Comparing the E-Z Reader Model to Other Models of Eye Movement Control in Reading

The E-Z Reader model provides a theoretical framework for understanding how word identification, visual processing, attention, and oculomotor control jointly determine when and where the eyes move during reading. Thus, in contrast to other reading models reviewed in this article, E-Z Reader can simultaneously account for many of the known effects of linguistic, visual, and oculomotor factors on eye movement control during reading. Furthermore, the core principles of the model have been generalized to other task domains (e.g., equation solving, visual search), and are broadly consistent with what is known about the architecture of the neural systems that support reading

Atypical eye contact in autism: Models, mechanisms and development

An atypical pattern of eye contact behaviour is one of the most significant symptoms of Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD). Recent empirical advances have revealed the developmental, cognitive and neural basis of atypical eye contact behaviour in ASD. We review different models and advance a new ‘fast-track modulator model’. Specifically, we propose that atypical eye contact processing in ASD originates in the lack of influence from a subcortical face and eye contact detection route, which is hypothesized to modulate eye contact processing and guide its emergent specialization during development

The neural substrates of natural reading: a comparison of normal and nonword text using eyetracking and fMRI

Most previous studies investigating the neural correlates of reading have presented text using serial visual presentation (SVP), which may not fully reflect the underlying processes of natural reading. In the present study, eye movements and BOLD data were collected while subjects either read normal paragraphs naturally or moved their eyes through paragraphs of pseudo-text (pronounceable pseudowords or consonant letter strings) in two pseudo-reading conditions. Eye movement data established that subjects were reading and scanning the stimuli normally. A conjunction fMRI analysis across natural- and pseudo-reading showed that a common eye-movement network including frontal eye fields, supplementary eye fields, and intraparietal sulci was activated, consistent with previous studies using simpler eye movement tasks. In addition, natural reading versus pseudo-reading showed different patterns of brain activation: normal reading produced activation in a well-established language network that included superior temporal gyrus/sulcus, middle temporal gyrus, angular gyrus, inferior frontal gyrus, and middle frontal gyrus, whereas pseudo-reading produced activation in an attentional network that included anterior/posterior cingulate and parietal cortex. These results are consistent with results found in previous single-saccade eye movement tasks and SVP reading studies, suggesting that component processes of eye-movement control and language processing observed in past fMRI research generalize to natural reading. The results also suggest that combining eyetracking and fMRI is a suitable method for investigating the component processes of natural reading in fMRI research

An Investigation of Reading Development Through Sensitivity to Sublexical Units

The present dissertation provides a novel perspective to the study of reading, focusing on sensitivity to sublexical units across reading development. Work towards this thesis has been conducted at SISSA and Macquarie University. The first study is an eye tracking experiment on natural reading, with 140 developing readers and 33 adult participants, who silently read multiline passages from story books in Italian. A developmental database of eye tracking during natural reading was created, filling a gap in the literature. We replicated well-documented developmental trends of reading behavior (e.g., reading rate and skipping rate increasing with age) and effects of word length and frequency on eye tracking measures. The second study, in collaboration with Dr Jon Carr, is a methodological paper presenting algorithms for accuracy enhancement of eye tracking recordings in multiline reading. Using the above-mentioned dataset and computational simulations, we assessed the performance of several algorithms (including two novel methods that we proposed) on the correction of vertical drift, the progressive displacement of fixation registrations on the vertical axis over time. We provided guidance for eye tracking researchers in the application of these methods, and one of the novel algorithms (based on Dynamic Time Warping) proved particularly promising in realigning fixations, especially in child recordings. This manuscript has recently been accepted for publication in Behavior Research Methods. In the third study, I examined sensitivity to statistical regularities in letter co-occurrence throughout reading development, by analysing the effects of n-gram frequency metrics on eye-tracking measures. To this end, the EyeReadIt eye-tracking corpus (presented in the first study) was used. Our results suggest that n-gram frequency effects (in particular related to maximum/average frequency metrics) are present even in developing readers, suggesting that sensitivity to sublexical orthographic regularities in reading is present as soon as the developing reading system can pick it up \u2013 in the case of this study, as early as in third grade. The results bear relevant implications for extant theories of learning to read, which largely overlook the contribution of statistical learning to reading acquisition. The fourth study is a magnetoencephalography experiment conducted at Macquarie University, in collaboration with Dr Lisi Beyersmann, Prof Paul Sowman, and Prof Anne Castles, on 28 adults and 17 children (5th and 6th grade). We investigated selective neural responses to morphemes at different stages of reading development, using Fast Periodic Visual Stimulation (FPVS) combined with an oddball design. Participants were presented with rapid sequences (6 Hz) of pseudoword combinations of stem/nonstem and suffix/nonsuffix components. Interleaved in this stream, oddball stimuli appeared periodically every 5 items (1.2 Hz) and were specifically designed to examine stem or suffix detection (e.g., stem+suffix oddballs, such as softity, were embedded in a sequence of nonstem+suffix base items, such as terpity). We predicted that neural responses at the oddball stimulation frequency (1.2 Hz) would reflect the detection of morphemes in the oddball stimuli. Sensor-level analysis revealed a selective response in a left occipito-temporal region of interest when the oddball stimuli were fully decomposable pseudowords. This response emerged for adults and children alike, showing that automatic morpheme identification occurs at relatively early stages of reading development, in line with major accounts of morphological decomposition. Critically, these findings also suggest that morpheme identification is modulated by the context in which the morphemes appear

