Executable Attribute Grammars for Modular and Efficient Natural Language Processing

Language-processors that are constructed using top-down recursive-descent with backtracking parsing are highly modular, and are easy to implement and maintain. However, a widely-held inaccurate view is that top-down processors are inherently exponential for ambiguous grammars and cannot accommodate left-recursive syntax rules. It has been known that exponential time and space complexities can be avoided by memoization and compact graph-structured representation, and that left- recursive productions can be accommodated through a variety of techniques. However, until now, memoization, compact representation, and techniques for handling left-recursion have either been presented independently, or else attempts at their integration have compromised modularity and correctness of the resulting parses. Specifying syntax and semantics to describe formal languages using denotational notation of attribute grammars (AGs) has been widely practiced. However, very little work has shown the usefulness of declarative AGs for constructing computational models of natural language. Previous top-down approaches fall short in accommodating ambiguous and general CFGs with arbitrary semantics in one pass as executable specifications. Existing approaches lack in providing a declarative syntax-semantics interface that can take full advantages of dependencies between attributes of syntactic constituents to model linguistically-motivated cases. This thesis solves these shortcomings by proposing a new modular top-down syntactic and semantic analysis system, which is efficient and accommodates all forms of CFGs. Moreover, this system provides notation to declaratively specify semantics by establishing arbitrary dependencies between attributes of syntactic categories to perform linguistically-motivated tasks such as: building directly-executable natural-language query processors, computing meanings of sentences using compositional semantics, performing contextual disambiguation tasks, modelling restrictive classes of languages etc

Happy-GLL: modular, reusable and complete top-down parsers for parameterized nonterminals

Parser generators and parser combinator libraries are the most popular tools for producing parsers. Parser combinators use the host language to provide reusable components in the form of higher-order functions with parsers as parameters. Very few parser generators support this kind of reuse through abstraction and even fewer generate parsers that are as modular and reusable as the parts of the grammar for which they are produced. This paper presents a strategy for generating modular, reusable and complete top-down parsers from syntax descriptions with parameterized nonterminals, based on the FUN-GLL variant of the GLL algorithm. The strategy is discussed and demonstrated as a novel back-end for the Happy parser generator. Happy grammars can contain `parameterized nonterminals' in which parameters abstract over grammar symbols, granting an abstraction mechanism to define reusable grammar operators. However, the existing Happy back-ends do not deliver on the full potential of parameterized nonterminals as parameterized nonterminals cannot be reused across grammars. Moreover, the parser generation process may fail to terminate or may result in exponentially large parsers generated in an exponential amount of time. The GLL back-end presented in this paper implements parameterized nonterminals successfully by generating higher-order functions that resemble parser combinators, inheriting all the advantages of top-down parsing. The back-end is capable of generating parsers for the full class of context-free grammars, generates parsers in linear time and generates parsers that find all derivations of the input string. To our knowledge, the presented GLL back-end makes Happy the first parser generator that combines all these features. This paper describes the translation procedure of the GLL back-end and compares it to the LALR and GLR back-ends of Happy in several experiments.Comment: 15 page

Purely functional GLL parsing

Generalised parsing has become increasingly important in the context of software language design and several compiler generators and language workbenches have adopted generalised parsing algorithms such as GLR and GLL. The original GLL parsing algorithms are described in low-level pseudo-code as the output of a parser generator. This paper explains GLL parsing differently, defining the FUN-GLL algorithm as a collection of pure, mathematical functions and focussing on the logic of the algorithm by omitting implementation details. In particular, the data structures are modelled by abstract sets and relations rather than specialised implementations. The description is further simplified by omitting lookahead and adopting the binary subtree representation of derivations to avoid the clerical overhead of graph construction. Conventional parser combinators inherit the drawbacks from the recursive descent algorithms they implement. Based on FUN-GLL, this paper defines generalised parser combinators that overcome these problems. Th

GLL parsing with flexible combinators

At SLE in 2014, Ridge presented the P3 combinator library with which parsers can be developed for left-recursive, non-deterministic and ambiguous grammars. A combinator expression in P3 yields a binarised grammar reflecting the expression's structure. The grammar is given to an underlying, generalised parsing procedure computing all derivations. In this paper we present a combinator library with a similar architecture to P3, adjusting it to avoid grammar binarisation. Avoiding binarisation has a significant positive effect on the running times of the underlying parsing procedure, which we demonstrate using real-world grammars. Binarisation is avoided by restricting the applicability of combinators, resulting in combinator expressions closely resembling BNF fragments. Usability is recovered by defining coercions that automatically convert expressions where necessary. As the underlying parsing procedure, we use a purely functional variant of generalised top-down (GLL) parsing

