Learning Controllers for Reactive and Proactive Behaviors in Human–Robot Collaboration

Designed to safely share the same workspace as humans and assist them in a variety of tasks, the new collaborative robots are targeting manufacturing and service applications that once were considered unattainable. The large diversity of tasks to carry out, the unstructured environments and the close interaction with humans call for collaborative robots to seamlessly adapt their behaviors so as to cooperate with the users successfully under different and possibly new situations (characterized, for example, by positions of objects/landmarks in the environment, or by the user pose). This paper investigates how controllers capable of reactive and proactive behaviors in collaborative tasks can be learned from demonstrations. The proposed approach exploits the temporal coherence and dynamic characteristics of the task observed during the training phase to build a probabilistic model that enables the robot to both react to the user actions and lead the task when needed. The method is an extension of the Hidden Semi-Markov Model where the duration probability distribution is adapted according to the interaction with the user. This Adaptive Duration Hidden Semi-Markov Model (ADHSMM) is used to retrieve a sequence of states governing a trajectory optimization that provides the reference and gain matrices to the robot controller. A proof-of-concept evaluation is first carried out in a pouring task. The proposed framework is then tested in a collaborative task using a 7 DOF backdrivable manipulator

Robotix-Academy Conference for Industrial Robotics (RACIR) 2019

Robotix-Academy Conference for Industrial Robotics (RACIR) is held in University of Liège, Belgium, during June 05, 2019. The topics concerned by RACIR are: robot design, robot kinematics/dynamics/control, system integration, sensor/ actuator networks, distributed and cloud robotics, bio-inspired systems, service robots, robotics in automation, biomedical applications, autonomous vehicles (land, sea and air), robot perception, manipulation with multi-finger hands, micro/nano systems, sensor information, robot vision, multimodal interface and human-robot interaction.

Bimanual robot skills: MP encoding, dimensionality reduction and reinforcement learning

