Incorporating working conditions to a mixed- model sequencing problem

Partiendo de una variante de un problema de secuenciación en líneas de productos mixtos (MMSP-W: Mixed-Model Sequencing Problem with Workload Minimisation), se proponen dos nuevos modelos que incorporan condiciones laborales a los puestos de trabajo de la línea. El primero tiene en cuenta la limitación de la saturación de los puestos de trabajo, mientras que el segundo contempla, además, la activación de los operarios a lo largo de la jornada laboral. Se realizan sendas experiencias computacionales, empleando un caso de estudio de la planta de motores de Nissan en Barcelona, con dos propósitos: (1) estudiar la repercusión que ocasiona la limitación de la saturación sobre la caída de la productividad de la línea, y (2) evaluar la recuperación de la productividad de la línea, mediante la activación de los operarios, manteniendo la misma calidad en las condiciones laborales conseguida al limitar la saturación.Beginning with a variation of the sequencing problem in a mixed-products line (MMSP-W: Mixed-Model Sequencing Problem with Workload Minimization), we propose two new models that incorporate the working conditions into the workstations on the line. The first model takes into account the saturation limit of the workstations, and the second model also includes the activation of the operators throughout the working day. Two computational experiments were carried out using a case study of the Nissan motor plant in Barcelona with two main objectives: (1) to study the repercussions of the saturation limit on the decrease in productivity on the line and (2) to evaluate the recovery of productivity on the line via activation of operators while maintaining the same quality in working conditions achieved by limiting the saturation. The obtained results show that the saturation limitation leads to suppose an important increase of work overload, which means average economic losses of 28,731.8 euros/day. However, the consideration of activity reduces these losses by 62.7%.Preprin

Consideration of human resources in the Mixed-model Sequencing Problem with Work Overload Minimization: Legal provisions and productivity improvement

Beginning with a variation of the sequencing problem in a mixed-products line (MMSP-W: Mixed-Model Sequencing Problem with Workload Minimization), we propose two new models that incorporate a set of working conditions in regard with human resources of workstations on the line. These conditions come from collective agreements and therefore must be respected by both company and labor unions. The first model takes into account the saturation limit of the workstations, and the second model also includes the activation of the operators throughout the working day. Two computational experiments were carried out using a case study of the Nissan motor plant in Barcelona with two main objectives: (1) to study the repercussions of the saturation limit on the decrease in productivity on the line and (2) to evaluate the recovery of productivity on the line via both activation of operators, while maintaining the same quality in working conditions achieved by limiting the saturation, and auxiliary processors. By results we state that saturation limitation leads an important increase of work overload, which means average economic losses of 28,731.8 Euros/day. However, the productivity reduction may be counteracted by the work pace factor increase, at certain moments of workday, and/or by the incorporation of auxiliary processors into the line.Postprint (author's final draft

Free and regular mixed-model sequences by a linear program-assisted hybrid algorithm GRASP-LP

A linear program-assisted hybrid algorithm (GRASP-LP) is presented to solve a mixed-model sequencing problem in an assembly line. The issue of the problem is to obtain manufacturing sequences of product models with the minimum work overload, allowing the free interruption of operations at workstations and preserving the production mix. The implemented GRASP-LP is compared with other procedures through a case study linked with the Nissan’ Engine Plant from Barcelona.Peer ReviewedPostprint (author's final draft

An expert system to minimize operational costs in mixed-model sequencing problems with activity factor

One of the major issues in industrial environments is currently maximizing productivity while reducing manufacturing cost. This can be seen clearly reflected in mixed-model assembly lines based systems, where obtaining efficient manufacturing sequences is a key to be competitive in a dynamic and globalized market. However, this continuous cost reduction and productivity growth should not penalize the welfare of employees. This work is intended to address this lack of compatibility between the economic and social objectives through the study of the mixed-model sequencing problem from both the business and labor perspective. This is done by considering the possibility of reducing or increasing processing times of operations by varying the work pace of line's operators within the permissible legal boundaries. Thus, depending on this flexible activation time of operators, the amount of completed work and idle time will be one or the other and, consequently, the productivity of the line will also improve or get worse. In this regard, we propose new approach to the sequencing problem without incurring cost increases and providing a safe working environment, in accordance with applicable law. This new approach leads to obtain efficient manufacturing sequences, in terms of both productivity and labor conditions. Specifically, the objective of the new problem is minimizing the unproductive costs of the line by incorporating the possibility of increasing production through the variation of the work pace of line's operators. Increasing the work pace of operators, the amount of non-completed work or the preventable idle time can be reduced and therefore, their associated costs too. In addition, and without losing sight of the effort involved in working with a work pace above the normal, we propose several economic criteria to compensate the activation of workers where necessaryPeer ReviewedPostprint (author's final draft

