Comparison of fatigue analysis approaches for predicting fatigue lives of hot-mix asphalt concrete (HMAC) mixtures

Hot-mix asphalt concrete (HMAC) mixture fatigue characterization constitutes a fundamental component of HMAC pavement structural design and analysis to ensure adequate field fatigue performance. HMAC is a heterogeneous complex composite material of air, binder, and aggregate that behaves in a non-linear elasto-viscoplastic manner, exhibits anisotropic behavior, ages with time, and heals during traffic loading rest periods and changing environmental conditions. Comprehensive HMAC mixture fatigue analysis approaches that take into account this complex nature of HMAC are thus needed to ensure adequate field fatigue performance. In this study, four fatigue analysis approaches; the mechanistic empirical (ME), the calibrated mechanistic with (CMSE) and without (CM) surface energy measurements, and the proposed NCHRP 1-37A 2002 Pavement Design Guide (MEPDG) were comparatively evaluated and utilized to characterize the fatigue resistance of two Texas HMAC mixtures in the laboratory, including investigating the effects of binder oxidative aging. Although the results were comparable, the CMSE/CM approaches exhibited greater flexibility and potential to discretely account for most of the fundamental material properties (including fracture, aging, healing, visco-elasticity, and anisotropy) that affect HMAC pavement fatigue performance. Compared to the other approaches, which are mechanistic-empirically based, the CMSE/CM approaches are based on the fundamental concepts of continuum micromechanics and energy theory

A probabilistic approach to detect structural problems in flexible pavement sections at network level assessment

Presently, most of the road agencies use Non-Destructive (NDT) tools to help them prioritise pavement maintenance and rehabilitation (M&R) activities at the network level, thus optimising the limited budgetary resources. One of the most widely used NDT techniques for pavement structural evaluations, at the network level assessment, is the Falling Weight Deflectometer (FWD). Using a database comprising of a wide array of typical layer moduli and thicknesses of traditional flexible pavements, that were generated based on multiple Monte Carlo numerical simulations, as a reference datum, this study successfully developed probabilistic models that allow for analysing the condition of a flexible pavement, at the network level, from FWD surface deflection data, namely the Deflection Bowl Parameters (DBPs), to identify which layers of the pavement structure present a probability of structural failure or damage

A Mechanistic-Empirical Impact Analysis of Different Truck Configurations on a Jointed Plain Concrete Pavement (JPCP)

Until the last decade, the 1993 American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHTO) design guide has been traditionally used for the design of flexible and rigid pavements in the USA and some parts of the world. However, because of its inability to meet the new traffic and material challenges, a Mechanistic Empirical Pavement Design Guide (MEPDG) was introduced based on an NCHRP 1-37 A study conducted in 2004. This study used the MEPDG software and associated models to determine, through comparative truck damage analysis, the effects of nine different truck configurations on a 12 inch-jointed plain concrete pavement (JPCP). The study recorded truck damages at the end of each analysis period (40 years) and comparatively analyzed the relative pavement damage in terms of fatigue cracking, faulting, and surface roughness. The results indicated that the most critical damage to the concrete pavement was caused by truck cases with high and uneven load distribution and relatively smaller size axles group (e.g. tandem). Other key findings included the following; (1) increase in damage when the truckloads were shifted between the same size axles, (2) decrease in truck damage when the truckloads were shifted from tandem axle to quad axles, and (3) no change in truck damage when the axle spacing was increased between wheels of a quad axle

Traffic volume and load data measurement using a portable weigh in motion system: A case study

AbstractTraditionally, traffic loading characteristics are collected for pavement design and performance prediction purposes using permanent roadside weigh-in-motion (WIM) stations. However, high installation and maintenance costs associated with these permanent WIM stations dictate that their deployment be mostly limited to major highways, such as the interstate network. Quite often however, pavement damage on high volume rural highways with heavy truck proportions is more severe than anticipated, and there is no effective way of quantifying the traffic loading on these highways. Therefore, this study was conducted to evaluate the potential application of portable WIM systems as a means for bringing the WIM technology to these high volume rural highways. A portable WIM unit was deployed in the Texas overweight corridor in Hidalgo County (Pharr District) near the USA-Mexico border on highway FM 1016 for collecting traffic data for a minimum of three weeks in each direction. The collected traffic data were analyzed to generate traffic parameters such as volume, load spectra, and overloading information both in terms of the gross vehicle weight (GVW) and axle weight. The computed traffic parameters were successful in partially explaining some of the existing pavement conditions on this highway. Overall, the study findings indicated that the portable WIM unit can be used as a convenient and cost-effective means for collecting reliable traffic information for design, analysis, and monitoring purposes. However, proper in-situ calibration of the portable WIM unit at each site is imperative prior to any real-time traffic data collection

