Using ACL2 to Verify Loop Pipelining in Behavioral Synthesis

Behavioral synthesis involves compiling an Electronic System-Level (ESL) design into its Register-Transfer Level (RTL) implementation. Loop pipelining is one of the most critical and complex transformations employed in behavioral synthesis. Certifying the loop pipelining algorithm is challenging because there is a huge semantic gap between the input sequential design and the output pipelined implementation making it infeasible to verify their equivalence with automated sequential equivalence checking techniques. We discuss our ongoing effort using ACL2 to certify loop pipelining transformation. The completion of the proof is work in progress. However, some of the insights developed so far may already be of value to the ACL2 community. In particular, we discuss the key invariant we formalized, which is very different from that used in most pipeline proofs. We discuss the needs for this invariant, its formalization in ACL2, and our envisioned proof using the invariant. We also discuss some trade-offs, challenges, and insights developed in course of the project.Comment: In Proceedings ACL2 2014, arXiv:1406.123

Desynchronization: Synthesis of asynchronous circuits from synchronous specifications

Asynchronous implementation techniques, which measure logic delays at run time and activate registers accordingly, are inherently more robust than their synchronous counterparts, which estimate worst-case delays at design time, and constrain the clock cycle accordingly. De-synchronization is a new paradigm to automate the design of asynchronous circuits from synchronous specifications, thus permitting widespread adoption of asynchronicity, without requiring special design skills or tools. In this paper, we first of all study different protocols for de-synchronization and formally prove their correctness, using techniques originally developed for distributed deployment of synchronous language specifications. We also provide a taxonomy of existing protocols for asynchronous latch controllers, covering in particular the four-phase handshake protocols devised in the literature for micro-pipelines. We then propose a new controller which exhibits provably maximal concurrency, and analyze the performance of desynchronized circuits with respect to the original synchronous optimized implementation. We finally prove the feasibility and effectiveness of our approach, by showing its application to a set of real designs, including a complete implementation of the DLX microprocessor architectur

Design Automation and Design Space Exploration for Quantum Computers

A major hurdle to the deployment of quantum linear systems algorithms and recent quantum simulation algorithms lies in the difficulty to find inexpensive reversible circuits for arithmetic using existing hand coded methods. Motivated by recent advances in reversible logic synthesis, we synthesize arithmetic circuits using classical design automation flows and tools. The combination of classical and reversible logic synthesis enables the automatic design of large components in reversible logic starting from well-known hardware description languages such as Verilog. As a prototype example for our approach we automatically generate high quality networks for the reciprocal $1/x$, which is necessary for quantum linear systems algorithms.Comment: 6 pages, 1 figure, in 2017 Design, Automation & Test in Europe Conference & Exhibition, DATE 2017, Lausanne, Switzerland, March 27-31, 201

Smart technologies for effective reconfiguration: the FASTER approach

Current and future computing systems increasingly require that their functionality stays flexible after the system is operational, in order to cope with changing user requirements and improvements in system features, i.e. changing protocols and data-coding standards, evolving demands for support of different user applications, and newly emerging applications in communication, computing and consumer electronics. Therefore, extending the functionality and the lifetime of products requires the addition of new functionality to track and satisfy the customers needs and market and technology trends. Many contemporary products along with the software part incorporate hardware accelerators for reasons of performance and power efficiency. While adaptivity of software is straightforward, adaptation of the hardware to changing requirements constitutes a challenging problem requiring delicate solutions. The FASTER (Facilitating Analysis and Synthesis Technologies for Effective Reconfiguration) project aims at introducing a complete methodology to allow designers to easily implement a system specification on a platform which includes a general purpose processor combined with multiple accelerators running on an FPGA, taking as input a high-level description and fully exploiting, both at design time and at run time, the capabilities of partial dynamic reconfiguration. The goal is that for selected application domains, the FASTER toolchain will be able to reduce the design and verification time of complex reconfigurable systems providing additional novel verification features that are not available in existing tool flows

Distributed Enforcement of Service Choreographies

Modern service-oriented systems are often built by reusing, and composing together, existing services distributed over the Internet. Service choreography is a possible form of service composition whose goal is to specify the interactions among participant services from a global perspective. In this paper, we formalize a method for the distributed and automated enforcement of service choreographies, and prove its correctness with respect to the realization of the specified choreography. The formalized method is implemented as part of a model-based tool chain released to support the development of choreography-based systems within the EU CHOReOS project. We illustrate our method at work on a distributed social proximity network scenario.Comment: In Proceedings FOCLASA 2014, arXiv:1502.0315

High-level verification flow for a high-level synthesis-based digital logic design

