Segmentation of 3D Models for Cultural Heritage Structural Analysis – Some Critical Issues

Cultural Heritage documentation and preservation has become a fundamental concern in this historical period. 3D modelling offers a perfect aid to record ancient buildings and artefacts and can be used as a valid starting point for restoration, conservation and structural analysis, which can be performed by using Finite Element Methods (FEA). The models derived from reality-based techniques, made up of the exterior surfaces of the objects captured at high resolution, are - for this reason - made of millions of polygons. Such meshes are not directly usable in structural analysis packages and need to be properly pre-processed in order to be transformed in volumetric meshes suitable for FEA. In addition, dealing with ancient objects, a proper segmentation of 3D volumetric models is needed to analyse the behaviour of the structure with the most suitable level of detail for the different sections of the structure under analysis. Segmentation of 3D models is still an open issue, especially when dealing with ancient, complicated and geometrically complex objects that imply the presence of anomalies and gaps, due to environmental agents such as earthquakes, pollution, wind and rain, or human factors. The aims of this paper is to critically analyse some of the different methodologies and algorithms available to segment a 3D point cloud or a mesh, identifying difficulties and problems by showing examples on different structures

SEGMENTATION OF 3D MODELS FOR CULTURAL HERITAGE STRUCTURALANALYSIS – SOME CRITICAL ISSUES

Cultural Heritage documentation and preservation has become a fundamental concern in this historical period. 3D modelling offers a perfect aid to record ancient buildings and artefacts and can be used as a valid starting point for restoration, conservation and structural analysis, which can be performed by using Finite Element Methods (FEA). The models derived from reality-based techniques, made up of the exterior surfaces of the objects captured at high resolution, are - for this reason - made of millions of polygons. Such meshes are not directly usable in structural analysis packages and need to be properly pre-processed in order to be transformed in volumetric meshes suitable for FEA. In addition, dealing with ancient objects, a proper segmentation of 3D volumetric models is needed to analyse the behaviour of the structure with the most suitable level of detail for the different sections of the structure under analysis. Segmentation of 3D models is still an open issue, especially when dealing with ancient, complicated and geometrically complex objects that imply the presence of anomalies and gaps, due to environmental agents such as earthquakes, pollution, wind and rain, or human factors. The aims of this paper is to critically analyse some of the different methodologies and algorithms available to segment a 3D point cloud or a mesh, identifying difficulties and problems by showing examples on different structures

Handling Objects by Their Handles

This paper presents an efficient method to decide robust grasps given new objects using example-based learning. A robust grasp is a stable grasp, suitable for object manipulation. Adaptability to object manipulation is ensured by imitating the human choice of the object grasping component, its handle. Stability is obtained by computing contact points, ensuring force-closure property, on that handle

Segmentation of 3D meshes combining the artificial neural network classifier and the spectral clustering

3D mesh segmentation has become an essential step in many applications in 3D shape analysis. In this paper, a new segmentation method is proposed based on a learning approach using the artificial neural networks classifier and the spectral clustering for segmentation. Firstly, a training step is done using the artificial neural network trained on existing segmentation, taken from the ground truth segmentation (done by humane operators) available in the benchmark proposed by Chen et al. to extract the candidate boundaries of a given 3D-model based on a set of geometric criteria. Then, we use this resulted knowledge to construct a new connectivity of the mesh and use the spectral clustering method to segment the 3D mesh into significant parts. Our approach was evaluated using different evaluation metrics. The experiments confirm that the proposed method yields significantly good results and outperforms some of the competitive segmentation methods in the literature.We would first like to thank Xiaobai Chen et al. for providing the Princeton segmentation benchmark (http://segeval.cs.princeton.edu/). We also would like to thank Liu and Hao Zhang et al. for helping us by providing the binary of the AEI and helping us to evaluate our method

