Heart and Skeletal Muscle Inflammation of Farmed Salmon Is Associated with Infection with a Novel Reovirus

Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar L.) mariculture has been associated with epidemics of infectious diseases that threaten not only local production, but also wild fish coming into close proximity to marine pens and fish escaping from them. Heart and skeletal muscle inflammation (HSMI) is a frequently fatal disease of farmed Atlantic salmon. First recognized in one farm in Norway in 1999[1], HSMI was subsequently implicated in outbreaks in other farms in Norway and the United Kingdom[2]. Although pathology and disease transmission studies indicated an infectious basis, efforts to identify an agent were unsuccessful. Here we provide evidence that HSMI is associated with infection with piscine reovirus (PRV). PRV is a novel reovirus identified by unbiased high throughput DNA sequencing and a bioinformatics program focused on nucleotide frequency as well as sequence alignment and motif analyses. Formal implication of PRV in HSMI will require isolation in cell culture and fulfillment of Koch's postulates, or prevention or modification of disease through use of specific drugs or vaccines. Nonetheless, as our data indicate that a causal relationship is plausible, measures must be taken to control PRV not only because it threatens domestic salmon production but also due to the potential for transmission to wild salmon populations

The serum proteome of Atlantic salmon, Salmo salar, during pancreas disease (PD) following infection with salmonid alphavirus subtype 3 (SAV3)

Salmonid alphavirus is the aetological agent of pancreas disease (PD) in marine Atlantic salmon, Salmo salar, and rainbow trout, Oncorhynchus mykiss, with most outbreaks in Norway caused by SAV subtype 3 (SAV3). This atypical alphavirus is transmitted horizontally causing a significant economic impact on the aquaculture industry. This histopathological and proteomic study, using an established cohabitational experimental model, investigated the correlation between tissue damage during PD and a number of serum proteins associated with these pathologies in Atlantic salmon. The proteins were identified by two-dimensional electrophoresis, trypsin digest and peptide MS/MS fingerprinting. A number of humoral components of immunity which may act as biomarkers of the disease were also identified. For example, creatine kinase, enolase and malate dehydrogenase serum concentrations were shown to correlate with pathology during PD. In contrast, hemopexin, transferrin, and apolipoprotein, amongst others, altered during later stages of the disease and did not correlate with tissue pathologies. This approach has given new insight into not only PD but also fish disease as a whole, by characterisation of the protein response to infection, through pathological processes to tissue recovery. Biological significance: Salmonid alphavirus causes pancreas disease (PD) in Atlantic salmon, Salmo salar, and has a major economic impact on the aquaculture industry. A proteomic investigation of the change to the serum proteome during PD has been made with an established experimental model of the disease. Serum proteins were identified by two-dimensional electrophoresis, trypsin digest and peptide MS/MS fingerprinting with 72 protein spots being shown to alter significantly over the 12 week period of the infection. The concentrations of certain proteins in serum such as creatine kinase, enolase and malate dehydrogenase were shown to correlate with tissue pathology while other proteins such as hemopexin, transferrin, and apolipoprotein, altered in concentration during later stages of the disease and did not correlate with tissue pathologies. The protein response to infection may be used to monitor disease progression and enhance understanding of the pathology of PD

Effect of functional feeds on fatty acid and eicosanoid metabolism in liver and head kidney of Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar L.) with experimentally induced Heart and Skeletal Muscle Inflammation

Heart and Skeletal Muscle Inflammation (HSMI) is an emerging viral disease caused by a novel Atlantic salmon reovirus (ASRV) affecting farmed fish. Primary symptoms associated with HSMI include myocardial and skeletal muscle necrosis indicating a severe inflammatory process. Recently, we applied the concept of clinical nutrition to moderate the long-term inflammatory process associated with HSMI in salmon subjected to experimental ASRV challenge. The use of functional feeds with lower lipid (hence energy) content reduced the inflammatory response to ASRV infection and the severity of associated heart lesions. The aim of the present study was to elucidate possible mechanisms underpinning the observed effects of the functional feeds, focussing on eicosanoid and fatty acid metabolism in liver and head kidney. Here we show that liver was also a site for histopathological lesions in HSMI showing steatosis reflecting impaired lipid metabolism. This study is also the first to evaluate the expression of a suite of key genes involved in pathways relating diet and membrane phospholipid fatty acid compositions, and the inflammatory response after ASRV infection. The expression of hepatic Δ6 and Δ5 desaturases was higher in fish fed the functional feeds, potentially increasing their capacity for endogenous production and availability of anti-inflammatory EPA. Effects on mobilization of lipids and changes in the LC-PUFA composition of membrane phospholipids, along with significant changes in the expression of the genes related to eicosanoid pathways, showed the important role of the head kidney in inflammatory diseases caused by viral infections. The results from the present study suggest that clinical nutrition through functional feeding could be an effective complementary therapy for emerging salmon viral diseases associated with long-term inflammation

Atlantic Salmon Reovirus Infection Causes a CD8 T Cell Myocarditis in Atlantic Salmon (Salmo salar L.)