Aplicat embargament des de la data de defensa fins 1/7/2018Premio a la mejor Tesis Doctoral sobre Robótica, Edición 2017, atorgat pel Comité Español de Automática.Finalista del 2018 George Girault PhD Award, from EuRoboticsIn our culture, robots have been in novels and cinema for a long time, but it has been specially in the last two decades when the improvements in hardware - better computational power and components - and advances in Artificial Intelligence (AI), have allowed robots to start sharing spaces with humans. Such situations require, aside from ethical considerations, robots to be able to move with both compliance and precision, and learn at different levels, such as perception, planning, and motion, being the latter the focus of this work. The first issue addressed in this thesis is inverse kinematics for redundant robot manipulators, i.e: positioning the robot joints so as to reach a certain end-effector pose. We opt for iterative solutions based on the inversion of the kinematic Jacobian of a robot, and propose to filter and limit the gains in the spectral domain, while also unifying such approach with a continuous, multipriority scheme. Such inverse kinematics method is then used to derive manipulability in the whole workspace of an antropomorphic arm, and the coordination of two arms is subsequently optimized by finding their best relative positioning. Having solved the kinematic issues, a robot learning within a human environment needs to move compliantly, with limited amount of force, in order not to harm any humans or cause any damage, while being as precise as possible. Therefore, we developed two dynamic models for the same redundant arm we had analysed kinematically: The first based on local models with Gaussian projections, and the second characterizing the most problematic term of the dynamics, namely friction. Such models allowed us to implement feed-forward controllers, where we can actively change the weights in the compliance-precision tradeoff. Moreover, we used such models to predict external forces acting on the robot, without the use of force sensors. Afterwards, we noticed that bimanual robots must coordinate their components (or limbs) and be able to adapt to new situations with ease. Over the last decade, a number of successful applications for learning robot motion tasks have been published. However, due to the complexity of a complete system including all the required elements, most of these applications involve only simple robots with a large number of high-end technology sensors, or consist of very simple and controlled tasks. Using our previous framework for kinematics and control, we relied on two types of movement primitives to encapsulate robot motion. Such movement primitives are very suitable for using reinforcement learning. In particular, we used direct policy search, which uses the motion parametrization as the policy itself. In order to improve the learning speed in real robot applications, we generalized a policy search algorithm to give some importance to samples yielding a bad result, and we paid special attention to the dimensionality of the motion parametrization. We reduced such dimensionality with linear methods, using the rewards obtained through motion repetition and execution. We tested such framework in a bimanual task performed by two antropomorphic arms, such as the folding of garments, showing how a reduced dimensionality can provide qualitative information about robot couplings and help to speed up the learning of tasks when robot motion executions are costly.A la nostra cultura, els robots han estat presents en novel·les i cinema des de fa dècades, però ha sigut especialment en les últimes