and from surrounding white matter tracts. While diffusion MRI may offer such contrast, it has lower resolution and lacks some boundaries visible in structural imaging. In this work, we present a Bayesian segmentation algorithm for the thalamus. This algorithm combines prior information from a probabilistic atlas with likelihood models for both structural and diffusion MRI, allowing segmentation of 25 thalamic labels per hemisphere informed by both modalities. We present an improved probabilistic atlas, incorporating thalamic nuclei identified from histology and 45 white matter tracts surrounding the thalamus identified in ultra-high gradient strength diffusion imaging. We present a family of likelihood models for diffusion tensor imaging, ensuring compatibility with the vast majority of neuroimaging datasets that include diffusion MRI data. The use of these diffusion likelihood models greatly improves identification of nuclear groups versus segmentation based solely on structural MRI. Dice comparison of 5 manually identifiable groups of nuclei to ground truth segmentations show improvements of up to 10 percentage points. Additionally, our chosen model shows a high degree of reliability, with median test-retest Dice scores above 0.85 for four out of five nuclei groups, whilst also offering improved detection of differential thalamic involvement in Alzheimer’s disease (AUROC 81.98%). The probabilistic atlas and segmentation tool will be made publicly available as part of the neuroimaging package FreeSurfer

Quantitative diffusion MRI with application to multiple sclerosis

Diffusion MRI (dMRI) is a uniquely non-invasive probe of biological tissue properties, increasingly able to provide access to ever more intricate structural and microstructural tissue information. Imaging biomarkers that reveal pathological alterations can help advance our knowledge of complex neurological disorders such as multiple sclerosis (MS), but depend on both high quality image data and robust post-processing pipelines. The overarching aim of this thesis was to develop methods to improve the characterisation of brain tissue structure and microstructure using dMRI. Two distinct avenues were explored. In the first approach, network science and graph theory were used to identify core human brain networks with improved sensitivity to subtle pathological damage. A novel consensus subnetwork was derived using graph partitioning techniques to select nodes based on independent measures of centrality, and was better able to explain cognitive impairment in relapsing-remitting MS patients than either full brain or default mode networks. The influence of edge weighting scheme on graph characteristics was explored in a separate study, which contributes to the connectomics field by demonstrating how study outcomes can be affected by an aspect of network design often overlooked. The second avenue investigated the influence of image artefacts and noise on the accuracy and precision of microstructural tissue parameters. Correction methods for the echo planar imaging (EPI) Nyquist ghost artefact were systematically evaluated for the first time in high b-value dMRI, and the outcomes were used to develop a new 2D phase-corrected reconstruction framework with simultaneous channel-wise noise reduction appropriate for dMRI. The technique was demonstrated to alleviate biases associated with Nyquist ghosting and image noise in dMRI biomarkers, but has broader applications in other imaging protocols that utilise the EPI readout. I truly hope the research in this thesis will influence and inspire future work in the wider MR community