371 research outputs found
On multi-objective stochastic user equilibrium
There is extensive empirical evidence that travellers consider many 'qualities' (travel time, tolls, reliability, etc.) when choosing between alternative routes. Two main approaches exist to deal with this in network assignment models: Combine all qualities into a single (linear) utility function, or solve a multi-objective problem. The former has the advantages of a unique solution and efficient algorithms; the latter, however, is more general, but leads to many solutions and is difficult to implement in larger systems. In the present paper we present three alternative approaches for combining the principles of multi-objective decision-making with a stochastic user equilibrium model based on random utility theory. The aim is to deduce a tractable, analytic method. The three methods are compared both in terms of their theoretical principles, and in terms of the implied trade-offs, illustrated through simple numerical examples
Recommended from our members
Modeling and optimizing network infrastructure for autonomous vehicles
Autonomous vehicle (AV) technology has matured sufficiently to be in testing on public roads. However, traffic models of AVs are still in development. Most previous work has studied AV technologies in micro-simulation. The purpose of this dissertation is to model and optimize AV technologies for large city networks to predict how AVs might affect city traffic patterns and travel behaviors. To accomplish these goals, we construct a dynamic network loading model for AVs, consisting of link and node models of AV technologies, which is used to calculate time-dependent travel times in dynamic traffic assignment. We then study several applications of the dynamic network loading to predict how AVs might affect travel demand and traffic congestion. AVs admit reduced perception-reaction times through technologies such as (cooperative) adaptive cruise control, which can reduce following headways and increase capacity. Previous work has studied these in micro-simulation, but we construct a mesoscopic simulation model for analyses on large networks. To study scenarios with both autonomous and conventional vehicles, we modify the kinematic wave theory to include multiple classes of flow. The flow-density relationship also changes in space and time with the class proportions. We present multiclass cell transmission model and prove that it is a Godunov approximation to the multiclass kinematic wave theory. We also develop a car-following model to predict the fundamental diagram at arbitrary proportions of AVs. Complete market penetration scenarios admit dynamic lane reversal -- changing lane direction at high frequencies to more optimally allocate road capacity. We develop a kinematic wave theory in which the number of lanes changes in space and time, and approximately solve it with a cell transmission model. We study two methods of determining lane direction. First, we present a mixed integer linear program for system optimal dynamic traffic assignment. Since this program is computationally difficult to solve, we also study dynamic lane reversal on a single link with deterministic and stochastic demands. The resulting policy is shown to significantly reduce travel times on a city network. AVs also admit reservation-based intersection control, which can make greater use of intersection capacity than traffic signals. AVs communicate with the intersection manager to reserve space-time paths through the intersection. We create a mesoscopic node model by starting with the conflict point variant of reservations and aggregating conflict points into capacity-constrained conflict regions. This model yields an integer program that can be adapted to arbitrary objective functions. To motivate optimization, we present several examples on theoretical and realistic networks demonstrating that naïve reservation policies can perform worse than traffic signals. These occur due to asymmetric intersections affecting optimal capacity allocation and/or user equilibrium route choice behavior. To improve reservations, we adapt the decentralized backpressure wireless packet routing and P0 traffic signal policies for reservations. Results show significant reductions in travel times on a city network. Having developed link and node models, we explore how AVs might affect travel demand and congestion. First, we study how capacity increases and reservations might affect freeway, arterial, and city networks. Capacity increases consistently reduced congestion on all networks, but reservations were not always beneficial. Then, we use dynamic traffic assignment within a four-step planning model, adding the mode choice of empty repositioning trips to avoid parking costs. Results show that allowing empty repositioning to encourage adoption of AVs could reduce congestion. Also, once all vehicles are AVs, congestion will still be significantly reduced. Finally, we present a framework to use the dynamic network loading model to study shared AVs. Results show that shared AVs could reduce congestion if used in certain ways, such as with dynamic ride-sharing. However, shared AVs also cause significant congestion. To summarize, this dissertation presents a complete mesoscopic simulation model of AVs that could be used for a variety of studies of AVs by planners and practitioners. This mesoscopic model includes new node and link technologies that significantly improve travel times over existing infrastructure. In addition, we motivate and present more optimal policies for these AV technologies. Finally, we study several travel behavior scenarios to provide insights about how AV technologies might affect future traffic congestion. The models in this dissertation will provide a basis for future network analyses of AV technologies.Civil, Architectural, and Environmental Engineerin
