Design, Characterization and Analysis of Component Level Electrostatic Discharge (ESD) Protection Solutions

Electrostatic Discharges (ESD) is a significant hazard to electronic components and systems. Based on a specific process technology, a given circuit application requires a customized ESD consideration that meets all the requirements such as the core circuit\u27s operating condition, maximum accepted leakage current, breakdown conditions for the process and overall device sizes. In every several years, there will be a new process technology becomes mature, and most of those new technology requires custom design of effective ESD protection solution. And usually the design window will shrinks due to the evolving of the technology becomes smaller and smaller. The ESD related failure is a major IC reliability concern and results in a loss of millions dollars each year in the semiconductor industry. To emulate the real word stress condition, several ESD stress models and test methods have been developed. The basic ESD models are Human Body model (HBM), Machine Mode (MM), and Charge Device Model (CDM). For the system-level ESD robustness, it is defined by different standards and specifications than component-level ESD requirements. International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) 61000-4-2 has been used for the product and the Human Metal Model (HMM) has been used for the system at the wafer level. Increasingly stringent design specifications are forcing original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) to minimize the number of off-chip components. This is the case in emerging multifunction mobile, industrial, automotive and healthcare applications. It requires a high level of ESD robustness and the integrated circuit (IC) level, while finding ways to streamline the ESD characterization during early development cycle. To enable predicting the ESD performance of IC\u27s pins that are directly exposed to a system-level stress condition, a new the human metal model (HMM) test model has been introduced. In this work, a new testing methodology for product-level HMM characterization is introduced. This testing framework allows for consistently identifying ESD-induced failures in a product, substantially simplifying the testing process, and significantly reducing the product evaluation time during development cycle. It helps eliminates the potential inaccuracy provided by the conventional characterization methodology. For verification purposes, this method has been applied to detect the failures of two different products. Addition to the exploration of new characterization methodology that provides better accuracy, we also have looked into the protection devices itself. ICs for emerging high performance precision data acquisition and transceivers in industrial, automotive and wireless infrastructure applications require effective and ESD protection solutions. These circuits, with relatively high operating voltages at the Input/Output (I/O) pins, are increasingly being designed in low voltage Complementary Metal-Oxide-Semiconductor (CMOS) technologies to meet the requirements of low cost and large scale integration. A new dual-polarity SCR optimized for high bidirectional blocking voltages, high trigger current and low capacitance is realized in a sub 3-V, 180-nm CMOS process. This ESD device is designed for a specific application where the operating voltage at the I/O is larger than that of the core circuit. For instance, protecting high voltage swing I/Os in CMOS data acquisition system (DAS) applications. In this reference application, an array of thin film resistors voltage divider is directly connected to the interface pin, reducing the maximum voltage that is obtained at the core device input down to ± 1-5 V. Its ESD characteristics, including the trigger voltage and failure current, are compared against those of a typical CMOS-based SCR. Then, we have looked into the ESD protection designs into more advanced technology, the 28-nm CMOS. An ESD protection design builds on the multiple discharge-paths ESD cell concept and focuses the attention on the detailed design, optimization and realization of the in-situ ESD protection cell for IO pins with variable operation voltages. By introducing different device configurations fabricated in a 28-nm CMOS process, a greater flexibility in the design options and design trade-offs can be obtained in the proposed topology, thus achieving a higher integration and smaller cell size definition for multi-voltage compatibility interface ESD protection applications. This device is optimized for low capacitance and synthesized with the circuit IO components for in-situ ESD protection in communication interface applications developed in a 28-nm, high-k, and metal-gate CMOS technology. ESD devices have been used in different types of applications and also at different environment conditions, such as high temperature. At the last section of this research work, we have performed an investigation of several different ESD devices\u27 performance under various temperature conditions. And it has been shown that the variations of the device structure can results different ESD performance, and some devices can be used at the high temperature and some cannot. And this investigation also brings up a potential threat to the current ESD protection devices that they might be very vulnerable to the latch-up issue at the higher temperature range