Mechanistic-empirical compatible traffic data generation : portable weigh-in-motion versus cluster analysis

Axle load distribution factors (ALDFs) are used as one of the primary traffic data inputs for mechanistic-empirical (ME) pavement design methods for predicting the impact of varying traffic loads on pavement performance with a higher degree of accuracy than empirical methods that are solely based on equivalent single axle load (ESAL) concept. Ideally, to ensure optimal pavement structural design, site-specific traffic load spectra data—generated from weigh-in-motion (WIM) systems—should be used during the pavement design process. However, because of the limited number of available permanent WIM stations (in Texas, for example), it is not feasible to generate a statewide ALDFs database for each highway or project from permanent WIM data. In this study, two possible alternative methods, namely, the direct measurement using a portable WIM system and the cluster analysis technique, were explored for generating site-specific ME-compatible traffic data for a highway test section, namely, state highway (SH) 7 in Bryan District (Texas). The traffic data were then used for estimating pavement performance using a ME pavement design software, namely, the Texas Mechanistic-Empirical Thickness Design System (TxME). The TxME-predicted pavement performance (e.g., rutting) using the portable WIM-generated traffic input parameters closely matched with the actual field performance. Overall, the study findings indicated that the portable WIM (with proper installation and calibration) constitutes an effective means for rapidly collecting reliable site-specific ME-compatible traffic data.https://www.astm.org/DIGITAL_LIBRARY/JOURNALS/TESTEVAL/index.html2021-05-01am2020Civil Engineerin

Comparative assessment of the interlayer shear-bond strength of geogrid reinforcements in hot-mix asphalt

With the increasing use of geogrid reinforcements to mitigate reflective cracking in hot-mix asphalt (HMA) overlays, interlayer (interface) bonding has become an even more critical aspect of HMA placement/construction to mitigate delamination and debonding of the HMA overlay. To comparatively evaluate the interlayer bond strength due to the effects of the geogrid reinforcements, the shear bond strength test was conducted in this laboratory study, using unreinforced control HMA samples as the reference datum. Cylindrical HMA samples (150 mm diameter) gyratory compacted in two 75-mm lift thicknesses, with the geogrid reinforcement in-between the two lifts, were used for testing at room temperature under a monotonically shear loading rate of 5 mm/min. Emulsified asphalt was used as the interlayer tack coat and six different geogrid materials, which are polyester-based (FA) and fiberglass-based (FG), were comparatively evaluated. As theoretically expected, the control (unreinforced) HMA samples exhibited superiority followed closely by samples reinforced with polyester-based geogrids. Although comparable to the values reported in the literature, HMA samples reinforced with fiberglass-based geogrids performed the poorest with the lowest interlayer bond strengths – that is the polyester-based outperformed the fiberglass-based geogrids. Overall, the interlayer bond strength exhibited a general decreasing trend with a decrease in the geogrid mesh size (open area), increase in the geogrid strand thickness, and material grade. Thus, in as much as reflective crack mitigation is structurally desired, due diligence must be cautiously exercised when selecting the geogrid type/grade for use in HMA reinforcement to ensure sufficient interlayer bonding and minimize any potential delamination/debonding problems in service.http://www.elsevier.com/locate/conbuildmat2019-12-10hj2019Civil Engineerin

Accelerated testing of an asphalt pavement with the third-scale model mobile load simulator (MMLS3)

