A Similarity Measure for Material Appearance

We present a model to measure the similarity in appearance between different materials, which correlates with human similarity judgments. We first create a database of 9,000 rendered images depicting objects with varying materials, shape and illumination. We then gather data on perceived similarity from crowdsourced experiments; our analysis of over 114,840 answers suggests that indeed a shared perception of appearance similarity exists. We feed this data to a deep learning architecture with a novel loss function, which learns a feature space for materials that correlates with such perceived appearance similarity. Our evaluation shows that our model outperforms existing metrics. Last, we demonstrate several applications enabled by our metric, including appearance-based search for material suggestions, database visualization, clustering and summarization, and gamut mapping.Comment: 12 pages, 17 figure

Leaming Visual Appearance: Perception, Modeling and Editing.

La apariencia visual determina como entendemos un objecto o imagen, y, por tanto, es un aspecto fundamental en la creación de contenido digital. Es un término general, englobando otros como la apariencia de los materiales, definida como la impresión que tenemos de un material, y la cual supone una interacción física entre luz y materia, y como nuestro sistema visual es capaz de percibirla. Sin embargo, modelar computacionalmente el comportamiento de nuestro sistema visual es una tarea difícil, entre otros motivos porque no existe una teoría definitiva y unificada sobre la percepción visual humana. Además, aunque hemos desarrollado algoritmos capaces de modelar fehacientemente la interacción entre luz y materia, existe una desconexión entre los parámetros físicos que usan estos algoritmos, y los parámetros perceptuales que el sistema visual humano entiende. Esto hace que manipular estas representaciones físicas, y sus interacciones, sea una tarea tediosa y costosa, incluso para usuarios expertos. Esta tesis busca mejorar nuestra comprensión de la percepción de la apariencia de materiales y usar dicho conocimiento para mejorar los algoritmos existentes para la generación de contenido visual. Específicamente, la tesis tiene contribuciones en tres áreas: proponiendo nuevos modelos computacionales para medir la similitud de apariencia; investigando la interacción entre iluminación y geometría; y desarrollando aplicaciones intuitivas para la manipulación de apariencia, en concreto, para el re-iluminado de humanos y para editar la apariencia de materiales.Una primera parte de la tesis explora métodos para medir la similaridad de apariencia. Ser capaces de medir cómo de similares son dos materiales, o imágenes, es un problema clásico en campos de la computación visual como visión por computador o informática gráfica. Abordamos primero el problema de similaridad en la apariencia de materiales. Proponemos un método basado en deep learning que combina imágenes con juicios subjetivos sobre la similitud de materiales, recogidos mediante estudios de usuario. Por otro lado, se explora el problema de la similaridad entre iconos. En este segundo caso, se hace uso de redes neuronales siamesas, y el estilo y la identidad que dan los artistas juega un papel clave en dicha medida de similaridad. La segunda parte avanza en la comprensión de cómo los factores de confusión (confounding factors) afectan a nuestra percepción de la apariencia de los materiales. Dos factores de confusión claves son la geometría de los objetos y la iluminación de la escena. Comenzamos investigando el efecto de dichos factores a la hora de reconocer los materiales a través de diversos experimentos y estudios estadísticos. También investigamos el efecto del movimiento del objeto en la percepción de la apariencia de materiales.En la tercera parte exploramos aplicaciones intuitivas para la manipulación de la apariencia visual. Primero, abordamos el problema de la re-iluminación de humanos. Proponemos una nueva formulación del problema, y basándonos en ella, se diseña y entrena un modelo basado en redes neuronales profundas para re-iluminar una escena. Por último, abordamos el problema de la edición intuitiva de materiales. Para ello, recopilamos juicios humanos sobre la percepción de diferentes atributos y presentamos un modelo, basado en redes neuronales profundas, capaz de editar materiales de forma realista simplemente variando el valor de los atributos recogidos.<br /

