88 research outputs found
Resilience, reliability, and coordination in autonomous multi-agent systems
Acknowledgements The research reported in this paper was funded and supported by various grants over the years: Robotics and AI in Nuclear (RAIN) Hub (EP/R026084/1); Future AI and Robotics for Space (FAIR-SPACE) Hub (EP/R026092/1); Offshore Robotics for Certification of Assets (ORCA) Hub (EP/R026173/1); the Royal Academy of Engineering under the Chair in Emerging Technologies scheme; Trustworthy Autonomous Systems “Verifiability Node” (EP/V026801); Scrutable Autonomous Systems (EP/J012084/1); Supporting Security Policy with Effective Digital Intervention (EP/P011829/1); The International Technology Alliance in Network and Information Sciences.Peer reviewedPostprin
HTN planning: Overview, comparison, and beyond
Hierarchies are one of the most common structures used to understand and conceptualise the world. Within the field of Artificial Intelligence (AI) planning, which deals with the automation of world-relevant problems, Hierarchical Task Network (HTN) planning is the branch that represents and handles hierarchies. In particular, the requirement for rich domain knowledge to characterise the world enables HTN planning to be very useful, and also to perform well. However, the history of almost 40 years obfuscates the current understanding of HTN planning in terms of accomplishments, planning models, similarities and differences among hierarchical planners, and its current and objective image. On top of these issues, the ability of hierarchical planning to truly cope with the requirements of real-world applications has been often questioned. As a remedy, we propose a framework-based approach where we first provide a basis for defining different formal models of hierarchical planning, and define two models that comprise a large portion of HTN planners. Second, we provide a set of concepts that helps in interpreting HTN planners from the aspect of their search space. Then, we analyse and compare the planners based on a variety of properties organised in five segments, namely domain authoring, expressiveness, competence, computation and applicability. Furthermore, we select Web service composition as a real-world and current application, and classify and compare the approaches that employ HTN planning to solve the problem of service composition. Finally, we conclude with our findings and present directions for future work. In summary, we provide a novel and comprehensive viewpoint on a core AI planning technique.<br/
Architecture for planning and execution of missions with fleets of unmanned vehicles
Esta tesis presenta contribuciones en el campo de la planificación automática y la
programación de tareas, la rama de la inteligencia artificial que se ocupa de la
realización de estrategias o secuencias de acciones típicamente para su ejecución por
parte de vehículos no tripulados, robots autónomos y/o agentes inteligentes. Cuando se
intenta alcanzar un objetivo determinado, la cooperación puede ser un aspecto clave. La
complejidad de algunas tareas requiere la cooperación entre varios agentes. Mas aún,
incluso si una tarea es lo suficientemente simple para ser llevada a cabo por un único
agente, puede usarse la cooperación para reducir el coste total de la misma. Para realizar
tareas complejas que requieren interacción física con el mundo real, los vehículos no
tripulados pueden ser usados como agentes. En los últimos años se han creado y utilizado
una gran diversidad de plataformas no tripuladas, principalmente vehículos que pueden
ser dirigidos sin un humano a bordo, tanto en misiones civiles como militares.
En esta tesis se aborda la aplicación de planificación simbólica de redes jerárquicas
de tareas (HTN planning, por sus siglas en inglés) en la resolución de problemas de
enrutamiento de vehículos (VRP, por sus siglas en inglés) [18], en dominios que implican
múltiples vehículos no tripulados de capacidades heterogéneas que deben cooperar para
alcanzar una serie de objetivos específicos.
La planificación con redes jerárquicas de tareas describe dominios utilizando una
descripción que descompone conjuntos de tareas en subconjuntos más pequeños de
subtareas gradualmente, hasta obtener tareas del más bajo nivel que no pueden ser
descompuestas y se consideran directamente ejecutables. Esta jerarquía es similar al modo
en que los humanos razonan sobre los problemas, descomponiéndolos en subproblemas
según el contexto, y por lo tanto suelen ser fáciles de comprender y diseñar.
Los problemas de enrutamiento de vehículos son una generalización del problema del
viajante (TSP, por sus siglas en inglés). La resolución del problema del viajante consiste
en encontrar la ruta más corta posible que permite visitar una lista de ciudades, partiendo
y acabando en la misma ciudad. Su generalización, el problema de enrutamiento de
vehículos, consiste en encontrar el conjunto de rutas de longitud mínima que permite
cubrir todas las ciudades con un determinado número de vehículos. Ambos problemas
cuentan con una fuerte componente combinatoria para su resolución, especialmente en el caso del VRP, por lo que su presencia en dominios que van a ser tratados con un planificador
HTN clásico supone un gran reto.
