Kilo-instruction processors: overcoming the memory wall

Historically, advances in integrated circuit technology have driven improvements in processor microarchitecture and led to todays microprocessors with sophisticated pipelines operating at very high clock frequencies. However, performance improvements achievable by high-frequency microprocessors have become seriously limited by main-memory access latencies because main-memory speeds have improved at a much slower pace than microprocessor speeds. Its crucial to deal with this performance disparity, commonly known as the memory wall, to enable future high-frequency microprocessors to achieve their performance potential. To overcome the memory wall, we propose kilo-instruction processors-superscalar processors that can maintain a thousand or more simultaneous in-flight instructions. Doing so means designing key hardware structures so that the processor can satisfy the high resource requirements without significantly decreasing processor efficiency or increasing energy consumption.Peer ReviewedPostprint (published version

Affordable kilo-instruction processors

Diversos motius expliquen l'estancament en el que es troba el desenvolupament del processador tradicional dissenyat per maximitzar el rendiment d'un únic fil d'execució. Per una banda, técniques agressives com la supersegmentacó del camí de dades o l'execució fora d'ordre tenen un impacte molt negatiu sobre el consum de potència i la complexitat del disseny. Altrament, l'increment en la freqüència del processador augmenta la discrepància entre la velocitat del processador i el temps d'accés a memòria principal. Tot i que les memòries cau redueixen considerablement el nombre d'accessos a memòria principal, aquests accessos introdueixen latencies prou grans per reduir considerablement el rendiment. Tècniques convencionals com l'execució fora d'ordre, útils per ocultar accessos a les memòries cau de 2on nivell, no estan pensades per ocultar latències tan grans. Caldrien cues amb mides de centenars d'instruccions i milers de registres per tal de no interrompre l'execució en el moment de produir-se un accés a memòria principal. Desafortunadament, la tecnologia disponible no és eficient per implementar aquestes estructures monolíticament, doncs resultaria un temps d'accés molt elevat, un consum de potència igualment elevat i un àrea no menyspreable. En aquesta tesi s'han estudiat tècniques que permeten l'implementació d'un processador amb capacitat per continuar processant instruccions en el cas de que es produeixin accessos a memòria principal. Les condicions per a que aquest processador sigui implementable són que estigui basat en estructures de mida convencional i que tingui una unitat de control senzilla. El repte es troba en conciliar un model de processador distribuït amb un control senzill. El problema del disseny del processador s'ha enfocat observant el comportament d'un processador de recursos infinits. S'ha observat que l'execució segueix uns patrons molt interessants, basats en la localitat d'execució. En aplicacions numèriques s'observa que més del 70% de les instruccions no depenen de accessos a memòria principal. Aixó és molt important doncs mostra que sempre hi ha una porció important d'instruccions executables poc després de la decodificació. Aixó permet proposar un nou tipus de processador amb dues unitats d'execució. La primera unitat (el "Cache Processor") processa a alta velocitat instruccions independents de memòria principal. La segona unitat ("Memory Processor") processa les instruccions dependents de accessos a memòria principal, pero de forma molt més relaxada, cosa que li permet mantenir milers de instruccions en vol. Aquesta proposta rep el nom de Decoupled KILO-Instruction Processor (D-KIP) i té forces avantatges: per un costat permet la construcció d'un kilo-instruction processor basat en estructures convencionals i per l'altre simplifica el disseny ja que minimitza les interaccions entre ambdos unitats d'execució.En aquesta tesi es proposen dos implementacions de processadors desacoblats: el D-KIP original, i el Flexible Heterogeneous MultiCore (FMC). Sobre aquestes propostes s'analitza el rendiment i es compara amb altres tècniques que incrementan el parallelisme de memoria, com el prefetching o l'execució "runahead". D'aquesta avaluació es desprén que el processador FMC té un rendiment similar al de un processador convencional amb una finestra de 1500 instruccions en vol. Posteriorment s'analitza l'integració del FMC en entorns multicore/multiprogrammats. La tesi es completa amb la proposta d'una cua de loads i stores (LSQ) per a aquest tipus de processador.Several motives explain the slowdown of high-performance single-thread processor development. On the one hand, aggressive techniques such as superpipelining or out-of-order execution have a considerable impact on power consumption and design complexity. On the other hand, the increment in processor frequencies has led to a large disparity between processor speed and memory access time. Although cache memories considerably reduce the number of accesses to main memory, the remaining accesses introduce latencies large enough to considerably decrease performance. Conventional techniques such as out-of-order execution, while effective in hiding L2 cache accesses, cannot hide latencies this large. Queues of hundreds of entries and thousands of registers would be necessary in order to prevent execution from stalling in the event of a L2 cache miss. Unfortunately, current technology cannot efficiently implement such structures monolithically, as access latencies would considerably increase, as would power consumption and area consumption.In this thesis we studied techniques that allow the processor to continue processing instructions in the event of main memory accesses. The conditions for such a processor to be implementable are that it should be based on structures of conventional size and that it should feature simple control logic. The challenge lies in being able to design a distributed processor with simple control. The design of this processor has been approached by analyzing the behavior of a processor with infinite resources. We have observed that execution follows a very interesting pattern based on execution locality. In numerical codes we observed that over 70% of all instructions do not depend on memory accesses. This is interesting since it shows that there is always a large portion of instructions that can be executed shortly after decode. This allows us to propose a new kind of processor with two execution units. The first unit, the Cache Processor, processes memory-independent instructions at high speed. The second unit, the Memory Processor, processes instructions that depend on main memory accesses, but using relaxed scheduling logic, which allows it to scale to thousands of in-flight instructions. This proposal, which receives the name of Decoupled KILO-Instruction Processor (D-KIP), has several advantages. On the one hand it allows the construction of a kilo-instruction processor based on conventional structures and, on the other hand, it simplifies the design as the interaction between both execution units is minimal. In this thesis two implementations for this kind of processor are presented: the original D-KIP and the Flexible Heterogeneous MultiCore (FMC). The performance of these proposals is analyzed and compared to other proposals that increase memory-level parallelism, such as prefetching or runahead execution. It is observed that the FMC processor performs at the same level of a conventional processor with a window of around 1500 instructions. Further, the integration of the FMC processor into a multicore/multiprogrammed environment is studied. This thesis concludes with the proposal of a two-level Load/Store Queue for this kind of processor