Thesis (MEng)--University of Stellenbosch, 2000.ENGLISH ABSTRACT: Accelerated pavement testing (APT) is the application of a wheel loading, to a prototype or actual layered, structural pavement system to determine pavement response and performance under controlled, accelerated accumulation of damage in a compressed time period. It is a tool used for the evaluation of performance of new pavement materials, distress mechanisms, pavement distress, and selection of rehabilitation strategies. In this study, the research work that was done in Jacksboro, Texas (USA) with the third-scale Model Mobile Load Simulator (MMLS3) as part of the APT programme of the Texas Department of Transportation (TxDOT) is presented. The primary objective was to evaluate the performance ofthe different asphalt concrete (AC) materials (Dustrol and Remixer) used on highway US 281, in terms of rutting and distress due to wet trafficking. The other objective was to investigate the difference in rutting between the MMLS3 and the full-scale Texas Mobile Load Simulator (TxMLS). The scope of the study included fieldwork, laboratory work and theoretical analysis. On average, the performance of the layer from the Dustrol process was found to be poorer than that of the Remixer process. The Dustrol process was more susceptible to moisture damage and less resistant to permanent deformation compared to the Remixer process. The MMLS3 and TxMLS permanent deformations in the upper 90 mm surface layers correlated well in terms of the respective vertical stresses imposed by the two APT devices, after allowing for the difference in environmental conditions during trafficking. Overall, the study demonstrated that the MMLS3, used in conjunction with nondestructive field and laboratory testing, is a significant cost-effective APT device that can be used for evaluating the response and performance of the (surface) layers of full-scale, in-service pavements.AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Versnelde Plaveisel Toetsing bestaan uit die gebruik van 'n wiellas op 'n prototipe of 'n bestaande gelaagde plaveiselstruktuur om die plaveiselgedrag onder beheerde en versnelde toename in skade in 'n verkorte periode te bepaal. Dit word gebruik om die gedrag van nuwe plaveiselmateriale, swigtingsmeganismes, plaveiselswigting en die keuse van rehabilitasie strategieë te evalueer. Die navorsingswerk met die derde skaal Model Mobile Load Simulator (MMLS3) wat onderneem is in Jacksboro, Texas (VSA), en deel uitmaak van die Versnelde Plaveisel Toetsingsprojek van die Texas Departement van Vervoer (TxDOT), word uiteengesit. Die hoofdoel van die studie was om die gedrag van twee verskillende asfaltmateriale, naamlik Dustrol en Remixer, wat gebruik is op die US 281-snelweg, in terme van sporing en swigting as gevolg van nat belastingstoestande te evalueer. 'n Verdere doelstelling was om die verskil in die gemete sporing tussen die MMLS3 en die volskaal Texas Mobile Load Simulator (TxMLS) te ondersoek. Die studie het veld- en laboratoriumtoetse en teoretiese analise behels. Die gedrag van die Dustrol laag is oor die algemeen swakker as die Remixer lae. Die Dustrol laag, in vergelyking met die Remixer lae, is meer vatbaar vir vogskade en spoor makliker. Nadat die invloed van verskillende omgewingstoestande gedurende asbelasting inaggeneem is, korreleer die sporing vir die MMLS3 en die TxMLS in die lae van die boonste 90mm van die plaveisel goed in terme van die vertikale spannings soos opgewek deur die twee toetstoestelle. In die geheel word bewys dat die MMLS3 tesame met nie-destruktiewe veld- en laboratoriumtoetse 'n belangrike koste-effektiewe versnelde plaveisel toetstoestel is, wat aangewend kan word in die evaluasieproses van die gedrag van (oppervlak) lae van volskaalse plaveisels in gebruik

Stresses and strains in asphalt-surfacing pavements

Paper presented at the South African Transport Conference 17 - 20 July 2000 "Action in transport for the new millennium", CSIR International Convention Centre, Pretoria, South Africa.This paper was transferred from the original CD ROM created for this conference. The material on the CD ROM was published using Adobe Acrobat technology. The original CD ROM was produced by Document Transformation Technologies Postal Address: PO Box 560 Irene 0062 South Africa. Tel.: +27 12 667 2074 Fax: +27 12 667 2766 E-mail: [email protected] URL: http://www.doctech.co.z

