A Practical Second-Order Fault Attack against a Real-World Pairing Implementation

Several fault attacks against pairing-based cryptography have been described theoretically in recent years. Interestingly, none of these have been practically evaluated. We accomplished this task and prove that fault attacks against pairing-based cryptography are indeed possible and are even practical — thus posing a serious threat. Moreover, we successfully conducted a second-order fault attack against an open source implementation of the eta pairing on an AVR XMEGA A1. We injected the first fault into the computation of the Miller Algorithm and applied the second fault to skip the final exponentiation completely. We introduce a low-cost setup that allowed us to generate multiple independent faults in one computation. The setup implements these faults by clock glitches which induce instruction skips. With this setup we conducted the first practical fault attack against a complete pairing computation

Performance Evaluation of Optimal Ate Pairing on Low-Cost Single Microprocessor Platform

The framework of low-cost interconnected devices forms a new kind of cryptographic environment with diverse requirements. Due to the minimal resource capacity of the devices, light-weight cryptographic algorithms are favored. Many applications of IoT work autonomously and process sensible data, which emphasizes security needs, and might also cause a need for specific security measures. A bilinear pairing is a mapping based on groups formed by elliptic curves over extension fields. The pairings are the key-enabler for versatile cryptosystems, such as certificateless signatures and searchable encryption. However, they have a major computational overhead, which coincides with the requirements of the low-cost devices. Nonetheless, the bilinear pairings are the only known approach for many cryptographic protocols so their feasibility should certainly be studied, as they might turn out to be necessary for some future IoT solutions. Promising results already exist for high-frequency CPU:s and platforms with hardware extensions. In this work, we study the feasibility of computing the optimal ate pairing over the BN254 curve, on a 64 MHz Cortex-M33 based platform by utilizing an optimized open-source library. The project is carried out for the company Nordic Semiconductor. As a result, the pairing was effectively computed in under 26* 10^6 cycles, or in 410 ms. The resulting pairing enables a limited usage of pairing-based cryptography, with a capacity of at most few cryptographic operations, such as ID-based key verifications per second. Referring to other relevant works, a competent pairing application would require either a high-frequency - and thus high consuming - microprocessor, or a customized FPGA. Moreover, it is noted that the research in efficient pairing-based cryptography is constantly taking steps forward in every front-line: efficient algorithms, protocols, and hardware-solutions

Failure of the Point Blinding Countermeasure Against Fault Attack in Pairing-Based Cryptography

Article published in the proceedings of the C2SI conference, May 2015.Pairings are mathematical tools that have been proven to be very useful in the construction of many cryptographic protocols. Some of these protocols are suitable for implementation on power constrained devices such as smart cards or smartphone which are subject to side channel attacks. In this paper, we analyse the efficiency of the point blinding countermeasure in pairing based cryptography against side channel attacks. In particular,we show that this countermeasure does not protect Miller's algorithm for pairing computation against fault attack. We then give recommendation for a secure implementation of a pairing based protocol using the Miller algorithm

Theory and Practice of Cryptography and Network Security Protocols and Technologies

In an age of explosive worldwide growth of electronic data storage and communications, effective protection of information has become a critical requirement. When used in coordination with other tools for ensuring information security, cryptography in all of its applications, including data confidentiality, data integrity, and user authentication, is a most powerful tool for protecting information. This book presents a collection of research work in the field of cryptography. It discusses some of the critical challenges that are being faced by the current computing world and also describes some mechanisms to defend against these challenges. It is a valuable source of knowledge for researchers, engineers, graduate and doctoral students working in the field of cryptography. It will also be useful for faculty members of graduate schools and universities