Para la aplicación de un planificador HTN en la resolución de problemas de enrutamiento
de vehículos desarrollamos dos métodos. En el primero de ellos presentamos un sistema
de optimización de soluciones basado en puntuaciones, que nos permite una nueva forma
de conexión entre un software especializado en la resolución del VRP con el planificador
HTN. Llamamos a este modo de conexión el método desacoplado, puesto que resolvemos
la componente combinatoria del problema de enrutamiento de vehículos mediante un
solucionador específico que se comunica con el planificador HTN y le suministra la
información necesaria para continuar con la descomposición de tareas. El segundo método
consiste en mejorar el planificador HTN utilizado para que sea capaz de resolver el
problema de enrutamiento de vehículos de la mejor forma posible sin tener que depender
de módulos de software externos. Llamamos a este modo el método acoplado. Con
este motivo hemos desarrollado un nuevo planificador HTN que utiliza un algoritmo de
búsqueda distinto del que se utiliza normalmente en planificadores de este tipo.
Esta tesis presenta nuevas contribuciones en el campo de la planificación con redes
jerárquicas de tareas para la resolución de problemas de enrutamiento de vehículos. Se
aplica una nueva forma de conexión entre dos planificadores independientes basada en
un sistema de cálculo de puntuaciones que les permite colaborar en la optimización de
soluciones, y se presenta un nuevo planificador HTN con un algoritmo de búsqueda distinto
al comúnmente utilizado. Se muestra la aplicación de estos dos métodos en misiones
civiles dentro del entorno de los Proyectos ARCAS y AEROARMS financiados por la
Comisión Europea y se presentan extensos resultados de simulación para comprobar la
validez de los dos métodos propuestos.This thesis presents contributions in the field of automated planning and scheduling,
the branch of artificial intelligence that concerns the realization of strategies or
action sequences typically for execution by unmanned vehicles, autonomous robots and/or
intelligent agents. When trying to achieve certain goal, cooperation may be a key aspect.
The complexity of some tasks requires the cooperation among several agents. Moreover,
even if the task is simple enough to be carried out by a single agent, cooperation can be
used to decrease the overall cost of the operation. To perform complex tasks that require
physical interaction with the real world, unmanned vehicles can be used as agents. In the
last years a great variety of unmanned platforms, mainly vehicles that can be driven without
a human on board, have been developed and used both in civil and military missions.
This thesis deals with the application of Hierarchical Task Network (HTN) planning
in the resolution of vehicle routing problems (VRP) [18] in domains involving multiple
heterogeneous unmanned vehicles that must cooperate to achieve specific goals.
HTN planning describes problem domains using a description that decomposes set of
tasks into subsets of smaller tasks and so on, obtaining low-level tasks that cannot be
further decomposed and are supposed to be executable. The hierarchy resembles the way
the humans reason about problems by decomposing them into sub-problems depending
on the context and therefore tend to be easy to understand and design.
Vehicle routing problems are a generalization of the travelling salesman problem (TSP).
The TSP consists on finding the shortest path that connects all the cities from a list, starting
and ending on the same city. The VRP consists on finding the set of minimal routes that
cover all cities by using a specific number of vehicles. Both problems have a combinatorial
nature, specially the VRP, that makes it very difficult to use a HTN planner in domains
where these problems are present.
Two approaches to use a HTN planner in domains involving the VRP have been tested.
The first approach consists on a score-based optimization system that allows us to apply a
new way of connecting a software specialized in the resolution of the VRP with the HTN
planner. We call this the decoupled approach, as we tackle the combinatorial nature of the
VRP by using a specialized solver that communicates with the HTN planner and provides
all the required information to do the task decomposition. The second approach consists on improving and enhancing the HTN planner to be capable of solving the VRP without
needing the use of an external software. We call this the coupled approach. For this reason,
a new HTN planner that uses a different search algorithm from these commonly used in
that type of planners has been developed and is presented in this work.
