fMRI Investigation of Cortical and Subcortical Networks in the Learning of Abstract and Effector-Specific Representations of Motor Sequences

A visuomotor sequence can be learned as a series of visuo-spatial cues or as a sequence of effector movements. Earlier imaging studies have revealed that a network of brain areas is activated in the course of motor sequence learning. However these studies do not address the question of the type of representation being established at various stages of visuomotor sequence learning. In an earlier behavioral study, we demonstrated that acquisition of visuo-spatial sequence representation enables rapid learning in the early stage and progressive establishment of somato-motor representation helps speedier execution by the late stage. We conducted functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) experiments wherein subjects learned and practiced the same sequence alternately in normal and rotated settings. In one rotated setting (visual), subjects learned a new motor sequence in response to an identical sequence of visual cues as in normal. In another rotated setting (motor), the display sequence was altered as compared to normal, but the same sequence of effector movements were used to perform the sequence. Comparison of different rotated settings revealed analogous transitions both in the cortical and subcortical sites during visuomotor sequence learning  a transition of activity from parietal to parietal-premotor and then to premotor cortex and a concomitant shift was observed from anterior putamen to a combined activity in both anterior and posterior putamen and finally to posterior putamen. These results suggest a putative role for engagement of different cortical and subcortical networks at various stages of learning in supporting distinct sequence representations

A Multi-disciplinary Approach to the Investigation of Aspects of Serial Order in Cognition

Serial order processing or Sequence processing underlies many human activities such as speech, language, skill learning, planning, problem solving, etc. Investigating the\ud neural bases of sequence processing enables us to understand serial order in cognition and helps us building intelligent devices. In the current paper, various\ud cognitive issues related to sequence processing will be discussed with examples. Some of the issues are: distributed versus local representation, pre-wired versus\ud adaptive origins of representation, implicit versus explicit learning, fixed/flat versus hierarchical organization, timing aspects, order information embedded in sequences, primacy versus recency in list learning and aspects of sequence perception such as recognition, recall and generation. Experimental results that give evidence for the involvement of various brain areas will be described. Finally, theoretical frameworks based on Markov models and Reinforcement Learning paradigm will be presented. These theoretical ideas are useful for studying sequential phenomena in a principled way

Investigation of sequence processing: A cognitive and computational neuroscience perspective

Serial order processing or sequence processing underlies many human activities such as speech, language, skill learning, planning, problem-solving, etc. Investigating the neural bases of sequence processing enables us to understand serial order in cognition and also helps in building intelligent devices. In this article, we review various cognitive issues related to sequence processing with examples. Experimental results that give evidence for the involvement of various brain areas will be described. Finally, a theoretical approach based on statistical models and reinforcement learning paradigm is presented. These theoretical ideas are useful for studying sequence learning in a principled way. This article also suggests a two-way process diagram integrating experimentation (cognitive neuroscience) and theory/ computational modelling (computational neuroscience). This integrated framework is useful not only in the present study of serial order, but also for understanding many cognitive processes

Motor skill learning between selection and execution.

Learning motor skills evolves from the effortful selection of single movement elements to their combined fast and accurate production. We review recent trends in the study of skill learning which suggest a hierarchical organization of the representations that underlie such expert performance, with premotor areas encoding short sequential movement elements (chunks) or particular component features (timing/spatial organization). This hierarchical representation allows the system to utilize elements of well-learned skills in a flexible manner. One neural correlate of skill development is the emergence of specialized neural circuits that can produce the required elements in a stable and invariant fashion. We discuss the challenges in detecting these changes with fMRI

From Parallel Sequence Representations to Calligraphic Control: A Conspiracy of Neural Circuits

Calligraphic writing presents a rich set of challenges to the human movement control system. These challenges include: initial learning, and recall from memory, of prescribed stroke sequences; critical timing of stroke onsets and durations; fine control of grip and contact forces; and letter-form invariance under voluntary size scaling, which entails fine control of stroke direction and amplitude during recruitment and derecruitment of musculoskeletal degrees of freedom. Experimental and computational studies in behavioral neuroscience have made rapid progress toward explaining the learning, planning and contTOl exercised in tasks that share features with calligraphic writing and drawing. This article summarizes computational neuroscience models and related neurobiological data that reveal critical operations spanning from parallel sequence representations to fine force control. Part one addresses stroke sequencing. It treats competitive queuing (CQ) models of sequence representation, performance, learning, and recall. Part two addresses letter size scaling and motor equivalence. It treats cursive handwriting models together with models in which sensory-motor tmnsformations are performed by circuits that learn inverse differential kinematic mappings. Part three addresses fine-grained control of timing and transient forces, by treating circuit models that learn to solve inverse dynamics problems.National Institutes of Health (R01 DC02852