dues quan les millores en hardware (millors capacitats de còmput) i els avenços en intel·ligència artificial han permès que els robots comencin a compartir espais amb els humans. Aquestes situacions requereixen, a banda de consideracions ètiques, que els robots siguin capaços de moure's tant amb suavitat com amb precisió, i d'aprendre a diferents nivells, com són la percepció, planificació i moviment, essent l'última el centre d'atenció d'aquest treball. El primer problema adreçat en aquesta tesi és la cinemàtica inversa, i.e.: posicionar les articulacions del robot de manera que l'efector final estigui en una certa posició i orientació. Hem estudiat el camp de les solucions iteratives, basades en la inversió del Jacobià cinemàtic d'un robot, i proposem un filtre que limita els guanys en el seu domini espectral, mentre també unifiquem tal mètode dins un esquema multi-prioritat i continu. Aquest mètode per a la cinemàtica inversa és usat a l'hora d'encapsular tota la informació sobre l'espai de treball d'un braç antropomòrfic, i les capacitats de coordinació entre dos braços són optimitzades, tot trobant la seva millor posició relativa en l'espai. Havent resolt les dificultats cinemàtiques, un robot que aprèn en un entorn humà necessita moure's amb suavitat exercint unes forces limitades per tal de no causar danys, mentre es mou amb la màxima precisió possible. Per tant, hem desenvolupat dos models dinàmics per al mateix braç robòtic redundant que havíem analitzat des del punt de vista cinemàtic: El primer basat en models locals amb projeccions de Gaussianes i el segon, caracteritzant el terme més problemàtic i difícil de representar de la dinàmica, la fricció. Aquests models ens van permetre utilitzar controladors coneguts com "feed-forward", on podem canviar activament els guanys buscant l'equilibri precisió-suavitat que més convingui. A més, hem usat aquests models per a inferir les forces externes actuant en el robot, sense la necessitat de sensors de força. Més endavant, ens hem adonat que els robots bimanuals han de coordinar els seus components (braços) i ser capaços d'adaptar-se a noves situacions amb facilitat. Al llarg de l'última dècada, diverses aplicacions per aprendre tasques motores robòtiques amb èxit han estat publicades. No obstant, degut a la complexitat d'un sistema complet que inclogui tots els elements necessaris, la majoria d'aquestes aplicacions consisteixen en robots més aviat simples amb costosos sensors d'última generació, o a resoldre tasques senzilles en un entorn molt controlat. Utilitzant el nostre treball en cinemàtica i control, ens hem basat en dos tipus de primitives de moviment per caracteritzar la motricitat robòtica. Aquestes primitives de moviment són molt adequades per usar aprenentatge per reforç. En particular, hem usat la búsqueda directa de la política, un camp de l'aprenentatge per reforç que usa la parametrització del moviment com la pròpia política. Per tal de millorar la velocitat d'aprenentatge en aplicacions amb robots reals, hem generalitzat un algoritme de búsqueda directa de política per a donar importància a les mostres amb mal resultat, i hem donat especial atenció a la reducció de dimensionalitat en la parametrització dels moviments. Hem reduït la dimensionalitat amb mètodes lineals, utilitzant les recompenses obtingudes EN executar els moviments. Aquests mètodes han estat provats en tasques bimanuals com són plegar roba, usant dos braços antropomòrfics. Els resultats mostren com la reducció de dimensionalitat pot aportar informació qualitativa d'una tasca, i al mateix temps ajuda a aprendre-la més ràpid quan les execucions amb robots reals són costoses.Award-winningPostprint (published version

