31 research outputs found
Convolutional Neural Networks for Epileptic Seizure Prediction
Epilepsy is the most common neurological disorder and an accurate forecast of
seizures would help to overcome the patient's uncertainty and helplessness. In
this contribution, we present and discuss a novel methodology for the
classification of intracranial electroencephalography (iEEG) for seizure
prediction. Contrary to previous approaches, we categorically refrain from an
extraction of hand-crafted features and use a convolutional neural network
(CNN) topology instead for both the determination of suitable signal
characteristics and the binary classification of preictal and interictal
segments. Three different models have been evaluated on public datasets with
long-term recordings from four dogs and three patients. Overall, our findings
demonstrate the general applicability. In this work we discuss the strengths
and limitations of our methodology.Comment: accepted for MLESP 201
Towards improved design and evaluation of epileptic seizure predictors
AbstractâObjective: Key issues in the epilepsy seizure prediction research are (1) the reproducibility of results (2) the
inability to compare multiple approaches directly. To overcome these problems, the Seizure Prediction Challenge was organized on Kaggle.com. It aimed at establishing benchmarks on a dataset with predefined train, validation and test sets. Our main objective is to analyse the competition format, and to propose improvements, which would facilitate a better comparison of algorithms. The second objective is to present a novel deep learning approach to seizure prediction and compare it to other commonly used methods using patient centered metrics. Methods: We used the competitionâs datasets to illustrate the effects of data contamination. Having better data partitions, we compared three types of models in terms of different objectives. Results: We found that correct selection of test samples is crucial when evaluating
the performance of seizure forecasting models. Moreover, we showed that models, which achieve state-of-the-art performance with respect to commonly used AUC, sensitivity and specificity metrics, may not yet be suitable for practical usage because of low precision scores. Conclusion: Correlation between validation and test datasets used in the competition limited its scientific value. Significance: Our findings provide guidelines which allow for a more objective evaluation of seizure prediction models
Towards Accurate Forecasting of Epileptic Seizures: Artificial Intelligence and Effective Connectivity Findings
LâĂ©pilepsie est une des maladies neurologiques les plus frĂ©quentes, touchant prĂšs dâun
pourcent de la population mondiale. De nos jours, bien quâenviron deux tiers des patients
Ă©pileptiques rĂ©pondent adĂ©quatement aux traitements pharmacologiques, il reste quâun tiers des
patients doivent vivre avec des crises invalidantes et imprévisibles. Quoique la chirurgie
dâĂ©pilepsie puisse ĂȘtre une autre option thĂ©rapeutique envisageable, le recours Ă la chirurgie de
résection demeure trÚs faible en partie pour des raisons diverses (taux de réussite modeste, peur
des complications, perceptions nĂ©gatives). Dâautres avenues de traitement sont donc souhaitables.
Une piste actuellement explorĂ©e par des groupes de chercheurs est de tenter de prĂ©dire les crises Ă
partir dâenregistrements de lâactivitĂ© cĂ©rĂ©brale des patients. La capacitĂ© de prĂ©dire la survenue de
crises permettrait notamment aux patients, aidants naturels ou personnels médical de prendre des
mesures de prĂ©caution pour Ă©viter les dĂ©sagrĂ©ments reliĂ©s aux crises voire mĂȘme instaurer un
traitement pour les faire avorter. Au cours des derniĂšres annĂ©es, dâimportants efforts ont Ă©tĂ©
dĂ©ployĂ©s pour dĂ©velopper des algorithmes de prĂ©diction de crises et dâen amĂ©liorer les
performances.
