Comparison of diarization tools for building speaker database

This paper compares open source diarization toolkits (LIUM, DiarTK, ALIZE-Lia_Ral), which were designed for extraction of speaker identity from audio records without any prior information about the analysed data. The comparative study of used diarization tools was performed for three different types of analysed data (broadcast news - BN and TV shows). Corresponding values of achieved DER measure are presented here. The automatic speaker diarization system developed by LIUM was able to identified speech segments belonging to speakers at very good level. Its segmentation outputs can be used to build a speaker database

Speech segmentation and speaker diarisation for transcription and translation

This dissertation outlines work related to Speech Segmentation – segmenting an audio recording into regions of speech and non-speech, and Speaker Diarization – further segmenting those regions into those pertaining to homogeneous speakers. Knowing not only what was said but also who said it and when, has many useful applications. As well as providing a richer level of transcription for speech, we will show how such knowledge can improve Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) system performance and can also benefit downstream Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks such as machine translation and punctuation restoration. While segmentation and diarization may appear to be relatively simple tasks to describe, in practise we find that they are very challenging and are, in general, ill-defined problems. Therefore, we first provide a formalisation of each of the problems as the sub-division of speech within acoustic space and time. Here, we see that the task can become very difficult when we want to partition this domain into our target classes of speakers, whilst avoiding other classes that reside in the same space, such as phonemes. We present a theoretical framework for describing and discussing the tasks as well as introducing existing state-of-the-art methods and research. Current Speaker Diarization systems are notoriously sensitive to hyper-parameters and lack robustness across datasets. Therefore, we present a method which uses a series of oracle experiments to expose the limitations of current systems and to which system components these limitations can be attributed. We also demonstrate how Diarization Error Rate (DER), the dominant error metric in the literature, is not a comprehensive or reliable indicator of overall performance or of error propagation to subsequent downstream tasks. These results inform our subsequent research. We find that, as a precursor to Speaker Diarization, the task of Speech Segmentation is a crucial first step in the system chain. Current methods typically do not account for the inherent structure of spoken discourse. As such, we explored a novel method which exploits an utterance-duration prior in order to better model the segment distribution of speech. We show how this method improves not only segmentation, but also the performance of subsequent speech recognition, machine translation and speaker diarization systems. Typical ASR transcriptions do not include punctuation and the task of enriching transcriptions with this information is known as ‘punctuation restoration’. The benefit is not only improved readability but also better compatibility with NLP systems that expect sentence-like units such as in conventional machine translation. We show how segmentation and diarization are related tasks that are able to contribute acoustic information that complements existing linguistically-based punctuation approaches. There is a growing demand for speech technology applications in the broadcast media domain. This domain presents many new challenges including diverse noise and recording conditions. We show that the capacity of existing GMM-HMM based speech segmentation systems is limited for such scenarios and present a Deep Neural Network (DNN) based method which offers a more robust speech segmentation method resulting in improved speech recognition performance for a television broadcast dataset. Ultimately, we are able to show that the speech segmentation is an inherently ill-defined problem for which the solution is highly dependent on the downstream task that it is intended for

