On multimodality of obnoxious faclity location models

Obnoxious single facility location models are models that have the aim to find the best location for an undesired facility. Undesired is usually expressed in relation to the so-called demand points that represent locations hindered by the facility. Because obnoxious facility location models as a rule are multimodal, the standard techniques of convex analysis used for locating desirable facilities in the plane may be trapped in local optima instead of the desired global optimum. It is assumed that having more optima coincides with being harder to solve. In this thesis the multimodality of obnoxious single facility location models is investigated in order to know which models are challenging problems in facility location problems and which are suitable for site selection. Selected for this are the obnoxious facility models that appear to be most important in literature. These are the maximin model, that maximizes the minimum distance from demand point to the obnoxious facility, the maxisum model, that maximizes the sum of distance from the demand points to the facility and the minisum model, that minimizes the sum of damage of the facility to the demand points. All models are measured with the Euclidean distances and some models also with the rectilinear distance metric. Furthermore a suitable algorithm is selected for testing multimodality. Of the tested algorithms in this thesis, Multistart is most appropriate. A small numerical experiment shows that Maximin models have on average the most optima, of which the model locating an obnoxious linesegment has the most. Maximin models have few optima and are thus not very hard to solve. From the Minisum models, the models that have the most optima are models that take wind into account. In general can be said that the generic models have less optima than the weighted versions. Models that are measured with the rectilinear norm do have more solutions than the same models measured with the Euclidean norm. This can be explained for the maximin models in the numerical example because the shape of the norm coincides with a bound of the feasible area, so not all solutions are different optima. The difference found in number of optima of the Maxisum and Minisum can not be explained by this phenomenon

Optimal location of single and multiple obnoxious facilities: Algorithms for the maximin criterion under different norms.

This thesis investigates the computational problem of locating obnoxious (undesirable) facilities in a way that minimizes their effect on a given set of clients (e.g. population centres). Supposing that the undesirable effects of such a facility on a given client are a decreasing function of the distance between them the objective is to locate these facilities as far away as possible from the given set of clients, subject to constraints that prevent location at infinity. Emphasis is given to the MAXIMIN criterion which is to maximize the minimum client-to-facility distance. Distances are measured either in the Euclidean or the rectilinear metric. The properties of the optimal solution to the single facility problem are viewed from different, seemingly unrelated, perspectives ranging from plane geometry to duality theory. In particular, duality results from a mixed integer programming model are used to derive new properties of the optimal solution to the rectilinear problem. A new algorithm is developed for the rectilinear problem where the feasible region is a convex polygon. Unlike previous approaches, this method does not require linear programming at all. In addition to this, an interactive graphical approach is proposed as a site-generation tool used to identify potential locations in realistic problems. Its main advantages are that it requires minimal user intervention and makes no assumptions regarding the feasible region. It has been applied in large scale problems with up to 1000 clients, whereas the largest reported application so far involved 10 clients. Alternative models are presented for the multi-facility problem as well. Each of them is based on different assumptions and is applicable to specific situations. Moreover, an algorithm is established for the two-facility problem based on the properties of the optimal solution. To the best of our knowledge this is the first attempt to address this problem in the plane. Finally, a number of unresolved issues, especially in the multi-facility problem, are outlined and suggested as further research topics

Problemas de localização-distribuição de serviços semiobnóxios: aproximações e apoio à decisão