Human perception-oriented segmentation for triangle meshes

A segmentação de malhas é um tópico importante de investigação em computação gráfica, em particular em modelação geométrica. Isto deve-se ao facto de as técnicas de segmentaçãodemalhasteremváriasaplicações,nomeadamentenaproduçãodefilmes, animaçãoporcomputador, realidadevirtual, compressãodemalhas, assimcomoemjogosdigitais. Emconcreto, asmalhastriangularessãoamplamenteusadasemaplicações interativas, visto que sua segmentação em partes significativas (também designada por segmentação significativa, segmentação perceptiva ou segmentação perceptualmente significativa ) é muitas vezes vista como uma forma de acelerar a interação com o utilizador ou a deteção de colisões entre esses objetos 3D definidos por uma malha, bem como animar uma ou mais partes significativas (por exemplo, a cabeça de uma personagem) de um dado objeto, independentemente das restantes partes. Acontece que não se conhece nenhuma técnica capaz de segmentar correctamente malhas arbitrárias −ainda que restritas aos domínios de formas livres e não-livres− em partes significativas. Algumas técnicas são mais adequadas para objetos de forma não-livre (por exemplo, peças mecânicas definidas geometricamente por quádricas), enquanto outras são mais talhadas para o domínio dos objectos de forma livre. Só na literatura recente surgem umas poucas técnicas que se aplicam a todo o universo de objetos de forma livre e não-livre. Pior ainda é o facto de que a maioria das técnicas de segmentação não serem totalmente automáticas, no sentido de que quase todas elas exigem algum tipo de pré-requisitos e assistência do utilizador. Resumindo, estes três desafios relacionados com a proximidade perceptual, generalidade e automação estão no cerne do trabalho descrito nesta tese. Para enfrentar estes desafios, esta tese introduz o primeiro algoritmo de segmentação baseada nos contornos ou fronteiras dos segmentos, cuja técnica se inspira nas técnicas de segmentação baseada em arestas, tão comuns em análise e processamento de imagem,porcontraposiçãoàstécnicasesegmentaçãobaseadaemregiões. Aideiaprincipal é a de encontrar em primeiro lugar a fronteira de cada região para, em seguida, identificar e agrupar todos os seus triângulos internos. As regiões da malha encontradas correspondem a saliências e reentrâncias, que não precisam de ser estritamente convexas, nem estritamente côncavas, respectivamente. Estas regiões, designadas regiões relaxadamenteconvexas(ousaliências)eregiõesrelaxadamentecôncavas(oureentrâncias), produzem segmentações que são menos sensíveis ao ruído e, ao mesmo tempo, são mais intuitivas do ponto de vista da perceção humana; por isso, é designada por segmentação orientada à perceção humana (ou, human perception- oriented (HPO), do inglês). Além disso, e ao contrário do atual estado-da-arte da segmentação de malhas, a existência destas regiões relaxadas torna o algoritmo capaz de segmentar de maneira bastante plausível tanto objectos de forma não-livre como objectos de forma livre. Nesta tese, enfrentou-se também um quarto desafio, que está relacionado com a fusão de segmentação e multi-resolução de malhas. Em boa verdade, já existe na literatura uma variedade grande de técnicas de segmentação, bem como um número significativo de técnicas de multi-resolução, para malhas triangulares. No entanto, não é assim tão comum encontrar estruturas de dados e algoritmos que façam a fusão ou a simbiose destes dois conceitos, multi-resolução e segmentação, num único esquema multi-resolução que sirva os propósitos das aplicações que lidam com malhas simples e segmentadas, sendo que neste contexto se entende que uma malha simples é uma malha com um único segmento. Sendo assim, nesta tese descreve-se um novo esquema (entenda-seestruturasdedadosealgoritmos)demulti-resoluçãoesegmentação,designado por extended Ghost Cell (xGC). Este esquema preserva a forma das malhas, tanto em termos globais como locais, ou seja, os segmentos da malha e as suas fronteiras, bem como os seus vincos e ápices são preservados, não importa o nível de resolução que usamos durante a/o simplificação/refinamento da malha. Além disso, ao contrário de outros esquemas de segmentação, tornou-se possível ter segmentos adjacentes com dois ou mais níveis de resolução de diferença. Isto é particularmente útil em animação por computador, compressão e transmissão de malhas, operações de modelação geométrica, visualização científica e computação gráfica. Em suma, esta tese apresenta um esquema genérico, automático, e orientado à percepção humana, que torna possível a simbiose dos conceitos de segmentação e multiresolução de malhas trianguladas que sejam representativas de objectos 3D.The mesh segmentation is an important topic in computer graphics, in particular in geometric computing. This is so because mesh segmentation techniques find many applications in movies, computer animation, virtual reality, mesh compression, and games. Infact, trianglemeshesarewidelyusedininteractiveapplications, sothattheir segmentation in meaningful parts (i.e., human-perceptually segmentation, perceptive segmentationormeaningfulsegmentation)isoftenseenasawayofspeedinguptheuser interaction, detecting collisions between these mesh-covered objects in a 3D scene, as well as animating one or more meaningful parts (e.g., the head of a humanoid) independently of the other parts of a given object. It happens that there is no known technique capable of correctly segmenting any mesh into meaningful parts. Some techniques are more adequate for non-freeform objects (e.g., quadricmechanicalparts), whileothersperformbetterinthedomainoffreeform objects. Only recently, some techniques have been developed for the entire universe of objects and shapes. Even worse it is the fact that most segmentation techniques are not entirely automated in the sense that almost all techniques require some sort of pre-requisites and user assistance. Summing up, these three challenges related to perceptual proximity, generality and automation are at the core of the work described in this thesis. In order to face these challenges, we have developed the first contour-based mesh segmentation algorithm that we may find in the literature, which is inspired in the edgebased segmentation techniques used in image analysis, as opposite to region-based segmentation techniques. Its leading idea is to firstly find the contour of each region, and then to identify and collect all of its inner triangles. The encountered mesh regions correspond to ups and downs, which do not need to be strictly convex nor strictly concave, respectively. These regions, called relaxedly convex regions (or saliences) and relaxedly concave regions (or recesses), produce segmentations that are less-sensitive to noise and, at the same time, are more intuitive from the human point of view; hence it is called human perception- oriented (HPO) segmentation. Besides, and unlike the current state-of-the-art in mesh segmentation, the existence of these relaxed regions makes the algorithm suited to both non-freeform and freeform objects. In this thesis, we have also tackled a fourth challenge, which is related with the fusion of mesh segmentation and multi-resolution. Truly speaking, a plethora of segmentation techniques, as well as a number of multiresolution techniques, for triangle meshes already exist in the literature. However, it is not so common to find algorithms and data structures that fuse these two concepts, multiresolution and segmentation, into a symbiotic multi-resolution scheme for both plain and segmented meshes, in which a plainmeshisunderstoodasameshwithasinglesegment. So, weintroducesuchanovel multiresolution segmentation scheme, called extended Ghost Cell (xGC) scheme. This scheme preserves the shape of the meshes in both global and local terms, i.e., mesh segments and their boundaries, as well as creases and apices are preserved, no matter the level of resolution we use for simplification/refinement of the mesh. Moreover, unlike other segmentation schemes, it was made possible to have adjacent segments with two or more resolution levels of difference. This is particularly useful in computer animation, mesh compression and transmission, geometric computing, scientific visualization, and computer graphics. In short, this thesis presents a fully automatic, general, and human perception-oriented scheme that symbiotically integrates the concepts of mesh segmentation and multiresolution