Solving multiprocessor drawbacks with kilo-instruction processors

Nowadays, a good multiprocessor system design has to deal with many drawbacks in order to achieve a good tradeoff between complexity and performance. For example, while solving problems like coherence and consistency is essential for correctness the way to solve processor stalls due to critical sections and synchronization points is desirable for performance. And none of these drawbacks has a straightforward solution. We show in our paper how the multi-checkpointing mechanism of the Kilo-Instruction Processors can be correctly leveraged in order to achieve a good complexity-effective multiprocessor design. Specifically, we describe a Kilo-Instruction Multiprocessor that transparently, i.e. without any software support, uses transaction-based memory updates. Our model simplifies the coherence and consistency hardware and gives the potential for easily applying different desirable speculative mechanisms to enhance performance when facing some synchronization constructs of current parallel applications.Postprint (published version

Characterizing and Subsetting Big Data Workloads

Big data benchmark suites must include a diversity of data and workloads to be useful in fairly evaluating big data systems and architectures. However, using truly comprehensive benchmarks poses great challenges for the architecture community. First, we need to thoroughly understand the behaviors of a variety of workloads. Second, our usual simulation-based research methods become prohibitively expensive for big data. As big data is an emerging field, more and more software stacks are being proposed to facilitate the development of big data applications, which aggravates hese challenges. In this paper, we first use Principle Component Analysis (PCA) to identify the most important characteristics from 45 metrics to characterize big data workloads from BigDataBench, a comprehensive big data benchmark suite. Second, we apply a clustering technique to the principle components obtained from the PCA to investigate the similarity among big data workloads, and we verify the importance of including different software stacks for big data benchmarking. Third, we select seven representative big data workloads by removing redundant ones and release the BigDataBench simulation version, which is publicly available from http://prof.ict.ac.cn/BigDataBench/simulatorversion/.Comment: 11 pages, 6 figures, 2014 IEEE International Symposium on Workload Characterizatio

A case for resource-conscious out-of-order processors

Modern out-of-order processors tolerate long-latency memory operations by supporting a large number of in-flight instructions. This is achieved in part through proper sizing of critical resources, such as register files or instruction queues. In light of the increasing gap between processor speed and memory latency, tolerating upcoming latencies in this way would require impractical sizes of such critical resources.To tackle this scalability problem, we make a case for resource-conscious out-of-order processors. We present quantitative evidence that critical resources are increasingly underutilized in these processors. We advocate that better use of such resources should be a priority in future research in processor architectures.Peer ReviewedPostprint (published version