Lean manual assembly 4.0: A systematic review

In a demand context of mass customization, shifting towards the mass personalization of products, assembly operations face the trade-off between highly productive automated systems and flexible manual operators. Novel digital technologies—conceptualized as Industry 4.0—suggest the possibility of simultaneously achieving superior productivity and flexibility. This article aims to address how Industry 4.0 technologies could improve the productivity, flexibility and quality of assembly operations. A systematic literature review was carried out, including 234 peer-reviewed articles from 2010–2020. As a result, the analysis was structured addressing four sets of research questions regarding (1) assembly for mass customization; (2) Industry 4.0 and performance evaluation; (3) Lean production as a starting point for smart factories, and (4) the implications of Industry 4.0 for people in assembly operations. It was found that mass customization brings great complexity that needs to be addressed at different levels from a holistic point of view; that Industry 4.0 offers powerful tools to achieve superior productivity and flexibility in assembly; that Lean is a great starting point for implementing such changes; and that people need to be considered central to Assembly 4.0. Developing methodologies for implementing Industry 4.0 to achieve specific business goals remains an open research topic

Assembly line balancing and activity scheduling for customised products manufacturing

Nowadays, end customers require personalized products to match their specific needs. Thus, production systems must be extremely flexible. Companies typically exploit assembly lines to manufacture produces in great volumes. The development of assembly lines distinguished by mixed or multi models increases their flexibility concerning the number of product variants able to be manufactured. However, few scientific contributions deal with customizable products, i.e., produces which can be designed and ordered requiring or not a large set of available accessories. This manuscript proposes an original two-step procedure to deal with the multi-manned assembly lines for customized product manufacturing. The first step of the procedure groups the accessories together in clusters according to a specific similarity index. The accessories belonging to a cluster are typically requested together by customers and necessitate a significant mounting time. Thus, this procedure aims to split accessories belonging to the same cluster to different assembly operators avoiding their overloads. The second procedure step consists of an innovative optimization model which defines tasks and accessory assignment to operators. Furthermore, the developed model defines the activity time schedule in compliance with the task precedencies maximizing the operator workload balance. An industrial case study is adopted to test and validate the proposed procedure. The obtained results suggest superior balancing of such assembly lines, with an average worker utilization rate greater than 90%. Furthermore, in the worst case scenario in terms of customer accessories requirement, just 4 line operators out of 16 are distinguished by a maximum workload greater than the cycle time

Balancing and Sequencing of Mixed Model Assembly Lines

Assembly lines are cost efficient production systems that mass produce identical products. Due to customer demand, manufacturers use mixed model assembly lines to produce customized products that are not identical. To stay efficient, management decisions for the line such as number of workers and assembly task assignment to stations need to be optimized to increase throughput and decrease cost. In each station, the work to be done depends on the exact product configuration, and is not consistent across all products. In this dissertation, a mixed model line balancing integer program (IP) that considers parallel workers, zoning, task assignment, and ergonomic constraints with the objective of minimizing the number of workers is proposed. Upon observing the limitation of the IP, a Constraint Programming (CP) model that is based on CPLEX CP Optimizer is developed to solve larger assembly line balancing problems. Data from an automotive OEM are used to assess the performance of both the MIP and CP models. Using the OEM data, we show that the CP model outperforms the IP model for bigger problems. A sensitivity analysis is done to assess the cost of enforcing some of the constraint on the computation complexity and the amount of violations to these constraints once they are disabled. Results show that some of the constraints are helpful in reducing the computation time. Specifically, the assignment constraints in which decision variables are fixed or bounded result in a smaller search space. Finally, since the line balance for mixed model is based on task duration averages, we propose a mixed model sequencing model that minimize the number of overload situation that might occur due to variability in tasks times by providing an optimal production sequence. We consider the skip-policy to manage overload situations and allow interactions between stations via workers swimming. An IP model formulation is proposed and a GRASP solution heuristic is developed to solve the problem. Data from the literature are used to assess the performance of the developed heuristic and to show the benefit of swimming in reducing work overload situations

Consideration of human resources in the Mixed-model Sequencing Problem with Work Overload Minimization: Legal provisions and productivity improvement

Postprint ESWA Volume 42, Issue 22, 1 December 2015, Pages 8896–8910Beginning with a variation of the sequencing problem in a mixed-products line (MMSP-W: Mixed-Model Sequencing Problem with Workload Minimization), we propose two new models that incorporate a set of working conditions in regard with human resources of workstations on the line. These conditions come from collective agreements and therefore must be respected by both company and labor unions. The first model takes into account the saturation limit of the workstations, and the second model also includes the activation of the operators throughout the working day. Two computational experiments were carried out using a case study of the Nissan motor plant in Barcelona with two main objectives: (1) to study the repercussions of the saturation limit on the decrease in productivity on the line and (2) to evaluate the recovery of productivity on the line via both activation of operators, while maintaining the same quality in working conditions achieved by limiting the saturation, and auxiliary processors. By results we state that saturation limitation leads an important increase of work overload, which means average economic losses of 28,731.8 Euros/day. However, the productivity reduction may be counteracted by the work pace factor increase, at certain moments of workday, and/or by the incorporation of auxiliary processors into the line.Postprint (published version