On-Chip ESD Protection Design: Optimized Clamps

The extensive use of Integrated Circuits (ICs) means complex working conditions for these tiny chips. To guarantee the ICs could work properly in various environments, some special protection strategies are required to improve the reliability of system. From all the possible reliability issues, the electrostatics discharge (ESD) might be the most common one. The peak current of electrostatics can be as high as tens of amperes and the peak voltage can be over thousand voltages. In contrast, the size of semiconductor device fabricated is continuing to scale down, making it even more vulnerable to high level overstress and current surge induced by ESD event. To protect the on-chip semiconductor from damage, some extra clamp cells are put together to consist a network. The network can redirect the superfluous current through the ESD network and clamp the voltage to a low level. In this dissertation, one design concept is introduced that uses the combination of some basic ESD devices to meet different requirements first, and then tries to establish parasitic current path among these devices to further increase the current handling capability. Some design cases are addressed to demonstrate this design concept is valid and efficient: 1. A combination of silicon-controlled-rectifier (SCR) and diode cluster is implemented to resolve the overshoot issue under fast ESD event. 2. A new SCR structure is introduced, which can be used as padding device to increase the clamping voltage without affecting other parameters. Based on this padding device, two design cases are introduced. 3. A controllable SCR clamp structure is presented, which has high current handling capability and can be controlled with by small signal. All these structures and topologies described in this dissertation are compatible with most of popular semiconductor fabrication process

Low-Leakage ESD Power Supply Clamps in General Purpose 65 nm CMOS Technology

Electrostatic discharge (ESD) is a well-known contributor that reduces the reliability and yield of the integrated circuits (ICs). As ICs become more complex, they are increasingly susceptible to such failures due to the scaling of physical dimensions of devices and interconnect on a chip [1]. These failures are caused by excessive electric field and/or excessive current densities and result in the dielectric breakdown, electromigration of metal lines and contacts. ESD can affect the IC in its different life stages, from wafer fabrication process to failure in the field. Furthermore, ESD events can damage the integrated circuit permanently (hard failure), or cause a latent damage (soft failure) [2]. ESD protection circuits consisting of I/O protection and ESD power supply clamps are routinely used in ICs to protect them against ESD damage. The main objective of the ESD protection circuit is to provide a low-resistive discharge path between any two pins of the chip to harmlessly discharge ESD energy without damaging the sensitive circuits. The main target of this thesis is to design ESD power supply clamps that have the lowest possible leakage current without degrading the ESD protection ability in general purpose TSMC 65 nm CMOS technology. ESD clamps should have a very low-leakage current and should be stable and immune to the power supply noise under the normal operating conditions of the circuit core. Also, the ESD clamps must be able to handle high currents under an ESD event. All designs published in the general purpose 65 nm CMOS technology have used the SCR as the clamping element since the SCR has a higher current carrying capability compared to an MOS transistor of the same area [3]. The ESD power supply clamp should provide a low-resistive path in both directions to be able to deal with both PSD and NDS zapping modes. The SCR based design does not provide the best ESD protection for the NDS zapping mode (positive ESD stress at VSS with grounded VDD node) since it has two parasitic resistances (RNwell and RPsub) and one parasitic diode (the collector to base junction diode of the PNP transistor) in the path from the VSS to VDD. Furthermore, SCR-based designs are not suitable for application that exposed to hot switching or ionizing radiation [2]. In GP process, the gate oxide thickness of core transistors is reduced compared with LP process counterpart to achieve higher performance designs for high-frequency applications using 1 V core transistors and 2.5 V I/O option. The thinner gate oxide layer results in higher leakage current due to gate tunneling [4]. Therefore, using large thin oxide MOS transistors as clamping elements will result in a huge leakage. In this thesis, four power supply ESD clamps are proposed in which thick oxide MOS transistors are used as the main clamping element. Therefore, the low-leakage current feature is achieved without significantly degrading the ESD performance. In addition, the parasitic diode of the MOS transistors provides the protection against NSD-mode. In this thesis, two different ESD power supply clamp architectures are proposed: standalone ESD power supply clamps and hybrid ESD power supply clamps. Two standalone clamps are proposed: a transient PMOS based ESD clamp with thyristor delay element (PTC), and a static diode triggered power supply (DTC). The standalone clamps were designed to protect the circuit core against ±125 V CDM stress by limiting the voltage between the two power rails to less than the oxide breakdown voltage of the core transistors, BVOXESD = 5 V. The large area of this architecture was the price for maintaining the low-leakage current and an adequate ESD protection. The hybrid clamp architecture was proposed to provide a higher ESD protection, against ±300 V CDM stress, while reducing the layout area and maintaining the low-leakage feature. In the hybrid clamp structure, two clamps are connected in parallel between the two power supply rails, a static clamp, and a transient clamp. The static clamp triggers first and starts to sink the ESD energy and then an RC network triggers the primary transient clamp to sink most of the ESD stress. Two hybrid designs were proposed: PMOS ESD power supply clamp with thyristor delay element and diodes (PTDC), and NMOS ESD power supply clamp with level shifter delay element and diode (NLDC). Simulation results show that the proposed clamps are capable of protecting the circuit core against ±1.5 kV HBM and at least against ±125 V CDM stresses. The measurement results show that all of the proposed clamps are immune against false triggering, and transient induced latch-up. Furthermore, all four designs have responded favorably to the 4 V ESD-like pulse voltage under both chip powered and not powered conditions and after the stress ends the designs turned off. Finally, TLP measurement results show that all four proposed designs meet the minimum design requirement of the ESD protection circuit in the 65 nm CMOS technology (i.e. HBM protection level of ±1.5 kV )