Towards an explicit account of implicit learning

Purpose of review: The human brain supports acquisition mechanisms that can extract structural regularities implicitly from experience without the induction of an explicit model. Reber defined the process by which an individual comes to respond appropriately to the statistical structure of the input ensemble as implicit learning. He argued that the capacity to generalize to new input is based on the acquisition of abstract representations that reflect underlying structural regularities in the acquisition input. We focus this review of the implicit learning literature on studies published during 2004 and 2005. We will not review studies of repetition priming ('implicit memory'). Instead we focus on two commonly used experimental paradigms: the serial reaction time task and artificial grammar learning. Previous comprehensive reviews can be found in Seger's 1994 article and the Handbook of Implicit Learning. Recent findings: Emerging themes include the interaction between implicit and explicit processes, the role of the medial temporal lobe, developmental aspects of implicit learning, age-dependence, the role of sleep and consolidation. Summary: The attempts to characterize the interaction between implicit and explicit learning are promising although not well understood. The same can be said about the role of sleep and consolidation. Despite the fact that lesion studies have relatively consistently suggested that the medial temporal lobe memory system is not necessary for implicit learning, a number of functional magnetic resonance studies have reported medial temporal lobe activation in implicit learning. This issue merits further research. Finally, the clinical relevance of implicit learning remains to be determined

Neural and Computational Mechanisms of Action Processing: Interaction between Visual and Motor Representations

Giese M A, Rizzolatti G. Neural and Computational Mechanisms of Action Processing: Interaction between Visual and Motor Representations. Neuron. 2015;88(1):167-180

Neural substrates and functional connectivity associated with sleep-dependent and independent consolidation of new motor skills