Doutoramento em Gestão IndustrialA presente tese resulta de um trabalho de investigação cujo objectivo se centrou no problema de localização-distribuição (PLD) que pretende abordar, de forma integrada, duas actividades logísticas intimamente relacionadas: a localização de equipamentos e a distribuição de produtos. O PLD, nomeadamente a sua modelação matemática, tem sido estudado na literatura, dando origem a diversas aproximações que resultam de diferentes cenários reais. Importa portanto agrupar as diferentes variantes por forma a facilitar e potenciar a sua investigação. Após fazer uma revisão e propor uma taxonomia dos modelos de localização-distribuição, este trabalho foca-se na resolução de alguns modelos considerados como mais representativos. É feita assim a análise de dois dos PLDs mais básicos (os problema capacitados com procura nos nós e nos arcos), sendo apresentadas, para ambos, propostas de resolução. Posteriormente, é abordada a localização-distribuição de serviços semiobnóxios. Este tipo de serviços, ainda que seja necessário e indispensável para o público em geral, dada a sua natureza, exerce um efeito desagradável sobre as comunidades contíguas. Assim, aos critérios tipicamente utilizados na tomada de decisão sobre a localização destes serviços (habitualmente a minimização de custo) é necessário adicionar preocupações que reflectem a manutenção da qualidade de vida das regiões que sofrem o impacto do resultado da referida decisão. A abordagem da localização-distribuição de serviços semiobnóxios requer portanto uma análise multi-objectivo. Esta análise pode ser feita com recurso a dois métodos distintos: não interactivos e interactivos. Ambos são abordados nesta tese, com novas propostas, sendo o método interactivo proposto aplicável a outros problemas de programação inteira mista multi-objectivo. Por último, é desenvolvida uma ferramenta de apoio à decisão para os problemas abordados nesta tese, sendo apresentada a metodologia adoptada e as suas principais funcionalidades. A ferramenta desenvolvida tem grandes preocupações com a interface de utilizador, visto ser direccionada para decisores que tipicamente não têm conhecimentos sobre os modelos matemáticos subjacentes a este tipo de problemas.This thesis main objective is to address the location-routing problem (LRP) which intends to tackle, using an integrated approach, two highly related logistics activities: the location of facilities and the distribution of materials. The LRP, namely its mathematical formulation, has been studied in the literature, and several approaches have emerged, corresponding to different real-world scenarios. Therefore, it is important to identify and group the different LRP variants, in order to segment current research and foster future studies. After presenting a review and a taxonomy of location-routing models, the following research focuses on solving some of its variants. Thus, a study of two of the most basic LRPs (capacitated problems with demand either on the nodes or on the arcs) is performed, and new approaches are presented. Afterwards, the location-routing of semi-obnoxious facilities is addressed. These are facilities that, although providing useful and indispensible services, given their nature, bring about an undesirable effect to adjacent communities. Consequently, to the usual objectives when considering their location (cost minimization), new ones must be added that are able to reflect concerns regarding the quality of life of the communities impacted by the outcome of these decisions. The location-routing of semi-obnoxious facilities therefore requires to be analysed using multi-objective approaches, which can be of two types: noninteractive or interactive. Both are discussed and new methods proposed in this thesis; the proposed interactive method is suitable to other multi-objective mixed integer programming problems. Finally, a newly developed decision-support tool to address the LRP is presented (being the adopted methodology discussed, and its main functionalities shown). This tool has great concerns regarding the user interface, as it is directed at decision makers who typically don’t have specific knowledge of the underlying models of this type of problems

Localización simple de servicios deseados y no deseados en redes con múltiples criterios

Análisis y desarrollo de varios modelos de localización de servicios deseados y no deseados en redes con múltiples criterios. Asimismo, se han propuesto algunas mejoras en modelos de localización de servicios no deseados en redes con un solo criterio. Por consiguiente, con respecto a la localización de servicios deseados sobre redes, se propone un algoritmo polinomial para solucionar el problema del cent-dian biobjetivo. También se ha estudiado la localización de un servicio en una red con múltiples objetivos tipo mediana. Asimismo, se ha desarrollado un algoritmo polinomial para solucionar el problema cent-dian multicriterio en redes con múltiples pesos por nodo y múltiples longitudes por arista. Con respecto a los problemas de localización de servicios no deseados, primero tratamos el problema de localización del 1-centro no deseado en redes. Demostramos que las cotas superiores ya propuestas en trabajos anteriores pueden ser ajustadas. Por medio de una formulación más adecuada del problema, se ha desarrollado un nuevo algoritmo polinomial el cual es más sencillo y computacionalmente más rápido que los ya divulgados en la literatura. También se ha analizado el problema de localizar una mediana no deseada en una red, obteniendo una nueva y mejor cota superior. Se presenta un nuevo algoritmo para solucionar este problema. Por otra parte, siguiendo la resolución del problema maxian, también se ha propuesto un nuevo algoritmo para solucionar el problema del anti-cent-dian en redes. Finalmente, se han estudiado los problemas del centro no deseado y de la mediana no deseada en redes multicriterio, estableciendo nuevas propiedades y reglas para eliminar aristas ineficientes. También se presenta el modelo anti-cent-dian como combinación convexa de los dos últimos problemas. Se propone una regla eficaz para quitar aristas que contienen puntos ineficientes, así como un algoritmo polinomial. Además, este modelo se puede modificar ligeramente para generalizar otros modelos presentados en la literatura