Hardware processors for pairing-based cryptography

Bilinear pairings can be used to construct cryptographic systems with very desirable properties. A pairing performs a mapping on members of groups on elliptic and genus 2 hyperelliptic curves to an extension of the finite field on which the curves are defined. The finite fields must, however, be large to ensure adequate security. The complicated group structure of the curves and the expensive field operations result in time consuming computations that are an impediment to the practicality of pairing-based systems. The Tate pairing can be computed efficiently using the ɳT method. Hardware architectures can be used to accelerate the required operations by exploiting the parallelism inherent to the algorithmic and finite field calculations. The Tate pairing can be performed on elliptic curves of characteristic 2 and 3 and on genus 2 hyperelliptic curves of characteristic 2. Curve selection is dependent on several factors including desired computational speed, the area constraints of the target device and the required security level. In this thesis, custom hardware processors for the acceleration of the Tate pairing are presented and implemented on an FPGA. The underlying hardware architectures are designed with care to exploit available parallelism while ensuring resource efficiency. The characteristic 2 elliptic curve processor contains novel units that return a pairing result in a very low number of clock cycles. Despite the more complicated computational algorithm, the speed of the genus 2 processor is comparable. Pairing computation on each of these curves can be appealing in applications with various attributes. A flexible processor that can perform pairing computation on elliptic curves of characteristic 2 and 3 has also been designed. An integrated hardware/software design and verification environment has been developed. This system automates the procedures required for robust processor creation and enables the rapid provision of solutions for a wide range of cryptographic applications

Secure architectures for pairing based public key cryptography

Along with the growing demand for cryptosystems in systems ranging from large servers to mobile devices, suitable cryptogrophic protocols for use under certain constraints are becoming more and more important. Constraints such as calculation time, area, efficiency and security, must be considered by the designer. Elliptic curves, since their introduction to public key cryptography in 1985 have challenged established public key and signature generation schemes such as RSA, offering more security per bit. Amongst Elliptic curve based systems, pairing based cryptographies are thoroughly researched and can be used in many public key protocols such as identity based schemes. For hardware implementions of pairing based protocols, all components which calculate operations over Elliptic curves can be considered. Designers of the pairing algorithms must choose calculation blocks and arrange the basic operations carefully so that the implementation can meet the constraints of time and hardware resource area. This thesis deals with different hardware architectures to accelerate the pairing based cryptosystems in the field of characteristic two. Using different top-level architectures the hardware efficiency of operations that run at different times is first considered in this thesis. Security is another important aspect of pairing based cryptography to be considered in practically Side Channel Analysis (SCA) attacks. The naively implemented hardware accelerators for pairing based cryptographies can be vulnerable when taking the physical analysis attacks into consideration. This thesis considered the weaknesses in pairing based public key cryptography and addresses the particular calculations in the systems that are insecure. In this case, countermeasures should be applied to protect the weak link of the implementation to improve and perfect the pairing based algorithms. Some important rules that the designers must obey to improve the security of the cryptosystems are proposed. According to these rules, three countermeasures that protect the pairing based cryptosystems against SCA attacks are applied. The implementations of the countermeasures are presented and their performances are investigated

Novel Area-Efficient and Flexible Architectures for Optimal Ate Pairing on FPGA

While FPGA is a suitable platform for implementing cryptographic algorithms, there are several challenges associated with implementing Optimal Ate pairing on FPGA, such as security, limited computing resources, and high power consumption. To overcome these issues, this study introduces three approaches that can execute the optimal Ate pairing on Barreto-Naehrig curves using Jacobean coordinates with the goal of reaching 128-bit security on the Genesys board. The first approach is a pure software implementation utilizing the MicroBlaze processor. The second involves a combination of software and hardware, with key operations in $F_{p}$ and $F_{p^{2}}$ being transformed into IP cores for the MicroBlaze. The third approach builds on the second by incorporating parallelism to improve the pairing process. The utilization of multiple MicroBlaze processors within a single system offers both versatility and parallelism to speed up pairing calculations. A variety of methods and parameters are used to optimize the pairing computation, including Montgomery modular multiplication, the Karatsuba method, Jacobean coordinates, the Complex squaring method, sparse multiplication, squaring in $G_{\phi 6}F_{p^{12}}$, and the addition chain method. The proposed systems are designed to efficiently utilize limited resources in restricted environments, while still completing tasks in a timely manner.Comment: 13 pages, 8 figures, and 5 table

Cryptographic Key Distribution In Wireless Sensor Networks Using Bilinear Pairings