Discriminative features for GMM and i-vector based speaker diarization

Speaker diarization has received several research attentions over the last decade. Among the different domains of speaker diarization, diarization in meeting domain is the most challenging one. It usually contains spontaneous speech and is, for example, susceptible to reverberation. The appropriate selection of speech features is one of the factors that affect the performance of speaker diarization systems. Mel Frequency Cepstral Coefficients (MFCC) are the most widely used short-term speech features in speaker diarization. Other factors that affect the performance of speaker diarization systems are the techniques employed to perform both speaker segmentation and speaker clustering. In this thesis, we have proposed the use of jitter and shimmer long-term voice-quality features both for Gaussian Mixture Modeling (GMM) and i-vector based speaker diarization systems. The voice-quality features are used together with the state-of-the-art short-term cepstral and long-term speech ones. The long-term features consist of prosody and Glottal-to-Noise excitation ratio (GNE) descriptors. Firstly, the voice-quality, prosodic and GNE features are stacked in the same feature vector. Then, they are fused with cepstral coefficients at the score likelihood level both for the proposed Gaussian Mixture Modeling (GMM) and i-vector based speaker diarization systems. For the proposed GMM based speaker diarization system, independent HMM models are estimated from the short-term and long-term speech feature sets. The fusion of the short-term descriptors with the long-term ones in speaker segmentation is carried out by linearly weighting the log-likelihood scores of Viterbi decoding. In the case of speaker clustering, the fusion of the short-term cepstral features with the long-term ones is carried out by linearly fusing the Bayesian Information Criterion (BIC) scores corresponding to these feature sets. For the proposed i-vector based speaker diarization system, the speaker segmentation is carried out exactly the same as in the previously mentioned GMM based speaker diarization system. However, the speaker clustering technique is based on the recently introduced factor analysis paradigm. Two set of i-vectors are extracted from the speaker segmentation hypothesis. Whilst the first i-vector is extracted from short-term cepstral features, the second one is extracted from the voice quality, prosody and GNE descriptors. Then, the cosine-distance and Probabilistic Linear Discriminant Analysis (PLDA) scores of i-vectors are linearly weighted to obtain a fused similarity score. Finally, the fused score is used as speaker clustering distance. We have also proposed the use of delta dynamic features for speaker clustering. The motivation for using deltas in clustering is that delta dynamic features capture the transitional characteristics of the speech signal which contain speaker specific information. This information is not captured by the static cepstral coefficients. The delta features are used together with the short-term static cepstral coefficients and long-term speech features (i.e., voice-quality, prosody and GNE) both for GMM and i-vector based speaker diarization systems. The experiments have been carried out on Augmented Multi-party Interaction (AMI) meeting corpus. The experimental results show that the use of voice-quality, prosody, GNE and delta dynamic features improve the performance of both GMM and i-vector based speaker diarization systems.La diarización del altavoz ha recibido varias atenciones de investigación durante la última década. Entre los diferentes dominios de la diarización del hablante, la diarización en el dominio del encuentro es la más difícil. Normalmente contiene habla espontánea y, por ejemplo, es susceptible de reverberación. La selección apropiada de las características del habla es uno de los factores que afectan el rendimiento de los sistemas de diarización de los altavoces. Los Coeficientes Cepstral de Frecuencia Mel (MFCC) son las características de habla de corto plazo más utilizadas en la diarización de los altavoces. Otros factores que afectan el rendimiento de los sistemas de diarización del altavoz son las técnicas empleadas para realizar tanto la segmentación del altavoz como el agrupamiento de altavoces. En esta tesis, hemos propuesto el uso de jitter y shimmer características de calidad de voz a largo plazo tanto para GMM y i-vector basada en sistemas de diarización de altavoces. Las características de calidad de voz se utilizan junto con el estado de la técnica a corto plazo cepstral y de larga duración de habla. Las características a largo plazo consisten en la prosodia y los descriptores de relación de excitación Glottal-a-Ruido (GNE). En primer lugar, las características de calidad de voz, prosódica y GNE se apilan en el mismo vector de características. A continuación, se fusionan con coeficientes cepstrales en el nivel de verosimilitud de puntajes tanto para los sistemas de diarización de altavoces basados ¿¿en el modelo Gaussian Mixture Modeling (GMM) como en los sistemas basados ¿¿en i-vector. . Para el sistema de diarización de altavoces basado en GMM propuesto, se calculan modelos HMM independientes a partir de cada conjunto de características. En la segmentación de los altavoces, la fusión de los descriptores a corto plazo con los de largo plazo se lleva a cabo mediante la ponderación lineal de las puntuaciones log-probabilidad de decodificación Viterbi. En la agrupación de altavoces, la fusión de las características cepstrales a corto plazo con las de largo plazo se lleva a cabo mediante la fusión lineal de las puntuaciones Bayesian Information Criterion (BIC) correspondientes a estos conjuntos de características. Para el sistema de diarización de altavoces basado en un vector i, la fusión de características se realiza exactamente igual a la del sistema basado en GMM antes mencionado. Sin embargo, la técnica de agrupación de altavoces se basa en el paradigma de análisis de factores recientemente introducido. Dos conjuntos de i-vectores se extraen de la hipótesis de segmentación de altavoz. Mientras que el primer vector i se extrae de características espectrales a corto plazo, el segundo se extrae de los descriptores de calidad de voz apilados, prosódicos y GNE. A continuación, las puntuaciones de coseno-distancia y Probabilistic Linear Discriminant Analysis (PLDA) entre i-vectores se ponderan linealmente para obtener una puntuación de similitud fundida. Finalmente, la puntuación fusionada se utiliza como distancia de agrupación de altavoces. También hemos propuesto el uso de características dinámicas delta para la agrupación de locutores. La motivación para el uso de deltas en la agrupación es que las características dinámicas delta capturan las características de transición de la señal de voz que contienen información específica del locutor. Esta información no es capturada por los coeficientes cepstrales estáticos. Las características delta se usan junto con los coeficientes cepstrales estáticos a corto plazo y las características de voz a largo plazo (es decir, calidad de voz, prosodia y GNE) tanto para sistemas de diarización de altavoces basados en GMM como en sistemas i-vector. Los resultados experimentales sobre AMI muestran que el uso de calidad vocal, prosódica, GNE y dinámicas delta mejoran el rendimiento de los sistemas de diarización de altavoces basados en GMM e i-vector.Postprint (published version