Communication of Digital Material Appearance Based on Human Perception

Im alltägliche Leben begegnen wir digitalen Materialien in einer Vielzahl von Situationen wie beispielsweise bei Computerspielen, Filmen, Reklamewänden in zB U-Bahn Stationen oder beim Online-Kauf von Kleidungen. Während einige dieser Materialien durch digitale Modelle repräsentiert werden, welche das Aussehen einer bestimmten Oberfläche in Abhängigkeit des Materials der Fläche sowie den Beleuchtungsbedingungen beschreiben, basieren andere digitale Darstellungen auf der simplen Verwendung von Fotos der realen Materialien, was zB bei Online-Shopping häufig verwendet wird. Die Verwendung von computer-generierten Materialien ist im Vergleich zu einzelnen Fotos besonders vorteilhaft, da diese realistische Erfahrungen im Rahmen von virtuellen Szenarien, kooperativem Produkt-Design, Marketing während der prototypischen Entwicklungsphase oder der Ausstellung von Möbeln oder Accesoires in spezifischen Umgebungen erlauben. Während mittels aktueller Digitalisierungsmethoden bereits eine beeindruckende Reproduktionsqualität erzielt wird, wird eine hochpräzise photorealistische digitale Reproduktion von Materialien für die große Vielfalt von Materialtypen nicht erreicht. Daher verwenden viele Materialkataloge immer noch Fotos oder sogar physikalische Materialproben um ihre Kollektionen zu repräsentieren. Ein wichtiger Grund für diese Lücke in der Genauigkeit des Aussehens von digitalen zu echten Materialien liegt darin, dass die Zusammenhänge zwischen physikalischen Materialeigenschaften und der vom Menschen wahrgenommenen visuellen Qualität noch weitgehend unbekannt sind. Die im Rahmen dieser Arbeit durchgeführten Untersuchungen adressieren diesen Aspekt. Zu diesem Zweck werden etablierte digitalie Materialmodellen bezüglich ihrer Eignung zur Kommunikation von physikalischen und sujektiven Materialeigenschaften untersucht, wobei Beobachtungen darauf hinweisen, dass ein Teil der fühlbaren/haptischen Informationen wie z.B. Materialstärke oder Härtegrad aufgrund der dem Modell anhaftenden geometrische Abstraktion verloren gehen. Folglich wird im Rahmen der Arbeit das Zusammenspiel der verschiedenen Sinneswahrnehmungen (mit Fokus auf die visuellen und akustischen Modalitäten) untersucht um festzustellen, welche Informationen während des Digitalisierungsprozesses verloren gehen. Es zeigt sich, dass insbesondere akustische Informationen in Kombination mit der visuellen Wahrnehmung die Einschätzung fühlbarer Materialeigenschaften erleichtert. Eines der Defizite bei der Analyse des Aussehens von Materialien ist der Mangel bezüglich sich an der Wahnehmung richtenden Metriken die eine Beantwortung von Fragen wie z.B. "Sind die Materialien A und B sich ähnlicher als die Materialien C und D?" erlauben, wie sie in vielen Anwendungen der Computergrafik auftreten. Daher widmen sich die im Rahmen dieser Arbeit durchgeführten Studien auch dem Vergleich von unterschiedlichen Materialrepräsentationen im Hinblick auf. Zu diesem Zweck wird eine Methodik zur Berechnung der wahrgenommenen paarweisen Ähnlichkeit von Material-Texturen eingeführt, welche auf der Verwendung von Textursyntheseverfahren beruht und sich an der Idee/dem Begriff der geradenoch-wahrnehmbaren Unterschiede orientiert. Der vorgeschlagene Ansatz erlaubt das Überwinden einiger Probleme zuvor veröffentlichter Methoden zur Bestimmung der Änhlichkeit von Texturen und führt zu sinnvollen/plausiblen Distanzen von Materialprobem. Zusammenfassend führen die im Rahmen dieser Dissertation dargestellten Inhalte/Verfahren zu einem tieferen Verständnis bezüglich der menschlichen Wahnehmung von digitalen bzw. realen Materialien über unterschiedliche Sinne, einem besseren Verständnis bzgl. der Bewertung der Ähnlichkeit von Texturen durch die Entwicklung einer neuen perzeptuellen Metrik und liefern grundlegende Einsichten für zukünftige Untersuchungen im Bereich der Perzeption von digitalen Materialien.In daily life, we encounter digital materials and interact with them in numerous situations, for instance when we play computer games, watch a movie, see billboard in the metro station or buy new clothes online. While some of these virtual materials are given by computational models that describe the appearance of a particular surface based on its material and the illumination conditions, some others are presented as simple digital photographs of real materials, as is usually the case for material samples from online retailing stores. The utilization of computer-generated materials entails significant advantages over plain images as they allow realistic experiences in virtual scenarios, cooperative product design, advertising in prototype phase or exhibition of furniture and wearables in specific environments. However, even though exceptional material reproduction quality has been achieved in the domain of computer graphics, current technology is still far away from highly accurate photo-realistic virtual material reproductions for the wide range of existing categories and, for this reason, many material catalogs still use pictures or even physical material samples to illustrate their collections. An important reason for this gap between digital and real material appearance is that the connections between physical material characteristics and the visual quality perceived by humans are far from well-understood. Our investigations intend to shed some light in this direction. Concretely, we explore the ability of state-of-the-art digital material models in communicating physical and subjective material qualities, observing that part of the tactile/haptic information (eg thickness, hardness) is missing due to the geometric abstractions intrinsic to the model. Consequently, in order to account for the information deteriorated during the digitization process, we investigate the interplay between different sensing modalities (vision and hearing) and discover that particular sound cues, in combination with visual information, facilitate the estimation of such tactile material qualities. One of the shortcomings when studying material appearance is the lack of perceptually-derived metrics able to answer questions like "are materials A and B more similar than C and D?", which arise in many computer graphics applications. In the absence of such metrics, our studies compare different appearance models in terms of how capable are they to depict/transmit a collection of meaningful perceptual qualities. To address this problem, we introduce a methodology to compute the perceived pairwise similarity between textures from material samples that makes use of patch-based texture synthesis algorithms and is inspired on the notion of Just-Noticeable Differences. Our technique is able to overcome some of the issues posed by previous texture similarity collection methods and produces meaningful distances between samples. In summary, with the contents presented in this thesis we are able to delve deeply in how humans perceive digital and real materials through different senses, acquire a better understanding of texture similarity by developing a perceptually-based metric and provide a groundwork for further investigations in the perception of digital materials

