76 research outputs found
From LTL and Limit-Deterministic B\"uchi Automata to Deterministic Parity Automata
Controller synthesis for general linear temporal logic (LTL) objectives is a
challenging task. The standard approach involves translating the LTL objective
into a deterministic parity automaton (DPA) by means of the Safra-Piterman
construction. One of the challenges is the size of the DPA, which often grows
very fast in practice, and can reach double exponential size in the length of
the LTL formula. In this paper we describe a single exponential translation
from limit-deterministic B\"uchi automata (LDBA) to DPA, and show that it can
be concatenated with a recent efficient translation from LTL to LDBA to yield a
double exponential, \enquote{Safraless} LTL-to-DPA construction. We also report
on an implementation, a comparison with the SPOT library, and performance on
several sets of formulas, including instances from the 2016 SyntComp
competition
Exploiting the Temporal Logic Hierarchy and the Non-Confluence Property for Efficient LTL Synthesis
The classic approaches to synthesize a reactive system from a linear temporal
logic (LTL) specification first translate the given LTL formula to an
equivalent omega-automaton and then compute a winning strategy for the
corresponding omega-regular game. To this end, the obtained omega-automata have
to be (pseudo)-determinized where typically a variant of Safra's
determinization procedure is used. In this paper, we show that this
determinization step can be significantly improved for tool implementations by
replacing Safra's determinization by simpler determinization procedures. In
particular, we exploit (1) the temporal logic hierarchy that corresponds to the
well-known automata hierarchy consisting of safety, liveness, Buechi, and
co-Buechi automata as well as their boolean closures, (2) the non-confluence
property of omega-automata that result from certain translations of LTL
formulas, and (3) symbolic implementations of determinization procedures for
the Rabin-Scott and the Miyano-Hayashi breakpoint construction. In particular,
we present convincing experimental results that demonstrate the practical
applicability of our new synthesis procedure
One Theorem to Rule Them All: A Unified Translation of LTL into {\omega}-Automata
We present a unified translation of LTL formulas into deterministic Rabin
automata, limit-deterministic B\"uchi automata, and nondeterministic B\"uchi
automata. The translations yield automata of asymptotically optimal size
(double or single exponential, respectively). All three translations are
derived from one single Master Theorem of purely logical nature. The Master
Theorem decomposes the language of a formula into a positive boolean
combination of languages that can be translated into {\omega}-automata by
elementary means. In particular, Safra's, ranking, and breakpoint constructions
used in other translations are not needed
Experimental Aspects of Synthesis
We discuss the problem of experimentally evaluating linear-time temporal
logic (LTL) synthesis tools for reactive systems. We first survey previous such
work for the currently publicly available synthesis tools, and then draw
conclusions by deriving useful schemes for future such evaluations.
In particular, we explain why previous tools have incompatible scopes and
semantics and provide a framework that reduces the impact of this problem for
future experimental comparisons of such tools. Furthermore, we discuss which
difficulties the complex workflows that begin to appear in modern synthesis
tools induce on experimental evaluations and give answers to the question how
convincing such evaluations can still be performed in such a setting.Comment: In Proceedings iWIGP 2011, arXiv:1102.374
Approximating Optimal Bounds in Prompt-LTL Realizability in Doubly-exponential Time
We consider the optimization variant of the realizability problem for Prompt
Linear Temporal Logic, an extension of Linear Temporal Logic (LTL) by the
prompt eventually operator whose scope is bounded by some parameter. In the
realizability optimization problem, one is interested in computing the minimal
such bound that allows to realize a given specification. It is known that this
problem is solvable in triply-exponential time, but not whether it can be done
in doubly-exponential time, i.e., whether it is just as hard as solving LTL
realizability.
We take a step towards resolving this problem by showing that the optimum can
be approximated within a factor of two in doubly-exponential time. Also, we
report on a proof-of-concept implementation of the algorithm based on bounded
LTL synthesis, which computes the smallest implementation of a given
specification. In our experiments, we observe a tradeoff between the size of
the implementation and the bound it realizes. We investigate this tradeoff in
the general case and prove upper bounds, which reduce the search space for the
algorithm, and matching lower bounds.Comment: In Proceedings GandALF 2016, arXiv:1609.0364
Synthesizing Dominant Strategies for Liveness
Reactive synthesis automatically derives a strategy that satisfies a given specification. However, requiring a strategy to meet the specification in every situation is, in many cases, too hard of a requirement. Particularly in compositional synthesis of distributed systems, individual winning strategies for the processes often do not exist. Remorsefree dominance, a weaker notion than winning, accounts for such situations: dominant strategies are only required to be as good as any alternative strategy, i.e.they are allowed to violate the specification if no other strategy would have satisfied it in the same situation. The composition of dominant strategies is only guaranteed to be dominant for safety properties, though; preventing the use of dominance in compositional synthesis for liveness specifications. Yet, safety properties are often not expressive enough. In this paper, we thus introduce a new winning condition for strategies, called delay-dominance, that overcomes this weakness of remorsefree dominance: we show that it is compositional for many safety and liveness specifications, enabling a compositional synthesis algorithm based on delay-dominance for general specifications. Furthermore, we introduce an automaton construction for recognizing delay-dominant strategies and prove its soundness and completeness. The resulting automaton is of single-exponential size in the squared length of the specification and can immediately be used for safraless synthesis procedures. Thus, synthesis of delay-dominant strategies is, as synthesis of winning strategies, in 2EXPTIME
- …