Toutefois, le manque dâenregistrements Ă©lectroencĂ©phalographiques intracrĂąniens (iEEG) de
longue durée de qualité, la quantité limitée de crises, ainsi que la courte durée des périodes
interictales constituaient des obstacles majeurs à une évaluation adéquate de la performance des
algorithmes de prĂ©diction de crises. RĂ©cemment, la disponibilitĂ© en ligne dâenregistrements iEEG
continus avec échantillonnage bilatéral (des deux hémisphÚres) acquis chez des chiens atteints
dâĂ©pilepsie focale Ă lâaide du dispositif de surveillance ambulatoire implantable NeuroVista a
partiellement facilitĂ© cette tĂąche. Cependant, une des limitations associĂ©es Ă lâutilisation de ces
donnĂ©es durant la conception dâun algorithme de prĂ©diction de crises Ă©tait lâabsence
dâinformation concernant la zone exacte de dĂ©but des crises (information non fournie par les
gestionnaires de cette base de données en ligne). Le premier objectif de cette thÚse était la mise
en oeuvre dâun algorithme prĂ©cis de prĂ©diction de crises basĂ© sur des enregistrements iEEG canins
de longue durée. Les principales contributions à cet égard incluent une localisation quantitative
de la zone dâapparition des crises (basĂ©e sur la fonction de transfert dirigĂ© âDTF), lâutilisation
dâune nouvelle fonction de coĂ»t via lâalgorithme gĂ©nĂ©tique proposĂ©, ainsi quâune Ă©valuation
quasi-prospective des performances de prĂ©diction (donnĂ©es de test dâun total de 893 jours). Les rĂ©sultats ont montrĂ© une amĂ©lioration des performances de prĂ©diction par rapport aux Ă©tudes
antérieures, atteignant une sensibilité moyenne de 84.82 % et un temps en avertissement de 10 %.
La DTF, utilisée précédemment comme mesure de connectivité pour déterminer le réseau
épileptique (objectif 1), a été préalablement validée pour quantifier les relations causales entre les
canaux lorsque les exigences de quasi-stationnarité sont satisfaites. Ceci est possible dans le cas
des enregistrements canins en raison du nombre relativement faible de canaux. Pour faire face
aux exigences de non-stationnarité, la fonction de transfert adaptatif pondérée par le spectre
(Spectrum weighted adaptive directed transfer function - swADTF) a Ă©tĂ© introduit en tant quâune
version variant dans le temps de la DTF. Le second objectif de cette thĂšse Ă©tait de valider la
possibilitĂ© dâidentifier les endroits Ă©metteurs (ou sources) et rĂ©cepteurs dâactivitĂ© Ă©pileptiques en
appliquant la swADTF sur des enregistrements iEEG de haute densité provenant de patients
admis pour Ă©valuation prĂ©-chirurgicale au CHUM. Les gĂ©nĂ©rateurs dâactivitĂ© Ă©pileptique Ă©taient
dans le volume réséqué pour les patients ayant des bons résultats post-chirurgicaux alors que
différents foyers ont été identifiés chez les patients ayant eu de mauvais résultats postchirurgicaux.
Ces rĂ©sultats dĂ©montrent la possibilitĂ© dâune identification prĂ©cise des sources et
rĂ©cepteurs dâactivitĂ©s Ă©pileptiques au moyen de la swADTF ouvrant la porte Ă la possibilitĂ© dâune
meilleure sĂ©lection dâĂ©lectrodes de maniĂšre quantitative dans un contexte de dĂ©veloppement
dâalgorithme de prĂ©diction de crises chez lâhumain.
Dans le but dâexplorer de nouvelles avenues pour la prĂ©diction de crises Ă©pileptiques, un
nouveau prĂ©curseur a aussi Ă©tĂ© Ă©tudiĂ© combinant lâanalyse des spectres dâordre supĂ©rieur et les
réseaux de neurones artificiels (objectif 3). Les résultats ont montré des différences
statistiquement significatives (p<0.05) entre lâĂ©tat prĂ©ictal et lâĂ©tat interictal en utilisant chacune
des caractéristiques extraites du bi-spectre. Utilisées comme entrées à un perceptron multicouche,
lâentropie bispectrale normalisĂ©e, lâentropie carrĂ© normalisĂ©e, et la moyenne ont atteint des
précisions respectives de 78.11 %, 72.64% et 73.26%.
