Towards Verifying Nonlinear Integer Arithmetic

We eliminate a key roadblock to efficient verification of nonlinear integer arithmetic using CDCL SAT solvers, by showing how to construct short resolution proofs for many properties of the most widely used multiplier circuits. Such short proofs were conjectured not to exist. More precisely, we give n^{O(1)} size regular resolution proofs for arbitrary degree 2 identities on array, diagonal, and Booth multipliers and quasipolynomial- n^{O(\log n)} size proofs for these identities on Wallace tree multipliers.Comment: Expanded and simplified with improved result

Formal Verification of Divider and Square-root Arithmetic Circuits Using Computer Algebra Methods

A considerable progress has been made in recent years in verification of arithmetic circuits such as multipliers, fused multiply-adders, multiply-accumulate, and other components of arithmetic datapaths, both in integer and finite field domain. However, the verification of hardware dividers and square-root functions have received only a limited attention from the verification community, with a notable exception for theorem provers and other inductive, non-automated systems. Division, square root, and transcendental functions are all tied to the basic Intel architecture and proving correctness of such algorithms is of grave importance. Although belonging to the same iterative-subtract class of architectures, they widely differ from each other. IEEE floating point standard specifies square-rooting and division as basic arithmetic operation alongside the usual three basic operations. The difficulty of formally verifying hardware implementation of a divider/square-root can be attributed mostly to the modeling of its characteristic function and the high memory complexity required by standard algebraic approach. The work proposed in this thesis discusses formal verification of combinational divider and square-root circuits. Specifically, it addresses the problem of formally verifying gate-level circuits using an algebraic model. In contrast to standard verification approaches using satisfiability (SAT) or equivalence checking, the proposed method verifies whether the gate-level circuit actually performs the intended function or not, without a need for a reference design. Firstly, we present a verification methodology for a constant divider, where the divisor value is fixed to a constant integer. Albeit simpler case of verification, it provides us with the basic understanding of verification techniques and the underlying issues applicable to divider verification. Secondly, a layered verification approach is proposed for the verification of generic array dividers. Finally, the work proposed in this thesis will further analyze the divider and square-root circuits and aim to curb the memory explosion issue experienced by computer algebra based verification methods in order to successfully verify large bit-width divider-type arithmetic circuits. More specifically, a novel idea of hardware rewriting is introduced, which avoids the high memory complexity. The mentioned technique verifies a 256-bit gate-level square-root circuit with around 260,000 gates in just under 18 minutes and 127-bit gate-level divider circuit in under one minute

Doctor of Philosophy

dissertationFormal verification of hardware designs has become an essential component of the overall system design flow. The designs are generally modeled as finite state machines, on which property and equivalence checking problems are solved for verification. Reachability analysis forms the core of these techniques. However, increasing size and complexity of the circuits causes the state explosion problem. Abstraction is the key to tackling the scalability challenges. This dissertation presents new techniques for word-level abstraction with applications in sequential design verification. By bundling together k bit-level state-variables into one word-level constraint expression, the state-space is construed as solutions (variety) to a set of polynomial constraints (ideal), modeled over the finite (Galois) field of 2^k elements. Subsequently, techniques from algebraic geometry -- notably, Groebner basis theory and technology -- are researched to perform reachability analysis and verification of sequential circuits. This approach adds a "word-level dimension" to state-space abstraction and verification to make the process more efficient. While algebraic geometry provides powerful abstraction and reasoning capabilities, the algorithms exhibit high computational complexity. In the dissertation, we show that by analyzing the constraints, it is possible to obtain more insights about the polynomial ideals, which can be exploited to overcome the complexity. Using our algorithm design and implementations, we demonstrate how to perform reachability analysis of finite-state machines purely at the word level. Using this concept, we perform scalable verification of sequential arithmetic circuits. As contemporary approaches make use of resolution proofs and unsatisfiable cores for state-space abstraction, we introduce the algebraic geometry analog of unsatisfiable cores, and present algorithms to extract and refine unsatisfiable cores of polynomial ideals. Experiments are performed to demonstrate the efficacy of our approaches