Heart and skeletal inflammation (HSMI) of farmed Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar L.) is a disease characterized by a chronic myocarditis involving the epicardium and the compact and spongious part of the heart ventricle. Chronic myositis of the red skeletal muscle is also a typical finding of HSMI. Piscine reovirus (PRV) has been detected by real-time PCR from farmed and wild salmon with and without typical changes of HSMI and thus the causal relationship between presence of virus and the disease has not been fully determined [1]. In this study we show that the Atlantic salmon reovirus (ASRV), identical to PRV, can be passaged in GF-1 cells and experimental challenge of naïve Atlantic salmon with cell culture passaged reovirus results in cardiac and skeletal muscle pathology typical of HSMI with onset of pathology from 6 weeks, peaking by 9 weeks post challenge. ASRV replicates in heart tissue and the peak level of virus replication coincides with peak of heart lesions. We further demonstrate mRNA transcript assessment and in situ characterization that challenged fish develop a CD8+ T cell myocarditis

Use of functional feeding strategies to protect Atlantic salmon from virally-induced inflammatory diseases- mechanistic insights revealed by transcriptomic analysis

Over the past few years one of the major concerns in the Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) farming industry has been the increasing incidence and severity of inflammatory viral diseases. Heart and skeletal muscle inflammation (HSMI) and cardiomyopathy syndrome (CMS) are currently two of the most prevalent viral diseases in commercial Atlantic salmon farms in Norway. Mortality levels in both diseases are generally low but morbidity can be very high with the associated chronic inflammatory response lasting for several months. The consequent reduced growth performance is causing considerable financial impact as HSMI has become increasingly widespread in recent years. The impact of CMS is further exacerbated as it generally affects large fish close to harvest. HSMI lesions occur in the atrium and ventricle in the heart including inflammation and necrosis in epi- endo- and myocardium along with myositis of red skeletal muscle. CMS lesions are commonly observed in the spongy myocardium in the atrium and ventricle of the heart with severe mononuclear inflammation and necrosis. Furthermore, circulatory disturbances associated with reduced cardiac function cause multifocal liver steatosis and necrosis in both diseases. Currently there are no vaccines or any other effective treatments for these diseases and so alternative therapies that could potentially modulate the intensity of the inflammatory response could be crucial to improve the clinical manifestation of the diseases. Therefore, the overall aim of the present study was to evaluate the concept of “clinical nutrition” to improve the clinical symptoms of both viral diseases, HSMI and CMS, through the use of functional feeds formulated with reduced lipid content and increased proportions of anti-inflammatory fatty acids to moderate the apparently uncontrolled inflammatory response in the heart tissue associated with both diseases and also alleviate the secondary hepatic lesions. The experimental work consisted of three major dietary trials in Atlantic salmon in seawater. Two large trials investigated the effects of functional feeds in Atlantic salmon challenged with Atlantic salmon piscine reovirus (ASRV) and piscine myocarditis virus (PMCV), the causal agents of HSMI and CMS, respectively. In both trials, heart transcriptome, heart and liver histopathology and tissue lipid and fatty acid compositions and metabolism were determined post-infection in fish fed with the functional feeds in comparison with fish fed with a standard commercial feed formulation considered as a reference diet. All the functional feeds were formulated to have reduced digestible energy through lower dietary lipid and higher protein contents, and increased levels and proportions of anti-inflammatory long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids (LC-PUFA), particularly eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) compared with the reference diets. Histopathology, fatty acid composition and gene expression of heart were assessed over a long time-period of 16 weeks and 14 weeks post-challenge with ASRV and PMCV, respectively. Viral load in heart tissue, hepatic histopathology and fatty acid composition of liver and head kidney along with expression of the genes involved in the eicosanoid and LC-PUFA and eicosanoid biosynthesis pathways were also determined in the HSMI trial. The third trial was a nutritional trial evaluating the effects of dietary digestible energy content on lipid and fatty acid metabolism in salmon fed diets containing graded amounts of lipid. Fatty acid composition of liver and heart were assessed over 12 weeks, along with the hepatic expression of genes of lipid and fatty acid metabolism. The results of this research are presented in four chapters (Chapters 2-5) as four paper manuscripts. The manuscripts/Papers are either published (Chapter 2), in review (Chapter 3 and 4) or drafted for submission (Chapter 5) in appropriate peer-reviewed international journals. Chapter 2 and 3 correspond to the HSMI trial, Chapter 4 to the nutritional trial, and Chapter 5 to the CMS trial. Chapter 2 showed that viral load and histopathology scores were lower in fish fed the functional feeds, especially diet FF1, which displayed better performance. Diet strongly influenced the expression of genes related with the immune and inflammatory responses, with delayed expression in fish fed the functional feeds. Up-regulation of pro-inflammatory genes was correlated with the higher viral load observed at early-mid stages of the disease in fish fed the reference diet (ST). Expression of genes related with the immune response at 16-weeks post challenge reflected the differences in immunomodulation between the functional feeds, with fish fed diet FF1 showing lower expression. Therefore, severity of the heart lesions was correlated with the intensity of the immune response and could be associated with tissue anti-inflammatory LC-PUFA levels. Chapter 3 was focused on liver histopathology, fatty acid composition and LC-PUFA biosynthesis, along with phospholipid fatty acid composition and eicosanoid production in head kidney and heart tissue at early and late stages of ASRV infection. Liver was severely affected by the virus at the beginning of the infection in fish fed the reference ST diet, but the level of lesions were similar in all dietary groups at the end of the trial. Hepatic expression of fatty acyl desaturases was significantly depressed in fish fed the ST diet compare with fish fed the functional feeds despite the lower levels of dietary LC-PUFA in that feed. Thus endogenous production and bioavailability of anti-inflammatory LC-PUFA was potentially enhanced in fish fed the functional feeds. Changes in tissue lipid content, mobilization of fatty acids involved in inflammatory responses and changes in expression of transcription factors and genes involved in eicosanoid biosynthesis were more prominent in head kidney, confirming the important role of this organ in dietary immunomodulation after viral infection. To a lesser extent similar changes were observed in heart tissue, suggesting in situ production of eicosanoids could also be important. The unexpected effects of diet on expression of genes of LC-PUFA biosynthesis were specifically investigated in the trial described in Chapter 4. One aim of this study was to clarify whether dietary lipid content or viral infection was the cause of altered expression of desaturase genes between the different diets. Hepatic expression of other genes of lipid and fatty acid metabolism were also determined to evaluate metabolic changes associated with dietary lipid/energy level. In general, reduction of dietary energy and lipid contents while maintaining similar proportions of dietary fatty acids, led to a general up-regulation of genes involved in lipid biosynthetic pathways. Thus salmon fed lower energy diet showed increased liver expression of fatty acyl desaturases in comparison with fish fed higher energy levels. Heart transcriptomic data in Chapter 5 showed a similar delay in the inflammatory response in fish fed the functional feeds after PCMV infection as observed in the HSMI study. Modulation of inflammatory responses, similar to that previously described after ASRV infection, was also observed in fish fed the functional feeds. However, the differences in the expression of immune related genes and the level of heart lesions were not as prominent at mid-late stages of the disease as in fish fed FF1 in the HSMI trial. The present study demonstrated the beneficial effects of a clinical nutrition approach via functional feeds in two viral inflammatory diseases, HSMI and CMS, currently affecting farmed Atlantic salmon. Dietary immunomodulation increased the availability of anti-inflammatory LC-PUFA and significantly influenced the expression of the genes related with the immune/inflammatory response reducing the level and severity of cardiac and liver lesions and therefore improving the performance of fish suffering the diseases