Les résultats de cette thÚse confirment la faisabilité de prédiction de crises à partir
dâenregistrements dâĂ©lectroencĂ©phalographie intracrĂąniens. Cependant, des efforts
supplĂ©mentaires en termes de sĂ©lection dâĂ©lectrodes, dâextraction de caractĂ©ristiques, dâutilisation
des techniques dâapprentissage profond et dâimplĂ©mentation Hardware, sont nĂ©cessaires avant
lâintĂ©gration de ces approches dans les dispositifs implantables commerciaux.----------ABSTRACT
Epilepsy is a chronic condition characterized by recurrent âunpredictableâ seizures. While
the first line of treatment consists of long-term drug therapy about one-third of patients are said to
be pharmacoresistant. In addition, recourse to epilepsy surgery remains low in part due to
persisting negative attitudes towards resective surgery, fear of complications and only moderate
success rates. An important direction of research is to investigate the possibility of predicting
seizures which, if achieved, can lead to novel interventional avenues.
The paucity of intracranial electroencephalography (iEEG) recordings, the limited number of
ictal events, and the short duration of interictal periods have been important obstacles for an
adequate assessment of seizure forecasting. More recently, long-term continuous bilateral iEEG
recordings acquired from dogs with naturally occurring focal epilepsy, using the implantable
NeuroVista ambulatory monitoring device have been made available on line for the benefit of
researchers. Still, an important limitation of these recordings for seizure-prediction studies was
that the seizure onset zone was not disclosed/available. The first objective of this thesis was to
develop an accurate seizure forecasting algorithm based on these canine ambulatory iEEG
recordings. Main contributions include a quantitative, directed transfer function (DTF)-based,
localization of the seizure onset zone (electrode selection), a new fitness function for the
proposed genetic algorithm (feature selection), and a quasi-prospective assessment of seizure
forecasting on long-term continuous iEEG recordings (total of 893 testing days). Results showed
performance improvement compared to previous studies, achieving an average sensitivity of
84.82% and a time in warning of 10 %.
The DTF has been previously validated for quantifying causal relations when quasistationarity
requirements are met. Although such requirements can be fulfilled in the case of
canine recordings due to the relatively low number of channels (objective 1), the identification of
stationary segments would be more challenging in the case of high density iEEG recordings. To
cope with non-stationarity issues, the spectrum weighted adaptive directed transfer function
(swADTF) was recently introduced as a time-varying version of the DTF. The second objective
of this thesis was to validate the feasibility of identifying sources and sinks of seizure activity
based on the swADTF using high-density iEEG recordings of patients admitted for pre-surgical monitoring at the CHUM. Generators of seizure activity were within the resected volume for
patients with good post-surgical outcomes, whereas different or additional seizure foci were
identified in patients with poor post-surgical outcomes. Results confirmed the possibility of
accurate identification of seizure origin and propagation by means of swADTF paving the way
for its use in seizure prediction algorithms by allowing a more tailored electrode selection.
Finally, in an attempt to explore new avenues for seizure forecasting, we proposed a new
precursor of seizure activity by combining higher order spectral analysis and artificial neural
networks (objective 3). Results showed statistically significant differences (p<0.05) between
preictal and interictal states using all the bispectrum-extracted features. Normalized bispectral
entropy, normalized squared entropy and mean of magnitude, when employed as inputs to a
multi-layer perceptron classifier, achieved held-out test accuracies of 78.11%, 72.64%, and
73.26%, respectively.
Results of this thesis confirm the feasibility of seizure forecasting based on iEEG recordings;
the transition into the ictal state is not random and consists of a âbuild-upâ, leading to seizures.