Bimanual robot skills: MP encoding, dimensionality reduction and reinforcement learning

In our culture, robots have been in novels and cinema for a long time, but it has been specially in the last two decades when the improvements in hardware - better computational power and components - and advances in Artificial Intelligence (AI), have allowed robots to start sharing spaces with humans. Such situations require, aside from ethical considerations, robots to be able to move with both compliance and precision, and learn at different levels, such as perception, planning, and motion, being the latter the focus of this work. The first issue addressed in this thesis is inverse kinematics for redundant robot manipulators, i.e: positioning the robot joints so as to reach a certain end-effector pose. We opt for iterative solutions based on the inversion of the kinematic Jacobian of a robot, and propose to filter and limit the gains in the spectral domain, while also unifying such approach with a continuous, multipriority scheme. Such inverse kinematics method is then used to derive manipulability in the whole workspace of an antropomorphic arm, and the coordination of two arms is subsequently optimized by finding their best relative positioning. Having solved the kinematic issues, a robot learning within a human environment needs to move compliantly, with limited amount of force, in order not to harm any humans or cause any damage, while being as precise as possible. Therefore, we developed two dynamic models for the same redundant arm we had analysed kinematically: The first based on local models with Gaussian projections, and the second characterizing the most problematic term of the dynamics, namely friction. Such models allowed us to implement feed-forward controllers, where we can actively change the weights in the compliance-precision tradeoff. Moreover, we used such models to predict external forces acting on the robot, without the use of force sensors. Afterwards, we noticed that bimanual robots must coordinate their components (or limbs) and be able to adapt to new situations with ease. Over the last decade, a number of successful applications for learning robot motion tasks have been published. However, due to the complexity of a complete system including all the required elements, most of these applications involve only simple robots with a large number of high-end technology sensors, or consist of very simple and controlled tasks. Using our previous framework for kinematics and control, we relied on two types of movement primitives to encapsulate robot motion. Such movement primitives are very suitable for using reinforcement learning. In particular, we used direct policy search, which uses the motion parametrization as the policy itself. In order to improve the learning speed in real robot applications, we generalized a policy search algorithm to give some importance to samples yielding a bad result, and we paid special attention to the dimensionality of the motion parametrization. We reduced such dimensionality with linear methods, using the rewards obtained through motion repetition and execution. We tested such framework in a bimanual task performed by two antropomorphic arms, such as the folding of garments, showing how a reduced dimensionality can provide qualitative information about robot couplings and help to speed up the learning of tasks when robot motion executions are costly.A la nostra cultura, els robots han estat presents en novel·les i cinema des de fa dècades, però ha sigut especialment en les últimes dues quan les millores en hardware (millors capacitats de còmput) i els avenços en intel·ligència artificial han permès que els robots comencin a compartir espais amb els humans. Aquestes situacions requereixen, a banda de consideracions ètiques, que els robots siguin capaços de moure's tant amb suavitat com amb precisió, i d'aprendre a diferents nivells, com són la percepció, planificació i moviment, essent l'última el centre d'atenció d'aquest treball. El primer problema adreçat en aquesta tesi és la cinemàtica inversa, i.e.: posicionar les articulacions del robot de manera que l'efector final estigui en una certa posició i orientació. Hem estudiat el camp de les solucions iteratives, basades en la inversió del Jacobià cinemàtic d'un robot, i proposem un filtre que limita els guanys en el seu domini espectral, mentre també unifiquem tal mètode dins un esquema multi-prioritat i continu. Aquest mètode per a la cinemàtica inversa és usat a l'hora d'encapsular tota la informació sobre l'espai de treball d'un braç antropomòrfic, i les capacitats de coordinació entre dos braços són optimitzades, tot trobant la seva millor posició relativa en l'espai. Havent resolt les dificultats cinemàtiques, un robot que aprèn en un entorn humà necessita moure's amb suavitat exercint unes forces limitades per tal de no causar danys, mentre es mou amb la màxima precisió possible. Per tant, hem desenvolupat dos models dinàmics per al mateix braç robòtic redundant que havíem analitzat des del punt de vista cinemàtic: El primer basat en models locals amb projeccions de Gaussianes i el segon, caracteritzant el terme més problemàtic i difícil de representar de la dinàmica, la fricció. Aquests models ens van permetre utilitzar controladors coneguts com "feed-forward", on podem canviar activament els guanys buscant l'equilibri precisió-suavitat que més convingui. A més, hem usat aquests models per a inferir les forces externes actuant en el robot, sense la necessitat de sensors de força. Més endavant, ens hem adonat que els robots bimanuals han de coordinar els seus components (braços) i ser capaços d'adaptar-se a noves situacions amb facilitat. Al llarg de l'última dècada, diverses aplicacions per aprendre tasques motores robòtiques amb èxit han estat publicades. No obstant, degut a la complexitat d'un sistema complet que inclogui tots els elements necessaris, la majoria d'aquestes aplicacions consisteixen en robots més aviat simples amb costosos sensors d'última generació, o a resoldre tasques senzilles en un entorn molt controlat. Utilitzant el nostre treball en cinemàtica i control, ens hem basat en dos tipus de primitives de moviment per caracteritzar la motricitat robòtica. Aquestes primitives de moviment són molt adequades per usar aprenentatge per reforç. En particular, hem usat la búsqueda directa de la política, un camp de l'aprenentatge per reforç que usa la parametrització del moviment com la pròpia política. Per tal de millorar la velocitat d'aprenentatge en aplicacions amb robots reals, hem generalitzat un algoritme de búsqueda directa de política per a donar importància a les mostres amb mal resultat, i hem donat especial atenció a la reducció de dimensionalitat en la parametrització dels moviments. Hem reduït la dimensionalitat amb mètodes lineals, utilitzant les recompenses obtingudes EN executar els moviments. Aquests mètodes han estat provats en tasques bimanuals com són plegar roba, usant dos braços antropomòrfics. Els resultats mostren com la reducció de dimensionalitat pot aportar informació qualitativa d'una tasca, i al mateix temps ajuda a aprendre-la més ràpid quan les execucions amb robots reals són costoses