Chip- and System-Level Reliability on SiC-based Power Modules

The blocking voltage, switching frequency and temperature tolerance of power devices have been greatly improved due to the revolution of wide bandgap (WBG) materials, such as silicon carbide (SiC) and gallium nitride (GaN). Owing to the development of SiC-based power devices, the power rating, operating voltage, and power density of power modules have been significantly improved. However, the reliability of SiC-based power modules has not been fully explored yet. Thus, this dissertation focuses on the chip- and system-level reliability on SiC-based power modules. For chip-level reliability, this work focuses on on-chip SiC ESD protection devices for SiC-based integrated circuits (ICs). In order to develop SiC ESD protection devices, SiC-based Ohmic contact and ion implantation have been studied. Nickel/Titanium/Aluminum (Ni/Ti/Al) metal stacks were deposited on SiC substrates to form Ohmic contact. Circular transfer length method (CTLM) structures were fabricated to characterize contact resistivity. Ion implantation was designed and simulated by Sentraurus technology computer aided design (TCAD) software. Secondary-ion mass spectrometry (SIMS) results show a good match with the simulation results. In addition, SiC ESD protection devices, such as N-type metal-oxide-semiconductor (NMOS), laterally diffused metal-oxide-semiconductor (LDMOS), high-voltage silicon controlled rectifier (HV-SCR) and low-voltage silicon controlled rectifier (LV-SCR), have been designed. Transmission line pulse (TLP) and very fast TLP (VF-TLP) measurements were carried out to characterize their ESD performance. The proposed SiC-based HV-SCR shows the highest failure current on TLP measurement and can be used as an area-efficient ESD protection device. On the other hand, for system-level reliability, this dissertation focuses on the galvanic isolation of high-temperature SiC power modules. Low temperature co-fired ceramics (LTCC) based high-temperature optocouplers were designed and fabricated as galvanic isolators. The LTCC-based high-temperature optocouplers show promising driving capability and steady response speed from 25 ºC to 250 ºC. In order to verify the performance of the high-temperature optocouplers at the system level, LTCC-based gate drivers that utilize the high-temperature optocouplers as galvanic isolators were designed and integrated into a high-temperature SiC-based power module. Finally, the high-temperature power module with integrated LTCC-based gate drivers was characterized by DPTs from 25 ºC to 200 ºC. The power module shows reliable switching performance at elevated temperatures