Om unntaket fra forskrift om offentlige anskaffelser for visse FOU-kontrakter

FOU-tjenester der oppdragsgiver ikke fullt ut betaler for tjenesten eller den ikke fullt ut tilfaller oppdragsgiver til bruk i dennes virksomhet, vil være unntatt anskaffelsesforskriften, jfr. § 1-3 (2) bokstav g. En slik tjeneste må innebære et element av forskning eller utvikling. Med dette menes at leverandøren må bidra til utvikling av kompetanse eller teknologi. Ren kartlegging, utredning eller faglig rådgivning basert på kunnskap som er kjent fra tidligere, vil ikke være omfattet av FOU-begrepet. Når en anskaffelse innfrir kravene til en unntaksbestemmelse angitt i anskaffelsesforskriften, vil hele anskaffelsesprosessen være unntatt de detaljerte reglene i forskriften. Lov om offentlige anskaffelser vil imidlertid gjelde. Den viktigste konsekvensen av dette er at oppdragsgiver er pålagt å innfri grunnleggende krav til anskaffelsen, slik de er nedfelt i offanskl. § 5. Dermed kan ikke oppdragsgiver unndra seg viktige prinsipper som likebehandling, objektivitet og gjennomsiktighet. Det skal også gjennomføres konkurranse så langt det er mulig. Kravene i offanskl. vil derfor medføre at det må stilles noen konkrete krav til anskaffelsesprosessen, som skriftlighet, utforming av konkurransegrunnlag, begrunnelsesplikt mv. Videre vil kontrakter som er unntatt anskaffelsesforskriften, være underlagt annet regelverk som regulerer offentlig virksomhet. En viktig fordel med unntaket fra anskaffelsesforskriften for de aktuelle forsknings- og utviklingstjenestene, er at man med dette kan styrke produksjon og industri i EØS-området, slik at aktører i EUs indre marked blir konkurransedyktige. Den største ulempen er at man ved ikke å følge anskaffelsesforskriftens prosedyreregler i større grad står i fare for å bryte viktige anbuds- og saksbehandlingsprinsipper