REINFORCED ENCODING FOR PLANNING AS SAT

Solving planning problems via translation to satisfiability (SAT) is one of the most successful approaches to automated planning. We propose a new encoding scheme, called Reinforced Encoding, which encodes a planning problem represented in the SAS+ formalism into SAT. The Reinforced Encoding is a combination of the transition-based SASE encoding with the classical propositional encoding. In our experiments we compare our new encoding to other known SAS+ based encodings. The results indicate, that he Reinforced encoding performs well on the benchmark problems of the 2011 International Planning Competition and can outperform all the other known encodings for several domains

Partial Weighted MaxSAT for Optimal Planning

Abstract. We consider the problem of computing optimal plans for proposi-tional planning problems with action costs. In the spirit of leveraging advances in general-purpose automated reasoning for that setting, we develop an approach that operates by solving a sequence of partial weighted MaxSAT problems, each of which corresponds to a step-bounded variant of the problem at hand. Our ap-proach is the first SAT-based system in which a proof of cost-optimality is ob-tained using a MaxSAT procedure. It is also the first system of this kind to incor-porate an admissible planning heuristic. We perform a detailed empirical eval-uation of our work using benchmarks from a number of International Planning Competitions.

Efficient Automated Planning with New Formulations

Problem solving usually strongly relies on how the problem is formulated. This fact also applies to automated planning, a key field in artificial intelligence research. Classical planning used to be dominated by STRIPS formulation, a simple model based on propositional logic. In the recently introduced SAS+ formulation, the multi-valued variables naturally depict certain invariants that are missed in STRIPS, make SAS+ have many favorable features. Because of its rich structural information SAS+ begins to attract lots of research interest. Existing works, however, are mostly limited to one single thing: to improve heuristic functions. This is in sharp contrast with the abundance of planning models and techniques in the field. On the other hand, although heuristic is a key part for search, its effectiveness is limited. Recent investigations have shown that even if we have almost perfect heuristics, the number of states to visit is still exponential. Therefore, there is a barrier between the nice features of SAS+ and its applications in planning algorithms. In this dissertation, we have recasted two major planning paradigms: state space search and planning as Satisfiability: SAT), with three major contributions. First, we have utilized SAS+ for a new hierarchical state space search model by taking advantage of the decomposable structure within SAS+. This algorithm can greatly reduce the time complexity for planning. Second, planning as Satisfiability is a major planning approach, but it is traditionally based on STRIPS. We have developed a new SAS+ based SAT encoding scheme: SASE) for planning. The state space modeled by SASE shows a decomposable structure with certain components independent to others, showing promising structure that STRIPS based encoding does not have. Third, the expressiveness of planning is important for real world scenarios, thus we have also extended the planning as SAT to temporally expressive planning and planning with action costs, two advanced features beyond classical planning. The resulting planner is competitive to state-of-the-art planners, in terms of both quality and performance. Overall, our work strongly suggests a shifting trend of planning from STRIPS to SAS+, and shows the power of formulating planning problems as Satisfiability. Given the important roles of both classical planning and temporal planning, our work will inspire new developments in other advanced planning problem domains

SAT-Based Parallel Planning Using a Split Representation of Actions

Planning based on propositional SAT(isfiability) is a powerful approach to computing step-optimal plans given a parallel execution semantics. In this setting: (i) a solution plan must be minimal in the number of plan steps required, and (ii) non-conflicting actions can be executed instantaneously in parallel at a plan step. Underlying SAT-based approaches is the invocation of a decision procedure on a SAT encoding of a bounded version of the problem. A fundamental limitation of existing approaches is the size of these encodings. This problem stems from the use of a direct representation of actions — i.e. each action has a corresponding variable in the encoding. A longtime goal in planning has been to mitigate this limitation by developing a more compact split — also termed lifted — representation of actions in SAT encodings of parallel step-optimal problems. This paper describes such a representation. In particular, each action and each parallel execution of actions is represented uniquely as a conjunct of variables. Here, each variable is derived from action pre and post-conditions. Because multiple actions share conditions, our encoding of the planning constraints is factored and relatively compact. We find experimentally that our encoding yields a much more efficient and scalable planning procedure over the state-of-the-art in a large set of planning benchmarks

Modelling and Solving Problems Using SAT Techniques

Řešení problémů plánování prostřednictvím překladů do splnitelnosti (SAT) je jedním z nejúspěšnějších přístupů k automatickému plánování. V této práci popíšeme několik způsobů jak přeložit problém plánování reprezentovaný v SAS+ formalismu do SAT. Přezkoumáme a přizpůsobíme stávající kódování a také zavedeme nové vlastní způsoby kódování. Porovnáme jednotlivá kódování pomocí výpočtu horních odhadů na velikosti formulí, které produkují, a pomocí spuštění rozsáhlých experimentů na referenčních problémech z Mezinárodní plánovací soutěže 2011. V experimentální části také porovnáme své kódování s nejmodernejšími kódováními z plánovače Madagascar. Experimenty ukazují, že naše techniky dokažou překonat tato kódování. V předložené práci také řešíme speciální případ optimalizace plánů -- odstranění redundantních akcí. Odstranění všech redundantních akcí je NP- úplný problém. Prostudujeme existující polynomialní heuristické přístupy a navrhneme vlastní heuristický přístup, který dokaže eliminovat vyšší počet a dražší redundantní akce než stávající techniky. Také navrhneme způsob kódování problému redundance plánů do SAT, který nám za použití MaxSAT řešičů umožní optimálně vyřešit problém eliminace redundantních akcí. Naše experimenty provedené s plány od nejmodernejších satisficing plánovačů pro referenční problémy...Solving planning problems via translation to satisfiability (SAT) is one of the most successful approaches to automated planning. In this thesis we describe several ways of encoding a planning problem represented in the SAS+ formalism into SAT. We review and adapt existing encoding schemes as well as introduce new original encodings. We compare the encodings by calculating upper bounds on the size of the formulas they produce as well as by running extensive experiments on benchmark problems from the 2011 International Planning Competition (IPC). In the experimental section we also compare our encodings with the state-of-the-art encodings of the planner Madagascar. The experiments show, that our techniques can outperform these state-of-the-art encodings. In the presented thesis we also deal with a special case of post-planning optimization -- elimination of redundant actions. The elimination of all redundant actions is NP-complete. We review the existing polynomial heuristic approaches and propose our own heuristic approach which can eliminate a higher number and more costly redundant actions than the existing techniques. We also propose a SAT encoding for the problem of plan redundancy which together with MaxSAT solvers allows us to solve the problem of action elimination optimally. Experiments done with...Katedra teoretické informatiky a matematické logikyDepartment of Theoretical Computer Science and Mathematical LogicMatematicko-fyzikální fakultaFaculty of Mathematics and Physic