This thesis presents new contributions in the field of hierarchical task network planning
for the resolution of vehicle routing problem domains. A new way of connecting two
independent planning systems based on a score calculation system that lets them cooperate
in the optimization of the solutions is applied, and a new HTN planner that uses a different
search algorithm from that usually used in other HTN planners is presented. These two
methods are applied in civil missions in the framework of the ARCAS and AEROARMS
Projects funded by the European Commission. Extensive simulation results are presented
to test the validity of the two approaches
Automated Hierarchical, Forward-Chaining Temporal Planner for Planetary Robots Exploring Unknown Environments
The transition of mobile robots from a controlled environment towards the real-world represents a major leap in terms of complexity coming primarily from three different factors: partial observability, nondeterminism and dynamic events. To cope with them, robots must achieve some intelligence behaviours to be cost and operationally effective.
Two particularly interesting examples of highly complex robotic scenarios are Mars rover missions and the Darpa Robotic Challenge (DRC). In spite of the important differences they present in terms of constraints and requirements, they both have adopted certain level of autonomy to overcome some specific problems. For instance, Mars rovers have been endowed with multiple systems to enable autonomous payload operations and consequently increase science return. In the case of DRC, most teams have autonomous footstep planning or arm trajectory calculation.
Even though some specific problems can be addressed with dedicated tools, the general problem remains unsolved: to deploy on-board a reliable reasoning system able to operate robots without human intervention even in complex environments. This is precisely the goal of an automated mission planner.
The scientific community has provided plenty of planners able to provide very fast solutions for classical problems, typically characterized by the lack of time and resources representation. Moreover, there are also a handful of applied planners with higher levels of expressiveness at the price of lowest performance. However, a fast, expressive and robust planner has never been used in complex robotic missions. These three properties represent the main drivers for the outcomes of the thesis.
To bridge the gap between classical and applied planning, a novel formalism named Hierarchical TimeLine Networks (HTLN) combining Timeline and HTN planning has been proposed. HTLN has been implemented on a mission planner named QuijoteExpress, the first forward-chaining timeline planner to the best of our knowledge. The main idea is to benefit from the great performance of forward-chaining search to resolve temporal problems on the state-space. In addition, QuijoteExpress includes search enhancements such as parallel planning by division of the problem in sub-problems or
advanced heuristics management. Regarding expressiveness, the planner incorporates HTN techniques that allow to define hierarchical models and solutions. Finally, plan robustness in uncertain scenarios has been addressed by means of sufficient plans that allow to leave parts of valid plans undefined.
To test the planner, a novel lightweight, timeline and ROS-based executive named SanchoExpress has been designed to translate the plans into actions understandable by the different robot subsystems.
The entire approach has been tested in two realistic and complementary domains. A cooperative multirover Mars mission and an urban search and rescue mission. The results were extremely positive and opens new promising ways in the field of automated planning applied to robotics
Recommended from our members
Integrating Recognition and Decision Making to Close the Interaction Loop for Autonomous Systems
Intelligent systems are becoming increasingly ubiquitous in daily life. Mobile devices are providing machine-generated support to users, robots are coming out of their cages in manufacturing to interact with co-workers, and cars with various degrees of self-driving capabilities operate amongst pedestrians and the driver. However, these interactive intelligent systems\u27 effectiveness depends on their understanding and recognition of human activities and goals, as well as their responses to people in a timely manner. The average person does not follow instructions step-by-step or act in a formulaic manner, but instead varies the order of actions and timing when performing a given task. People explore their surroundings, make mistakes, and may interrupt an activity to handle more urgent matters. The decisions that an autonomous intelligent system makes should account for such noise and variance regardless of the form of interaction, which includes adapting action choices and possibly its own goals.While most people take these aspects of interaction for granted, they are complex and involve many specific tasks that have primarily been studied independently within artificial intelligence. This results in open-loop interactive experiences where the user must perform a fixed input command or the intelligent system performs a hard-coded output response---one of the components of the interaction cannot adapt with respect to the other for longer-term back-and-forth interactions. This dissertation explores how developments in plan recognition, activity recognition, intent recognition, and autonomous planning can work together to develop more adaptive interactive experiences between autonomous intelligent systems and the people around them. In particular, we consider a unifying perspective of recognition algorithms that provides sufficient information to dynamically produce short-term automated planning problems, and we present ways to run these algorithms faster for the real-time needs of interaction. This exploration leads to the introduction of the Planning and Recognition Together Close the Interaction Loop (PReTCIL) framework that serves as a first step towards identifying how we can address the problem of closing the interaction loop, in addition to new questions that need to be considered
- …