Material Visualisation for Virtual Reality: The Perceptual Investigations

Material representation plays a significant role in design visualisation and evaluation. On one hand, the simulated material properties determine the appearance of product prototypes in digitally rendered scenes. On the other hand, those properties are perceived by the viewers in order to make important design decisions. As an approach to simulate a more realistic environment, Virtual Reality (VR) provides users a vivid impression of depth and embodies them into an immersive environment. However, the scientific understanding of material perception and its applications in VR is still fairly limited. This leads to this thesis’s research question on whether the material perception in VR is different from that in traditional 2D displays, as well as the potential of using VR as a design tool to facilitate material evaluation.       This thesis is initiated from studying the perceptual difference of rendered materials between VR and traditional 2D viewing modes. Firstly, through a pilot study, it is confirmed that users have different perceptual experiences of the same material in the two viewing modes. Following that initial finding, the research investigates in more details the perceptual difference with psychophysics methods, which help in quantifying the users’ perceptual responses. Using the perceptual scale as a measuring means, the research analyses the users’ judgment and recognition of the material properties under VR and traditional 2D display environments. In addition, the research also elicits the perceptual evaluation criteria to analyse the emotional aspects of materials. The six perceptual criteria are in semantic forms, including rigidity, formality, fineness, softness, modernity, and irregularity.       The results showed that VR could support users in making a more refined judgment of material properties. That is to say, the users perceive better the minute changes of material properties under immersive viewing conditions. In terms of emotional aspects, VR is advantageous in signifying the effects induced by visual textures, while the 2D viewing mode is more effective for expressing the characteristics of plain surfaces. This thesis has contributed to the deeper understanding of users’ perception of material appearances in Virtual Reality, which is critical in achieving an effective design visualisation using such a display medium

Perceptual reparameterization of material properties

The recent increase in both the range and the subtlety of computer graphics techniques has greatly expanded the possibilities for synthesizing images. In many cases, however, the relationship between the parameters of an algorithm and the resulting perceptual effect is not straightforward. Since the ability to produce specific, intended effects is a natural pre-requisite for many scientific and artistic endeavors, this is a strong drawback. Here, we demonstrate a generalized method for determining both the qualitative and quantitative mapping between parameters and perception. Multidimensional Scaling extracts the metric structure of perceived similarity between the objects, as well as the transformation between similarity space and parameter space. Factor analysis of semantic differentials is used to determine the aesthetic structure of the stimulus set. Jointly, the results provide a description of how specific parameter changes can produce specific semantic changes. The method is demonstrated using two datasets. The first dataset consisted of glossy objects, which turned out to have a 2D similarity space and five primary semantic factors. The second dataset, transparent objects, can be described with a non-linear, 1D similarity map and six semantic factors. In both cases, roughly half of the factors represented aesthetic aspects of the stimuli, and half the low-level material properties. Perceptual reparameterization of computer graphics algorithms (such as those dealing with the representation of surface properties) offers the potential to improve their accessibility. This will not only allow easier generation of specific effects, but also enable more intuitive exploration of different image properties