La mémoire n’est pas un processus unitaire et est souvent divisée en deux catégories majeures: la mémoire déclarative (pour les faits) et procédurale (pour les habitudes et habiletés motrices). Pour perdurer, une trace mnésique doit passer par la consolidation, un processus par lequel elle devient plus robuste et moins susceptible à l’interférence. Le sommeil est connu comme jouant un rôle clé pour permettre le processus de consolidation, particulièrement pour la mémoire déclarative. Depuis plusieurs années cependant, son rôle est aussi reconnu pour la mémoire procédurale. Il est par contre intéressant de noter que ce ne sont pas tous les types de mémoire procédurale qui requiert le sommeil afin d’être consolidée. Entre autres, le sommeil semble nécessaire pour consolider un apprentissage de séquences motrices (s’apparentant à l’apprentissage du piano), mais pas un apprentissage d’adaptation visuomotrice (tel qu’apprendre à rouler à bicyclette). Parallèlement, l’apprentissage à long terme de ces deux types d’habiletés semble également sous-tendu par des circuits neuronaux distincts; c’est-à-dire un réseau cortico-striatal et cortico-cérébelleux respectivement. Toutefois, l’implication de ces réseaux dans le processus de consolidation comme tel demeure incertain. Le but de cette thèse est donc de mieux comprendre le rôle du sommeil, en contrôlant pour le simple passage du temps, dans la consolidation de ces deux types d’apprentissage, à l’aide de l’imagerie par résonnance magnétique fonctionnelle et d’analyses de connectivité cérébrale. Nos résultats comportementaux supportent l’idée que seul l’apprentissage séquentiel requiert le sommeil pour déclencher le processus de consolidation. Nous suggérons de plus que le putamen est fortement associé à ce processus. En revanche, les performances d’un apprentissage visuomoteur s’améliorent indépendamment du sommeil et sont de plus corrélées à une plus grande activation du cervelet. Finalement, en explorant l’effet du sommeil sur la connectivité cérébrale, nos résultats démontrent qu’en fait, un système cortico-striatal semble être plus intégré suite à la consolidation. C’est-à-dire que l’interaction au sein des régions du système est plus forte lorsque la consolidation a eu lieu, après une nuit de sommeil. En opposition, le simple passage du temps semble nuire à l’intégration de ce réseau cortico-striatal. En somme, nous avons pu élargir les connaissances quant au rôle du sommeil pour la mémoire procédurale, notamment en démontrant que ce ne sont pas tous les types d’apprentissages qui requièrent le sommeil pour amorcer le processus de consolidation. D’ailleurs, nous avons également démontré que cette dissociation de l’effet du sommeil est également reflétée par l’implication de deux réseaux cérébraux distincts. À savoir, un réseau cortico-striatal et un réseau cortico-cérébelleux pour la consolidation respective de l’apprentissage de séquence et d’adaptation visuomotrice. Enfin, nous suggérons que la consolidation durant le sommeil permet de protéger et favoriser une meilleure cohésion au sein du réseau cortico-striatal associé à notre tâche; un phénomène qui, s’il est retrouvé avec d’autres types d’apprentissage, pourrait être considéré comme un nouveau marqueur de la consolidation.Memory in humans is generally divided into two broad categories: declarative (for facts and events) and procedural (for skills and motor abilities). To persist, memories undergo a process referred to as consolidation, where a fresh, initially labile memory trace becomes more robust and stable. Sleep is known to play an important role in declarative memory consolidation, and in the past decade, there has been increasing evidence for a role of sleep in the consolidation of procedural memory as well. Interestingly, however, the beneficial effects of sleep do not seem to be homogenous. Motor sequence learning consolidation, in particular, has been found to be particularly sensitive to sleep effects, while the consolidation of motor adaptation has not. Moreover, neuroimaging research, has demonstrated that the long term retention of these two types of motor abilities rely on different neuronal networks, namely the cortico-striatal and cortico-cerebellar systems, respectively. Yet the implication of these networks in the consolidation of these two types of motor memory remains unclear. The aim of the present doctoral thesis was thus to determine the influence of sleep, while controlling for the simple passage of daytime, on the consolidation of a motor sequence learning task vs. a motor adaptation task. We further aimed to bring new insights into the underlying brain regions involved in consolidating these two forms of motor skills. Consistent with previous research, we found off-line improvements in performance for motor adaptation learning, independent of whether participants had a night of sleep or remained awake during daytime. Furthermore, these improvements were correlated with activity in the cerebellum. In contrast, we found that off-line increases in performance in motor sequence learning were evident after a night of sleep but not over the day; and the putamen was strongly associated with this sleep-dependent consolidation process. Finally, while measuring brain changes in connectivity associated with the latter process, we observed that sleep-dependent consolidation is reflected by an increased level of integration within the cortico-striatal system, but not in other functional networks. Conversely, the simple passage of daytime in the wake state seems to result in decreased cortico-striatal integration. In sum our results highlight that not all motor memories undergo sleep-dependent consolidation. We demonstrated that these different paths to consolidation are also reflected by distinct underlying neuronal systems, namely a cortico-striatal and cortico-cerebellar network associated with the consolidation of motor sequence and motor adaptation learning respectively. Furthermore, we propose that consolidation of motor sequences during sleep protects and favors cohesion within the cortico-striatal system, a phenomenon that, if replicated in other types of memories, may be considered as a new marker of sleep-dependent consolidation

Learning and Production of Movement Sequences: Behavioral, Neurophysiological, and Modeling Perspectives

A growing wave of behavioral studies, using a wide variety of paradigms that were introduced or greatly refined in recent years, has generated a new wealth of parametric observations about serial order behavior. What was a mere trickle of neurophysiological studies has grown to a more steady stream of probes of neural sites and mechanisms underlying sequential behavior. Moreover, simulation models of serial behavior generation have begun to open a channel to link cellular dynamics with cognitive and behavioral dynamics. Here we summarize the major results from prominent sequence learning and performance tasks, namely immediate serial recall, typing, 2XN, discrete sequence production, and serial reaction time. These populate a continuum from higher to lower degrees of internal control of sequential organization. The main movement classes covered are speech and keypressing, both involving small amplitude movements that are very amenable to parametric study. A brief synopsis of classes of serial order models, vis-à-vis the detailing of major effects found in the behavioral data, leads to a focus on competitive queuing (CQ) models. Recently, the many behavioral predictive successes of CQ models have been joined by successful prediction of distinctively patterend electrophysiological recordings in prefrontal cortex, wherein parallel activation dynamics of multiple neural ensembles strikingly matches the parallel dynamics predicted by CQ theory. An extended CQ simulation model-the N-STREAMS neural network model-is then examined to highlight issues in ongoing attemptes to accomodate a broader range of behavioral and neurophysiological data within a CQ-consistent theory. Important contemporary issues such as the nature of working memory representations for sequential behavior, and the development and role of chunks in hierarchial control are prominent throughout.Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency/Office of Naval Research (N00014-95-1-0409); National Institute of Mental Health (R01 DC02852