Multimodal urban mobility and multilayer transport networks
Transportation networks, from bicycle paths to buses and railways, are the
backbone of urban mobility. In large metropolitan areas, the integration of
different transport modes has become crucial to guarantee the fast and
sustainable flow of people. Using a network science approach, multimodal
transport systems can be described as multilayer networks, where the networks
associated to different transport modes are not considered in isolation, but as
a set of interconnected layers. Despite the importance of multimodality in
modern cities, a unified view of the topic is currently missing. Here, we
provide a comprehensive overview of the emerging research areas of multilayer
transport networks and multimodal urban mobility, focusing on contributions
from the interdisciplinary fields of complex systems, urban data science, and
science of cities. First, we present an introduction to the mathematical
framework of multilayer networks. We apply it to survey models of multimodal
infrastructures, as well as measures used for quantifying multimodality, and
related empirical findings. We review modelling approaches and observational
evidence in multimodal mobility and public transport system dynamics, focusing
on integrated real-world mobility patterns, where individuals navigate urban
systems using different transport modes. We then provide a survey of freely
available datasets on multimodal infrastructure and mobility, and a list of
open source tools for their analyses. Finally, we conclude with an outlook on
open research questions and promising directions for future research.Comment: 31 pages, 4 figure
Recommended from our members
Modeling Choice Problems with Heterogeneous User Preferences in the Transportation Network
Users of transportation systems need to make a variety of different decisions for their trips in the network, while their objective is to keep the generalized costs of their own trips minimized. In the transportation network, there is a diversity of different factors that can influence the decisions of the users, while the relative importance of these factors varies among the heterogeneous users with different trip purposes. Nonetheless, the cumulative result of the individual decisions of the users seeking to minimize their costs according to their own preferences leads to the user equilibrium condition in which no one can reduce his/her cost by changing his/her decision. In this research, we adapt the concept of the efficient frontier from portfolio theory (Markowitz, 1952) in finance in order to model the bicriterion choice behavior of users with heterogeneous preferences in transportation networks. We show that the efficient frontier has a set of primary properties that remains general in different problems. Thus, the primary properties of the efficient frontier can be employed to analytically model and solve different bicriterion choice problems in transportation.
For the first application, we use these properties to propose an analytical model for the morning commute problem when there is a heterogeneity associated with preferences of the users (Vickrey, 1969; Daganzo, 1985). A dynamic pricing strategy is also proposed to optimize the bottleneck by minimizing the total cost for users. In addition to the morning commute problem, Vickrey’s congestion theory is also shown to have applications in modeling and optimizing the operation of the demand responsive transit (DRT) system with time-dependent demand and state-dependent capacity as queueing systems. The efficiency of the DRT system can be improved by implementing a dynamic pricing strategy. The analytical solution of the morning commute problem can be also extended for modeling and pricing the DRT system when there is a heterogeneity associated with the preferences of the DRT service users.
For another application of the efficient frontier in modeling choice problems in transportation, we propose a traffic assignment model to account for the heterogeneity in sensitivity of the users to travel time reliability in a network under travel time variability. However, the proposed model can have wide applications in modeling the equilibrium condition of different multicriterion choice problems in transportation
Models and Solution Algorithms for Asymmetric Traffic and Transit Assignment Problems
Modeling the transportation system is important because it provides a “common ground” for discussing policy and examining the future transportation plan required in practices. Generally, modeling is a simplified representation of the real world; however, this research added value to the modeling practice by investigating the asymmetric interactions observed in the real world in order to explore potential improvements of the transportation modeling.