Staged parser combinators for efficient data processing

Parsers are ubiquitous in computing, and many applications depend on their performance for decoding data efficiently. Parser combinators are an intuitive tool for writing parsers: tight integration with the host language enables grammar specifications to be interleaved with processing of parse results. Unfortunately, parser combinators are typically slow due to the high overhead of the host language abstraction mechanisms that enable composition. We present a technique for eliminating such overhead. We use staging, a form of runtime code generation, to dissociate input parsing from parser composition, and eliminate intermediate data structures and computations associated with parser composition at staging time. A key challenge is to maintain support for input dependent grammars, which have no clear stage distinction. Our approach applies to top-down recursive-descent parsers as well as bottom-up nondeterministic parsers with key applications in dynamic programming on sequences, where we auto-generate code for parallel hardware. We achieve performance comparable to specialized, hand-written parsers

Parsing for agile modeling

Agile modeling refers to a set of methods that allow for a quick initial development of an importer and its further refinement. These requirements are not met simultaneously by the current parsing technology. Problems with parsing became a bottleneck in our research of agile modeling. In this thesis we introduce a novel approach to specify and build parsers. Our approach allows for expressive, tolerant and composable parsers without sacrificing performance. The approach is based on a context-sensitive extension of parsing expression grammars that allows a grammar engineer to specify complex language restrictions. To insure high parsing performance we automatically analyze a grammar definition and choose different parsing strategies for different parts of the grammar. We show that context-sensitive parsing expression grammars allow for highly composable, tolerant and variable-grained parsers that can be easily refined. Different parsing strategies significantly insure high-performance of parsers without sacrificing expressiveness of the underlying grammars

Stream Processing using Grammars and Regular Expressions

In this dissertation we study regular expression based parsing and the use of grammatical specifications for the synthesis of fast, streaming string-processing programs. In the first part we develop two linear-time algorithms for regular expression based parsing with Perl-style greedy disambiguation. The first algorithm operates in two passes in a semi-streaming fashion, using a constant amount of working memory and an auxiliary tape storage which is written in the first pass and consumed by the second. The second algorithm is a single-pass and optimally streaming algorithm which outputs as much of the parse tree as is semantically possible based on the input prefix read so far, and resorts to buffering as many symbols as is required to resolve the next choice. Optimality is obtained by performing a PSPACE-complete pre-analysis on the regular expression. In the second part we present Kleenex, a language for expressing high-performance streaming string processing programs as regular grammars with embedded semantic actions, and its compilation to streaming string transducers with worst-case linear-time performance. Its underlying theory is based on transducer decomposition into oracle and action machines, and a finite-state specialization of the streaming parsing algorithm presented in the first part. In the second part we also develop a new linear-time streaming parsing algorithm for parsing expression grammars (PEG) which generalizes the regular grammars of Kleenex. The algorithm is based on a bottom-up tabulation algorithm reformulated using least fixed points and evaluated using an instance of the chaotic iteration scheme by Cousot and Cousot

Tagungsband zum 21. Kolloquium Programmiersprachen und Grundlagen der Programmierung

Das 21. Kolloquium Programmiersprachen und Grundlagen der Programmierung (KPS 2021) setzt eine traditionelle Reihe von Arbeitstagungen fort, die 1980 von den Forschungsgruppen der Professoren Friedrich L. Bauer (TU München), Klaus Indermark (RWTH Aachen) und Hans Langmaack(CAU Kiel) ins Leben gerufen wurde.Die Veranstaltung ist ein offenes Forum für alle interessierten deutschsprachigen Wissenschaftlerinnen und Wissenschaftler zum zwanglosen Austausch neuer Ideen und Ergebnisse aus den Forschungsbereichen Entwurf und Implementierung von Programmiersprachen sowie Grundlagen und Methodik des Programmierens. Dieser Tagungsband enthält die wissenschaftlichen Beiträge,die bei dem 21. Kolloquium dieser Tagungsreihe präsentiert wurden, welches vom 27. bis 29. September 2021 in Kiel stattfand und von der Arbeitsgruppe Programmiersprachen und Übersetzerkonstruktion der Christian-Albrechts-Universität zu Kiel organisiert wurde