ANALYSIS AND VERIFICATION OF ARITHMETIC CIRCUITS USING COMPUTER ALGEBRA APPROACH

Despite a considerable progress in verification of random and control logic, advances in formal verification of arithmetic designs have been lagging. This can be attributed mostly to the difficulty of efficient modeling of arithmetic circuits and data paths without resorting to computationally expensive Boolean methods, such as Binary Decision Diagrams (BDDs) and Boolean Satisfiability (SAT) that require ``bit blasting\u27\u27, i.e., flattening the design to a bit-level netlist. Similarly, approaches that rely on computer algebra and Satisfiability Modulo Theories (SMT) methods are either too abstract to handle the bit-level complexity of arithmetic designs or require solving computationally expensive decision or satisfiability problems. On the other hand, theorem provers, popular solvers used in industry, require a significant human interaction and intimate knowledge of the design to guide the proof process. The work proposed in this thesis aims at overcoming the limitations of verifying arithmetic circuits, especially at the post-synthesis, implementation phase. It addresses the verification problem at an algebraic level, treating an arithmetic circuit and its specification as an algebraic system. Specifically, verification approach employed in this work is based on the algebraic rewriting method. In this method, the circuit is modeled in the algebraic domain, where both the circuit specification and its gate-level implementation are represented as polynomials. This work formally analyzes the algebraic approach and compares it with the established computer algebra methods based on Grobner basis reduction. It shows that algebraic rewriting is more effective than the Grobner basis reduction from the computational point of view. This thesis addresses two classes of arithmetic circuits that could not directly benefit from this type of functional verification, since performing algebraic rewriting of such circuits encounters a serious memory issue. The circuits that fall in the first category are approximate arithmetic circuits, such as truncated integer multipliers. Different truncation schemes are considered, including bit deletion, bit truncation, and rounding. The proposed verification method is based on reconstructing the truncated multiplier to a complete, exact multiplier; it is then followed by algebraic rewriting to prove that it indeed implements multiplication over the required range of bits. The reconstruction of the multiplier helps avoid the memory overload issue as it creates a clean multiplier with a well defined specification polynomial. The other class of circuits that suffer from memory overload during algebraic rewriting are circuits subjected to some arithmetic constraints. An example of such circuits is a divider, where the divisor value cannot be zero. The other example can be found in the basic blocks of the constant divider, where the value of carry into each block must be less than the divisor value. In general, such constraints will be modeled using the concept of vanishing monomials. A case-splitting method is proposed along with the modified algebraic rewriting to resolve the memory issue. The proposed verification method not only can prove that the circuit performs a correct function under the desired (valid) conditions, but also will test all the undesired (invalid) cases. This work also addresses logic debugging of combinational arithmetic circuits over field F2k , including Galois field multipliers. Galois Field (GF) arithmetic has numerous applications in digital communication, cryptography and security engineering, and formal verification of such circuits is of prime importance. In addition to functional verification of GF multipliers, this work proposes a novel and effective method for identifying and correcting bugs in such circuits, commonly referred to as debugging. In this work we propose a novel approach to debugging of GF arithmetic circuits based on forward rewriting, which enables functional verification and debugging at the same time. This technique can handle multiple bugs, does not suffer from the polynomial size explosion encountered by other methods, and allows one to identify and automatically correct bugs in GF circuits. The techniques and algorithms proposed in this dissertation have been implemented in several computer programs, some stand-alone, and some integrated with a popular synthesis and verification tool, ABC. The experimental results for verification and debugging are compared with the state-of-the-art SAT, SMT, and other computer algebraic solvers

Proceedings of the 21st Conference on Formal Methods in Computer-Aided Design – FMCAD 2021

The Conference on Formal Methods in Computer-Aided Design (FMCAD) is an annual conference on the theory and applications of formal methods in hardware and system verification. FMCAD provides a leading forum to researchers in academia and industry for presenting and discussing groundbreaking methods, technologies, theoretical results, and tools for reasoning formally about computing systems. FMCAD covers formal aspects of computer-aided system design including verification, specification, synthesis, and testing

Some Applications of the Weighted Combinatorial Laplacian

The weighted combinatorial Laplacian of a graph is a symmetric matrix which is the discrete analogue of the Laplacian operator. In this thesis, we will study a new application of this matrix to matching theory yielding a new characterization of factor-criticality in graphs and matroids. Other applications are from the area of the physical design of very large scale integrated circuits. The placement of the gates includes the minimization of a quadratic form given by a weighted Laplacian. A method based on the dual constrained subgradient method is proposed to solve the simultaneous placement and gate-sizing problem. A crucial step of this method is the projection to the flow space of an associated graph, which can be performed by minimizing a quadratic form given by the unweighted combinatorial Laplacian.Andwendungen der gewichteten kombinatorischen Laplace-Matrix Die gewichtete kombinatorische Laplace-Matrix ist das diskrete Analogon des Laplace-Operators. In dieser Arbeit stellen wir eine neuartige Charakterisierung von Faktor-Kritikalität von Graphen und Matroiden mit Hilfe dieser Matrix vor. Wir untersuchen andere Anwendungen im Bereich des Entwurfs von höchstintegrierten Schaltkreisen. Die Platzierung basiert auf der Minimierung einer quadratischen Form, die durch eine gewichtete kombinatorische Laplace-Matrix gegeben ist. Wir präsentieren einen Algorithmus für das allgemeine simultane Platzierungs- und Gattergrößen-Optimierungsproblem, der auf der dualen Subgradientenmethode basiert. Ein wichtiger Bestandteil dieses Verfahrens ist eine Projektion auf den Flussraum eines assoziierten Graphen, die als die Minimierung einer durch die Laplace-Matrix gegebenen quadratischen Form aufgefasst werden kann