The Asymmetric Transportation Equilibrium Problem (ATEP) is designed to precisely model actual transportation systems by considering asymmetric interactions of flows. The enhanced representation of the transportation system by the ATEP is promising because there are various asymmetric interactions in real transportation such as intersections, highway ramps, and toll roads and in the structure of the transit fares.
This dissertation characterizes the ATEP with an appropriate solution algorithm and its applications. First, the research investigates the factors affecting the convergence of the ATEP. The double projection method is applied to various asymmetric types and complexities in the different sizes of networks in order to identify the influential factors including demand intensities, network configuration, route composition between modes, and sensitivity of the cost function. Secondly, the research develops an enhancement strategy for improvement in computational speed for the double projection method. The structural characteristics of the ATEP are used to develop the convergence enhancement strategy that significantly reduces the computational burdens.
For the application side, instances of asymmetric interactions observed in in-vehicle crowding and the transit fare structure are modeled to provide a suggestion on policy approach for a transit agency. The direct application of the crowding model into the real network indicates that crowd modeling with multi user classes could influence the public transportation system planning and the revenue achievement of transit agencies. Moreover, addition of the disutility factor, crowding, not always causes the increase of disutility from the transit uses. The application of the non-additive fare structure in the Utah Transit Authority (UTA) network addresses the potential of the distance-based fare structure should the UTA make a transition to this fare structure from their current fare model. The analysis finds that the zero base fare has the highest potential for increasing the transit demand. However, collecting less than $0.50 with a certain buffer distance for the first boarding has potential for attracting the users to UTA\u27s transit market upon the fare structure change
Optimal Design of Signal Controlled Road Networks Using Differential Evolution Optimization Algorithm
This study proposes a traffic congestion minimization model in which the traffic signal setting optimization is performed through a combined simulation-optimization model. In this model, the TRANSYT traffic simulation software is combined with Differential Evolution (DE) optimization algorithm, which is based on the natural selection paradigm. In this context, the EQuilibrium Network Design (EQND) problem is formulated as a bilevel programming problem in which the upper level is the minimization of the total network performance index. In the lower level, the traffic assignment problem, which represents the route choice behavior of the road users, is solved using the Path Flow Estimator (PFE) as a stochastic user equilibrium assessment. The solution of the bilevel EQND problem is carried out by the proposed Differential Evolution and TRANSYT with PFE, the so-called DETRANSPFE model, on a well-known signal controlled test network. Performance of the proposed model is compared to that of two previous works where the EQND problem has been solved by Genetic-Algorithms- (GAs-) and Harmony-Search- (HS-) based models. Results show that the DETRANSPFE model outperforms the GA- and HS-based models in terms of the network performance index and the computational time required
Handling multiple objectives in optimization of externalities as objectives for dynamic traffic management.
Dynamic traffic management (DTM) is acknowledged in various policy documents as an important instrument to improve network performance. This network performance is not only a matter of accessibility, since the externalities of traffic are becoming more and more important objectives as well. Optimization of network performance using DTM measures is a specific example of a network design problem (NDP) and incorporation of externality objectives results in a multi objective network design problem (MO NDP)). Solving this problem resorts in a Pareto optimal set of solutions. A framework is presented with the non-dominated sorting algorithm (NSGAII), the Streamline dynamic traffic assignment model and several externality models, that is used to solve this MO NDP. With a numerical experiment it is shown that the Pareto optimal set provides important information for the decision making process, which would not have been available if the optimization problem was simplified by incorporation of a compensation principle in advance. However, in the end a solution has to be chosen as the best compromise. Since the Pareto optimal set can be difficult to comprehend, ranking it may be necessary to assist the decision makers. Cost benefit analysis which uses the economic compensation principle is a method that is often used for ranking the alternatives. This research shows, that travel time costs are by far the most dominant objective. Therefore other ranking methods should be considered. Differences between these methods are explained and it is illustrated that the outcomes and therefore the eventual decisions taken can be different
- …