A hybrid dynamic programming for solving a mixed-model sequencing problem with production mix restriction and free interruptions

In this article, we propose a hybrid procedure based on bounded dynamic programming assisted by linear programming to solve the mixed-model sequencing problem with workload minimization with serial workstations, free interruption of the operations and with production mix restrictions. We performed a computational experiment with 23 instances related to a case study of the Nissan powertrain plant located in Barcelona. The results of our proposal are compared with those obtained by mixed integer linear programming.Peer ReviewedPostprint (author's final draft

Productivity and flexibility improvement of assembly lines for high-mix low-volume production. A white goods industry case

Las tendencias globales de la personalización e individualización en masa impulsan la producción industrial en serie corta y variada; y por tanto una gran variedad de productos en pequeñas cantidades. Por ello, la customización en masa precisa de sistemas de ensamblaje que sean a la vez altamente productivos y flexibles, a diferencia de la tradicional oposición entre ambas características. La llamada cuarta revolución industrial trae diversas tecnologías habilitadoras que podrían ser útiles para abordar este problema. Sin embargo, las metodologías para implementar el ensamblaje 4.0 todavía no han sido resueltas. De hecho, para aprovechar todas las ventajas potenciales de la Industria 4.0, es necesario contar con un nivel previo de excelencia operacional y un análisis holístico de los sistemas productivos. Esta tesis tiene como objetivo entender y definir cómo mejorar la productividad y la flexibilidad de las operaciones de montaje en serie corta y variada.Esta meta se ha dividido en tres objetivos. El primer objetivo consiste en comprender las relaciones entre la Industria 4.0 y las operaciones de ensamblaje, así como sus implicaciones para los operarios. El segundo objetivo consiste en desarrollar una metodología y las herramientas necesarias para evaluar el rendimiento de diferentes configuraciones de cadenas de ensamblaje. El último objetivo consiste en el diseño de sistemas de ensamblaje que permitan incrementar su productividad al menos un 25 %, produciendo en serie corta y variada, mediante la combinación de puestos de montaje manual y estaciones automatizadas.Para abordar la fase de comprensión y definición del problema, se llevó a cabo una revisión bibliográfica sistemática y se desarrolló un marco conceptual para el Ensamblaje 4.0. Se desarrollaron, verificaron y validaron dos herramientas de evaluación del rendimiento: un modelo matemático analítico y varios modelos de simulación por eventos discretos. Para la verificación, y como punto de partida para los análisis, se ha utilizado un caso de estudio industrial de un fabricante global de electrodomésticos. Se han empleado múltiples escenarios de simulación y técnicas de diseño de experimentos para investigar tres cuestiones clave.En primer lugar, se identificaron los factores más críticos para el rendimiento de líneas de montaje manuales multi-modelo. En segundo lugar, se analizó el rendimiento de líneas de montaje semiautomáticas paralelas con operarios móviles en comparación con líneas semiautomáticas o manuales con operarios fijos, empleando diversos escenarios de demanda en serie corta y variada. Por último, se investigó el uso de trenes milkrun para la logística interna de líneas de ensamblaje multi-modelo bajo la influencia de perturbaciones.Los resultados de las simulaciones muestran que las líneas paralelas con operarios móviles pueden superar a las de operarios fijos en cualquier escenario de demanda, alcanzando como mínimo el objetivo de mejorar la productividad en un 25% o más. También permiten reducir cómodamente el número de operarios trabajando en la línea sin afectar negativamente al equilibrado de la misma, posibilitando la producción eficiente de bajo volumen. Los resultados de las simulaciones de logística interna indican que los milkrun pueden proteger las líneas de ensamblaje de las perturbaciones originadas en procesos aguas arriba.Futuras líneas de investigación en base a los resultados obtenidos en esta tesis podrían incluir la expansión e integración de los modelos de simulación actuales para analizar las cadenas de montaje paralelas con operarios móviles incorporando logística, averías y mantenimiento, problemas de control de calidad y políticas de gestión de los retrabajos. Otra línea podría ser el uso de diferentes herramienta para el análisis del desempeño como, por ejemplo, técnicas de programación de la producción que permitan evaluar el desempeño operacional de diferentes configuraciones de cadenas de montaje con operarios móviles, tanto en términos de automatización como de organización en planta. Podrían incorporarse tecnologías de la Industria 4.0 a los modelos de simulación para evaluar su impacto operacional global ¿como cobots para ensamblaje o para la manipulación de materiales, realidad aumentada para el apoyo cognitivo a los operarios, o AGVs para la conducciónde los trenes milkrun. Por último, el trabajo presentado en esta tesis acerca las líneas de ensamblaje semiautomáticas con operarios móviles a su implementación industrial.<br /