Using Deep Neural Networks for Speaker Diarisation

Speaker diarisation answers the question “who spoke when?” in an audio recording. The input may vary, but a system is required to output speaker labelled segments in time. Typical stages are Speech Activity Detection (SAD), speaker segmentation and speaker clustering. Early research focussed on Conversational Telephone Speech (CTS) and Broadcast News (BN) domains before the direction shifted to meetings and, more recently, broadcast media. The British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) supplied data through the Multi-Genre Broadcast (MGB) Challenge in 2015 which showed the difficulties speaker diarisation systems have on broadcast media data. Diarisation is typically an unsupervised task which does not use auxiliary data or information to enhance a system. However, methods which do involve supplementary data have shown promise. Five semi-supervised methods are investigated which use a combination of inputs: different channel types and transcripts. The methods involve Deep Neural Networks (DNNs) for SAD, DNNs trained for channel detection, transcript alignment, and combinations of these approaches. However, the methods are only applicable when datasets contain the required inputs. Therefore, a method involving a pretrained Speaker Separation Deep Neural Network (ssDNN) is investigated which is applicable to every dataset. This technique performs speaker clustering and speaker segmentation using DNNs successfully for meeting data and with mixed results for broadcast media. The task of diarisation focuses on two aspects: accurate segments and speaker labels. The Diarisation Error Rate (DER) does not evaluate the segmentation quality as it does not measure the number of correctly detected segments. Other metrics exist, such as boundary and purity measures, but these also mask the segmentation quality. An alternative metric is presented based on the F-measure which considers the number of hypothesis segments correctly matched to reference segments. A deeper insight into the segment quality is shown through this metric