Chip- and System-Level Reliability on SiC-based Power Modules

The blocking voltage, switching frequency and temperature tolerance of power devices have been greatly improved due to the revolution of wide bandgap (WBG) materials, such as silicon carbide (SiC) and gallium nitride (GaN). Owing to the development of SiC-based power devices, the power rating, operating voltage, and power density of power modules have been significantly improved. However, the reliability of SiC-based power modules has not been fully explored yet. Thus, this dissertation focuses on the chip- and system-level reliability on SiC-based power modules. For chip-level reliability, this work focuses on on-chip SiC ESD protection devices for SiC-based integrated circuits (ICs). In order to develop SiC ESD protection devices, SiC-based Ohmic contact and ion implantation have been studied. Nickel/Titanium/Aluminum (Ni/Ti/Al) metal stacks were deposited on SiC substrates to form Ohmic contact. Circular transfer length method (CTLM) structures were fabricated to characterize contact resistivity. Ion implantation was designed and simulated by Sentraurus technology computer aided design (TCAD) software. Secondary-ion mass spectrometry (SIMS) results show a good match with the simulation results. In addition, SiC ESD protection devices, such as N-type metal-oxide-semiconductor (NMOS), laterally diffused metal-oxide-semiconductor (LDMOS), high-voltage silicon controlled rectifier (HV-SCR) and low-voltage silicon controlled rectifier (LV-SCR), have been designed. Transmission line pulse (TLP) and very fast TLP (VF-TLP) measurements were carried out to characterize their ESD performance. The proposed SiC-based HV-SCR shows the highest failure current on TLP measurement and can be used as an area-efficient ESD protection device. On the other hand, for system-level reliability, this dissertation focuses on the galvanic isolation of high-temperature SiC power modules. Low temperature co-fired ceramics (LTCC) based high-temperature optocouplers were designed and fabricated as galvanic isolators. The LTCC-based high-temperature optocouplers show promising driving capability and steady response speed from 25 ºC to 250 ºC. In order to verify the performance of the high-temperature optocouplers at the system level, LTCC-based gate drivers that utilize the high-temperature optocouplers as galvanic isolators were designed and integrated into a high-temperature SiC-based power module. Finally, the high-temperature power module with integrated LTCC-based gate drivers was characterized by DPTs from 25 ºC to 200 ºC. The power module shows reliable switching performance at elevated temperatures

Understanding, modeling, and mitigating system-level ESD in integrated circuits

This dissertation describes several studies regarding the effects of system-level electrostatic discharge (ESD) and how to model and mitigate them. The topics in this dissertation fall into two broad categories: modeling pieces of a system-level ESD test setup and phenomenological studies. Simulation is an important tool for achieving quality designs quickly. However, modeling methodologies for system-level ESD are not yet mature. This dissertation aims to improve (i) simulation models of ESD protection elements, (ii) simulation models of ESD guns, and (iii) analytic models of rail-clamp circuits used for power-on ESD protection. Simulation models for two common ESD protection elements, diodes and silicon controlled rectifiers (SCR) are presented and evaluated, specifically with regard to the origins of poor voltage clamping. These models can be used for ESD network design and simulation; their applicability is not limited only to system-level ESD. Next, a circuit simulation model for an ESD gun (used to produce system-level ESD stresses) is presented. This model can be used for trouble-shooting and design. Lastly, an analytic model of rail-clamp circuits during system-level ESD is presented. These circuits can produce unstable oscillations or ringing on the supply; such problems must be eliminated during design. Analytic models help the designer understand how circuit parameters will impact the circuit’s performance. System-level ESD is a relatively new requirement being imposed on IC manufacturers; as such, current understanding of how system-level ESD affects ICs is not yet mature. This dissertation includes two studies that expand upon this knowledge. The first demonstrates that ground bounce due system-level ESD stress can lead to severe problems, including latch-up and power integrity problems. The second reports observations regarding input noise signals at an IC pin during system-level ESD stress. Lastly, this dissertation discusses experimental design of a test chip that will be manufactured shortly after this dissertation is completed. These experiments focus on observing and suppressing various errors that can occur during system-level ESD, arising from both noise at the inputs and power fluctuations. Additionally, this test chip includes standalone test structures that are used to reproduce power supply problems predicted in other sections of this dissertation