Individual differences in newborn visual attention associate with temperament and behavioral difficulties in later childhood

Recently it was shown that individual differences in attention style in infants are associated with childhood effortful control, surgency, and hyperactivity-inattention. Here we investigated whether effortful control, surgency and behavioral problems in childhood can be predicted even earlier, from individual differences in newborns’ average duration of gaze to stimuli. Eighty newborns participated in visual preference and habituation studies. Parents completed questionnaires at follow up (mean age = 7.5 years, SD = 1.0 year). Newborns’ average dwell time was negatively associated with childhood surgency (β = -.25, R2 = .04, p = .02) and total behavioral difficulties (β = -.28, R2 = .05, p = .04) but not with effortful control (β = .03, R2 = .001, p = .76). Individual differences in newborn visual attention significantly associated with individual variation in childhood surgency and behavioral problems, showing that some of the factors responsible for this variation are present at birth

A visual M170 effect of morphological complexity

Recent masked priming studies on visual word recognition have suggested that morphological decomposition is performed prelexically, purely on the basis of the orthographic properties of the word form. Given this, one might expect morphological complexity to modulate early visual evoked activity in electromagnetic measures. We investigated the neural bases of morphological decomposition with magnetoencephalography (MEG). In two experiments, we manipulated morphological complexity in single word lexical decision without priming, once using suffixed words and once using prefixed words. We found that morphologically complex forms display larger amplitudes in the M170, the same component that has been implicated for letterstring and face effects in previous MEG studies. Although letterstring effects have been reported to be left-lateral, we found a right-lateral effect of morphological complexity, suggesting that both hemispheres may be involved in early analysis of word forms

Understanding semantic competition in complex phrase comprehension and production

This thesis investigated the relationship between complex phrase comprehension and production. The work aimed to identify whether parallel competition effects exist between the two tasks; and importantly, the extent to which these effects drive from common processes and knowledge bases. In three studies, participants viewed pictures of various entities doing different actions. For each picture, they comprehended a recorded description (e.g. the teddy bear/man that the girl is hugging) about the entity being acted upon, and were asked to describe it in a production task. They also completed a number of cognitive assessments measuring vocabulary, inhibition, etc. Study 1 found that phrases containing highly similar and reversible nouns are more difficult to comprehend and produce in adults. Importantly, this difficulty varied as a function of individual inhibition skills over above vocabulary in both tasks, and production additionally recruited task-specific motor inhibition processes. Study 2 replicated the reversibility-based effects with children and adolescents. But young children differed from older participants as they experienced greater production interference and are less skilled in using certain production options to alleviate interference. Unlike adults, their language performance was predicted by variance on working memory capacity. Study 3 used eye-tracking to examine the time course of production competition. The results showed reversibility-based competition manifest at verb position, and is particularly relevant to individual’s semantic inhibition skill. This parallels previous comprehension findings, thus suggests shared competition resolution processes across tasks. Together, these findings suggest common reversibility-based competition processes underlying comprehension and production, and across development. Current models arguing for shared prediction processes in adults can potentially incorporate common inhibition mechanisms; however, our data imply that non-shared processes should also be considered. On the other hand, unlike adults, our children’s data supports the capacity-constraint account in language processing, thus suggesting a discontinuity of cognitive functioning in language development