Speech Activity and Speaker Change Point Detection for Online Streams

Disertační práce je věnována dvěma si blízkým řečovým úlohám a následně jejich použití v online prostředí. Konkrétně se jedná o úlohy detekce řeči a detekce změny mluvčího. Ty jsou často nedílnou součástí systémů pro zpracování řeči (např. pro diarizaci mluvčích nebo rozpoznávání řeči), kde slouží pro předzpracování akustického signálu. Obě úlohy jsou v literatuře velmi aktivním tématem, ale většina existujících prací je směřována primárně na offline využití. Nicméně právě online nasazení je nezbytné pro některé řečové aplikace, které musí fungovat v reálném čase (např. monitorovací systémy).Úvodní část disertační práce je tvořena třemi kapitolami. V té první jsou vysvětleny základní pojmy a následně je nastíněno využití obou úloh. Druhá kapitola je věnována současnému poznání a je doplněna o přehled existujících nástrojů. Poslední kapitola se skládá z motivace a z praktického použití zmíněných úloh v monitorovacích systémech. V závěru úvodní části jsou stanoveny cíle práce.Následující dvě kapitoly jsou věnovány teoretickým základům obou úloh. Představují vybrané přístupy, které jsou buď relevantní pro disertační práci (porovnání výsledků), nebo jsou zaměřené na použití v online prostředí.V další kapitole je předložen finální přístup pro detekci řeči. Postupný návrh tohoto přístupu, společně s experimentálním vyhodnocením, je zde detailně rozebrán. Přístup dosahuje nejlepších výsledků na korpusu QUT-NOISE-TIMIT v podmínkách s nízkým a středním zašuměním. Přístup je také začleněn do monitorovacího systému, kde doplňuje svojí funkcionalitou rozpoznávač řeči.Následující kapitola detailně představuje finální přístup pro detekci změny mluvčího. Ten byl navržen v rámci několika po sobě jdoucích experimentů, které tato kapitola také přibližuje. Výsledky získané na databázi COST278 se blíží výsledkům, kterých dosáhl referenční offline systém, ale předložený přístup jich docílil v online módu a to s nízkou latencí.Výstupy disertační práce jsou shrnuty v závěrečné kapitole.The main focus of this thesis lies on two closely interrelated tasks, speech activity detection and speaker change point detection, and their applications in online processing. These tasks commonly play a crucial role of speech preprocessors utilized in speech-processing applications, such as automatic speech recognition or speaker diarization. While their use in offline systems is extensively covered in literature, the number of published works focusing on online use is limited.This is unfortunate, as many speech-processing applications (e.g., monitoring systems) are required to be run in real time.The thesis begins with a three-chapter opening part, where the first introductory chapter explains the basic concepts and outlines the practical use of both tasks. It is followed by a chapter, which reviews the current state of the art and lists the existing toolkits. That part is concluded by a chapter explaining the motivation behind this work and the practical use in monitoring systems; ultimately, this chapter sets the main goals of this thesis.The next two chapters cover the theoretical background of both tasks. They present selected approaches relevant to this work (e.g., used for result comparisons) or focused on online processing.The following chapter proposes the final speech activity detection approach for online use. Within this chapter, a detailed description of the development of this approach is available as well as its thorough experimental evaluation. This approach yields state-of-the-art results under low- and medium-noise conditions on the standardized QUT-NOISE-TIMIT corpus. It is also integrated into a monitoring system, where it supplements a speech recognition system.The final speaker change point detection approach is proposed in the following chapter. It was designed in a series of consecutive experiments, which are extensively detailed in this chapter. An experimental evaluation of this approach on the COST278 database shows the performance of approaching the offline reference system while operating in online mode with low latency.Finally, the last chapter summarizes all the results of this thesis

Spatial features of reverberant speech: estimation and application to recognition and diarization

Distant talking scenarios, such as hands-free calling or teleconference meetings, are essential for natural and comfortable human-machine interaction and they are being increasingly used in multiple contexts. The acquired speech signal in such scenarios is reverberant and affected by additive noise. This signal distortion degrades the performance of speech recognition and diarization systems creating troublesome human-machine interactions.This thesis proposes a method to non-intrusively estimate room acoustic parameters, paying special attention to a room acoustic parameter highly correlated with speech recognition degradation: clarity index. In addition, a method to provide information regarding the estimation accuracy is proposed. An analysis of the phoneme recognition performance for multiple reverberant environments is presented, from which a confusability metric for each phoneme is derived. This confusability metric is then employed to improve reverberant speech recognition performance. Additionally, room acoustic parameters can as well be used in speech recognition to provide robustness against reverberation. A method to exploit clarity index estimates in order to perform reverberant speech recognition is introduced. Finally, room acoustic parameters can also be used to diarize reverberant speech. A room acoustic parameter is proposed to be used as an additional source of information for single-channel diarization purposes in reverberant environments. In multi-channel environments, the time delay of arrival is a feature commonly used to diarize the input speech, however the computation of this feature is affected by reverberation. A method is presented to model the time delay of arrival in a robust manner so that speaker diarization is more accurately performed.Open Acces