Evaluación de la resistencia al agrietamiento de mezclas asfálticas en caliente en función de su envejecimiento a partir del ensayo de tensión directa

Hot mix asphalt (HMA) is a heterogeneous composite material of asphalt-binder, aggregates, air voids, and other additives including lime, fibers, etc., predominantly used for pavement construction. With time, the HMA mix ages, which leads to changes in the material properties and response behavior. This paper documents a laboratory study that was conducted to evaluate the suitability of the direct-tension (DT) test to assess the effects of asphalt-binder aging on the HMA mix fracture properties and cracking-resistance potential. Two dense-graded HMA mixes were subjected to different laboratory aging exposure conditions and then tested with the DT test. From this test, the HMA mix fracture response was characterized in terms of the tensile strength, tensile strain at peak failure load, stiffness, and fracture energy. Overall, the results indicated that asphalt-binder aging has a detrimental effect on the fracture response and cracking-resistance of HMA mixes, which can be captured based on the DT test. Therefore, the asphalt-binder aging needs to be considered and properly accounted for during the material design and analysis stages of HMA mixes. However, research with more HMA mixes and correlation with field data is strongly recommended to validate the laboratory findings reported in this paper.La mezcla asfáltica en caliente (MAC) es un material compuesto, heterogéneo, integrado por cemento asfáltico (o asfalto), agregados, vacíos y otros aditivos incluyendo cal, fibras, etc., usado predominantemente para la construcción de pavimentos. A lo largo del tiempo, la MAC sufre envejecimiento, lo cual conlleva cambios en las propiedades del material y en su respuesta. Este artículo documenta un estudio de laboratorio llevado a cabo para evaluar la posibilidad de emplear el ensayo de tensión directa (TD) para determinar los efectos del envejecimiento del asfalto sobre las propiedades de fractura y resistencia al agrietamiento de MAC. Dos MAC de gradación densa fueron sometidas a diferentes condiciones de envejecimiento en laboratorio y luego sometidas al ensayo de TD. A partir de este ensayo, el comportamiento ante fractura se caracterizó en términos de la resistencia a tensión, deformación unitaria de tensión a la carga de falla, rigidez y energía de fractura. En general, los resultados indicaron que el envejecimiento por oxidación del asfalto tiene un efecto negativo sobre la respuesta ante fractura y la resistencia al agrietamiento de la MAC, el cual puede ser captado por medio del ensayo de TD. Por lo tanto, el envejecimiento del asfalto debe ser considerado y cuantificado en forma adecuada durante el diseño y análisis de la MAC. Sin embargo, se recomienda adelantar investigación adicional con otras mezclas y correlacionar resultados con datos de campo para validar la información de laboratorio reportada en este artículo

EVALUATION OF HMA CRACKING RESISTANCE AS A FUNCTION OF LABORATORY AGING BASED ON THE DIRECT-TENSION TEST (EVALUACIÓN DE LA RESISTENCIA AL AGRIETAMIENTO DE MEZCLAS ASFÁLTICAS EN CALIENTE EN FUNCIÓN DE SU ENVEJECIMIENTO A PARTIR DEL ENSAYO DE TENSIÓN DIREC