Implicit transactional memory in kilo-instruction multiprocessors

Although they have been the main server technology for many years, multiprocessors are undergoing a renaissance due to multi-core chips and the attractive scalability properties of combining a number of such multi-core chips into a system. The widespread use of multiprocessor systems will make performance losses due to consistency models and synchronization styles of popular programming models even more evident than they already are. Known architectural approaches to combat these losses are generally too complex, too specialized, or not transparent to software. In this article, we introduce implicit transactional memory as a generalized architectural concept to remove unnecessary performance losses caused by consistency models and synchronization styles. We show how the concept of implicit transactions can be implemented with low complexity by leveraging the multi-checkpoint mechanism of the Kilo-Instruction Processor. By relying on a general speculation substrate, this method supports even the strictest consistency model – sequential consistency – potentially as effectively as weaker models and it allows multiple threads to speculatively execute critical sections, beyond barriers and event synchronizations.Postprint (published version

Hardware support for Local Memory Transactions on GPU Architectures

Graphics Processing Units (GPUs) are popular hardware accelerators for data-parallel applications, enabling the execution of thousands of threads in a Single Instruction - Multiple Thread (SIMT) fashion. However, the SIMT execution model is not efficient when code includes critical sections to protect the access to data shared by the running threads. In addition, GPUs offer two shared spaces to the threads, local memory and global memory. Typical solutions to thread synchronization include the use of atomics to implement locks, the serialization of the execution of the critical section, or delegating the execution of the critical section to the host CPU, leading to suboptimal performance. In the multi-core CPU world, transactional memory (TM) was proposed as an alternative to locks to coordinate concurrent threads. Some solutions for GPUs started to appear in the literature. In contrast to these earlier proposals, our approach is to design hardware support for TM in two levels. The first level is a fast and lightweight solution for coordinating threads that share the local memory, while the second level coordinates threads through the global memory. In this paper we present GPU-LocalTM as a hardware TM (HTM) support for the first level. GPU-LocalTM offers simple conflict detection and version management mechanisms that minimize the hardware resources required for its implementation. For the workloads studied, GPU-LocalTM provides between 1.25-80X speedup over serialized critical sections, while the overhead introduced by transaction management is lower than 20%.Universidad de Málaga. Campus de Excelencia Internacional Andalucía Tech

Implicit transactional memory in chip multiprocessors

Chip Multiprocessors (CMPs) are an efficient way of designing and use the huge amount of transistors on a chip. Different cores on a chip can compose a shared memory system with a very low-latency interconnect at a very low cost. Unfortunately, consistency models and synchronization styles of popular programming models for multiprocessors impose severe performance losses. Known architectural approaches to combat these losses are too complex, too specialized, or not transparent to the software. In this article, we introduce “implicit transactional memory” as a generalized architectural concept to remove such performance losses. We show how the concept of implicit transactions can be implemented at a low complexity by leveraging the multi-checkpoint mechanism of the Kilo-Instruction Processor. By relying on a general speculation substrate, it supports even the strictest consistency model – sequential consistency – potentially as effectively as weaker models and it allows multiple threads to speculatively execute critical sections, beyond barriers and event synchronizations.Postprint (published version

Out-of-order commit processors

Modern out-of-order processors tolerate long latency memory operations by supporting a large number of in-flight instructions. This is particularly useful in numerical applications where branch speculation is normally not a problem and where the cache hierarchy is not capable of delivering the data soon enough. In order to support more in-flight instructions, several resources have to be up-sized, such as the reorder buffer (ROB), the general purpose instructions queues, the load/store queue and the number of physical registers in the processor. However, scaling-up the number of entries in these resources is impractical because of area, cycle time, and power consumption constraints. We propose to increase the capacity of future processors by augmenting the number of in-flight instructions. Instead of simply up-sizing resources, we push for new and novel microarchitectural structures that achieve the same performance benefits but with a much lower need for resources. Our main contribution is a new checkpointing mechanism that is capable of keeping thousands of in-flight instructions at a practically constant cost. We also propose a queuing mechanism that takes advantage of the differences in waiting time of the instructions in the flow. Using these two mechanisms our processor has a performance degradation of only 10% for SPEC2000fp over a conventional processor requiring more than an order of magnitude additional entries in the ROB and instruction queues, and about a 200% improvement over a current processor with a similar number of entries.Peer ReviewedPostprint (published version