Precision analysis for hardware acceleration of numerical algorithms

The precision used in an algorithm affects the error and performance of individual computations, the memory usage, and the potential parallelism for a fixed hardware budget. However, when migrating an algorithm onto hardware, the potential improvements that can be obtained by tuning the precision throughout an algorithm to meet a range or error specification are often overlooked; the major reason is that it is hard to choose a number system which can guarantee any such specification can be met. Instead, the problem is mitigated by opting to use IEEE standard double precision arithmetic so as to be ‘no worse’ than a software implementation. However, the flexibility in the number representation is one of the key factors that can be exploited on reconfigurable hardware such as FPGAs, and hence ignoring this potential significantly limits the performance achievable. In order to optimise the performance of hardware reliably, we require a method that can tractably calculate tight bounds for the error or range of any variable within an algorithm, but currently only a handful of methods to calculate such bounds exist, and these either sacrifice tightness or tractability, whilst simulation-based methods cannot guarantee the given error estimate. This thesis presents a new method to calculate these bounds, taking into account both input ranges and finite precision effects, which we show to be, in general, tighter in comparison to existing methods; this in turn can be used to tune the hardware to the algorithm specifications. We demonstrate the use of this software to optimise hardware for various algorithms to accelerate the solution of a system of linear equations, which forms the basis of many problems in engineering and science, and show that significant performance gains can be obtained by using this new approach in conjunction with more traditional hardware optimisations

Aproximación de ecuaciones diferenciales mediante una nueva técnica variacional y aplicaciones

[SPA] En esta Tesis presentamos el estudio teórico y numérico de sistemas de ecuaciones diferenciales basado en el análisis de un funcional asociado de forma natural al problema original. Probamos que cuando se utiliza métodos del descenso para minimizar dicho funcional, el algoritmo decrece el error hasta obtener la convergencia dada la no existencia de mínimos locales diferentes a la solución original. En cierto sentido el algoritmo puede considerarse un método tipo Newton globalmente convergente al estar basado en una linearización del problema. Se han estudiado la aproximación de ecuaciones diferenciales rígidas, de ecuaciones rígidas con retardo, de ecuaciones algebraico‐diferenciales y de problemas hamiltonianos. Esperamos que esta nueva técnica variacional pueda usarse en otro tipo de problemas diferenciales. [ENG] This thesis is devoted to the study and approximation of systems of differential equations based on an analysis of a certain error functional associated, in a natural way, with the original problem. We prove that in seeking to minimize the error by using standard descent schemes, the procedure can never get stuck in local minima, but will always and steadily decrease the error until getting to the original solution. One main step in the procedure relies on a very particular linearization of the problem, in some sense it is like a globally convergent Newton type method. We concentrate on the approximation of stiff systems of ODEs, DDEs, DAEs and Hamiltonian systems. In all these problems we need to use implicit schemes. We believe that this approach can be used in a systematic way to examine other situations and other types of equations.Universidad Politécnica de Cartagen

Correct synthesis and integration of compiler-generated function units

PhD ThesisComputer architectures can use custom logic in addition to general pur- pose processors to improve performance for a variety of applications. The use of custom logic allows greater parallelism for some algorithms. While conventional CPUs typically operate on words, ne-grained custom logic can improve e ciency for many bit level operations. The commodi ca- tion of eld programmable devices, particularly FPGAs, has improved the viability of using custom logic in an architecture. This thesis introduces an approach to reasoning about the correctness of compilers that generate custom logic that can be synthesized to provide hardware acceleration for a given application. Compiler intermediate representations (IRs) and transformations that are relevant to genera- tion of custom logic are presented. Architectures may vary in the way that custom logic is incorporated, and suitable abstractions are used in order that the results apply to compilation for a variety of the design parameters that are introduced by the use of custom logic