Abstract. High-level synthesis (HLS) is a method for generating register-transfer level (RTL) hardware description of digital logic designs from high-level languages, such as C/C++/SystemC or MATLAB. The performance and productivity benefits of HLS stem from the untimed, high abstraction level input languages. Another advantage is that the design and verification can focus on the features and high-level architecture, instead of the low-level implementation details. The goal of this thesis was to define and implement a high-level verification (HLV) flow for an HLS design written in C++. The HLV flow takes advantage of the performance and productivity of C++ as opposed to hardware description languages (HDL) and minimises the required RTL verification work. The HLV flow was implemented in the case study of the thesis. The HLS design was verified in a C++ verification environment, and Catapult Coverage was used for pre-HLS coverage closure. Post-HLS verification and coverage closure were done in Universal Verification Methodology (UVM) environment. C++ tests used in the pre-HLS coverage closure were reimplemented in UVM, to get a high initial RTL coverage without manual RTL code analysis. The pre-HLS C++ design was implemented as a predictor into the UVM testbench to verify the equivalence of C++ versus RTL and to speed up post-HLS coverage closure. Results of the case study show that the HLV flow is feasible to implement in practice. The flow shows significant performance and productivity gains of verification in the C++ domain when compared to UVM. The UVM implementation of a somewhat incomplete set of pre-HLS tests and formal exclusions resulted in an initial post-HLS coverage of 96.90%. The C++ predictor implementation was a valuable tool in post-HLS coverage closure. A total of four weeks of coverage work in pre- and post-HLS phases was required to reach 99% RTL coverage. The total time does not include the time required to build both C++ and UVM verification environments.Korkean tason verifiointivuo korkean tason synteesiin perustuvalle digitaalilogiikkasuunnitelmalle. Tiivistelmä. Korkean tason synteesi (HLS) on menetelmä, jolla generoidaan rekisterisiirtotason (RTL) laitteistokuvausta digitaalisille logiikkasuunnitelmille käyttäen korkean tason ohjelmointikieliä, kuten C-pohjaisia kieliä tai MATLAB:ia. HLS:n suorituskykyyn ja tuottavuuteen liittyvät hyödyt perustuvat ohjelmointikielien tarjoamaan korkeampaan abstraktiotasoon. HLS:ää käyttäen suunnittelu- ja varmennustyö voi keskittyä ominaisuuksiin ja korkean tason arkkitehtuuriin matalan tason yksityiskohtien sijaan. Tämän diplomityön tavoite oli määritellä ja implementoida korkean tason verifiointivuo (HLV-vuo) C++:lla kirjoitetulle HLS-suunnitelmalle. HLV-vuo hyödyntää ohjelmointikielien tarjoamaa suorituskykyä ja korkeampaa abstraktion tasoa kovonkuvauskielien sijaan ja siten minimoi RTL:n varmennukseen vaadittavaa työtä. HLV vuo implementoitiin tapaustutkimuksessa. HLS-suunnitelma varmennettiin C++ -verifiointiympäristössä, ja Catapult Coveragea käytettiin kattavuuden analysointiin. RTL-kattavuutta mitattiin universaalilla verifiointimetodologialla (UVM) tehdyssä ympäristössä. C++ varmennuksessa käytetyt testivektorit implementoitiin uudelleen UVM-ympäristössä, jotta RTL-kattavuuden lähtötaso olisi korkea ilman manuaalista RTL-analyysiä. C++-suunnitelma implementoitiin prediktorina (referenssimallina) UVM-testipenkkiin koodikattavuuden parantamiseksi. Tapaustutkimuksen tulokset osoittavat, että määritelty HLV-vuo on toteutettavissa käytännössä. Vuota käyttämällä saavutetaan merkittäviä suorituskyky- ja tuottavuusetuja C++ -testiympäristössä verrattuna UVM-ympäristöön. 90.60% koodikattavuuden saavuttavien C++ testivektoreiden uudelleenimplementoiti UVM-ympäristössä tuotti 96.90% RTL-kattavuuden. C++-predictorin implementointi oli merkittävä työkalu RTL-kattavuustavoitteen saavuttamisessa

Enabling Automated Bug Detection for IP-based Designs using High-Level Synthesis

Modern System-on-Chip (SoC) architectures are increasingly composed of Intellectual Property (IP) blocks, usually designed and provided by different vendors. This burdens system designers with complex system-level integration and verification. In this paper, we propose an approach that leverages HLS techniques to automatically find bugs in designs composed of multiple IP blocks. Our method is particularly suitable for industrial adoption because it works without exposing sensitive information (e.g., the design specification or the component generation process). This advocates the definition and the adoption of an interoperable format for cross-vendor hardware bug detection

Reusing RTL assertion checkers for verification of SystemC TLM models

The recent trend towards system-level design gives rise to new challenges for reusing existing RTL intellectual properties (IPs) and their verification environment in TLM. While techniques and tools to abstract RTL IPs into TLM models have begun to appear, the problem of reusing, at TLM, a verification environment originally developed for an RTL IP is still under-explored, particularly when ABV is adopted. Some frameworks have been proposed to deal with ABV at TLM, but they assume a top-down design and verification flow, where assertions are defined ex-novo at TLM level. In contrast, the reuse of existing assertions in an RTL-to-TLM bottom-up design flow has not been analyzed yet, except by using transactors to create a mixed simulation between the TLM design and the RTL checkers corresponding to the assertions. However, the use of transactors may lead to longer verification time due to the need of developing and verifying the transactors themselves. Moreover, the simulation time is negatively affected by the presence of transactors, which slow down the simulation at the speed of the slowest parts (i.e., RTL checkers). This article proposes an alternative methodology that does not require transactors for reusing assertions, originally defined for a given RTL IP, in order to verify the corresponding TLM model. Experimental results have been conducted on benchmarks with different characteristics and complexity to show the applicability and the efficacy of the proposed methodology