Hot mix asphalt (HMA) is a heterogeneous composite material of asphalt-binder, aggregates, air voids, and other additives including lime, fibers, etc., predominantly used for pavement construction. With time, the HMA mix ages, which leads to changes in the material properties and response behavior. This paper documents a laboratory study that was conducted to evaluate the suitability of the direct-tension (DT) test to assess the effects of asphalt-binder aging on the HMA mix fracture properties and cracking-resistance potential. Two dense-graded HMA mixes were subjected to different laboratory aging exposure conditions and then tested with the DT test. From this test, the HMA mix fracture response was characterized in terms of the tensile strength, tensile strain at peak failure load, stiffness, and fracture energy. Overall, the results indicated that asphalt-binder aging has a detrimental effect on the fracture response and cracking-resistance of HMA mixes, which can be captured based on the DT test. Therefore, the asphalt-binder aging needs to be considered and properly accounted for during the material design and analysis stages of HMA mixes. However, research with more HMA mixes and correlation with field data is strongly recommended to validate the laboratory findings reported in this paper.Resumen: La mezcla asfáltica en caliente (MAC) es un material compuesto, heterogéneo, integrado por cemento asfáltico (o asfalto), agregados, vacíos y otros aditivos incluyendo cal, fibras, etc., usado predominantemente para la construcción de pavimentos. A lo largo del tiempo, la MAC sufre envejecimiento, lo cual conlleva cambios en las propiedades del material y en su respuesta. Este artículo documenta un estudio de laboratorio llevado a cabo para evaluar la posibilidad de emplear el ensayo de tensión directa (TD) para determinar los efectos del envejecimiento del asfalto sobre las propiedades de fractura y resistencia al agrietamiento de MAC. Dos MAC de gradación densa fueron sometidas a diferentes condiciones de envejecimiento en laboratorio y luego sometidas al ensayo de TD. A partir de este ensayo, el comportamiento ante fractura se caracterizó en términos de la resistencia a tensión, deformación unitaria de tensión a la carga de falla, rigidez y energía de fractura. En general, los resultados indicaron que el envejecimiento por oxidación del asfalto tiene un efecto negativo sobre la respuesta ante fractura y la resistencia al agrietamiento de la MAC, el cual puede ser captado por medio del ensayo de TD. Por lo tanto, el envejecimiento del asfalto debe ser considerado y cuantificado en forma adecuada durante el diseño y análisis de la MAC. Sin embargo, se recomienda adelantar investigación adicional con otras mezclas y correlacionar resultados con datos de campo para validar la información de laboratorio reportada en este artículo.Hot mix asphalt (HMA) is a heterogeneous composite material of asphalt-binder, aggregates, air voids, and other additives including lime, fibers, etc., predominantly used for pavement construction. With time, the HMA mix ages, which leads to changes in the material properties and response behavior. This paper documents a laboratory study that was conducted to evaluate the suitability of the direct-tension (DT) test to assess the effects of asphalt-binder aging on the HMA mix fracture properties and cracking-resistance potential. Two dense-graded HMA mixes were subjected to different laboratory aging exposure conditions and then tested with the DT test. From this test, the HMA mix fracture response was characterized in terms of the tensile strength, tensile strain at peak failure load, stiffness, and fracture energy. Overall, the results indicated that asphalt-binder aging has a detrimental effect on the fracture response and cracking-resistance of HMA mixes, which can be captured based on the DT test. Therefore, the asphalt-binder aging needs to be considered and properly accounted for during the material design and analysis stages of HMA mixes. However, research with more HMA mixes and correlation with field data is strongly recommended to validate the laboratory findings reported in this paper.Resumen: La mezcla asfáltica en caliente (MAC) es un material compuesto, heterogéneo, integrado por cemento asfáltico (o asfalto), agregados, vacíos y otros aditivos incluyendo cal, fibras, etc., usado predominantemente para la construcción de pavimentos. A lo largo del tiempo, la MAC sufre envejecimiento, lo cual conlleva cambios en las propiedades del material y en su respuesta. Este artículo documenta un estudio de laboratorio llevado a cabo para evaluar la posibilidad de emplear el ensayo de tensión directa (TD) para determinar los efectos del envejecimiento del asfalto sobre las propiedades de fractura y resistencia al agrietamiento de MAC. Dos MAC de gradación densa fueron sometidas a diferentes condiciones de envejecimiento en laboratorio y luego sometidas al ensayo de TD. A partir de este ensayo, el comportamiento ante fractura se caracterizó en términos de la resistencia a tensión, deformación unitaria de tensión a la carga de falla, rigidez y energía de fractura. En general, los resultados indicaron que el envejecimiento por oxidación del asfalto tiene un efecto negativo sobre la respuesta ante fractura y la resistencia al agrietamiento de la MAC, el cual puede ser captado por medio del ensayo de TD. Por lo tanto, el envejecimiento del asfalto debe ser considerado y cuantificado en forma adecuada durante el diseño y análisis de la MAC. Sin embargo, se recomienda adelantar investigación adicional con otras mezclas y correlacionar resultados con datos de campo para validar la información de laboratorio reportada en este artículo