Design, Characterization And Analysis Of Electrostatic Discharge (esd) Protection Solutions In Emerging And Modern Technologies

Electrostatic Discharge (ESD) is a significant hazard to electronic components and systems. Based on a specific processing technology, a given circuit application requires a customized ESD consideration that includes the devices’ operating voltage, leakage current, breakdown constraints, and footprint. As new technology nodes mature every 3-5 years, design of effective ESD protection solutions has become more and more challenging due to the narrowed design window, elevated electric field and current density, as well as new failure mechanisms that are not well understood. The endeavor of this research is to develop novel, effective and robust ESD protection solutions for both emerging technologies and modern complementary metal–oxide–semiconductor (CMOS) technologies. The Si nanowire field-effect transistors are projected by the International Technology Roadmap for Semiconductors as promising next-generation CMOS devices due to their superior DC and RF performances, as well as ease of fabrication in existing Silicon processing. Aiming at proposing ESD protection solutions for nanowire based circuits, the dimension parameters, fabrication process, and layout dependency of such devices under Human Body Mode (HBM) ESD stresses are studied experimentally in company with failure analysis revealing the failure mechanism induced by ESD. The findings, including design methodologies, failure mechanism, and technology comparisons should provide practical knowhow of the development of ESD protection schemes for the nanowire based integrated circuits. Organic thin-film transistors (OTFTs) are the basic elements for the emerging flexible, printable, large-area, and low-cost organic electronic circuits. Although there are plentiful studies focusing on the DC stress induced reliability degradation, the operation mechanism of OTFTs iv subject to ESD is not yet available in the literature and are urgently needed before the organic technology can be pushed into consumer market. In this work, the ESD operation mechanism of OTFT depending on gate biasing condition and dimension parameters are investigated by extensive characterization and thorough evaluation. The device degradation evolution and failure mechanism under ESD are also investigated by specially designed experiments. In addition to the exploration of ESD protection solutions in emerging technologies, efforts have also been placed in the design and analysis of a major ESD protection device, diodetriggered-silicon-controlled-rectifier (DTSCR), in modern CMOS technology (90nm bulk). On the one hand, a new type DTSCR having bi-directional conduction capability, optimized design window, high HBM robustness and low parasitic capacitance are developed utilizing the combination of a bi-directional silicon-controlled-rectifier and bi-directional diode strings. On the other hand, the HBM and Charged Device Mode (CDM) ESD robustness of DTSCRs using four typical layout topologies are compared and analyzed in terms of trigger voltage, holding voltage, failure current density, turn-on time, and overshoot voltage. The advantages and drawbacks of each layout are summarized and those offering the best overall performance are suggested at the en

Advances in Solid State Circuit Technologies

This book brings together contributions from experts in the fields to describe the current status of important topics in solid-state circuit technologies. It consists of 20 chapters which are grouped under the following categories: general information, circuits and devices, materials, and characterization techniques. These chapters have been written by renowned experts in the respective fields making this book valuable to the integrated circuits and materials science communities. It is intended for a diverse readership including electrical engineers and material scientists in the industry and academic institutions. Readers will be able to familiarize themselves with the latest technologies in the various fields

Design, Simulation and Characterization of Novel Electrostatic Discharge Protection Devices and Circuits in Advanced Silicon Technologies