A review of network location theory and models

Cataloged from PDF version of article.In this study, we review the existing literature on network location problems. The study has a broad scope that includes problems featuring desirable and undesirable facilities, point facilities and extensive facilities, monopolistic and competitive markets, and single or multiple objectives. Deterministic and stochastic models as well as robust models are covered. Demand data aggregation is also discussed. More than 500 papers in this area are reviewed and critical issues, research directions, and problem extensions are emphasized.Erdoğan, Damla SelinM.S

The hazardous waste location-routing problem

Cataloged from PDF version of article.As a result of high industrialization and technology hazardous waste management problem has now become an unavoidable problem of the world. Hazardous waste management involves collection, transportation, treatment and disposal of hazardous wastes. In this thesis, the existing models in the literature are analyzed in terms of applicability. A new multiobjective location-routing model is proposed by combining the applicable aspects from different models. Our model also includes the constraints that reflect certain requirements that have been observed in the literature but could not been incorporated into the models correctly together with the additional constraints that we propose. The aim of the model is to decide on the following questions: where to open treatment centers with which technologies, where to open disposal centers, how to route different types of hazardous wastes to which of the compatible treatment technologies, and how to route waste residues to disposal centers. The model has two objectives of minimizing total cost and minimizing transportation risk. A large scale implementation of the model in the Central Anatolian Region of Turkey is presented.Alumur, SibelM.S

Locating a bioenergy facility using a hybrid optimization method

In this paper, the optimum location of a bioenergy generation facility for district energy applications is sought. A bioenergy facility usually belongs to a wider system, therefore a holistic approach is adopted to define the location that optimizes the system-wide operational and investment costs. A hybrid optimization method is employed to overcome the limitations posed by the complexity of the optimization problem. The efficiency of the hybrid method is compared to a stochastic (genetic algorithms) and an exact optimization method (Sequential Quadratic Programming). The results confirm that the hybrid optimization method proposed is the most efficient for the specific problem. (C) 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved

Minisum and minimax transfer point location problem with random demands points

This paper is concerned with analyzing some models of the weighted transfer point location problem under the minisum and minimax criterions when demand points are randomly distributed over regions of the plane and the location of the service facility is known. In case of minisum objective with rectilinear distance, an iterative procedure was constructed for estimating the optimal transfer point location using the hyperbolic application procedure. Exact analytic solution was obtained when the random demand points follow uniform distributions. A unified analytic optimal solution was provided for all types of probability distributions of the random demand points when the distance is the squared Euclidean distance. For minimax objective with squared Euclidean distance, an iterative procedure based on Karush-Kuhn-Tucker conditions was developed to produce an approximate solution to the optimal solution. Illustrative numerical examples were provided

Minimax and Maximin Fitting of Geometric Objects to Sets of Points

This thesis addresses several problems in the facility location sub-area of computational geometry. Let S be a set of n points in the plane. We derive algorithms for approximating S by a step function curve of size k \u3c n, i.e., by an x-monotone orthogonal polyline ℜ with k \u3c n horizontal segments. We use the vertical distance to measure the quality of the approximation, i.e., the maximum distance from a point in S to the horizontal segment directly above or below it. We consider two types of problems: min-ε, where the goal is to minimize the error for a given number of horizontal segments k and min-#, where the goal is to minimize the number of segments for a given allowed error ε. After O(n) preprocessing time, we solve instances of the latter in O(min{k log n, n}) time per instance. We can then solve the former problem in O(min{n2, nk log n}) time. Both algorithms require O(n) space. The second contribution is a heuristic for the min-ε problem that computes a solution within a factor of 3 of the optimal error for k segments, or with at most the same error as the k-optimal but using 2k - 1 segments. Furthermore, experiments on real data show even better results than what is guaranteed by the theoretical bounds. Both approximations run in O(n log n) time and O(n) space. Then, we present an exact algorithm for the weighted version of this problem that runs in O(n2) time and generalize the heuristic to handle weights at the expense of an additional log n factor. At this point, a randomized algorithm that runs in O(n log2 n) expected time for the unweighted version is presented. It easily generalizes to the weighted case, though at the expense of an additional log n factor. Finally, we treat the maximin problem and present an O(n3 log n) solution to the problem of finding the furthest separating line through a set of weighted points. We conclude with solutions to the obnoxious wedge problem: an O(n2 log n) algorithm for the general case of a wedge with its apex on the boundary of the convex hull of S and an O(n2) algorithm for the case of the apex of a wedge coming from the input set S