3D object retrieval and segmentation: various approaches including 2D poisson histograms and 3D electrical charge distributions.

Nowadays 3D models play an important role in many applications: viz. games, cultural heritage, medical imaging etc. Due to the fast growth in the number of available 3D models, understanding, searching and retrieving such models have become interesting fields within computer vision. In order to search and retrieve 3D models, we present two different approaches: one is based on solving the Poisson Equation over 2D silhouettes of the models. This method uses 60 different silhouettes, which are automatically extracted from different viewangles. Solving the Poisson equation for each silhouette assigns a number to each pixel as its signature. Accumulating these signatures generates a final histogram-based descriptor for each silhouette, which we call a SilPH (Silhouette Poisson Histogram). For the second approach, we propose two new robust shape descriptors based on the distribution of charge density on the surface of a 3D model. The Finite Element Method is used to calculate the charge density on each triangular face of each model as a local feature. Then we utilize the Bag-of-Features and concentric sphere frameworks to perform global matching using these local features. In addition to examining the retrieval accuracy of the descriptors in comparison to the state-of-the-art approaches, the retrieval speeds as well as robustness to noise and deformation on different datasets are investigated. On the other hand, to understand new complex models, we have also utilized distribution of electrical charge for proposing a system to decompose models into meaningful parts. Our robust, efficient and fully-automatic segmentation approach is able to specify the segments attached to the main part of a model as well as locating the boundary parts of the segments. The segmentation ability of the proposed system is examined on the standard datasets and its timing and accuracy are compared with the existing state-of-the-art approaches