It is envisaged that the use of cheap and tiny wireless sensors will soon bring a third wave of evolution in computing systems. Billions of wireless senor nodes will provide a bridge between information systems and the physical world. Wireless nodes deployed around the globe will monitor the surrounding environment as well as gather information about the people therein. It is clear that this revolution will put security solutions to a great test. Wireless Sensor Networks (WSNs) are a challenging environment for applying security services. They differ in many aspects from traditional fixed networks, and standard cryptographic solutions cannot be used in this application space. Despite many research efforts, key distribution in WSNs still remains an open problem. Many of the proposed schemes suffer from high communication overhead and storage costs, low scalability and poor resilience against different types of attacks. The exclusive usage of simple and energy efficient symmetric cryptography primitives does not solve the security problem. On the other hand a full public key infrastructure which uses asymmetric techniques, digital signatures and certificate authorities seems to be far too complex for a constrained WSN environment. This thesis investigates a new approach to WSN security which addresses many of the shortcomings of existing mechanisms. It presents a detailed description on how to provide practical Public Key Cryptography solutions for wireless sensor networks. The contributions to the state-of-the-art are added on all levels of development beginning with the basic arithmetic operations and finishing with complete security protocols. This work includes a survey of different key distribution protocols that have been developed for WSNs, with an evaluation of their limitations. It also proposes Identity- Based Cryptography (IBC) as an ideal technique for key distribution in sensor networks. It presents the first in-depth study of the application and implementation of Pairing- Based Cryptography (PBC) to WSNs. This is followed by a presentation of the state of the art on the software implementation of Elliptic Curve Cryptography (ECC) on typical WSNplatforms. New optimized algorithms for performing multiprecision multiplication on a broad range of low-end CPUs are introduced as well. Three novel protocols for key distribution are proposed in this thesis. Two of these are intended for non-interactive key exchange in flat and clustered networks respectively. A third key distribution protocol uses Identity-Based Encryption (IBE) to secure communication within a heterogeneous sensor network. This thesis includes also a comprehensive security evaluation that shows that proposed schemes are resistant to various attacks that are specific to WSNs. This work shows that by using the newest achievements in cryptography like pairings and IBC it is possible to deliver affordable public-key cryptographic solutions and to apply a sufficient level of security for the most demanding WSN applications

Physical attacks on pairing-based cryptography

In dieser Dissertation analysieren wir Schwächen paarungsbasierter kryptographischer Verfahren gegenüber physikalischen Angriffen wie Seitenkanalangriffen und Fehlerangriffen. Verglichen mit weitverbreiteten Primitiven, beispielsweise basierend auf elliptischen Kurven, ist noch relativ wenig über Angriffsmöglichkeiten aufpaarungsbasierte Verfahren bekannt. Ein Grund dafür ist die hohe Komplexität paarungsbasierter Kryptographie und fehlende Standards für die Festlegung von Parametern, Algorithmen und Verfahren. Des Weiteren läßt sich Wissen aus dem Zusammenhang mit elliptischen Kurven aufgrundstruktureller Unterschiede nicht direkt übertragen. Um ein besseres Verständnis des Problems zu erlangen, präsentieren wir in dieser Arbeit neue physikalische Angriffe auf paarungsbasierte Kryptographie. Unsere Ergebnisse, einschließlich deren praktische Umsetzung, machen deutlich, dass physikalische Angriffe eine Gefahr für die Implementierung paarungsbasierter kryptographischer Verfahren darstellen. Diese Gefahr sollte weiter untersucht und bei der Realisierung dieser Verfahren berücksichtig werden. Weiterhin zeigen unsere Ergebnisse, dass eine Einigung über verwendete Parameter, Algorithmen und Verfahren erzielt werden sollte, um die Komplexität von paarungsbasierter Kryptographie hinischtlich physikalische rAngriffe zu vermindern.In this thesis, we analyze the vulnerability of pairing-based cryptographic schemes against physical attacks like side-channel attacks (SCAs) or fault attacks (FAs). Compared to well-established cryptographic schemes, for example, from standard elliptic curve cryptography (ECC), less is known about weaknesses of pairing-based cryptography (PBC) against those attacks. Reasons for this shortcoming are the complexity of PBC and a missing consensus on parameters, algorithms, and schemes,e.g., in the form of standards. Furthermore, the structural difference between ECC and PBC prevents a direct application of the results from ECC. To get a better understanding of the subject, we present new physical attacks on PBC. Our results, including the practical realizations of our attacks, show that physical attacks are a threat for PBC and need further investigation. Our work also shows that the community should agree on parameters, algorithms, and schemes to reduce the complexity of PBC with respect to physical attacks.Peter Günther ; Supervisor: Prof. Dr. rer. nat. Johannes BlömerTag der Verteidigung: 14.03.2016Universität Paderborn, Univ., Dissertation, 201