Electrostatic Discharge (ESD) has been one of the major reliability concerns in the advanced silicon technologies and it becomes more important with technology scaling. It has been reported that more than 35% of the failures in integrated circuits (ICs) are ESD induced. ESD event is a phenomenon that a finite amount of charges transfer between two objects with different potential in a quite short time. Such event contains a large energy and the ICs without proper ESD protection could be destroyed easily, so ESD protection solutions are essential to semiconductor industry. ESD protection design consists of on-chip and off-chip ESD protection design, and the research works in this dissertation are all conducted in on-chip level, which incorporate the ESD protection devices and circuits into the microchip, to provide with basic ESD protection from manufacturing to customer use. The basic idea of ESD protection design is to provide a path with low impedance which directs most of the ESD current to flow through itself instead of the core circuit, and the ESD protection path must be robust enough to make sure that it does not fail before the core circuit. In this way, proper design on protection devices and circuits should be considered carefully. To assist the understanding and design of ESD protection, the ESD event in real world has been classified into a few ESD model including Human Body Model (HBM), Machine Model (MM), Charged Device Model (CDM), etc. Some mainstream testing method and industry standard are also introduced, including Transmission Line Pulse (TLP), and IEC 61000-4-2. ESD protection devices including diode, Gate-Grounded N-type MOSFET (GGNMOS), Silicon Controlled Rectifier (SCR) are basic elements for ESD protection design. In this dissertation, the device characteristics in ESD event and their applications are introduced. From the perspective of the whole chip ESD protection design, the concept of circuit level ESD protection and the ESD clamps are also briefly introduced. Technology Computer Aided Design (TCAD) and Simulation Program with Integrated Circuit Emphasis (SPICE) simulation is widely used in ESD protection design. In this dissertation, TCAD and SPICE simulation are carried out for a few times for both of pre-tapeout evaluation on characteristics of the proposed device and circuit and post-tapeout analysis on structure operating mechanism. Automotive electronics has been a popular subject in semiconductor industry, and due to the special requirement of the automotive applications like the capacitive pins, the ESD protection device used in such applications need to be specially designed. In this dissertation, a few SCRs without snapback are discussed in detail. To avoid core circuit damages caused the displacement current induced by the large snapback in conventional SCR, an eliminated/minimized snapback is preferred in a selection of the protection device. Two novel SCRs are proposed for High Voltage (HV), Medium Voltage (MV), and Low Voltage (LV) automotive ESD protection. The typical operating temperature for ICs is up to 125°C, however in automotive applications, the operating temperature may extend up to 850°C. In this way, the characteristics of the ESD protection device under the elevated temperatures will be an essential part to investigate for automotive ESD protection design. In this dissertation, the high temperature characteristics of ESD protection devices including diode and a few SCRs is measured and discussed in detail. TCAD simulation are also conducted to explain the underlying physical mechanism. This work provides with a useful insight and information to ESD protection design in high temperature applications. Besides the high temperature environment, ESD protection are also highly needed for electronics working in other extreme environment like the space. Space is an environment that contains kinds of radiation source and at the same time can generate abundant ESD. The ESD adhering to the space systems could be a potential threat to the space electronics. At the same time, the characteristics of the ESD protection part especially the basic protection device used in the space electronics could be influenced after the irradiation in the space. Therefore, the investigation of the radiation effects on ESD protection devices are necessary. In this dissertation, the total ionizing dose (TID) effects on ESD protection devices are investigated. The devices are irradiated with 1.5 MeV He+ and characterized with TLP tester. The pre- and post-irradiation characteristics are compared and the variation on key ESD parameters are analyzed and discussed. This work offers a useful insight on ESD devices\u27 operation under TID and help with the device designing on ESD protection devices for space electronics. Single ESD protection devices are essential part constructing the ESD protection network, however the optimization on ESD clamp circuit design is also important on building an efficient whole chip ESD protection network. In this dissertation, the design and simulation of a novel voltage triggered ESD detection circuit are introduced. The voltage triggered ESD detection circuit is proposed in a 0.18 um CMOS technology. Comparing with the conventional RC based detection circuit, the proposed circuit realizes a higher triggering efficiency with a much smaller footprint, and is immune to false triggering under fast power-up events. The proposed circuit has a better sensitivity to ESD event and is more reliable in ESD protection applications. The leakage current has been a concern with the scaling down of the thickness of the gate oxide. Therefore, a proper design of the ESD clamp for power rail ESD protection need to be specially considered. In this dissertation, a design of a novel ESD clamp with low leakage current is analyzed. The proposed clamp realized a pretty low leakage current up to 12 nA, and has a smaller footprint than conventional design. It also has a long hold-on time under ESD event and a quick turn-off mechanism for false triggering. SPICE simulation is carried out to evaluate the operation of the proposed ESD clamp