Learning Controllers for Reactive and Proactive Behaviors in Human-Robot Collaboration

Designed to safely share the same workspace as humans and assist them in a variety of tasks, the new collaborative robots are targeting manufacturing and service applications that once were considered unattainable. The large diversity of tasks to carry out, the unstructured environments and the close interaction with humans call for collaborative robots to seamlessly adapt their behaviors so as to cooperate with the users successfully under different and possibly new situations (characterized, for example, by positions of objects/landmarks in the environment, or by the user pose). This paper investigates how controllers capable of reactive and proactive behaviors in collaborative tasks can be learned from demonstrations. The proposed approach exploits the temporal coherence and dynamic characteristics of the task observed during the training phase to build a probabilistic model that enables the robot to both react to the user actions and lead the task when needed. The method is an extension of the Hidden Semi-Markov Model where the duration probability distribution is adapted according to the interaction with the user. This Adaptive Duration Hidden Semi-Markov Model (ADHSMM) is used to retrieve a sequence of states governing a trajectory optimization that provides the reference and gain matrices to the robot controller. A proof-of-concept evaluation is first carried out in a pouring task. The proposed framework is then tested in a collaborative task using a 7 DOF backdrivable manipulator

Robotic Trajectory Tracking: Position- and Force-Control

This thesis employs a bottom-up approach to develop robust and adaptive learning algorithms for trajectory tracking: position and torque control. In a first phase, the focus is put on the following of a freeform surface in a discontinuous manner. Next to resulting switching constraints, disturbances and uncertainties, the case of unknown robot models is addressed. In a second phase, once contact has been established between surface and end effector and the freeform path is followed, a desired force is applied. In order to react to changing circumstances, the manipulator needs to show the features of an intelligent agent, i.e. it needs to learn and adapt its behaviour based on a combination of a constant interaction with its environment and preprogramed goals or preferences. The robotic manipulator mimics the human behaviour based on bio-inspired algorithms. In this way it is taken advantage of the know-how and experience of human operators as their knowledge is translated in robot skills. A selection of promising concepts is explored, developed and combined to extend the application areas of robotic manipulators from monotonous, basic tasks in stiff environments to complex constrained processes. Conventional concepts (Sliding Mode Control, PID) are combined with bio-inspired learning (BELBIC, reinforcement based learning) for robust and adaptive control. Independence of robot parameters is guaranteed through approximated robot functions using a Neural Network with online update laws and model-free algorithms. The performance of the concepts is evaluated through simulations and experiments. In complex freeform trajectory tracking applications, excellent absolute mean position errors (<0.3 rad) are achieved. Position and torque control are combined in a parallel concept with minimized absolute mean torque errors (<0.1 Nm)

Real-time Human Workload Estimation and Its Application in Adaptive Haptic Shared Control

Automated vehicles (AVs) are promising to have the potential to reduce driving-related injuries and deaths. However, autonomous driving technology is currently limited in its scope and reliability, giving rise to the semi-autonomous driving model, where the autonomy and the human share the control of the vehicle. Workload, despite being an important human factor, has not yet been considered when designing adaptive shared control. Recently, researchers have started to apply machine learning techniques to classify mental workload into different levels. However, most of these studies have adopted either a single-model-single-feature approach or a single-model-all-features approach. However different machine learning models are suitable for different features, how to leverage different models for different features is critical. To address these shortcomings and research gaps, the goals of this dissertation were to (1) examine whether and to what extent haptic shared control performance can be improved by incorporating operators' workload; (2) develop a computational model for workload estimation, and the model should be able to leverage different machine learning models that work best for different features; and (3) investigate the generalizability of the workload estimation model. To address these research goals, this dissertation was composed of four research phases with two pilot studies and four human subject experiments. (1) Collaborating with Yifan Weng, Dr. Tulga Ersal, and Prof. Jeffrey Stein from the Department of Mechanical Engineering at the University of Michigan, we developed a teleoperated dual-task shared control simulation platform where the human shared control of a ground vehicle with autonomy while performing a surveillance task simultaneously. In addition, we developed a real-time eye-tracking system based on Tobii Pro Glasses 2 to measure the human gaze points in a world frame and pupil sizes. (2) We proposed a workload-adaptive haptic shared control scheme together with our collaborators. We conducted two human subject experiments during this phase. The results indicated that the proposed workload-adaptive haptic shared control scheme can reduce human workload, increase human trust in the system, increase driving performance, and reduce human effort without sacrificing surveillance task performance. (3) We proposed a Bayesian inference model for workload estimation that can leverage the different machine learning models that work best for different features. Specifically, we used support-vector machines (SVMs) for pupil size change, the Hidden Markov Model (HMM) for gaze trajectory, SVMs for fixation feature, and Gaussian Mixture Models (GMMs) for fixation trajectory. The empirical results indicated that our proposed model achieved a 0.82 F1 score for workload imposed by varying surveillance task urgency. (4) We investigated the generalizability of our proposed Bayesian inference model for workload estimation by conducting two human subject experiments with 24 participants and using different factors to impose human workload, i.e., obstacle headway and driving speed. The results indicated that our proposed model achieved a 0.68 F1 score for the workload imposed by obstacle avoidance and the personalized version of our proposed model can distinguish the workload imposed by different driving speeds under high surveillance task urgency.PHDRoboticsUniversity of Michigan, Horace H. Rackham School of Graduate Studieshttp://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/169623/1/ruikunl_1.pd