However, additional efforts in terms of electrode selection, feature extraction, hardware and deep
learning implementation, are required before the translation of current approaches into
commercial devices
A Performance Comparison of Neural Network and SVM Classifiers Using EEG Spectral Features to Predict Epileptic Seizures
Epilepsy is one of the most common neurological disorders, and aïŹicts approximately 70 million people globally. 30-40% of patients have refractory epilepsy, where seizures cannot be controlled by anti-epileptic medication, and surgery is neither appropriate, nor available. The unpredictable nature of epileptic seizures is the primary cause of mortality among patients, and leads to signiïŹcant psychosocial disability. If seizures could be predicted in advance, automatic seizure warning systems could transform the lives of millions of people. This study presents a performance comparison of artiïŹcial neural network and sup port vector machine classiïŹers, using EEG spectral features to predict the onset of epileptic seizures. In addition, the study also examines the inïŹuence of EEG window size, feature selection, and data sampling on classiïŹcation performance. A total of 216 generalised models were trained and tested on a public seizure database, which contained over 1300 hours of EEG data from 7 subjects. The results showed that ANN outperform SVM, when using spectral features (p = 0.035). The beta and gamma frequency bands were shown to be the best predictors of seizure onset. No signiïŹcant diïŹerences in performance were determined for the dif ferent window sizes, or for the feature selection methods. The data sampling method signiïŹcantly inïŹuenced the performance (p \u3c 0.001), and highlighted the importance of treating class imbalance in EEG datasets
Bispectrum and recurrent neural networks: Improved classification of interictal and preictal states
This work proposes a novel approach for the classification of interictal and preictal brain states based on bispectrum analysis and recurrent Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) neural networks. Two features were first extracted from bilateral intracranial electroencephalography (iEEG) recordings of dogs with naturally occurring focal epilepsy. Single-layer LSTM networks were trained to classify 5-min long feature vectors as preictal or interictal. Classification performances were compared to previous work involving multilayer perceptron networks and higher-order spectral (HOS) features on the same dataset. The proposed LSTM network proved superior to the multilayer perceptron network and achieved an average classification accuracy of 86.29% on held-out data. Results imply the possibility of forecasting epileptic seizures using recurrent neural networks, with minimal feature extraction
Machine learning from wristband sensor data for wearable, noninvasive seizure forecasting
Objective:
Seizure forecasting may provide patients with timely warnings to adapt their daily activities and help clinicians deliver more objective, personalized treatments. Although recent work has convincingly demonstrated that seizure risk assessment is in principle possible, these early approaches relied largely on complex, often invasive setups including intracranial electrocorticography, implanted devices, and multichannel electroencephalography, and required patient-specific adaptation or learning to perform optimally, all of which limit translation to broad clinical application. To facilitate broader adaptation of seizure forecasting in clinical practice, noninvasive, easily applicable techniques that reliably assess seizure risk without much prior tuning are crucial. Wristbands that continuously record physiological parameters, including electrodermal activity, body temperature, blood volume pulse, and actigraphy, may afford monitoring of autonomous nervous system function and movement relevant for such a task, hence minimizing potential complications associated with invasive monitoring and avoiding stigma associated with bulky external monitoring devices on the head.
Methods:
Here, we applied deep learning on multimodal wristband sensor data from 69 patients with epilepsy (total duration > 2311 hours, 452 seizures) to assess its capability to forecast seizures in a statistically significant way.
Results:
Using a leave-one-subject-out cross-validation approach, we identified better-than-chance predictability in 43% of the patients. Time-matched seizure surrogate data analyses indicated forecasting not to be driven simply by time of day or vigilance state. Prediction performance peaked when all sensor modalities were used, and did not differ between generalized and focal seizure types, but generally increased with the size of the training dataset, indicating potential further improvement with larger datasets in the future.
Significance:
Collectively, these results show that statistically significant seizure risk assessments are feasible from easy-to-use, noninvasive wearable devices without the need of patient-specific training or parameter optimization
Prediction of canine epilepsy
Seizure prediction is a problem in biomedical science which now is possible to solve with machine learning methods. A seizure prediction system has the power to assist those affected by epilepsy in better managing their medication, daily activities and improving the quality of life. Usage of machine learning algorithms and the availability of long term Intracranial Electroencephalographic (iEEG) recordings have tremendously reduced the complications involved in the challenging seizure prediction problem. Data, in the form of iEEG was collected from canines with naturally occurring epilepsy for the analysis and a seizure prediction system consisting of a machine learning based pipeline was implemented to generate seizure warnings when potential preictal activity is observed in the iEEG recording. A comparison between the different extracted features, dimensionality reduction techniques, and machine learning techniques was performed to investigate the relative effectiveness of the different techniques in the application of seizure prediction. The machine learning protocol performed significantly better than a chance prediction algorithm in all the analyzed subjects. Moreover, the analysis revealed subject-specific neurophysiological changes in the extracted features prior to lead seizures suggesting the existence of a distinct, identifiable preictal state